Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92968 (KAR)
LAXUMAN S/O PUNDAIAH BACHA v. SYED AHMED MOIUDDIN QUADRI S/O LATE ZAHURUDDIN
RSA/7127/2012 · 2025-11-27
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92968 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92968 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
##
$%"& '
! "#
! $ %#&# '
#
! (
! ! "&
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
* ! + ! ,** **
$
- $
,$ # !+ '(%
%#''#
,$ +
$
"
'
! + +%#'' #
-,$
$
"
. #'+ ! )
*
,- !,** ! $ %#&# '
- 3 -
,
'',
&''
&&''
, +%
$
"'''#
..#
! *
! ! ('#
, / , 0
! ,
1
+
" *
1
+
23456789 :8;679 23382< 5: => <8?2< @85A: 6B 98B879274 62CDE2727998B879274 6@2A24A2F 2::25<57? 4@8 FD9?E874 279 98;A88 92489 &''
- 4 -
32::89 => ,2:4 A2;G 6DA4% 592A 57 6&&'' 57 A8H8A:57? 4@8 FD9?E874 279 98;A88 92489 "'''# 32::89 =>
A< 5H5< D9?8 *A 7 592A 57
6..# 279 98;A8857? 4@8 :D54 6B 4@8 3<25745BB 4@8A8=> 98;<2A57? 3<25745BB 2: 2=:6<D48 6I78A 279 57 36::8::5676B:D54<279
,6A 4@8 :2G8 6B ;67H87587;8 4@8 32A458: 2A8 A8B8AA89462:38A4@85AA27G=8B6A84@8A52<6DA4
" A58BB2;4:6B4@8;2:82A82:D798A 8B6A8 4@8 A52< 6DA4 4@8 3<25745BB0: ;2:8 I2: 4@24 678
@2@ 5J2ED9957 I2: 4@8 6A5?572< 6I78A 6B 2?A5;D<4DA2<<279=82A57? > 6'E82:DA57?&2;A8:" ?D742: :54D2489 24 @59A5 H5<<2?8 4 I2: :38;5B5;2<<> ;67487989 4@24 @2@ 5J2ED9957 @29 E298 27 6A2< ?5B4 *@5=257B2H6DA6B4@83<25745BB57A8:38;46B"?D742:6D4 6B 4@8 :259 <279 I@5;@ 36A4567 76I B6AE: 4@8 :D54 3A638A4> @8 3<25745BB BDA4@8A 2::8A489 4@24 4@8 :D54 3A638A4> ;67:5:4: 6B 2 2J2A 279 2 45<89 @6D:8 279 4@24 3DA:D274 46 4@8 6A2< ?5B4 @8 @2: =887 57 8C;<D:5H8
- 5 -
36::8::5676B4@8:2593A638A4>@83<25745BB2<:6;<25E89 4@24 57 4@8 >82A .&. D367 H8A5B5;24567 6B 4@8 A8H87D8 A8;6A9: @8 7645;89 4@24 4@8 72E8 6B 678 2: 6
5992332 @29 =887 ED42489 57 4@8 A8;6A9 6B A5?@4: 57 A8:38;46B4@88745A8<27957;<D957?4@8:D543A638A4>8H87 4@6D?@ 2: @29 3DA;@2:89 67<> & 2;A8: 2:89 67 4@8 2<<8?896A2<?5B44@83<25745BB2::8A489454<86H8A"?D742:
279 57:454D489 4@8 3A8:874 :D54 :88G57? 2 98;<2A24567 6B 2=:6<D48 6I78A:@53 279 2 ;67:8KD87452< 98;A88 6B 38A384D2< 57FD7;4567 A8:4A25757? 4@8 98B879274: BA6E 5748AB8A57?I54@@5:36::8::567
@8 6A5?572< 98B879274: 8748A89 23382A27;8 D367 :8AH5;8 6B :DEE67: 279 B5<89 4@85A IA54487 :4248E874 987>57? 4@8 8745A8 ;2:8 6B 4@8 3<25745BB ;;6A957? 46 4@8 98B879274:
> 6' 6A5?572<<> E82:DA89.2;A8:"?D742:D46B4@242;A8?D742:
I2: 2;KD5A89 => 4@8 5A ,6A;8 D4@6A54> @8 A8E25757? 8C4874 2;;6A957?
