- 1 - !"# $%& && '#( ) ! ! " # $%#!& ' ($ $ ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " % !* +%#!& $ " % !* ! +%#!& $ $ %#!& ' ($" , &&# -) "" *() " . " " && & $ - !! &$ " $". " /$ - 3 - % 01234453612475857759:;<05=631>3?<23@31?2< <05 A9@>5?< 3?9 3B379 93<59 && & 432259 1? C!! & :; <05 71?=1436 12<71=< 3?9 5221C?2 A9@5 3?9 31=0A7 (8C7 20C7< D<05 <71:A?36E) 255F1?@ 5?03?=5>5?<C8<05=C>45?23<1C? ?5 A7G3732390A2:3?9C8=631>3?<C>5< B1<03==195?<C?*&&3?92A==A>:59<C<051?HA7152 12 B185 15 =631>3?< C =016975? 3?9 >C<057 81659 =631> 45<1<1C? :58C75 <05 <71:A?36 255F1?@ =C>45?23<1C? C8 2!&&&&& % 05 <71:A?36 38<57 =C?219571?@ <05 5?<175 5G195?=5C?75=C793B3795932A>C82 %36C?@ B1<01?<5752<3<<0573<5C8 I4573??A>87C><0593<5C8 45<1<1C?<16675361J3<1C?05<71:A?36032C:257G59<03<<0575 B323=C?<71:A<C7;?5@61@5?=5C?:C<0G501=6521?<0573<1CC8 #&#& @@715G59 :; <05 2319 A9@>5?< 3?9 3B379 <05 47525?< 344536 12 475857759 1? B01=0 1< 12 =C?<5?959 <03< B0165 A7G3 73239 B32 47C=5591?@ C? 012 >C<C7=;=65 :5371?@ 75@12<73<1C? C % % * 71957 C8 <05 3?C<057 - 4 - G501=65 :5371?@ 75@12<73<1C? C % % !* =3>5 1? 3 73203?9?5@61@5?<>3??573?9932059<C<05>C<C7=;=65C8 <05 A7G373239323752A6<052A2<31?59@715GCA21?HA7152 3?9 9159 2A:25KA5?<6; 05 95=53259 A7G3 73239 B32 BC7F1?@ 32 3 >32C? 3?9 537?1?@ 32A>C8 2#&&& %457 >C?<0 :A< <05 <71:A?36 032 =C?2195759 <05 1?=C>5 C8 <05 95=53259 A7G3 73239 3< 2!#& % 457 >C?<0 5 B32 3@59 & ;5372 5 12 5?<1<659 <C #&I <CB3792 8A<A75 47C245=<21?2<539C8!&I3?9>53@573>CA?<2B575@73?<59 A?957C<057053920595=53259B321?<050C241<368C7# 93;2 05 =631>3?<2 375 5?<1<659 <C 3 2A> C8 2!&&&& % 53=0 <CB3792 =C?2C7<1A> ? <05 =037@5%2055< 3< L 1< B32 2<3<59 <03< <0575 B32 =C?<71:A<C7; ?5@61@5?=5 C? <05 437< C8 <05 95=53259 1? 83=< <05 95=53259 B32 7191?@ 012 >C<C7=;=65 C? <05 5L<75>5 658< 2195 C8 <05 7C39 05 7524C?95?< C 36C?@ B1<0 41661C? 71957 B32 7191?@ 012 >C<C7=;=65 1? 3 7320 3?9 ?5@61@5?< >3??57 3?9 932059 <C <05 >C<C7=;=65 C8 <05 95=53259 0A2 05 75KA52<59 8C7 >C9181=3<1C?C8<05A9@>5?<3?93B379 5379<0537@A>5?<287C>:C<021952 - 5 - ! 537?59=CA?2568C7<057524C?95?<C2A:>1<2 <03< <05 =C>4631?< 12 @1G5? 3@31?2< <05 971G57 C8 :C<0 G501=652 3?9 3==C791?@6; <05 =037@5%2055< 12 362C 81659 3@31?2<:C<0<05971G572C5;5B1<?522523755L3>1?593?9 <0A2 <05 <71:A?36 032 71@0<6; 32252259 <05 =C?<71:A<59 ?5@61@5?=55KA366;3?91<12<C:5=C?817>59 # 537?59 =CA?256 8C7 <05 3445663?<2 =631>3?<2 2A:>1<2<03<<0595=53259 A7G373239B320C691?@971G1?@ 61=5?=53?9<0571957C83?C<057>C<C7=;=65B32?C<0C691?