Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92960 (KAR)
ARUN v. DEVENAGOUDA AND ANR
MFA/201317/2024 · 2025-11-10
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92960 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92960 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$%! &# '"( #&#
'"( #$(%""$ #"#&&"
)%* +
!"#$
% &
'
"
#
("
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
!"#" %
&
)* # "##
"
'
)
)
"+,&"' ) -
)
)
"!""#,
. !#" )
)
/
)
)
0
0
"( &0
'
" 123 455647 89:6; 6<=2>9 "+,&"' >? >=>; 612<763 <= "$ &16;6294?=6; ;6?6;;6: => 43 @=16 <=A' 143 B669 ?276: BC =16 <742D49= <147769E29E =16 F8:ED69= :4=6:
"!""#,54336:BC=16;29<2547692>;2G27 8:E649: 6DB6;2F4C458;429>!#"
- 3 -
)4<=3 E2G29E ;236 => =16 ?2729E >? =16 455647 B;26?7C 3=4=6:4;6=14=>9"""#"!4=4B>8=#!(5D964; =16 749: >? >96 ;2 1858; >9 4;=4:>92 <;>33 => 6:49458; ;>4: H2=129 =16 72D2=3 >? 29E438E8; >72<6 =4=2>9=16<742D49=47>9EH2=1123?;269:>96949:14: B669=;4G67729E?;>D6:29458;=>>;474B69<122774E6>9 4 D>=>;<C<76 B64;29E 6E23=;4=2>9 >.#,." " = =14= =2D6 =16 :;2G6; >? 4 ;4<=>; 49: ;4276; B64;29E 6E23=;4=2>9 >.,!.($$!.($$+ <4D6 4= 4 12E1 3566:49:294;43149:96E72E69=D4996;49::4316:=16 D>=>;<C<76 3 4 ;6387= >? =16 4?>;6342: 4<<2:69= =16 <742D49=383=4296:E;26G>8329F8;26349:H431>352=472I6:
, 16<742D49=?276:456=2=2>989:6;6<=2>9"!!>?=16 <=366J29E<>D56934=2>9
=H435764:6:=14=163569= 32E92?2<49=4D>89==>H4;:3D6:2<476K569363<>9G6C49<6 <14;E63 49: >=16; ;674=6: <>3=3
= H43 ?8;=16; 5764:6:
=14= =16 4<<2:69= ><<8;;6: 3>767C >9 4<<>89= >? ;431 49: 96E72E69=:;2G29E>?=16>??69:29EG612<76BC2=3:;2G6;
- 4 -
( 5>9 36;G2<6 >? 9>=2<6 =16 ;635>9:69= >3" 49:
45564;6: =1;>8E1 <>89367 49: ?276: H;2==69 3=4=6D69= :69C29E=164G6;D69=3D4:629=16<742D56=2=2>9
9 =16 B4323 >? =16 5764:29E3 >? =16 54;=263 =16 742D3;2B8947?;4D6:=1623386349:=16;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=16 6G2:69<6 16 ;2B8947 BC 2D58E96: F8:ED69= 49: 4H4;:14354;=7C477>H6:=16<742D56=2=2>949:167:=14= =16<742D49=2369=2=76:=>4<>D56934=2>9>?3#+$##. 47>9EH2=129=6;63=4==16;4=6>?!L5449:167:=14==16 ;635>9:69=>3"49:4;6F>29=7C49:36G6;477C724B76=> 54C <>D56934=2>9 4D>89= => =16 56=2=2>96; 16 ;635>9:69=>3147729:6D92?C=16;635>9:69=>"49: ;635>9:69=>H43:2;6<=6:=>:65>32==16<>D56934=2>9 4D>89=47>9EH2=129=6;63=629E4EE;26G6:=165;6369= 455647143B669?276:
! ;22;6D4=1764;96:<>8936745564;29E?>;=16 <742D49=143;4236:=16?>77>H29E<>9=69=2>93
- 5 -