46 4@8 98B879274: I2: 2<5872489 =>
@2@ 5J2ED995757B2H6DA6B2:D798A2A8?5:48A89:2<8
- 6 -
9889 6B .( 2: 5: :42489 46 @2H8 :D=:8KD874<> ;67H8>894@88745A8A8E25757?8C48746B&2;A8:"?D742: 57B2H6DA6B4@86A5?572<98B879274:@D:4@898B879274: ;67487989 4@24 4@8 3<25745BB @29 7854@8A 454<8 76A 36::8::567 # @8A52<6DA4BA2E895::D8:27938AE544894@8 32A458: 46 <829 6A2< 279 96;DE8742A> 8H5987;8 367 ;67:598A245674@8A52<6DA427:I8A89::D8 6:279 57 4@8 78?245H8 @6<957? 4@24 4@8 3<25745BB @29 B25<89 46 8:42=<5:@454<8 6A36::8::567 6H8A4@8 :D54 <279 E82:DA57? " ?D742: 67:8KD874<> 4@8 5::D8 A8?2A957? 2<<8?89 5748AB8A87;8I2:2<:627:I8A892?257:44@83<25745BB@5<8 9657?:64@8A52<6DA4A8<58967C
%'4@8:2<89889 8C8;D489=>4@86A5?572<6I78A279@8<94@24:57;82;A8 ?D742: @29 =887 2;KD5A89 => 4@8 5A ,6A;8 D4@6A54> 2794@8A8E25757?&2;A8::6<9462:4@83<25745BB0:;<25E 6B 27 6A2< ?5B4 ;6D<9 764 :4279 @8 6DA4 2<:6 76489 4@8 3<25745BB0:29E5::56757;A6::%8C2E57245674@244@86A5?572< 8C4874 6B > 6' I2: . 2;A8: " ?D742: 8B8AA57? 46
- 7 -
4@8 A8?5:48A89 :2<8 9889: 57 B2H6DA 6B 2: 279 :D=:8KD874<>4@898B879274:4@8A52<6DA4@8<94@244@8 2<<8?896A2<?5B4*C
%959764;67B8A27>H2<59454<8@8 :D54I2:2;;6A957?<>95:E5::89
@8,5A:4338<<2486DA467A8233A25:2<6B4@8 8745A88H5987;8A8H8A:894@8FD9?E8746B4@8A52<6DA4 4 2<<6I89 4@8 23382< 67 4@8 A82:6757? 4@24 :57;8 98B879274 6I2:2::8A457?454<827936::8::5676H8A27 8C48748C;88957?&2;A8:5478;8::2A5<>B6<<6I894@244@8 3<25745BB ED:4 @2H8 454<8 6H8A 4@8 L8C;8:: 8C4874M 6B " ?D742: 7 4@5: =2:5: 4@8 338<<248 6DA4 98;A889 4@8 :D54 98;<2A57? 4@8 3<25745BB 46 =8 4@8 6I78A 6B " ?D742:
279 ?A27457? ;67:8KD87452< A8<58B: @8 98B879274: 76I A83A8:87489 => 4@85A <8?2< @85A: @2H8 3A8B8AA89 4@8 3A8:874:8;67923382<;@2<<87?57?4@8A8H8A:2< ( @5: 6DA4 29E54489 4@8 :8;679 23382< 279 BA2E894@8B6<<6I57?:D=:427452<KD8:4567:6B<2I
- 8 -
! " # $
%
$
"
& &"
"
&
"%'
()*()+),-.,/0)/(012-3,/(),(0)*(( & 8B6A84@5:6DA498<H8:57464@8E2448A57H58I 454<8 96;DE874: 3A69D;89 => =64@ 32A458: 4@5: 6DA4 988E:54B5446;D<<6D44@8B<6I6B454<8;@2A4I@5;@I6D<9 872=<84@5:6DA4462:;8A4257I@84@8A4@86A5?572<6I78A
@2@ 5J2ED9957 @29 A8425789 27> 36A4567 67 3A638A4> =82A57? > 6'@8;@2A45:2:D798A
- 9 -
> 6'*.2;A8:"?D742:
A5?572<6I78A* @2@ 5J2ED9957
5A,6A;82D4@6A54>2;KD5A892;A8?D742:
*H598C% %8KD5:5456746@2796H8A2;KD5A89<279=> 5A,6A;82D4@6A54>
8E25757?8C4874&2;A8:?D742:
&2;A8::6<946 2:*H598C
%'92489'(' .(
2::6<9462CE27*B24@8A6B98B879274:
*&2;A8:"?D742:H598C
%92489'('.((
. @8 3<25745BB 5: 4A2;57? 454<8 4@A6D?@ 6A5?572< 6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9957 46 4@8 8C4874 6B " ?D742:
<25745BB 5:2::8A457?4@246A5?572<6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9957 @2:6A2<<>?5B489"?D742:6B:259<279B6<<6I89=>2:2<8 9889574@8>82A.."@8B<6I;@2A4I@5;@5:8C4A2;489 :D3A2 95:;<6:8: 4@24 2?A5;D<4DA2< <279 =82A57? > 6' 6A5?572<<> E82:DA89 . 2;A8: " ?D742: 8B879274: =>
- 10 -
3<2;57?
