- 1 - !"! #$" % $ & '&()* '& )) + !"!#$ %%%%% &# % % !"!#$ '% ( %% ) * % % %% * !"!$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + &, % !"!#$ & + !"!#$ '% (+ %*- *.&) % * #"& * () % % % /$!% ** + + * % % * * ** % $&()()()&(!)*$& % * 0 + - 3 - (%0 + ) 1234 35 36786923 923:6742;;2 <123714 =>67?1< 2;;12357: @>3 AB1 ;1A5A5>713? 274 35 +292423 B2B2C64457 <123714 5:B >63A >D137917A %<12413 2;;12357: @>3 31?;>7417A > 274 <123714 =>67?1< 35 24<>>3 2AE27232E272=B23E2 FB> 25414 AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7>7C1B2<@>@AB1=>9;<25727A B5? ;1A5A5>7 5? @5<14 67413 1=A5>7 #"& >@ AB1 B232A5E2 2:2358 6328?B2 27B5A2 $& F5AB AB1 @><<>F57:;32E13 !" ##$% & ' ( ) " & *+"!,-./,0 1,/20/ 0 '+ ./30&("2-2.!4 - 4 - & *2=A? >@ AB1 =2?1 FB5=B 231 6A9>?A 71=1??23E @>345?;>?2<>@AB1;31?17A;1A5A5>72312?67413 =>9;<257A=291A>C1@5<14F5AB1F >F7%><5=1 5423 CE 2G6 > 2AA2A35 2> B1<C2 FB5=B F2? 31:5?A1314 57 3591 >/$! >7 $#$#$! @>3 AB1 >@@17=1?;675?B2C<1674131=A5>7?$&()()()124 F5AB1=A5>7&(!)>@AB1B232A5E2E2E227B5A2$& # 5?A >@ AB1 =>9;<257A 2D13917A? F>6<4 31D12< AB2A25G572ABC157:AB11<413C3>AB13>@AB1=>9;<25727A C157: AB1 ;27=B2E2A 919C13 274 ?>=52< F>3813 B24 =>7A1?A14 AB1 1<1=A5>7 274 F2? 1<1=A14 AB35=1 2? AB1 ;27=B2E2A 919C13 B1 ?254 25G572AB B24 :25714 2@@1=A5>7 @3>9 AB1 D5<<2:13? C1=26?1 >@ B5? ?>=52< ?13D5=1 7 2==>67A >@ ?6==1??5D1<E C157: 1<1=A14 CE AB1 D5<<2:13? 2? ;27=B2E2A 919C13 AB131 F2? 35D2<3E 41D1<>;14 F5AB AB1 2==6?14 ;13?>7? 274 ?254 25G572AB 7 >3413 A> A281 31D17:1 2:257?A 25G572AB 274 2<?> 57 D51F >@ 123<513 =359572< =2?1? 2<< AB1 2==6?14 ;13?>7? ?254 A> B2D1 - 5 - B2A=B142;<27<<1:2A5>72:257?AAB1;31?17A;1A5A5>713? 5? AB2A AB1E 231 AB1 ;23AE A> AB1 =>7?;532=E ?254 A> B2D1 A2817;<2=157AB1B>6?1>@>71B29232>FB>5?=5A142? 2=B23:1?B11AF5A71??2?! ! %63?627A A> ?6=B =>7?;532=E AB1 963413 >@ 25G572AB B2? A2817 ;<2=1 >7 $#$#$! D17 2==>3457: A> AB1 =><697 >/ >@ AB1 =B23:1?B11A 1H=1;A AB2A ;31?17A;1A5A5>713?231;23A>@=>7?;532=EB2D57:B2A=B14 AB1 ;<27 57 AB1 B>6?1 >@ B29232> AB131 5? 7> >AB13 92A1352< 2D25<2C<1 >7 31=>34 2? 5? =>7A17414 CE AB1 ;1A5A5>713? B1 ;1A5A5>713? 231 57 =6?A>4E >7 274 @3>9 $$#$! 274 #$#$! 