- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '() * !"#$% &'' ( ! ) ' ' $ * $ #$ ''!'"%% ! ' ! ' $% * $ #$ * % ' %#$ $% ! * '+'! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # !,! ' ! "%%% &' ( ! '! * - $%%" .' ) **!() * ' ' ! ' '' ! * /! %% ' ' ' /! ! "$"% '' * /! ! 0 /!'! % 123324 5678394: ;<= ><==97 24 %% ?4 2="$"%<47$%@A:B9'C?41?><D?=:C?1: <47 9==?24= /6789 <47 <: <?1B6C (E2C =B2C: F:B9 C?@64<DG) B?= <>>9<D ?= E?D97 @A :B9 1D<?3<4: ?4 2"$"% - 3 - B9 1D<?3<4: <897 A9<C= 3?DH I9472C 39: ;?:B <4 <11?794: 24 %% <47 =6=:<?497 8C?9I26= ?456C?9= B9C9E2C9 B9 E?D97 < 1D<?3 >9:?:?24 @9E2C9 :B9 C?@64<D 1D<?3?48 123>94=<:?24 2E ="$%%%%% B9 C?@64<D 124=?79C?48 :B9 94:?C9 9I?79419 24 C912C7 8C<4:97 123>94=<:?24 2E =%#%% ;?:B ?4:9C9=: <: J >< EC23 :B9 7<:9 2E >9:?:?24 :?DD C9<D?=<:?24 <47 7?C91:97 C9=>24794: 24=6C<419 23><4A :2 79>2=?: :B9=<39 88C?9I97@A:B9=<?75678394:<47<;<C7:B9 ?456C97 1D<?3<4: B<= >C9E9CC97 :B?= <>>9<D ?4 ;B?1B ?: ?= 124:94797 :B<: B9 ;<= <897 " A9<C= <47 =6=:<?497 8C?9I26= ?456C?9= <= >9C :B9 ;2647 19C:?E?1<:9 9 =>94: B689397?1<D9K>94=9=<47<D=26479C8249D2:2E><?4<47 =6EE9C?489;<=9<C4?48="%%%>9C324:B@6::B9 C?@64<D B<= :<H94 B?= ?41239 <: 24DA =$"% >9C 324:B'721:2C<==9==97:B97?=<@?D?:A<:"J:2:B9 ;B2D9 @27A @6: :B9 C?@64<D B<= 124=?79C97 24DA "J B9<3264:=<;<C7976479C2:B9CB9<7=<C939<8C9B9 - 4 - ?4:9C9=:?=:2@9<;<C797<:J><?4=:9<72EJ>< B6=C9L69=:97E2C94B<419394:2E123>94=<:?24 $ 9<C7:B9<C86394:=2E@2:B=?79= " B268B :B9 <>>9DD<4: =:<:97 :B<: B9 ;<= 9<C4?48="%%%>9C324:BB9B<=42:>C276197<4A ?41239>C22EB9C9E2C9:B9C?@64<DB<=C?8B:DA:<H94B?= 42:?24<D ?41239 <: =$"% >9C 324:B <= >9C :B9 86?79D?49=2E:B9<C4<:<H<:<:998<D9CI?19=6:B2C?:A <=:B9<11?794:?=2E:B9A9<C%9;<=<897A9<C= :B9C9E2C9:B936D:?>D?9C;<=C?8B:DA:<H94<=F#G=>9C :B9 ;2647 19C:?E?1<:9K' :B9 <>>9DD<4: B<= =6=:<?497 ) 98D2I?48 ?456CA :2 :B9 <@72394 ;?:B =H?4 <47 =2E: :?==69 D2== 9K>2=?48 @2;9D D22>= =>D994 @D<779C <47 :9=:?=<1:?I9@D997?48>C9=94:)99><@C<=?242I9C:B9 D9E: H499 ;?:B =H?4 D2== <1:?I9 @D997?48 >C9=94: ):9479C49==>C9=94:2I9CD63@9CI94:?D<:2C26:2E;B?1B ?456CA 2=<47<C98C?9I26=?44<:6C9<47?456CA 2 ?==?3>D9?44<:6C9B9<>>9DD<4:9K<3?497:B9721:2C<= '<47B9?==6977?=<@?D?:A19C:?E?1<:96479CK'= - 5 - >9C :B9 7?=<@?D?:A 19C:?E?1<:9 :B9 <>>9DD<4: B<= =6=:<?497 )'9DI?1<47C?8B:19:<@6D63EC<1:6C9<47)@7243?