A8<527;8 67 C% 2A8 2=<8 46 98E67:4A248 4@24 4@8 5A%B6A;8 2D4@6A54> 2;KD5A89 2;A8 ?D742:
@8A8B6A8 2B48A 2;KD5:54567 @2@ 5J2ED9957 A8425789 2 36A4567E82:DA57?&2;A8:?D742:@8A8=D442<8H5987;8 <259=>98B879274 62<:6A8H82<:4@24 @2@ 5J2ED9957 2<5872489&2;A8:6B<27957B2H6DA6B 2:D798A4@8 A8?5:48A89:2<8988992489'(' .(24C%
'2:57 4DA7@6I8H8A;67H8>89 DAH8> 6'E82:DA57?&2;A8:
"?D742:4@6D?@@293DA;@2:8967<>&2;A8:
' @8338<<2486DA43A6=2=<>?64:I2>892I2> =>4@8:2<898896=425789=>98B879274 62CDE2746 278C48746B&2;A8:"?D742:I@87@5:H8796A2:@29 3DA;@2:89 67<> & 2;A8: 4 5: 3A6=2=<> 57 4@5: ;6748C4 338<<248 6DA4 @2: H874DA89 57 8C2E5757? 4@8 454<8 6B 98B879274 6279I@5<89657?:64@8338<<2486DA4@2:
3A6;88989 46 @6<9 4@24 B5A:4 98B8792741: H8796A 72E8<> 2: @29 3DA;@2:89 67<> & 2;A8: 279 4@8A8B6A8 @8 ;6D<9 764@2H8:6<9&2;A8:"?D742:
- 11 -
@8 338<<248 6DA4 3A6=2=<> @2: E5:A829 4@8 8745A8 8H5987;8 67 A8;6A9 4@6D?@ 98B879274: E2> 764 @2H82;KD5A89454<846278C48746B&2;A8:"?D742:I@5<8 6=425757? 4@8 :2<8 9889 BA6E 2: 6I8H8A 4@8 ;6A8 KD8:4567 I@5;@ A8KD5A89 244874567 6B 4@8 338<<248 6DA4 I2: I@84@8A 4@8 6A5?572< 6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9957 @29 A842578927>36A45676B4@8<27957H58I6B2;KD5:545676B 2;A8?D742:=>4@85A%B6A;82D4@6A54>279272<58724567 57B2H6DA6B2:46278C48746B&2;A8:B48A989D;457? 2;A8?D742:2;KD5A89=>5A%B6A;82D4@6A54>279&2;A8:
3DA;@2:89 => 2: I@24 I6D<9 A8E257 5: ?D742: 64@ 4@832A458:57D78KD5H6;2<48AE:29E544@244@8A8E25757? ?D742:5:22J2AI@8A84@8A82A8=DA52<:2794@8A85: 6786<9A66E@8A8B6A86A5?572<6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9@57 @29 764 24 2<< A8425789 27> 36A4567 57 > 6' @2H57? 2<5872489 4@8 =2<27;8 8C4874 6B & 2;A8: 2B48A 4@8 2;KD5:54567 => 4@8 25A36A4 2D4@6A5458: @8 :2<8 9889 6=425789 => 2: H598 C%
' ;<82A<> 98E67:4A2484@24
@2@ 5J2ED9957244@8E6:4I2:5736::8::5676B4@8
- 12 -
?D742: 6B 2J2A I@5;@ ;27764 =8 2<5872489 57 H58I 6B 4@8A8 =857? 2 2J2A 57 4@8 :259 ?D742: @8A8B6A8 6A5?572< 6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9957 ;6D<9 764 @2H8 6A2<<> ;67H8>89"?D742:57 > 6' 7 4@8 =2;G?A6D79 6B 4@8:8 :5?75B5;274 98425<: 4@5:6DA47889:468C2E578I@84@8A4@8338<<2486DA4 @2: E5:A829 4@8 454<8 96;DE874: 3A69D;89 => =64@ 4@8 32A458: 279 I@84@8A 4@8 338<<248 6DA4 @2: 29@8A89 46 4@8E2792483A6H5989D798AA98AD<8"'279"6B
