Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92970 (KAR)
VENKATESH AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200209/2024 · 2025-07-17
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92970 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92970 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!%
$&&
'
'(&)*
')) +
!! ! "
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
$
%
$
$ $
! $
#
& #
'!! ( )
* ! - 3 -
! !! *
& # ' ! ( ! !)
!! *
()
* ! ! !$ "! $
" *
** ! " %
*! !! *
*
$
+$
!$ (! +$
)
,-./ .0 1-02-34-567-. 1-3/.050 8,-.3,/ 9:63;,8 <:. 21, -==,88-32 -3/ 72 -.20 !-208 8,-.3,/ 0>1 :6.2 :?,.37,32 !8,-/,. <:. 21, .,;=:3/,32&
2-2,
- 4 -
==,88-32; -., 21, -996;,/ =,.;:3; @1: ;6<<,.,/-3:./,.:<9:3?0920:303 : "/-2,/
" A4 21, 0;2.092 -3/ ,;;0:3; $6/>, -/>0.0 -3/;,32,39,/-;63/,. !"#
$
%
&
!"#
$
'
(!"#
$
! %%")
- 5 -
& *
% &
(!"#
$
& ! (*%%%")
&*
(!"#
$
&
% !"#
$
( & ! *%%%")
&* (
%!"#
$
'
%'!"#
$
- 6 -
'
! %%")
& *
% & + )
& ,
-
& (. /
0
,#
,
& *
+1 #,
2+)".'
,
3
*-92; :< 21, 9-;, @1091 -., 627:;2 3,9,;;-.4 <:./0;=:;-8:<21,=.,;,32-==,-8-.,-;63/,. 9:7=8-032 9-7, 2: A, 8:/>,/ @021 -/>0.0 6.-8!:809,9:32,3/03>21-2:3 -2-A:62# =703,35-2,;1->-. -3/-3,-..91-996;,/:
:A.-4- @-; =8-403> 7-25- 2 21-2 B63926., 21,
- 7 -
;;0;2-32 6A&3;=,92:. A4 3-7, 80 ,,.-33-
->>0! -A6>:@/-!:809,:3;2-A8,-88-==-,-/ :3;2-A8, -3:21,. -88-==- !:809, :3;2-A8,
10?-;1-35-.4,2-3:21,.!:809,:3;2-A8,-8:3>@02121, =-391@023,;;,;.-0/,/:3:A.-4- 321,.-0/21,1,-/:<21,.-0/=-.24@-;-A8, 2:9-=26.,:A.-4--3/21,4@,.,,3C60.03>@0211073,-. ,35-2,;1 ->-. .91 2 21-2 B63926., ;-0/ :A.-4- ;-0/2:1-?,-A6;,/21,!:809,03<082148-3>6->,-3/:21,. -996;,/=,.;:3;9-7,21,.,-3/21,4-8;:;2-.2,/-A6;03> 21, !:809, =-.24 03 <08214 8-3>6->, -3/ ;2-.2,/ -;;-68203> 21,7 !:809,.,;0;2,/21,-92;:<21,-==,88-32;-3/A4 ?0.26,:<21,-92-22.0A62-A8,2:21,-==,88-32;!:809,@,., =.,?,32,/<.:7/0;91-.>03>21,0./624 1,.,@-;=14;09-8 -;;-682:321,.-0/2,-7 1,.,<:.,-8821,=,.;:3;@,., -..,;2,/ -3/ - 9:7=8-032 9-7, 2: A, 8:/>,/ 03 .07, :
- 8 -
-;,/ :3 21, 9:7=8-032 -/>0.0 6.-8 !:809, .,>0;2,.,/21,9-;,->-03;221,-==,88-32;1,.,03-3/-<2,. 21:.:6>103?,;20>-20:3<08,/21,91-.>,&;1,,2->-03;221, -==,88-32; 1,.,03 <:. 21, :<<,39,; =630;1-A8, 63/,. ,920:3;
".,-/@021 ,920:3%:<! ,-.3,/$6/>, 2::5 9:>30D-39,:<21, :<<,39,; -3/ 9:77022,/ 21, 7-22,. 2: 21, ,;;0:3; :6.2 -;
:<<,39,63/,. ,920:3:<!@-;,E986;0?,842.0-A8,A4 21, ,;;0:3;$6/>,
