Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92969 (KAR)
MOINUDDIN PATEL v. SABER PASHA S/O MAHEBOOB PATEL
RSA/200377/2018 · 2025-11-13
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92969 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92969 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$#%##
&&
'&(
)
! "
# $
%
&
! "
# $
'
(( ' &
()( !(
( !(
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(%!(
(!(()
*'
&
''
&
+
% # #+ $
,-./0.11 ./
2(!(() .3 ./ 04.3 3562/7 -885-, 95./: -::;.5<57 9= 045 >?7:@5/0 -/7 2;75; 7-057 ()(!( 8-3357 ./ 2 !( 2/ 045 1.,5 21 045 5/.2; .<., ?7:5 -3-<-A-,=-/ -0 -3-<-A-,=-/ B45;5./-105; ;515;;57 02 -3 045 C'.;30 885,,-05 2?;0D 12;
9;5<.0=E9=F4.64045'.;30 885,,-052?;0F4.,5-,,2F./: 045-885-,1.,579=0457515/7-/0350-3.75045>?7:@5/0 -/7756;557-057(%!(8-3357./045-12;53-.73?.0 ./
2(!(()2/0451.,521045;./6.8-,.<.,?7:5 -3-<-A-,=-/ B45;5./-105; ;515;;57 02 -3 045 C ;.-, 2?;0D 12; 9;5<.0=E -/7 7.3@.3357 045 3?.0 21 045 8,-./0.11 12; 3856.1.685;12;@-/65-/7:;-/057-,05;/-05;5,.5121;51?/7
- 3 -
21 -7<-/65 -@2?/0 21 3(((( F.04 ./05;530 -0 045 ;-0521(G85;-//?@1;2@0457-0521;565.80
!
45-92<53?.0./
2(!(().31.,579=045 8,-./0.11 -:-./30 045 7515/7-/0 12; ;5,.51 21 3856.1.6 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0 21 3-,5 7-057 !(%!(( -/7 12; 62/35H?5/0.-, ;5,.51 21 85;@-/5/0 ./>?/60.2/ F.04 ;538560 02 045 3?.0 8;285;0= -/7 12; -,05;/-0.<5 ;5,.51 21 ;51?/7 21 -7<-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ -@2?/0 21 3(((( F.04 ./05;530 -0 045 ;-05 21 G 85; -//?@ 1;2@((I!((0.,,;5-,.J-0.2/
%
45 3?9>560 @-005; 21 045 3?.0 .3 ,-/7 95-;./: =2)@5-3?;./:%-6;533.0?-057-0.;/-:-2/.,,-:5 -3-<-A-,=-/ 0-,?A B45;5./-105; ;515;;57 02 -3 045 C3?.0 8;285;0=D12;9;5<.0=E
I -35210458,-./0.11.304-0454-75/05;57./02 -:;55@5/0 02 8?;64-35 045 3?.0 8;285;0= F.04 045 7515/7-/0 2/ !(%!(( 12; - 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 21 3((( 85; -6;5 -/7 020-, 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 95./:
- 4 -
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
515/7-/0 2/ -885-;-/65 1.,57 F;.005/ 30-05@5/0 -7@.00./: 045 7536;.80.2/ 21 045 3?.0 8;285;0= -/7 45 4-<./: 5/05;57 ./02 -:;55@5/0 21 3-,5 2/ !(%!((F.040458,-./0.1112;020-,3-,562/3.75;-0.2/21
- 5 -
3%I(((0.33856.1.6-,,=62/05/7579=0457515/7-/0 04-0 45 -/7 4.3 1-@.,= 4-7 34.1057 02 .7-; 12; 045.;
,.<5,.4227 -/7 F5;5 ;53.7./: ./ - ;5/057 42?35 45 7515/7-/0./05/757028?;64-35-42?35./.7-;02F/12; -662@@27-0.2/214.31-@.,=-/7F-3.//55721@2/5=0 .312;04.38?;8235454-7-:;5570235,,0453?.08;285;0= 020458,-./0.11