4' )2;3=7C =16 <742D49= 4336;=3 =14= 16 H43 64;929E 3"###.56;D>9=1BCH>;J29E43416756;>H6G6; =16;2B89471436;;6:29=4J29E=1629<>D643D6;67C43 3 +#.56;D>9=1 B' 6<>9:7C =16 <742D49= 143 6K4D296: =16 :><=>; 43 .16;2B894789:6;G4786:=16<742D49=03H1>76.B>:C :234B272=C4="L<>9=;4:2<=29E=166G2:69<6>?=16:><=>;
=14==16<742D49=38??6;6:( L:234B272=C=>7>H6;72DB 49:,,+(L=>=168556;72DB <' 12;:7C <>932:6;29E =16 6G2:69<6 >? :><=>; 49: =16 29F8;263 38??6;6: BC =16 <742D49= =16 <>D56934=2>9 4H4;:6: BC =16 ;2B8947 ?>; 5429 49: 38??6;29E 7>33 >? 4D692=263 49: >=16; 29<2:69=47 <14;E63 23 >9 =16 7>H6; 32:669<63>8E1=?>;69149<6D69=>?<>D56934=2>9
2=1 =16 4B>G6 <>9=69=2>93 =16 764;96: <>89367 3>8E1==>477>H=16455647
- 6 -
+ 9=16>=16;149:;2354772764;96:<>89367 45564;29E ?>; =16
938;49<6 >D549C 143 ;4236: =16 ?>77>H29E<>89=6;.<>9=69=2>93 4' )2;3=7C=164336;=2>9>?<742D49==14=16H4364;929E 3"###. 56; D>9=1 ;6D4293 8938B3=49=24=6: :86 => 74<J>?:><8D69=4;C6G2:69<6
9=164B369<6>?5;>>?>? 29<>D6 =16 ;2B8947 143 ;2E1=7C 4336336: =16 9>=2>947 29<>D6>?=16<742D49=433 +#.56;D>9=1 B' 6<>9:7C=16<742D49=1436K4D296:=16:><=>;6 143 4336336: =16 7>H6; 72DB :234B272=C 43 ( L 49: 8556;72DB:234B272=C43,,+(L16;2B8947<>932:6;29E =1629F8;263383=4296:BC=16<742D49=49:6G2:69<6>?=16 :><=>; 143 ;2E1=7C 4336336: =16 H1>76 B>:C :234B272=C 4=
"L <' 12;:7C <>932:6;29E =16 29F8;263 383=4296: BC =16 <742D49= D6:2<47 ;6<>;:3 6G2:69<6 >? :><=>; 49:
<>932:6;29E =16 4E6 49: 4G><4=2>9 >?
=16 <742D49= =16 >G6;477<>D56934=2>94H4;:6:BC=16;2B894723F83=49: ;643>94B7649:2=:>639>=H4;;49=29=6;?6;69<6
- 7 -
2=1 =16 4B>G6 <>9=69=2>93 =16 764;96: <>89367 3>8E1==>:23D233=16455647
64;: =16 764;96: <>89367 ?>; =16 54;=263 49: 56;836:=16F8:ED69=49:4H4;:>?=16;2B8947
$ = 23 9>= 29 :2358=6 =14= =16 <742D49= 143 383=4296:
29F8;26329=16;>4:=;4??2<4<<2:69=><<8;;6:>9"""#"! :86=>;43149:96E72E69=:;2G29E>?=16>??69:29EG612<76 BC2=3:;2G6;>?=16;4<=>;49:;4276;B64;29E;6E23=;4=2>9 >.,!.($$!.($$+
"# 356;H>89:<6;=2?2<4=6=16<742D49=143383=4296: 29F8;263=>164:96<J<163=76?==12E176?=76E;2E1==12E1 49:76?=67B>H49:-.;4C31>H3<>D5>89:E;4:6. :23=47 18D6;83?;4<=8;649:H2=1<>DD298=6:>76<;49>9?;4<=8;6 H2=1:237><4=2>976?=<>DD298=6:?;4<=8;6314?=?6D8;76?= 32:6 <>DD298=6: ?;4<=8;6 >? =2B24 49: ?2B874 76?= 32:6 <>DD298=6: ?;4<=8;6 >? 314?= ?6D8; ;2E1= 32:6 6 H43 2954=269=?>;456;2>:>?!:4C361436K4D296::><=>;
- 8 -
43