" 3 .,9,0=2 :< 21, .,9:./; 21, ,;;0:3; $6/>, 2::5 9:>30D-39, -3/ .,>0;2,.,/ 21, 9-;, 03
: "-3/:3/6,2.0-89:3?092,/21,-==,88-32;-3/ ;,32,39,/ -; .,<,..,/ 2: ;6=.- ,03> ->>.0,?,/ A4 21, ;-7,-==,88-32;-.,A,<:.,210;:6.2
.0 1-02-34-567-. 1-3/.050 8,-.3,/ 9:63;,8 <:. 21, -==,88-32; .,02,.-203> 21, >.:63/; 6.>,/ 03 21, -==,-8 7,7:.-3/67 9:32,3/,/ 21-2 ,E9,=2 21, !:809,
- 9 -
!,.;:33,8 21,., -., 3: 03/,=,3/,32 @023,;;,; 2: 21, 0390/,32-3/21,:.-82,;207:34:<21,7,7A,.;:<21,.-0/ 2,-7-.,3:2103>A62;,8<;,.?03>2,;207:34@10911-;3:2 A,,3=.:=,.849:3;0/,.,/A421,8,-.3,/ .0-8$6/>,@108, .,9:./03> -3 :./,. :< 9:3?0920:3 -3/ ;:6>12 <:. -88:@03> 21,-==,-8 # 82,.3-20?,84 .0 1-02-34-567-.
1-3/.050 @:68/ 9:32,3/ 21-2 21, 03B6.0,; ;6;2-03,/ A4 21, 03B6.,/ !:809, !,.;:33,8 0; /,=092,/ 03 :63/ ,.20<09-2,; -2 E;!-3/!@1091-.,-/7022,/84;07=8,03B6.0,;-3/ @1-21-;A,,3;,0D,/A421,03?,;20>-20:3->,3940;
F ;2095 1,.,<:., .,9:./03> :< -3 :./,. :< 9:3?0920:3 63/,. ,920:3 :< ! 0; 039:..,92 .,;68203> 03 70;9-..0->, :< B6;209, -3/ ;:6>12 <:. -88:@03> 21, -==,-8 2:21-2,E2,32 % ,@:68/<6.21,.9:32,3/21-2;039,21,.,0;3:
3,9,;;-.4 03>.,/0,32; ,;2-A80;1,/ A4 21, =.:;,9620:3 2: =.:?, 21, :<<,39,; -88,>,/ ->-03;2 21,7 -2 21, 7:;2 02
- 10 -
@:68/A,9:3;0/,.,/-;-<.,,<0>12A,2@,,321,.-0/2,-7 -3/ 21, -996;,/ =,.;:3; -3/ 2-503> 3:2, :< 21, ;-7, 96;2:/4 =,.0:/ :< /-4; -8.,-/4 63/,.>:3, A4 ,-91 :< 21, -996;,/ =,.;:3; 7-4 A, 2.,-2,/ -; =,.0:/ :< 07=.0;:37,32A4,31-3903>21,<03,-7:632.,-;:3-A84
72.-20!-2088,-.3,/0>1:6.2 :?,.37,32!8,-/,.;6==:.2;21,07=6>3,/B6/>7,32
1, @:68/ <6.21,. 9:32,3/ 21-2 -/7022,/84 A-;,/ :3 21, 9.,/0A8, 03<:.7-20:3 21, .-0/ =-.24 9:7=.0;03> :< ;;0;2-32 6A&3;=,92:. !:809, 3;=,92:. !:809, 9:3;2-A8,; -3/ 03/,=,3/,32 =-391&@023,;;,; @,32 3,-.,35-2,;1->-..91-3/<:63/:A.4-03/68>03>03 -25-1,321,49-=26.,/107-3/@-;03C60.03>:21,. -996;,/ =,.;:3; -..0?,/ 21,., -3/ =095,/ 6= 21, C6-..,8 @021 21, !:809, =-.24 -3/ @021:62 21,., A,03> -34 =.:?:9-20:3@1-2;:,?,.21,4;2-.2,/-;;-68203>21,!:809, =-.24 -3/ 03 21, =.:9,;; 21,4 3:2 :384 =.,?,32,/ 21, /0;91-.>, :< 21, :<<090-8 /624 A4 21, =6A809 ;,.?-32; A62
- 11 -
-8;: =14;09-884 -;;-682,/ 21,7 .,;68203> 03 2,-.03> :< 21, 630<:.7-3/.,7:?03>21,A622:3;<.:721,630<:.7;10.2 -3/ 03B6.0,; 9-6;,/ 2: 21,7 A4 6;->, :<
F ;2095 .,;68203> 03 !:809, !,.;:33,8 ;6;2-0303> 03B6.0,; ?0/, :63/ ,.20<09-2,; -2 E;! -3/ ! 0;;6,/ A4 21, :92:.@1:0;,E-703,/-;!"