L
4-0 45 4-7 5/05;57 ./02 -/ -:;55@5/0 F.04 2/5
45.A4-34.7-/7 3-7?30-11-028?;64-35-42?35 8;285;0=3.0?-057-0?,3?@-,,..7-;12;-62/3.75;-0.2/ 3I(((( 4-0 45 4-7 5<5/ 8-.7 3((((( 02F-;730458-;08-=@5/0213-,562/3.75;-0.2/ 4-0045 0.@595./:0455335/652104562/0;-600458,-./0.111-.,57 02 85;12;@ 4.3 8-;0 21 045 62/0;-60 7538.05 ;585-057 ;5H?5303 9= 045 7515/7-/0 ./ 045 8;535/65 21 F.0/53353
458,-./0.1175,.95;-05,=-<2.7570285;12;@4.38-;021045 62/0;-609=8-=./:0459-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/?502 0451-.,?;52/0458-;0210458,-./0.117515/7-/0F-3/20 -9,5 02 85;12;@ 4.3 8-;0 21 045 62/0;-60 21 3-,5 F4.64 45
- 6 -
4-7 5/05;57 ./02 F.04
45.A4 -34.7 -/7 3-7 ?30-1- ;53?,0./: ./ 3((((( 8-.7 9= 4.@ 95./: 12;15.057 9= 045 3-.7 <5/72;3 4-0 045 8,-./0.11 F-3 /5<5; ;5-7= -/7 F.,,./:0285;12;@4.38-;02104562/0;-60 33?6445.3 /205/0.0,5712;-/=;5,.51213856.1.685;12;@-/655/65 32?:4012;7.3@.33-,210453?.0
45 ;.-, 2?;0 1;-@57045 12,,2F./:.33?53 12; .0362/3.75;-0.2/
! "# $
% & ' #
' (
'
! %
- 7 -
)
"# $ $*+ (
,
$*+ (
-
./
,-./0.11 5K-@./57 4.@35,1 -3 & -/7 04;55 F.0/53353 -3 &3! 02 I -/7 5K4.9.057 ! 726?@5/03 -3 K302!515/7-/05K-@./574.@35,1-3&-/7 04;55 F.0/53353 -3 &3!
02 I -/7 5K4.9.057 ( 726?@5/03 -3 K3 02 ( / -88;56.-0.2/ 21 5<.75/65045 ;.-,2?;0-/3F5;57.33?523%-/7./ 045-11.;@-0.<5-/7.33?523!I02L./045/5:-0.<5-/7 62/35H?5/0,=756;5570453?.07.;560./:0457515/7-/002 5K56?05-/7;5:.305;7557213-,5./1-<2?;210458,-./0.11 9= ;565.<./: 045 -77.0.2/-, 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 21
- 8 -
3%((((( -/7 9= F.047;-F./: 045 -@2?/0 21 3!I((((75823.0579=0458,-./0.11./0452?;0
) 5./: -::;.5<57 8,-./0.11 8;515;;57 ;5:?,-; -885-,./ 2 !(9512;5045'.;30 885,,-052?;0 2/3.75;./: 045 :;2?/73 ?;:57 045 '.;30 885,,-05 2?;0 1;-@5704512,,2F./:82./0312;62/3.75;-0.2/ 0* (
*
* 1
2 (
(
*
3
'*/
( / ;5-88;56.-0.2/ 045 '.;30 885,,-05 2?;0 -/3F5;5782./02./045/5:-0.<5-/782./023!02I ./045-11.;@-0.<5-/762/35H?5/0,=-,,2F57045-885-,350 -3.75045>?7:@5/0-/7756;558-33579=045 ;.-,2?;0 7.3@.3357 045 3?.0 -/7 7.;56057 045 7515/7-/0 02 ;51?/7
- 9 -
3((((8-.79=0458,-./0.11F.04./05;530-0045;-05 21 (G 85; -//?@ 1;2@ 045 7-05 21 ;565.80 5./: -::;.5<570458;535/0-885-,9=0458,-./0.11
4.3 2?;0 9= 2;75; 7-057 (%(%!(!% -7@.0057 045 -885-, 02 62/3.75; 045 12,,2F./: 3?930-/0.-, H?530.2/21,-F 0
1
4&*5
(
(
/
! ;. >-=?@-; ,5-;/5762?/35,-885-;./: 12; 045 8,-./0.11 ;5.05;-0./: 045 :;2?/73 ?;:57 ./ 045 @5@2;-/7?@21-885-,3?9@.03