" 4 5: :844<89 3A57;53<8 6B <2I 4@24 57 :D54 B6A 98;<2A245676B6I78A:@534@8=DA987:KD2A8<><58:674@8 3<25745BB 46 8:42=<5:@ @5: 454<8 46 4@8 :D54 3A638A4> 279 @8 ED:4:D;;889674@8:4A87?4@6B@5:6I7;2:827976467 4@8I82G78::6B4@898B8792741:;2:8@838C6DA4572 <279E2AG FD9?E874 A8798A89 57 4@8 ;2:8 6B
@2: ;<82A<>@8<94@2423<25745BB:88G57?98;<2A245676B454<8ED:4 8:42=<5:@4@24@8@2: 2 H2<59279 2 :D=:5:457? 454<846 4@8
- 13 -
3A638A4> @8 =DA987 6B 3A66B 57 2 98;<2A24567 :D54 5:
2<I2>: 67 4@8 3<25745BB @8 B25<DA8 6B 98B879274 46 8:42=<5:@@5:454<8968:7642D46E245;2<<>A8:D<457298;A88 57B2H6DA6B3<25745BB 74@83A8:874;2:84@8D795:3D489B2;4:A8H82< 4@24 5 @8 6A5?572< 6I78A @2@ 5J2ED9957 @8<9 .
2;A8:"?D742: 55 D46B4@5:2;A8?D742:I2:2;KD5A89=> 4@85A%B6A;82D4@6A54> 555 7 8C4874 6B & 2;A8: I2: :6<9 D798A 2 A8?5:48A89:2<89889462: 5H BDA4@8A 36A4567 6B ?D742: 5: 29E54489<> 6;;D3589=>22J2A279276<9:4AD;4DA8 # 4 5: 4A548 <2I 4@24 D798A 8;4567 ( 6B 4@8 A27:B8A6B
A638A4>;4&&67<>238A:67L;6E384874 46 ;674A2;4 279 87454<89 46 4A27:B8A2=<8 3A638A4> 6A
- 14 -
2D4@6A5:894695:36:86B54764@5:6I7M;27E2G82H2<59 4A27:B8A,DA4@8A 8;4567&3A6H598:4@2424A27:B8A32::8:
46 4@8 4A27:B8A88 2<< 4@8 5748A8:4 I@5;@ 4@8 4A27:B8A6A 5:
4@87 ;232=<8 6B 32::57? 57 4@8 3A638A4> 279 57 4@8 <8?2< 57;59874:4@8A86B@D:4@8;6E38487;>6B4@84A27:B8A6A 5: 9848AE5789 2: 67 4@8 9248 6B 4A27:B8A 279 67;8 27 6I78A@2:2<5872489@5:8745A85748A8:4@8;82:8:46@2H8 27> A5?@4 454<8 6A 5748A8:4 46 ;67H8> :D=:8KD874<> I@84@8A=>:2<8?5B46A64@8AI5:8 7 4@8 3A8:874 ;2:8 4@8 8H5987;8 ;<82A<> 95:;<6:8: 4@24 @2@ 5J2ED9957 @2H57? :6<9 & 2;A8: 6B <279462:2792BDA4@8A2;A8?D742:@2H57?=887 2;KD5A89 => 4@8 5A%B6A;8 2D4@6A54> =8:598: ?D742:
B6AE57? 32A4 6B 2 2J2A @29 764 A8425789 27> 36A4567 6B 4@86A5?572<.2;A8:"?D742:67:8KD874<>@8I2:764 ;6E384874 57 <2I 46 8BB8;4 27> 4A27:B8A 6A2< 6A IA54487 4@8A82B48A57A8:38;46B4@82<<8?89A8:59D2<"?D742:
( @8 <2I 5: I8<< :844<89 4@24 76 38A:67 ;27 4A27:B8A 2 =8448A 454<8 4@27 @8 @5E:8<B 36::8::8:
- 15 -
87;23:D<2489574@8E2C5EL78E6924KD69767@2=84M7
!" # $ %&' ( 4@8670=<8 D3A8E86DA4@8<94@24 (
&"
"
"
' & 5E5<2A<>57) ' *(+ (4@8 D3A8E86DA4A8548A24894@24 #
" "
" &)
&""
' . 7 ) %", - . &&
%