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
- 12 -
;6;2-0321,9:3?0920:3:<21,-==,88-32;<:. -8821,:<<,39,;G ) 1,21,. 21, 07=6>3,/ B6/>7,32 0;
;6<<,.03> <.:7 -34 8,>-8 03<0.7024 :. =,.?,.;024 9-8803> 032,.<,.,39, A4 210; :6.2G ) 1,21,.21,;,32,39,0;,E9,;;0?,G ) 1-2:./,.G
,-.(/01-20134.1/
3 21, 9-;, :3 1-3/ 21, 210./ -==,88-32 F :A.-4- 1-?03> A,,3 03/68>,/ 03 =8-403> 21, -25- :3 21
92:A,. 3,-. ,35-2,;1 ->-. -3/- 3,-. .911-/A,,39-=26.,/A421,.-0/=-.241,-/,/A4! -2-A:62# =71,321,!:809,@,.,,3C60.03>;-0/ :A.-4- :21,. -==,88-32; 9-7, 21,., -3/ <:.7,/ -3 638-@<68-;;,7A84:321,;=:2@021-3032,320:32:=0956= 21, C6-..,8 @021 21, .-0/ =-.24 -3/ ;2-.2,/ -A6;03> 21, !:809,!,.;:33,8-3/=14;09-884-;;-682,/21,7
- 13 -
" 3 21, =.:9,;; 21, 630<:.7 @:.3 A4 ! @-;
2:.3-3/21,;10.2A622:3;@,.,962:<<<.:721,;10.2 1, ;-7, 0; .,9:?,.,/ 63/,.
21, ;,0D6., =-3913-7- -3/ 7-.5,/A,<:.,21,:6.2-;
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
- 14 -
@023,;;,; 1-?, -8;: =-.284 ;6==:.2,/ 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:303-/702203>21,0.;0>3-26.,-3/ :321, =-3913-7- 1,4 /0/ 3:2 ;6==:.2 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:3032:2:
!#F-5;17-3!%FD0D-A6-3/! F 10?-==- -., 21, :21,. @023,;;,; :3 @1:7 21, =.:;,9620:3 =8-9,; .,80-39, 7:3> 21,7 !;# -3/ % 1-?, 3:2 ;6==:.2,/ 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:3 2: -34 ,E2,32 :@,?,. ! ;6==:.2,/ 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:3=-.284310;,?0/,39,-8;:3:6;,<687-2,.0-8 0; ,80902,/ ;: -; 2: -/?-39, 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:3 ;91,@03> 21, -<:.,;-0/ ,?0/,39, <.:7 21, .,9:./ @1-2 .,7-03;0;21,:.-82,;207:34:<21,7,7A,.;:<21,.-0/ =-.24 9:6=8,/ @021 :63/ ,.20<09-2,; 0;;6,/ A4 21, :92:. @1: 0; ,E-703,/ -; !" -3/ 21, 3?,;20>-203> <<09,. - 15 -