! 4-0045'.;30 885,,-052?;05;;57./;5<5;3./: -F5,,62/3.75;57>?7:@5/0-/7756;558-33579=045 ;.-, 2?;0 4-0-:;55@5/07-057!(%!((-0KI4-3/20 955/ 7.38?057 32 -,32 ;565.80 21 3((( -/7 3(((((,-05;8-.79=0458,-./0.119=F-=21645H?5
- 10 -
4-00458,-./0.114-72/35<5;-,266-3.2/3-88;2-6457045 7515/7-/0 ;5H?530./: 4.@ 02 ;565.<5 045 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ -/7 02 5K56?05 045 3-,5 7557 2/ 62@8,.-/65 9= 045 7515/7-/0 02 045 3-.7 ;5H?5303 -/7 75@-/73 ;53?,057 ./ 8,-./0.11 .33?./: 045 ,5:-, /20.65 2/ !!(( -385;KL
!! 515;;./: 02 K!I -/A 30-05@5/0 21 045 8,-./0.11 45 3?9@.03 04-0 -3 2/ I(!(( 045;5 F-3 3?11.6.5/0 9-,-/65-<-.,-9,5 ./ 045 -662?/0 21 0458,-./0.11 5-,32;515;302K!30-05@5/0219-/A-662?/02132/ 21 045 8,-./0.11 -/7 3?9@.03 04-0 045;5 F-3 3?11.6.5/0 -@2?/0-<-.,-9,5./0453-.7-662?/0-3F5,, 4-012;045 8?;8235 21 75@2/30;-0./: ;5-7./533 -/7 F.,,./:/533 045 3-.7 0F2 726?@5/03 -0 K3!I -/7 !
F5;5 3?11.6.5/0
4-0 -8-;0 045 8,-./0.11 4-7 5<5/ 75823.057 045 9-,-/65 3?@ 21 3!I((( 2/ (%!(( 9512;5 045 .<., 2?;0 / -77.0.2/ -3 7.;56057 9= 045 0;.-, 2?;0 045 8,-./0.11 4-7 -,32 75823.057 3%((((( -3 -77.0.2/-, 3-,562/3.75;-0.2/ 4?3453?9@.0304-0045;5.33?11.6.5/0
- 11 -
@-05;.-,@-75-<-.,-9,59=0458,-./0.112/;562;702342F 4.3;5-7./533-/7F.,,./:/533./85;12;@./:4.38-;021045 62/0;-60 !% 515;;./:0262/05/0321;58,=7-057(%(!(() 8;27?657-0K).33?579=0457515/7-/0453?9@.0304-0 04562/05/0321K);?/362/0;-;=020457515/65350?8 9=0457515/7-/0./045F;.005/30-05@5/0 4-0042?:4.0 .30453856.1.66-35217515/7-/004-0454-75/05;57./02 -:;55@5/0 F.04 045 8,-./0.11 2/,= 02 @550 4.3 1./-/6.-, ;5H?.;5@5/0219?=./:-;53.75/0.-,42?35-0.7-;-/704-0 45 4-7 5/05;57 ./02 -/ -:;55@5/0 F.04 65;0-./ 3-7 ?30-1- 2/ !I(!!(( -3 85; K 045;5 .3 /2 @5/0.2/./:210453-@5 ./045;58,=/20.6504-0F-335/0 2/ (%(!(() -3 85; K) 4?3 45 3?9@.03 04-0 045 3-.7726?@5/0-0K-3;.:40,=0-A5//20521045 ;.-, 2?;0F-3/20;5,.-9,5
!I 4-0 5<5/ 2045;F.35 045 <5/72;3 ./ 045 3-.7 726?@5/0K/-@5,= 3-7?30-1-4-7/2;.:400235,, 045 8;285;0= 3?9>560 @-005; 21 3-.7 726?@5/0 -3 45 F-3
- 12 -
/20 045 2F/5; 21 045 3-.7 8;285;0= F4.64 1-60 4-3 /20 955/ 0-A5/ /205219= 045'.;30 885,,-052?;0 .@5./ 045./30-/06-35045;512;56-//209545,702955335/6521 - 62/0;-60 -3 045 7515/7-/0 4-3 1-.,57 02 8;2<5 045 .@@./5/0 ;5H?.;5@5/0 21 1?/73 12; 4.3 8?;64-35 21 ;53.75/0.-,42?35
% 5 ;5,.53 ?82/ 045 >?7:@5/0 21 045 2/D9,5 85K 2?;0 ./ 045 6-35 21
;582;057 ./
-/7 355A3 -,,2F./:21045-885-,
I 5
;. @95A-; ,5-;/57 62?/35, -885-;./:12;0457515/7-/03?9@.03