9 123 6G2:69<6 16 143 :65>36: =14= =16 <742D49= 143 38??6;6: 56;D4969= 51C32<47 2D542;D69= ;674=6:=>7>H6;72DB23( L49:;674=6:=>8556;72DB ,,+(L >932:6;29E =16 6G2:69<6 >? :><=>; 49:
4G><4=2>9>?=16<742D49=49:D6:2<47;6<>;:3H64;6>? =16>5292>9=14=H1>76B>:C:234B272=C234336336:43 L
"" 16<742D49=<742D3=14=16H4364;929E3"###. 56; D>9=1 8= 16 143 9>= 5;>:8<6: 49C :><8D69=3 => 38B3=49=24=6=1634D616;6?>;629=164B369<6>?5;>>? >? 29<>D6 9>=2>947 29<>D6 143 => B6 4336336: 16 ;2B8947143;2E1=7C<>932:6;6:=169>=2>94729<>D6>?=16 <742D49=433 +#.56;D>9=149:<>;;6<=7C=4J69=16 D87=25726; 45572<4B76 => 123 4E6 E;>85 43 @" A 183 =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: ?>; <>D56934=2>9 >? 3! ! , &3 +#.M"M" M L' >9 4<<>89= >? @7>33 >? ?8=8;6 29<>D6A
" 86 => =16 4<<2:69= =16 <742D49= 143 38??6;6:
E;26G>83 29F8;263 >932:6;29E =16 5;>7>9E6: 5429 :8;29E =;64=D69=43H67743=1656;D4969=:234B272=C<6;=2?26:BC
- 9 -
=16:><=>; H6 4;6 29<7296: => 69149<6=16 <>D56934=2>9 4H4;:6: BC =16 ;2B8947 89:6; =16 164: >? 05429 49:
38??6;29E30 ?;>D 3####. => -
!, 49: 89:6;
=16 164: >? 07>33 >? 4D692=2630 ?;>D 3"####. => -!,
", 16 94=8;6 >? 29F8;263 29:2<4=63 =14= =16 <742D49= D83=14G6B66989:6;;63=49:=;64=D69=?>;456;2>:>? =1;66 D>9=13 >936N869=7C =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: ?>;
<>D56934=2>9 >? - ! , &3 +#.M, D>9=13' 89:6;=16164:@7>33>?29<>D6:8;29E742:8556;2>:A
"( >932:6;29E=1694=8;6>?29F8;263=16<>D56934=2>9 4H4;:6: BC =16 ;2B8947 89:6; >=16; 164:3 23 F83= 49: ;643>94B76
" 183 =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => =16 ?>77>H29E <>D56934=2>9
- 10 -
./01-234151607 6407013026- -2827606 9:3;0 749512< )-* -2827606 9:3;4- 573 )-* 42949:38??6;29E3 #### !#### 6:2<47B277329<8;;6: 49:?8=8;6D6:2<47 6K5693634==69:49= <>9G6C49<6>8;23129E ?>>:49:>=16; 29<2:69=476K569363
" !!"
" !!" >33>?29<>D6:8;29E 742:8556;2>: + ## !# >33>?4D692=263
"#### ,#### >33>??8=8;629<>D6>9 4<<>89=>?56;D4969= :234B272=C ,## $## 32< !! ! ! 51606 !! ! ! "! 9=16;6387==16?>77>H29E>;:6;2354336:
4' 1645564723
B' 16F8:ED69=>?=16742D3;2B894723D>:2?26:
- 11 -
<' 16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => 4 =>=47 <>D56934=2>9 >? -! !
, :' 16
938;49<6 >D549C 23 :2;6<=6: => :65>32= =16 <>D56934=2>9 4D>89= 47>9E H2=1 29=6;63=
!L 54 ?;>D =16 :4=6 >? ?2729E >? =16 <742D 56=2=2>9=277=16:4=6>?;6472I4=2>9H2=129456;2>:>? 32K H66J3 ?;>D =16 :4=6 >? ;6<625= >? <>5C >? =123 F8:ED69= 6' 16:65>32=49:;676436>?4D>89=31477B6D4:629 =6;D3>?=164H4;:>?=16;2B8947
#6, )&#* (
#6, )$(%""$* (
23=>"7>!