Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92965 (KAR)

MALLESH @ MALLIKARJUN S/O SURYAKANTH BIRADAR v. SHANKARLINGAYYA S. HIREMATH AND ANR

MFA/202548/2019 · 2025-11-13

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$% &!'!(!! !!(( )$* + ! "# $%$& ' " # ( % $% )* $%+& ( (( (+!$ $%+& ' " (, (# Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( -!"#( ( &&%& + &% ( $-!&& +. / &&& . ( 0 ' 1234556472382769:;<16=742>4?<4@42?3<<16 AB9@>6?< 4?9 4C4D9 94<69 &&%& 543369 :; <16 992<2E?476?2ED2F27B9@64?9 474:BD4@2G8ED 31ED< HD2:B?47IJ 2? E+ &% 366K2?@ 6?14?=6>6?<E8=E>56?34<2E? 16 2?ABD69 =742>4?< 4@69 ;64D3 >6< C2<1 4? 4==296?< E? &- 4?9 3B3<42?69 @D26FEB3 2?ABD263 16 =742>4?< 82769 4 =742> 56<2<2E? :68ED6 <16 D2:B?47 366K2?@ =E>56?34<2E? E8 3&&&&& 16 D2:B?47 48<6D =E?3296D2?@ <16 6?<2D6 6F296?=6 E? D6=ED9 4C4D969 <16 =E>56?34<2E? E8 3$-!&& C2<1 2?<6D63< 4<+.56D4??B>8DE><1694<6E856<2<2E?<277D6472L4<2E? - 3 - 16 D2:B?47 92D6=<69 D635E?96?< E M EC?6D E8 <16 F612=76 <E 54; <16 =E>56?34<2E? 4?9 6NE?6D4<69 D635E?96?< E ?3BD4?=6 E>54?; 8DE> 2<3 724:272<; @@D26F69 :; <16 3429 4C4D9 <16 4556774?<=742>4?< 143 5D686DD69<123455647 ! 64D94D@B>6?<3E8477<1654D<2634?956DB369 <16>4<6D24734F4274:76E?D6=ED9 / < 23 <16 >42? =E?<6?<2E? E8 <16 4556774?<=742>4?<<14<<16D2:B?471434C4D969>64@D6 =E>56?34<2E? B?96D 477 16493 64D?69 =EB?367 8ED <16 4556774?<=742>4?< 3B:>2<<69 <14< <16 =742>4?< C43 64D?2?@ 3$&&& 56D >E?<1 :B< <16 D2:B?47 C2<1EB< 4?;:4323143<4K6?<162?=E>64<3 &&&56D>E?<1 6=E?<6?969<14<<16E=<ED14343363369!$.9234:272<; <E <16 C1E76 :E9; :B< <16 D2:B?47 6DD69 2? <4K2?@ E?7; . 9234:272<; 4?9 <1B3 D6OB63<69 8ED 6?14?=2?@ <16 =E>56?34<2E?2?12384FEBD - 4 - $ < 23 3B:>2<<69 :; <16 764D?69 =EB?367 8ED D635E?96?< E M EC?6D E8 <16 F612=76 <14< <16 =E>56?34<2E?4C4D969:;<16D2:B?4723AB3<4?95DE56D C12=1 ?6693 ?E 2?<6D86D6?=6 6 8BD<16D 5D4;3 4? ED96D 8EDH54;4?9D6=EF6DI + 356DN$MEB?96D<282=4<6<16=742>4?< 1433B3<42?69<168E77EC2?@2?ABD263 ?3B55ED<E8123=436=742>4?<6N4>2?69<16E=<ED 43 C1E E:36DF69 <14< <16 =742>4?< 149 3B3<42?69 <D4B>4<2= :D42? 2?ABD; 4?9 2?ABD; <E 768< 76@ :76692?@ 74=6D4<69CEB?93EF6D3=4754?9EF6D768<76@4?94356D 3=4?E8:D42?4?9ND4;3163B3<42?69=E?<B32E?2? <1474>B3 2? 47E?@ 56D2>636?=651472= =23<6D? 4?9 - 5 - <6?<ED247764876<34?92?<D4F6?<D2=B74D16>EDD14@64?9<14< <16=742>4?<C43923=14D@692?3<4:76=E?92<2E?6233B69 N- M 234:272<; 6D<282=4<6 3<4<2?@ !$. 9234:272<; <E 6?<2D6 :E9; 16 D2:B?47 =E?3296D69 ! E8 !$. ! .438B?=<2E?479234:272<;123EBD<82?93?ED643E?<E 2?<6D86D6C2<1<16342982?92?@3 - 1EB@1 <16 =742>4?< 3<4<63 <14< 16 C43 64D?2?