@ G3619 971G1?@ 61=5?=5 2 457 <05 2=5?5 C8 C885?=5 43?=03?3>3 <05 95=53259 A7G3 73239 B32 C? <05 5L<75>5 658< 2195 C8 <05 7C39 0A2 75KA52<59 8C7 >C9181=3<1C?C8<05=C?<71:A<C7;?5@61@5?=5C?012437< 05=631>3?<2919?C<5L3>1?5<05=C>4631?3?<<C 47CG5 <03< <0575 12 ?C ?5@61@5?=5 C? <05 437< C8 95=53259 A7G37323905<71:A?36032?CC<057C4<1C?:A<<C756;C? <05 =037@5%2055< 3?9 <C 322522 <05 =C?<71:A<C7; ?5@61@5?=5 5KA366; 012 CA7< 81?92 ?C 7532C? <C 1?<578575 1? <05 2319 =C?<71:A<C7;?5@61@5?=532252259:;<05<71:A?36 - 6 - * 05 =631>3?<2 2<3<59 <03< A7G3 73239 B32 537?1?@ 3 2A> C8 2#&&& % $A< <05 =631>3?<2 03G5 ?C< 47C9A=59 3?; 1?=C>5 47CC8 <C 47CG5 012 1?=C>5 05 95=53259>5<B1<03==195?<1?<05;537&05?=532457 <05 @A19561?52 C8 <05 37?3<3F3 <3<5 5@36 57G1=52 A<0C71<;012?C<1C?361?=C>512<C:5<3F5?3<2!#& % 3?9!&I12<C:539959<CB37928A<A7547C245=<23?9 !<012 <C :5 959A=<59 <CB3792 4572C?36 5L45?252 05 95=53259 B323@59&;537232C?<0593<5C8<053==195?<5?=5<05 >A6<146157 12 <C :5 <3F5? 3< D*E 5?=5 <05 6C22 C8 9545?95?=;1232A?957 2!#& % M 2#*&& . . * . N O 2&##& % 05 <71:A?36 032 3B37959 3 2A> C8 2*&&&& % <CB3792>591=365L45?2520523>512=C775=<3?9?5592?C 1?<578575?=5 05 =631>3?< C 12 5?<1<659 8C7 6C22 C8 =C?2C7<1A> C8 2!!&&& % 631>3?< C2 3?9 ! 375 5?<1<659 8C7 4375?<36 =C?2C7<1A> C8 2!!&&& % 53=0 631>3?<C#125?<1<658C7816136=C?2C7<1A>C82!!&&& % - 7 - "A7<057 <05 =631>3?<2 375 5?<1<65 8C7 3 2A> C8 2&&& % <CB3792 =C?G5?<1C?36 05392 5?=5 <05 <C<36 =C>45?23<1C? 1232A?957 * +,-./01+2.,342 0523 C22C89545?95?=; 2&##& % 591=365L45?252 2*&&&& % C22C8=C?2C7<1A> 2&&&& % ! C?G5?<1C?360539 2&&& % 3,* .!!6!7 537?59 =CA?256 8C7 <05 ?2A73?=5 =C>43?; 2A:>1<2 <03< 1? G15B C8 <05 C7957 432259 :; <05 <71:A?36 #&I C8 <05 =C>45?23<1C? 3>CA?< 3B37959 :; <05 <71:A?36 032:55?367539;954C21<59:;<05> & ==C791?@6;<058C66CB1?@C7957 (1) 0534453612437<6;366CB59, (11) ? G15B C8 =C?<71:A<C7; ?5@61@5?=5 C8 A7G5 73239<05=631>3?<23755?<1<65<C#&I152 * *# % CA< C8 2*##& % 3B37959 :; <012 CA7< 36C?@ B1<0 1?<5752< 3< <05 73<5 C8 I 457 3??A> 87C> <05 93<5 C8 - 8 - 45<1<1C?<166<0593<5C875361J3<1C?323@31?2<2 % P#&IC82!# %Q3B37959:;<05<71:A?36, (111) 05 7524C?95?< C 12 9175=<59 <C 954C21< <05 5?03?=59 =C>45?23<1C? C8 2!! % 36C?@ B1<0 1?<5752< B1<01?C?5>C?<087C><0593<5C8<012C7957, (1G) ? 2A=0 954C21< <05 =631>3?< C 12 457>1<<59 <C B1<0973B <05 5?<175 =C>45?23<1C? 3>CA?< 36C?@ B1<0 1?<5752<3==7A59C?1< (G) 05 7524C?95?< C 12 3< 61:57<; <C 75=CG57 <05 5?03?=59=C>45?23<1C?87C><05CB?57C8<05G501=65 .-7 '&( % 12<C6C