31?;1=A5D1<E B1 D><67A23E ?A2A1917A>@;1A5A5>713>23AB585?7>4>6CA31=>3414 CE AB1 57D1?A5:2A5>7 2:17=E C6A 7> 31=>D13E B2? A2817 ;<2=1 ;63?627A A> AB1 ?254 D><67A23E ?A2A1917A 2D57: 7>A14AB1@2=A>@@5<57:AB1=B23:1?B11AAB1;1A5A5>713?231 C1@>31AB5?>63A?11857::327A>@C25< - 6 - / 35 +292423 B2B2C64457 <123714 5:B >63A >D137917A %<12413 274 <123714 =>67?1< 35 24<>>3 2AE27232E272=B23E2 25457: AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7 >;;>?1?AB1:327A>@C25< " A 5? AB1 =>7A17A5>7 >@ AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7 AB2A =>7?;532=E F5<< B2D1 A> C1 :2AB1314 @3>9 AB1 2AA17427A =53=69?A27=1?2?A>;3>D1AB1=>7?;532=E4531=A1D5417=1 5? ?1<4>9 2D25<2C<1 B1E 2<?> =>7A174 AB2A AB5? >63A 2A AB5? ?A2:1 =277>A B><4 9575 A352< A> @574 >6A FB1AB13 AB1 ;1A5A5>713? F131 ;23A >@ =>7?;532=E >3 7>A 274 AB131@>31 B2D57:31:234A>AB1 92A1352<2D25<2C<157AB1 @>39 >@ ?A2A1917A >@ B29232> FB13157 B1 B2? ?;1=5@5=2<<E?A2A14C1@>31AB157D1?A5:2A5>7>@@5=13AB2AAB1 =>7?;532=E B2? A2817 ;<2=1 57 B5? 31?5417=1 FB131 9257 2==6?14+>B72<5E2?174E274AB1;31?17A;1A5A5>713?2<?> B2445?=6??142C>6AAB1A2857:2F2E<5@1>@AB1C3>AB13>@ AB1=>9;<25727A274AB131@>31?>6:BA@>345?95??2<>@AB1 C25<;1A5A5>7 - 7 - , 2D57:B1234AB123:6917A?>7C>AB?541?AB5? >63A ;136?14 AB1 92A1352< >7 31=>34 91A5=6<>6?<E 7 ?6=B ;136?2< >@ AB1 92A1352< >7 31=>34 5A 5? =3E?A2< =<123 AB2A 1H=1;A AB1 ?A2A1917A >@ B29232>! AB1 57D1?A5:2A5>7 2:17=E 5? 7>A 2C<1 A> =><<1=A 27E >AB13 92A1352<?>2?A>1?A2C<5?BAB1@2=A>@AB1;1A5A5>713?C157: AB1 ;23A >@ =>7?;532=E ?254 A> B2D1 A2817 ;<2=1 57 AB1 B>6?1 >@ B29232> @A13 2331?A >@ ;1A5A5>713 >23AB58 B1 B2? C117 ?6CG1=A14 A> =6?A>452< 57A133>:2A5>7274B5?D><67A23E?A2A1917A5?31=>3414 $ A 5? ;13A5717A A> 7>A1 AB2A ;63?627A A> ?254 D><67A23E ?A2A1917A 7> 31=>D13E B2? A2817 ;<2=1 B1 57D1?A5:2A5>72:17=EB2?AB6?=>7=<6414AB157D1?A5:2A5>7 C2?14 >7 AB1 ?A2A1917A >@ ! 2<>71 AB2A AB1 ;1A5A5>713?231;23A>@=>7?;532=E B1AB13 2A 2<< AB1 ;1A5A5>713? B24 ;<2E14 27 2=A5D13><157B2A=B57:AB1=>7?;532=EA>A2812F2EAB1<5@1 >@AB1C3>AB13>@AB1=>9;<25727A(25G572AB41=12?14)5?2 - 8 - @2=A AB2AB2? A>C1 1?A2C<5?B14CE AB1;3>?1=6A5>746357: AB1=>63?1>@1D5417=1 A 5? ?1AA<14 ;357=5;<1? >@ <2F 274 31I6531? 7> 19;B2?5?AB2A2AAB1A591>@=>7?541357:AB1C25<31I61?A AB1>63A?231;31=<6414@3>9B><457:9575A352<A>2??1?? AB1 9135A? 274 419135A? >@ AB1 =2?1 2? AB1 ?291 92E ;31G645=1 AB1 35:BA? >@ AB1 ;23A51? >71 F2E >3 AB1 >AB13 46357:AB1A352< & B6?41?5?A57:@3>9B><457:AB19575A352<@3>9 AB1 92A1352< >7 31=>34 5? 