I 4-0 12; 045 8?;8235 21 ;5-7./533 -/7 F.,,./:/5338,-./0.11@?308,5-7-/78;2<54.3./05/0.2/21 290-././:045
-,5557-/75112;03@-75045;5218;.2;02 045 5K8.;= 21 7-05 1.K57 ./ 045 -:;55@5/0 -/7 /20 3?935H?5/0 045;521 4-0 ./ ./30-/0 6-35 045;5 .3 /2 F4.385; 5.045; ./ 045 8,-./0 2; ./ 045 5<.75/65 ;5:-;7./:
- 13 -
8,-./0.11 4-<./:@-75 -/=5112;0 F4-0325<5; 02290-./ 045 557 21
-,5 9= 8-=./: 045 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 950F55/!(%!((-/7(!((<5/045/20.654-3 955/.33?572/ !!(( .5@2;504-/2/5-/7-4-,1 =5-;3?935H?5/0020457-051.K5712;85;12;@-/6521045 -:;55@5/0-/70453?.04-3955/1.,572/!((!(().5 95=2/70F2=5-;31;2@0457-0521-:;55@5/0
I!
5 82./03 2?0 04-0 8,-./0.11 4-7 @5;5,= 8-.7 - 3?@213(((-00450.@521-:;55@5/0-/7454-7/2 32?;65 21 1?/73 5<5/ 02 8-= 3((((( F4.64 F-3 -:;55702958-.7F.04./2/5@2/041;2@0457-0521045 -:;55@5/0 F4.64 -7@.0057,= 45 4-7 92;;2F57 1;2@ 045 1-045;./,-F214.37-?:405;
I% 4-0045 ;.-,2?;04-75;;57./756;55./:045 3?.0F.042?0-<5;0./:0204535-38560321045@-005; 4-0 5<5/ .1 045 7515/7-/0 4-7 /20 8;2<57 04-0 45 4-<./:
5/05;57 ./02 -:;55@5/0 21
-,5 2/ !I(!!(( F.04 3-7 ?30-1- -/7 -/2045; 045 3-@5 F2?,7 /20 64-/:5 045
- 14 -
3.0?-0.2/./-3@?64-3.0.312;0458,-./0.1102530-9,.344.3 6-352/4.32F/30;5/:04-/7/202/045F5-A/53321045 7515/7-/0 4-0 045 ;5,.51 21 3856.1.6 85;12;@-/65 95./:
5H?.0-9,5 8,-./0.11 6-//20 6,-.@ .0 -3 - @-005; 21 ;.:40 F.042?0 530-9,.34./: 4.3 92/- 1.753 ./ 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0
II 4-0 K!I-/A
0-05@5/0 8;27?657 9= 045 8,-./0.11 .3 21 /2 -<-., ./-3@?64 -3 2/ 045 7-05 1.K57 12; 85;12;@-/65 21 -:;55@5/0 045 3-.7 726?@5/0 ;51,56057 2/,=-<-.,-9.,.0=21-92?03II(./045-/A
?935H?5/0 1?/73./045-/A 662?/0F2?,7/20@550045;5H?.;5@5/0 218,-./0.1195./:;5-7=-/7F.,,./:0285;12;@4.362/0;-60 9512;5 045 85;.27 30.8?,-057 12; 045 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0 42?:4 K!-/A
0-05@5/0 21 4.3 32/ .3 8;27?657 45 4-3 /20 955/ 5K-@./57 3 3?64 045 3-.7 726?@5/06-//2095;5,.57?82/
I 5 3?9@.03 045 <5;= 1-60 04-0 - <5;= 342;0 85;.27 F-3 1.K57 12; 045 85;12;@-/65 21 -:;55@5/0 .5
- 15 -
-92?0 ,533 04-/ 0F2 -/7 4-,1 @2/043 F2?,7 ./7.6-05 045 ?;:5/6= F.04 F4.64 045 7515/7-/0 ;5H?.;57 045 1?/73 02 @5504.3;5H?.;5@5/053?9@.0304-00458,-./0.11 ./4.3 75823.0.2/ 4-3 /20 75/.57 7515/7-/0 5/05;./: ./02 -:;55@5/0 02 8?;64-35 04542?358;285;0= ./.7-; 4-0 -8-;0&I045<5;=F.0/533210458,-./0.114-3-7@.0057 04-07?502/2/8-=@5/0210453-,562/3.75;-0.2/9=045 8,-./0.11045-:;55@5/04-7955/6-/65,,57
/ 3?882;0 21 4.3 62/05/0.2/3 45 ;5,.53 ?82/ 12,,2F./:>?7:@5/03
!