: /:6A2 03 - 7-22,. :< 210; 3-26., 21, =.:;,9620:3 0; ,E=,92,/ 2: =8-9, ;:7, 03/,=,3/,32 ,?0/,39, :@,?,. 21,., 0; 3: 2:2-8 A-. 03 -==.,90-203> 21, ,?0/,39, :< 21, :<<090-8 @023,;;,; 0< 02 03;=0.,; 21, 9:3<0/,39, 03 21, :6.2 -A:62 21,0. 2,;207:34 691 2,;207:340;2:A,9:3;0/,.,/A421,:6.2@021,E2.-9-., -3/ 9-620:3 2: .,7:?, 21, =:;;0A08024 :< 21, <-8;, 07=809-20:3:<21,-996;,/ 2 0; 03 210; .,>-./ 21, :.-8 2,;207:34 :< 21, !! 2:!-3/! 3,,/;2:A,-==.,90-2,/ 88 21,;, @023,;;,; 1-?, ;6==:.2,/ 21, 9-;, :< 21, =.:;,9620:3 -3/ /,=:;,/ A,<:., 21, :6.2 -A:62 21, 0390/,3221-2:996..,/:321
92:A,. -2-A:62# =73,-.,35-2,;1->-. -3/-3,-.21,.91 1,:.-82,;207:34:<21,=.:;,9620:3@023,;;,; 0;9:..:A:.-2,/A421,:63/,.20<09-2,0;;6,/A4!" @1,.,63/,.!-3/! 1-?,;6;2-03,/;07=8,03B6.0,;
- 16 -
384 @021 -3 032,320:3 2: <-8;,84 07=809-2, 21, -==,88-32;0321,9-;,@14@:68/!-3/! 03<8092;,8< 03B6.4 -3/ >,2 - /:967,32 =.,=-.,/ <:. 21, =6.=:;, :< >,2203> -3 :./,. :< 9:3?0920:3 ->-03;2 21, -==,88-32; 0; - C6,;20:3 21-2 .,7-03; 63-3;@,.,/ ,;=,90-884 03 21, -A;,39,:<=.,?0:6;,37024:.-307:;024A,2@,,3-996;,/ -3/=:809,=-.24
" *6.21,. 03 21, 9.:;;&,E-703-20:3 :< 21,;, @023,;;,;21,.,0;3:7-2,.0-8@10910;,80902,/@1,.,A4 :3, 9-3 03<,. 21-2 21,., ,E0;2,/ - =.,?0:6; ,37024 :. -307:;024A,2@,,3!-3/21,-==,88-32; !,.203,3284 21, -996;,/ =,.;:3; /0/ 3:2 :<<,.
-34 ,E=8-3-20:3 @1-2;:,?,. @108, .,9:./03> 21, -996;,/ ;2-2,7,32 ,E9,=2 /,3403> -88 21, 039.0703-203> 90.967;2-39,; # -503>3:2,:<21,;,-;=,92;:<21,7-22,.03- 96768-20?, 7-33,. -; 9:68/ A, ;,,3 <.:7 21, 7-2,.0-8 ,?0/,39, =8-9,/ :3 .,9:./ -88 03>.,/0,32; .,C60.,/ 2:
- 17 -
-22.-9221,:<<,39,63/,. ,920:3:<!0;3:27-/, :62A421,=.:;,9620:3,;=,90-88403-8821,03B6.0,;A,03> 2.,-2,/-;;07=8,03B6.0,;03E;!-3/! % : /:6A2 7,., 3-26., :< 03B6.4 @:68/ 3:2 A, ;6<<090,322:9:3;0/,.21,<-92:<,E0;2,39,:<-8803>.,/0,32; <:. 21, :<<,39, 63/,. ,920:3 :< ! -; 0; .0>1284 9:32,3/,/ A4 72 .-20 !-208 8,-.3,/ 0>1 :6.2 :?,.37,32!8,-/,. 62 <:. ,;2-A80;103> 21, :<<,39, 63/,. ,920:3 :<!21,=.:;,9620:30;,E=,92,/2:=.:?,-88;691 03>.,/0,32; 3-7,84 7:20?, =.,=-.-20:3 -3/ -926-8 9:770;;0:3 :< 21, -92 -3/ =,. 91-39, 21, 03B6.,/ 9:68/ ;6.?0?, 03 21, 0390/,32 : ;691 /,>.,, :< ,?0/,39, 0; <:.219:703>:3.,9:./ 1,.,<:.,0321,07=6>3,/B6/>7,32.,9:./03> -3:./,.:<9:3?0920:3<:.21,:<<,39,63/,. ,920:3:< ! 3,,/; 2: A, ;,2 -;0/, -<2,. .,&-==.,90-20:3 :< 21,