@3$&&&56D>E?<116143?E<5DE9B=694?; 9E=B>6?< <E 5DEF6 <16 34>6 3 <16 4==296?< 23 E8 <16 ;64D&-4356D<16=14D<233B69:;<16 4D?4<4K4<4<6 6@47 6DF2=63 B<1ED2<; <123 EBD< 966>3 2< 455DE5D24<6 <ED6433633<162?=E>6E8<16=742>4?<4<3&$&56D >E?<1 43 4@42?3< 3 &&& 43363369 :; <16 D2:B?47 ==ED92?@7; <16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<769 8ED 7E33 E8 8B<BD6 64D?2?@43B?96D 3&$&NN%N.P3+$+%& % 16 =742>4?< C43 49>2<<69 2? <16 1E352<47 8ED -94;3E?3296D2?@<1656D2E9E81E352<472L4<2E??4<BD6 - 6 - E8 2?ABD263 4?9 E<16D D676F4?< 84=<ED3 <123 EBD< 82?93 2< AB3< 4?9 D643E?4:76 <E 4C4D9 4? 4>EB?< E8 3-$&&& 8ED 542? 4?9 3B886D2?@ 3!&&&& 8ED 7E33 E8 4>6?2<263 4?93!&&&&8ED<D4?35ED<4<2E?6N<D4?EBD231>6?<4?9 4<<6?94?< =14D@63 (BD<16D 9B6 <E 2?ABD263 <16 =742>4?< >2@1<?E<14F64<<6?9694?;CEDK4<7643<8ED456D2E9E8/ >E?<13 16?=6 <123 EBD< 82?93 2< D643E?4:76 <E 4C4D9 3/&&& 8ED 7E33 E8 2?=E>6 9BD2?@ 7429 B5 56D2E9 EC6F6D <16 =E>56?34<2E? E8 3&$&& 4C4D969:; <16D2:B?478ED>692=476N56?363?6693?E2?<6D86D6?=6 16 =E>56?34<2E? 4C4D969 :; <16 D2:B?47 23 >E92826943B?96D 7 E 6493 C4D9:;<16 D2:B?47 C4D9:;<123 EBD< 42?4?93B886D2?@ 3!$&&& 3-$&&& 692=47N56?363 3&$&& 3&$&& ! E33 E8 8B<BD6 64D?2?@=454=2<; 3!!!&& 3+$+%& / D4?35ED<4<2E? 6N<D4 ?EBD231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?<=14D@63 3%$&& 3!&&&& - 7 - $ E33E84>6?2<263 3&&&& 3!&&&& + E33 E8 2?=E>6 9BD2?@ 7429 B5 56D2E9 3%&&& 3/&&& E<47 3$-!&& 3+//%& 16D6C277:66?14?=6>6?<E83+%%& & E9EB:<<16D2:B?47143D2@1<7;E:36DF69<14< <16 9D2F6D E8 <16 F612=76 C43 ?E< 1E792?@ F4729 D2F2?@ 2=6?=6 43 E? <16 94<6 E8 4==296?< 4?9 43 3B=1 <16D6 23 F2E74<2E? E8 <16 <6D>3 4?9 =E?92<2E?3 E8 <16 E72=; 4?9 16?=6 6NE?6D4<69 <16 D635E?96?< E ?3BD4?=6 E>54?;8DE>2<3724:272<;4?992D6=<69D635E?96?<EM EC?6D E8 <16 F612=76 <E 54; <16 =E>56?34<2E? B< D635E?96?< E 143 ?E< 965E32<69 <16 =E>56?34<2E? 6?=6 D67;2?@ E? <16 AB9@>6?<E8<1656N EBD< 2? <16 =436 E8 D635E?96?< E M ?3BD4?=6 E>54?; 23 92D6=<69 <E 54; <16 =E>56?34<2E? <E <16 =742>4?< 4< <16 82D3< 2?3<4?=6 4?9 <16D648<6DD6=EF6D<1634>68DE>D635E?96?<E 1 "&%#!&% - 8 - ?<16D63B7<<168E77EC2?@ED96D23543369 "2# 5564723 "22# 16=742>4?< 236?<2<7698ED<16<E<47 =E>56?34<2E?E83+//%&C2<12?<6D63<4< +.56D4??B>8DE><1694<6E856<2<2E?<277<16 94<6E8D6472L4<2E? "222# 635E?96?< E M ?3BD4?=6 E>54?; 23 92D6=<69 <E 965E32< <16 48ED63429 =E>56?34<2E?4>EB?<47E?@C2<12?<6D63<C2<12? E?6>E?<18DE><1694<6E8<123AB9@>6?<4?9 23 4< 72:6D<; <E D6=EF6D <16 34>6 8DE> D635E?96?<E "2F# ? 3B=1 965E32< <16 =742>4?< 23 56D>2<<69<EC2<19D4C<166?<2D64>EB?<47E?@ C2<12?<6D63<4==DB69E?2< ,-. )(!! * ' 23<E7E!!