/0'** 114@86DA4BDA4@8A 6=:8AH89 4@24 67<> 2 38A:67 @2H57? 3A8:874 :D=:5:457? 454<8 ;27 8BB8;4 2 H2<59 4A27:B8A D798A 4@8 A27:B8A 6B A638A4>;4
- 16 -
' 33<>57?4@8:8:844<89 3A57;53<8: 54 5:E275B8:4 4@2467;8 @2@ 5J2ED995732A489I54@@5:8745A85748A8:4 574@83A638A4>@8I2:95H8:4896B6I78A:@53279;82:89 46 =8 L2 38A:67 87454<89 46 4A27:B8A2=<8 3A638A4>M D798A
8;4567 ( @8 2<<8?89 6A2< ?5B4 57 B2H6DA 6B 4@8 3<25745BB 8H875B2::DE8946=8E2985:4@8A8B6A8H6592=5754562: 54 8E272489 BA6E 678 I@6 <2;G89 4@8 A8KD5:548 ;6E38487;82796I78A:@53464A27:B8A @D:4@88745A84>6B4@8<279:4279:2;;6D7489 B6A 7;8 54 5: :@6I7 4@24 4@8 4642< 8C4874 6B . 2;A8: " ?D742:I2:854@8A:6<92;KD5A896A6;;D3589=>22J2A 76 A8:59D2< 8C4874 6B " ?D742: A8E25789 I54@ @2@ 5J2ED995746?5B46A;67H8>464@83<25745BB: @82<<8?896A2<?5B45:2<:6764:D=:427452489=> 27> ;6?874 8H5987;8 4@8A8 5: 76 A8;6A9 6B 98<5H8A> 6B 36::8::567 76 ;6AA6=6A2457? I5478::8: 46 4@8 98;<2A24567 6B?5B427976ED4245676AA8H87D8874A>A8;6?75J57?4@8 :2E8
- 17 -
" @8 338<<248 6DA4 4@8A8B6A8 ;6EE54489 2 :8A56D: 8AA6A 57 3A8:DE57? 454<8 57 B2H6DA 6B 4@8 3<25745BB E8A8<> =8;2D:8 4@8 98B879274: ;<25E89 36::8::567 57 8C;8:: 6B & 2;A8:
D;@ A82:6757? 5: ;674A2A> 46 :844<89 3A57;53<8: 6B <2I 279 2E6D74: 46 38AH8A:54> 2: 54 8BB8;45H8<> :@5B4: 4@8 =DA987 6B 3A66B BA6E4@8 3<25745BB 46 4@898B879274 ,6A 4@8 B6A8?657?
A82:67: 4@5: 6DA4 5: 6B 4@8 ;67:598A89H58I4@244@8FD9?E87427998;A886B4@8,5A:4 338<<248 6DA4 2A8 I@6<<> D7:D:42572=<8 57 <2I 279 67 B2;4: @8 338<<248 6DA4 @2: B25<89 46 233A8;5248 4@8 :844<89 <8?2< 3A57;53<8: ?6H8A757? :D54: B6A 98;<2A24567 6B 454<8 279 54: B57957?: 2A8 H5452489 => 38AH8A:54> B6A 4@8 B6<<6I57?A82:67:
*5 @8 338<<248 6DA4 8AA6786D:<> :@5B489 4@8 =DA987 6B 3A66B 6746 4@8 98B879274: => 3A8:DE57? 4@24 4@8 3<25745BB @29 454<8 E8A8<> =8;2D:8 4@8 98B879274: ;<25E89 36::8::567 6H8A 27 8C4874 8C;88957? & 2;A8:
D;@ 27 233A62;@ 5: 95A8;4<>
- 18 -
;674A2A> 46 4@8 :844<89 <2I 4@24 4@8 3<25745BB ED:4 :D;;889674@8:4A87?4@6B@5:6I7454<827976467 4@8I82G78::6B4@898B8792740:;2:8 *55 @8 338<<248 6DA4 ;6E3<848<> 5?76A89 4@8 D795:3D489 96;DE8742A> 8H5987;8 I@5;@ ;<82A<> 8:42=<5:@89 4@24 4@8 8745A8 8C4874 6B . 2;A8: " ?D742::46692;;6D7489B6A2;A8?D742:4@A6D?@ 2;KD5:54567 => 4@8 5A ,6A;8 & 2;A8: 4@A6D?@ 2 A8?5:48A89:2<8988957B2H6DA6B2:279?D742: ;6E3A5:57?22J2A279276<9:4AD;4DA87;84@8:8 B2;4::46693A6H894@8H8A>B6D79245676B4@82<<8?89 6A2< ?5B4 ;6<<23:89 2: 76 <279 A8E25789 I54@ 4@8 4A27:B8A6A *555 @8 338<<248 6DA4 B25<89 46 233<> 8;4567: ( 279 & 6B 4@8 A27:B8A 6B