"
"# $ %
;582;057./&'(M
)* $ $+ $ ;582;057./',
-
$
./0 $ ;582;057./!&#'%12'
5/65355A312;7.3@.33-,21045-885-, L 5-;75;?357045;562;73
- 16 -
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
45 7.38?05 .3 2/,= F.04 ;5:-;7 02 8,-./0.11 /20 8-=./:0459-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/213!I(((-/7 290-././: 045 557 21
-,5 -3 -:;557 ./ 05;@3 21 045 -:;55@5/0F.04./04530.8?,-05785;.27.5(!(
) 512;5 -7<5;0./: 02 045 3?9@.33.2/3 21 045 ,5-;/5762?/35,12;0458-;0.53F.04;5:-;702045.33?53./ 62/0;2<5;3=.0.3-88;28;.-0502;515;8-;-:;-842I%21
- 17 -
045 >?7:@5/0 21 045 85K 2?;0 ./ 045 6-35 21 # $ ;5,.57 ?82/ 9= 045 ,5-;/57 62?/35,12;0457515/7-/0-3?/75; 0* 6
"
7
8 ) 8 &
" 5
) ( ( #
+ (
(
9
8 )
8 " 5 ( (
(
* -
(+ *-
(
" 5
* -
&
1
( (
3 */
- 18 -
!( .5F57 ./ 045 ,.:40 21 045 -12;53-.7 8;./6.8,53 045 1-603 21 04.3 6-35 @-A5 .0 6,5-; 04-0 045 8,-./0.11 -/7 045 7515/7-/0 4-7 5/05;57 ./02 -:;55@5/0 7-057 !(%!(( -0 KI F.04 3856.1.6 @.,5302/5 350 72F/ 045;5?/75;F4.64-;5-3?/75;
5
$*+
( '**9
! ( ( '*'*
( :" *
5
(3 &
:" **
- ( 1 ( *
! 45 8,-./0.11 ./ 4.3 -11.7-<.0 1.,57 ./,.5? 21 4.3 5<.75/654-3;5.05;-05704562/05/03210458,-./0 42?:4 -0 8-;-:;-84 2 21 045 -11.7-<.0 5<.75/65 8,-./0.11 4-3 30-057 04-0 2/ 35<5;-, 266-3.2/3 45 4-7 ;5H?53057 045 7515/7-/0 02 ;565.<5 045 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ -@2?/0-/7025K56?05045-932,?057557./4.31-<2?;9= 75,.<5;./: 045 -60?-, -/7 84=3.6-, 8233533.2/ 21 3?.0
- 19 -
8;285;0= /2 3856.1.6 7-053 2; 045 0.@5 21 3?64 75@-/73 @-759=0458,-./0.11-;512;0462@./:
!!