<D ?456CA:;<=2@=9CI97@A:B9721:2C:B<::B9C9?=64?:97 EC<1:6C92EC?8B:<19:<@6D63;?:B<C:BC??:?=2EB?><47H499 <47<==9==97:B97?=<@?D?:A<:"J:2:B9;B2D9@27A<47 <D=2 =6889=:97 <42:B9C =6C89CA E2C <C:BC?:?= 2E C?8B: B?> <479=:?3<:97:B912=:2E=6C89CA<="D<1B9721:2C <==9==97 :B9 7?=<@?D?:A <: "J C7 2E "J 1239= :2 ;B?1B =B26D7 C264797 2EE :2 J 2;9I9C :B9 C?@64<D B<= :<H94 :B9 7?=<@?D?:A <: "J B9C9E2C9 :B?= 26C:E?47=42C9<=24:2?4:9CE9C9;?:B:B9=<39 9<C497 1264=9D E2C :B9 <>>9DD<4: B<= C9D?97 6>24:B95678394:2E:B9?I?=?24 941B2E:B?=26C:?4 :B9 1<=9 2E ?4 !(%%)<47=6@3?::97 :B<:<=>9C:B9=<?75678394::B9<>>9DD<4:?=94:?:D97E2C E6:6C9>C2=>91:= 6::B9D9<C4971264=9DE2CC9=>24794: 2 2>>2=97 :B9 =<39 73?::97DA :B9 <>>9DD<4: - 6 - =6=:<?497"J7?=<@?D?:A:2:B9;B2D9@27A<47?:?=32C9 :B<4%JB9C9E2C9:B?=26C:E?47=?:C9<=24<@D9:2:<H9 :B9 E6:6C9 >C2=>91:= <: $%J B6= :B9 D2== 2E E6:6C9 9<C4?48=;26D7@9 =$"%M$%JKK#K"JN=$#% B9 C?@64<D B<= <;<C797 <4 <3264: 2E =" :2;<C7= 397?1<D 9K>94=9= <47 ?: 4997= 42 ?4:9CE9C9419 # *6C:B9C124=?79C?48:B94<:6C92E?456C?9=:B?= 26C: E?47= ?: C9<=24<@D9 :2 8C<4: <4 <3264: 2E =%%%%% E2C E6:6C9 397?1<D 9K>94=9= (=6C8?1<D 9K>94=9=)<=>9C:B99I?794192E' B9 <3264: <;<C797 @A :B9 C?@64<D 6479C 2:B9C B9<7= ?= 56=: <47 >C2>9C <47 ?: 4997= 42 ?4:9CE9C9419 % 9419:B9<>>9DD<4:?=94:?:D97E2C:B9327?E?97 123>94=<:?246479C7?EE9C94:B9<7=<=@9D2; - 7 - '<?4<47=6EE9C?48 ="%%%% 97?1<D9K>94=9= =" *6:6C9397?1<D9K>94=9= =%%%%% 2==2EE6:6C99<C4?48= =$#% 97?1<D <::947<4:G= <47 426C?=B394:9K>94=9= =%%%% 2==2E?4123976C?48D<?76>>9C?27 =$"% 2==2E<394?:?9= ="%%%% 2:<D 9==<;<C797@AC?@64<D 4B<419394: = ## =%#%% + ## B9 4=6C<419 23><4A B<= <DC9<7A 79>2=?:97 :B9 <3264: <;<C797 @A :B9 C?@64<D B6= :B9 <>>9DD<4: ?= 94:?:D97E2C94B<4197123>94=<:?242E=#$"#;?:B ?4:9C9=: <: J >9C <4463 <47 :B9C9E2C9 :B9 <>>9<D 79=9CI9=:2@9<DD2;97?4><C: 4:B9C9=6D::B9E2DD2;?482C79C?=><==97 (?) >>9<D?=<DD2;97?4><C: (??) B9 <>>9DD<4:1D<?3<4: ?= 94:?:D97 E2C :B9 94B<4197 123>94=<:?24 2E =#$"# ;?:B ?4:9C9=: <: J >9C <4463 EC23 :B9 7<:9 2E >9:?:?24 :?DD :B9 7<:9 2E C9<D?O<:?24 - 8 - (???) 9=>24794: 24=6C<419 23><4A ?= 7?C91:97:279>2=?::B9=<?7<3264:;?:B?4249324:BEC23 :B97<:92E:B?=5678394: (?I) 4 =61B 79>2=?: :B9 <>>9DD<4: ?= >9C3?::97 :2 ;?:B7C<; :B9 94:?C9 <3264: <D248 ;?:B ?4:9C9=: <11C697 24?: 9<C4971264=9DE2CC9=>24794: 2?=>9C3?::97:2E?D9 I<H<D<:B;?:B?4:;2;99H= !,- '&!! ) % ?=: 2D 2