- 18 -
7-2,.0-8 ,?0/,39, :3 .,9:./ -3/ <:. 21, .,;2 :< 21, :<<,39,;9:3?0920:3:./,.3,,/;2:7-032-03,/ :21,-<:.,;-0/,E2,3203.,9:./03>-3:./,.:< 9:3?0920:3 63/,. ,920:3 :< ! 21, 07=6>3,/ B6/>7,320;;6<<,.03><.:78,>-803<0.7024 1,.,<:., <.:7 21, -A:?, /0;96;;0:3 =:032 :;-3/-.,-3;@,.,/=-.2840321,-<<0.7-20?,84 ,-.(/01-2013
10;:6.21-?03>.,9:./,/-9-2,>:.09-8<03/03> :3=:032:;-3/-;-A:?,-3/0;:<9:3;0/,.,/:=030:3 21-2-==,88-32;1-?,2:A,-9C6022,/:<21,:<<,39,63/,. ,920:3 :< ! <:. 21, .,7-0303> :<<,39,; 0< 21, 96;2:/4 =,.0:/ :< /-4; -8.,-/4 63/,.>:3, A4 ,-91 :< 21, -==,88-32; 0< 2.,-2,/ -; =,.0:/ :< 07=.0;:37,32 A4 ,31-3903><03,-7:6322:A,=-0/A4,-91:<-==,88-32;03 .,;=,92:<-88:21,.=.:?,/:<<,39,,3/;:<B6;209,@:68/
- 19 -
A,7,299:./03>84=:032:0;-3;@,.,/=-.2840321, -<<0.7-20?, ,-.(/01-2013
3 ?0,@ :< 21, <03/03> :< 210; :6.2 :3 =:032 :;2:-;-A:?,21,<:88:@03>
0) ==,-80;
00) ==,88-32; -., -9C6022,/ :< 21, :<<,39, =630;1-A8,63/,. ,920:3:<! 000) *:. .,;2 :< 21, :<<,39,; 21, :./,. :< 9:3?0920:3 =-;;,/ A4 21, .0-8 $6/>, ;2-3/;63-82,.,/ 0?) :3;,C6,3284 21, ;,32,39, :< 07=.0;:37,32:./,.,/A421,8,-.3,/ .0-8 $6/>, 0; 7:/0<0,/ A4 9:3;0/,.03> 21, /-4; 96;2:/4 =,.0:/ -; =,.0:/ :< 07=.0;:37,32 <:. 21, .,7-0303> =.:?,/ :<<,39,; -3/ /0.,9203> 21, -==,88-32; 2: =-4 - ;67 :< ; & ,-91 -;
- 20 -
,31-39,/ <03, -7:632 :3 :. A,<:., # ?) *-086.,2:=-421,,31-39,/<03,-7:632 ,-91 :< 21, -==,88-32; ;1-88 63/,.>: ;07=8, 07=.0;:37,32 <:. - =,.0:/ :< :3, 4,-.<:.21,.,7-0303>=.:?,/:<<,39,; ?0) 62:<21,<03,-7:632.,9:?,.,/-;67 :<; &,-910;:./,.,/2:A,=-0/ -; 9:7=,3;-20:3 2: !; -3/
.,;=,920?,8463/,./6,0/,320<09-20:3 ?00) ,7-0303> -7:632 ;1-88 A, -==.:=.0-2,/ 2:@-./;/,<.-403>,E=,3;,;:<21, 2-2,
<<09, 0; /0.,92,/ 2: .,26.3 21, .0-8 :6.2 ,9:./; @0219:=4:<210;B6/>7,32<:.21@021<:.0;;6,:<7:/0<0,/ 9:3?0920:3@-..-32 /* '%) ! 0;2: 8:" &!