45 05;@3 21 045 -:;55@5/0 -0 KI -3 5K0;-605745;5./-92<5F2?,7./7.6-0504-00458-;0.534-7 -:;557 04-0 045
-,5 557 F2?,7 95 5K56?057 -/7 ;5:.305;572/2;9512;5(!((2/8,-./0.118-=./:045 9-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/213!I((( 45;512;5-3 ;.:40,= 62/05/057 9= ,5-;/57 62?/35, 12; 045 7515/7-/0 .0 F-3 ./6?@95/0 ?82/ 045 8,-./0.11 02 4-<5 3856.1.6-,,= 8,5-757-/78;2<570455112;03@-759=4.@950F55/045 7-05 21 8-=@5/0 21 3((((( -/7 045 30.8?,-057 85;.27.5(!(( 452;-,5<.75/65-3/2057-92<5 210458,-./0.11.362/38.6?2?3,=3.,5/02/04.3-3856021045 @-005;
!%
45 8,-./0.11 4-3 1?;045; 7582357 04-0 -105; 4-<./:F-.05712;3?11.6.5/00.@57538.0535<5;-,;5H?5303 @-75 9= 4.@ 5<5/ 04;2?:4 045 8-/64-3 02 045 -:;55@5/0 045;5 F-3 /2 823.0.<5 ;5382/35 1;2@ 045
- 20 -
7515/7-/0/0456;2335K-@./-0.2/8,-./0.114-37582357 04-0 45 4-7 955/ 02 045 42?35 21 045 7515/7-/0 8;.2; 02 (!((355A./: 4.@ 02 5K56?05 045-932,?0555721 -,5 9= ;565.<./: 045 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 9?0 45 6-//20 3-= 045 -60?-, 7-05 -/7 7-=3 5 4-3 1?;045; 7582357 04-0 45 -,2/5 4-7 955/ 02 045 42?35 21 045 7515/7-/0-3A./:12;5K56?0.2/21
-,55579?0454-7 /20 8-.7 045 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ -@2?/0 02 045 7515/7-/054-3-,32-7@.005704-0454-7/2005/75;57 045 ;5@-././: 9-,-/65 3-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/ 2/ (!(( ?0454-72115;57028-=0453-@542F5<5;045;5.3/2 F.0/53312;0453-@5
!I 454-3 -,32 758235704-0 454-78?0 12;04045 @-005;9512;50458-/64-3-105;!7-=321(!((9?0 045;5.3/2F;.0./:./04-0;5:-;7 4-0456-//203-=-302 F45/ 045 8-/64-3 756,./57 02 ;532,<5 045 7.38?05 ?0 045=4-75K8;53357045.;./-9.,.0=2/35<5;-,266-3.2/
- 21 -
!
54-375/.5704-00457515/7-/04-762/0-6057 4.@ 04;2?:4 045 842/5 02 5K56?05 045
-,5 557 9= ;565.<./:0459-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/54-35K8;53357 4.3.:/2;-/6504-02/(!((7515/7-/04-762@502 4.3<.,,-:5-,2/:F.04 3-7?30-1-
-=57/-=-0 ,.-/7 ,0-@-34 -05, 1;2@ .7-; -/7 2/5 .=-J?77./ 1;2@ -,,.A457 #$ 54-3 75/.5704-07515/7-/0 4-7 955/ 02 4.3 42?35 2/ (!(( F.04 045 3-.7 F.0/53353 -3A./: 4.@028-=0459-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/-/7028-=045 3-,5-@2?/054-3-,328,5-757.:/2;-/65-302F45045; 045-:;55@5/0218?;64-35F-36-/65,,577?5024.3/2/ 8-=@5/021045@2/5=2/045:.<5/7-0554-38,5-757 4.3.:/2;-/65F.04;5:-;7027515/7-/0;53.7./:./-;5/057 42?35 -/7 ./05/7./: 02 8?;64-35 - 42?35 ./ .7-; 9= -,.5/-0./:0453?.08;285;0=54-3-,328,5-757.:/2;-/65 21 45 A/2F./: -92?0 7515/7-/0 5/05;./: ./02 -:;55@5/0 F.04 3-7 ?30-1- F42 8?;64-35 045 42?35 8;285;0= 5 4-3 -,32 8,5-757 .:/2;-/65 -3 02 3-7 ?30-1- 12;15.0./:
- 22 -
3((((( 8-.7 9= 045 7515/7-/0 02F-;73 8-;0 8-=@5/0213-,562/3.75;-0.2/029?=04542?358;285;0=
!L / 1?;045;-/65 02 4.3 6-35 21 ;5-7= -/7 F.,,./:/533 8,-./0.11 4-3 8;27?657 K!I F4.64 .3 045 -/A
0-05@5/0 12; 045 85;.27 950F55/ !(!(( 02 %((L!(( 5;?3-, 21 F4.64 62?,7 ./7.6-05 -3 2/ I(!(( - 7-= 8;.2; 02 045 30.8?,-057 7-05 21 (!(( 045 -@2?/0 ./ 9-,-/65 ;51,56057 ./ 4.3 -/A 662?/0 .3 3III(I ,5-;,= 045;5 .3 /2 -@2?/0 -<-.,-9,5 ./ 045 -/A 662?/0 21 045 8,-./0.11 8;.2; 02 045 7-05 30.8?,-057 12; 045 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0 2F5<5;045;5-885-;3029565;0-./75823.021645H?512; 3 ((((2/(%(!((-/7-@2?/095./:-<-.,-9,5 950F55/ (%(!(( 02 !(!(( ;-/:./: 950F55/ 3 (((023%L((((
! 5;?3-,210452;-,5<.75/65210458,-./0.11F.04 04-021045-12;53-.7726?@5/0-;=5<.75/65F2?,7./7.6-05 04-0 042?:4 045 8,-./0.11 4-7 -,,5:57,= -88;2-6457 045
- 23 -
7515/7-/0 -7@.0057,= 45 4-3 /20 2115;57 02 8-= 045 9-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/
! ?0 21 045 04;55 F.0/53353 5K-@./57 9= 045 8,-./0.11 &% .3 2/5 21 045 -00530./: F.0/53353 02 045 -:;55@5/0-0KI-,3262/3.75;57-3-8-/64- 453-.7 F.0/533./4.375823.0.2/4-3-7@.005704-00457515/7-/0 4-7 62@5 02 4.@ -/7 ./12;@57 04-0 045 8,-./0.11 F-3 /20 8-=./: 045 -@2?/0 -3 -:;557 9= 4.@ -/7 04-0 4.3 0;-/3-60.2/ 21 8?;64-3./: 045 42?35 -0 .7-; F-3 95./: 6-/65,,57 4-0454-7-,3230-05704-0045
4-99.;-05, F-3/2072./:0453?;<5=
!) 5;?3-,21045-12;53-.775823.0.2/21&%F42 .3 045 @-05;.-, F.0/533 8-;0.6?,-;,= ./ <.5F 21 45 95./:
8-/64- ./ 045 -:;55@5/0 F2?,7 ./7.6-05 04-0 045 7515/7-/0 4-7 ./7557 6-;;.57 045 62@8,-./0 21 /2/ 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0 9= 045 8,-./0.11 -/7 4-7 5K8;533574.3:;.5<-/65214.3-:;55@5/095./:6-/65,,57 12;/2/8-=@5/0210453-,562/3.75;-0.2/9=0458,-./0.11
- 24 -
%(
45 <5;= 2F/ <5;3.2/ 21 045 8,-./0.11 -/7 4.3 F.0/533&%F2?,7./7.6-0504-0/25112;03F5;5@-759= 045 8,-./0.11 02 290-./ 045 557 21
-,5 9= 2115;./: 045 9-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/9512;504530.8?,-05785;.2721 -:;55@5/0
% /2045;-3856021045@-005;0295355/.304-0 045/20.65-0KL4-3955/.33?572/ !!(( F4.64 .3 @2;5 04-/ -105; =5-; @2/043 1;2@ 045 7-057 30.8?,-057 12; 85;12;@-/65 21 045 -:;55@5/0 2 F4.385; ./0458,-./0-302-/=5112;0@-759=0458,-./0.117?;./: 04.385;.27 ;58,=020453-.7/20.654-3955/.33?579= 0457515/7-/02/(%(!(() -/7 045 3?.0 4-3 955/1.,57 2/!((!(()
%!