A638A4> ;4 && 279 6H8A<66G89 4@8 =57957? 3A57;53<8: <259 96I7 => 4@8 670=<8 D3A8E86DA457 )
279 )%",*:D3A2I@5;@D78KD5H6;2<<> @6<9 4@24 2 4A27:B8A6A I@6 @2: 95H8:489 @5E:8<B 6B
- 19 -
6I78A:@53 5: 764 ;6E384874 46 8BB8;4 27> BDA4@8A 4A27:B8A@82<<8?896A2<?5B44@8A8B6A8I2:H6592= 575456 *5H@8338<<2486DA40:;67;<D:5674@244@83<25745BB @293A6H89454<85:D7:D336A489=>27>29E5::5=<86A ;6?874 8H5987;8 7 B2;4 4@8A8 5: 76 8H5987;8 6B 98<5H8A>6B36::8::56776;6AA6=6A2457?I5478::8:46 4@8 2<<8?89 6A2< ?5B4 279 76 ED424567 6A A8H87D8 874A>A8;6?75J57? 54 @8 338<<248 6DA40: B57957? 5:
4@8A8B6A8 :38;D<245H8 ;674A2A> 46 4@8 A8;6A9 279 38AH8A:8 *H @8 338<<248 6DA4 @2: 5?76A89 4@8 ;248?6A5;2< 29E5::567: 8<5;5489 57 4@8 ;A6::%8C2E5724567 6B 4@8 3<25745BB2:I8<<2:4@8A8?5:48A8996;DE874:B6AE57? 4@8;@2576B454<82<<6BI@5;@3657489462;6E3<848 2=:87;86B27>A8:59D2<8C48744@24;6D<9@2H8=887 ?5B489464@83<25745BB
- 20 -
*H5 7 <5?@4 6B 4@8 2=6H8 ?<2A57? 57B5AE5458: 4@5:
6DA4 5: ;67:4A25789 46@6<9 4@24 4@8 B57957?: 6B 4@8 ,5A:4 338<<248 6DA4 :DBB8A BA6E 38AH8A:54> 2A8 ;674A2A>464@896;DE8742A>8H5987;867A8;6A9279 2A8=2:8967278AA6786D:A8H8A:2<6B4@8=DA9876B 3A66B @8 FD9?E874 279 98;A88 6B 4@8 338<<248 6DA4;27764=8:D:425789 # ,A6E 2=6H8 54 5: :887 4@24 4@8 B57957? 6B 4@8 338<<248 6DA4 4@24 4@8 3<25745BB @2: 8:42=<5:@89 @5: 454<8 6H8A4@8"?D742:6B<2795:38AH8A:832<32=<>8AA6786D: 279;674A2A>46454<896;DE874:;;6A957?<>36574765:
27:I8A8957/
2279365747657400"
2 ,6A4@8B6A8?657?A82:67:4@5:6DA432::8:4@8 B6<<6I57?
- 21 -
5 @8 ;23456789 8;679 3382< B5<89 => 4@8 <8?2< @85A: 6B 98B879274 6 N 2CDE27 279 98B879274 6 N @2A24A2F ;2<<57? 57KD8:45674@8FD9?E87427998;A8892489 &''32::89=>4@8,2:4A2;G6DA4% 592A 57 6&&'' 5: @8A8=> /3
55 @8FD9?E87427998;A8892489&'' 32::89 => 4@8 ,2:4 A2;G 6DA4% 592A 57 6&&''5::842:598 555 @8FD9?E87427998;A8892489"'''# 32::89 => 4@8
A57;532< 5H5< D9?8 *D756A 5H5:567 592A 57 6..# 5: A8:46A89 5H 2A458:46=82A4@85AA8:38;45H8;6:4:
*% $&
"
5:4 6" < 6