2;;31=52A14 @>3 AB1 <595A14 ;63;>?1>@=>7?541357:AB1C25<31I61?A>@AB1;1A5A5>713? AB5?>63A5?>@AB1=>7?541314>;575>7AB2AB2D57:31:234 A> AB1 @2=A AB2A AB1 =B23:1?B11A 5? @5<14 AB1 9257 2;;31B17?5>7 >@ AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7 AB2A AB1 ;1A5A5>713? 92E 41?A3>E AB1 1D5417=1 >@ AB1 =3591 F>6<4 :1A I61<<14 274 AB131@>31;1A5A5>713?231A>C117<23:14>7C25< # B5? >63A B2? 2<3124E A2817 ?6=B 2 D51F 57 31?;1=A >@ 2==6?14 >! FB> B2? C117 :327A14 - 9 - 27A5=5;2A>3E C25< CE AB5? >63A 57 359572< %1A5A5>7 >$$,#$! ! B1E1A27>AB132;;31B17?5>7AB2A5?1H;31??14 CE AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7 41?13D1? =>7?54132A5>7 572?96=B 2? AB1>AB132==6?1492E2<?>2;;3>2=BAB1>63A@>3:327A >@C25<>7AB1:3>674>@;235AE 6=B272;;31B17?5>7=272<?>C191AF5ABCE >C?13D57: AB2A AB1 =2?1 >@ AB1 ;1A5A5>713? 231 2<A>:1AB13 45@@1317A@3>9AB1>AB13;13?>7?2:257?AFB>9AB1 92A1352< 1D5417=1 231 2D25<2C<1 B131@>31 5A 5? @>3 AB1;3>?1=6A5>7A>>;;>?1FB17AB1>AB13;1A5A5>713?231 2;;3>2=B14AB1>63A@>3:327A>@C25<572==>3427=1F5AB <2F / << >AB13 2;;31B17?5>7? 1H;31??14 CE AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7 =27 C1 91A F5AB CE 59;>?57: ?65A2C<1 274 ?A357:17A=>745A5>7? - 10 - " ==>3457:<E57D51F>@AB1@>31:>57:45?=6??5>7 AB1@><<>F57:>34135?;2??14 (2) B1359572<%1A5A5>75?2<<>F14 (C) B1 ;1A5A5>713? 231 4531=A14 A> C1 17<23:14 >7 C25< 57 3591 >/$! >@ 1F >F7 %><5=1 A2A5>75423@>3AB12@>31?254>@@17=1??6CG1=A A>AB1@><<>F57:=>745A5>7? (5) B1 ;1A5A5>713? ?B2<< 1H1=6A1 2 ;13?>72< C>74 @>3 2 ?69 >@ ?$$$$$ (6;11? 71 28B) 12=BF5ABAF>?631A51?@>3AB1<581?69 >@AB1?2A5?@2=A5>7>@AB1 352<>63A (55) B1 ;1A5A5>713? ?B2<< 7>A A29;13 AB1 ;3>?1=6A5>7F5A71??1?5727E927713 (555) B1;1A5A5>713??B2<<2AA174AB1>63A 31:6<23<E (5D) B1 ;1A5A5>713? ?B2<< 7>A <12D1 AB1 G635?45=A5>7 >@ AB1 5423 5?A35=A F5AB>6A;35>3;1395??5>7 - 11 - (D) B1 ;1A5A5>713? ?B2<< 7>A 57D><D1 57 >AB13=359572<2=A5D5A51? (D5) 327A >@ C25< A> AB1 ;31?17A ;1A5A5>713? ?B2<< 7>A 2=A 2? ;235AE5731?;1=A>@>AB13;1A5A5>713? 5><2A5>7 >@ 27E >71 >@ AB1 =>745A5>7? F>6<4 17A5A<1 AB1;3>?1=6A5>7A>?118@>3=27=1<<2A5>7>@C25< 4 &% ) " % 5?A><> %