451-603/-;;-057-92<5;5-7./045,.:4021045 8-;-:;-84 2I% 21 >?7:@5/0 21 045 85K 2?;0 ./ 045 6-3521 # $F4-05@5;:53.304-0045 8,-./0.114-3/200-A5/3058312;62@8,50.2/210;-/3-60.2/ -3-:;55754-72/,=8-.7-3@-,,3?@213(((-0
- 25 -
045 0.@5 21 -:;55@5/0 -/7 4-7 8-.7 3((((( 045;5-105;04-00229=92;;2F./:1;2@0451-045;./,-F21 4.37-?:405;-/7454-7/21?/73./4.3-/A 662?/0-3 2/(!((
%% /0452045;4-/78,-./0.114.@35,14-38,5-757 .:/2;-/65 -92?0 7515/7-/0 -88;2-64./: 4.@ F.04 045 F.0/53353 /-@57 ,-./0.11 4-3 /20 3856.1.6-,,= 75/.57 -92?07515/7-/0-88;2-64./:4.@9?04-3@5;5,=8,5-757 .:/2;-/65 4.375823.0.2/;5-7./045,.:402175823.0.2/21 &%217515/7-/062@8,-././:-92?08,-./0.11/20@-A./: 045 8-=@5/0 ./ 0.@5 ;53?,0./: ./ 4.3 -@2?/0 95./: 12;15.057-/./15;5/654-302957;-F/04-00457515/7-/0 F-3 ./7557 ;5-7= 02 5K56?05 045 3-,5 7557 9= ;565.<./: 0459-,-/653-,562/3.75;-0.2/F.04./0450.@530.8?,-057
%I 5;58;27?60.2/21K!342F./:045-@2?/0 -<-.,-9,5./045-662?/0214.332/F2?,7/20953?11.6.5/0 F.042?05K-@././:4.@ 4.3.3./045,.:40210451-6004-0 -662;7./: 02 045 8,-./0.11 45 4-7 5<5/ 92;;2F57
- 26 -
3((((( 1;2@ 045 1-045;./,-F 21 4.3 7-?:405; 1 045-@2?/0F-3 -<-.,-9,5./32/+3 -662?/0045;5 F-3 /2 /55712;4.@024-<592;;2F57045@2/5=1;2@0451-045;
./,-F 21 045 -662?/0 0 F2?,7 ./7.6-05 04-0 045 8,-./0.11 F-3-8-;01;2@/2095./:;5-7=0285;12;@4.38-;021045 62/0;-604-7/21?/73028-=045-@2?/0
%
4-0 045 ;5,.-/65 8,-657 2/ 9= 045 ,5-;/57 62?/35,12;0458,-./0.112/>?7:@5/021045 85K2?;0./ 045 6-35 21 # $ .3 21/2 -<-.,-3 ./ 045 3-.7 6-35 045 8,-./0.11 4-7 8-.7 0F2 04.;7 21 045 62/3.75;-0.2/-00450.@5215K56?0.2/2162/0;-60-/7F-3 ;5H?.;57028-=2/,=0453@-,,-@2?/0210459-,-/653-,5 62/3.75;-0.2/F4.64.3/200456-35-04-/7
%L / 04-0 <.5F 21 045 @-005; 045 ;5-32/3 -/7 62/6,?3.2/3-;;.<57-09=045'.;30 885,,-052?;06-//20 95 12?/7 1-?,0 F.04 45 3?930-/0.-, H?530.2/ 21 ,-F .3 045;512;5-/3F5;57-662;7./:,=
- 27 -
% / <.5F 21 045 -92<5 1./7./:3 -/7 62/6,?3.2/ 04.32?;072/201./7.0/56533-;=0275,<5./02045-38560 21 7515/7-/0 5/05;./: ./02 -:;55@5/0 02 8?;64-35 045 42?35 -/7 045 3-@5 95./: 6-/65,,57 F4.64 .3 ./62/35H?5/0.-,
%
45 '.;30 885,,-05 2?;0 4-3 :;-/057 -,05;/-0.<5 ;5,.51 21 ;51?/7 21 045 -@2?/0 8-.7 9= 045 8,-./0.11020457515/7-/0F.04./05;530-0(G2/3.75;./: 0450.@5F4.64.362/3?@57./045@-005;04.32?;0.321 045 62/3.75;57 <.5F 04-0 045 ./05;530 -@2?/0 7.;56057 02 958-.7-0(G955/4-/65702 G
%) &.04045-92<52935;<-0.2/045>?7:@5/0-/7 2;75;8-33579=045'.;30 885,,-052?;0.362/1.;@57
I(
45-885-,.3
*+ '##( % & .302
,2M