Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92912 (KAR)
NINGANAGOUDA AND ANR v. DR. NINGANAGOUDA AND ANR
MFA/203912/2023 · 2025-12-08
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92912 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92912 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $% #
$% !%&! ##
'&( )* ## +,
'&(
)
*
! "
#
$
! ! %
!&&
% ''' ' ( ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#)*!( (& &$! ! ' % ' %% ! !*
% ! "
# ! ! *+
! ! & )'$
' %* * ,#$*% %*'%%) -( ( %!& -'* * ' * ' %% % % ! ) ' ' ' % % ! -
-& ( %'*' '. ' * ! +, )
*
! ! ! )
! "
#
$
- 3 -
! ! %
!&&
% ''' ' ( ! #)*!( (& &$! ! ' % ' %% ! !*
% ! "
# ! ! *+
! ! & )'$
' %* * ,#$ * % %*'%% )-( ( %!&, - '**'*' %% % % ! ) ' ' ' % % ! , ( % '
* ' '. ' * ! ' %*/
% * %
' %) '
% '0%! '!! 123 '0%! ! - 4 -
% #'0%! '!! $
! %* 4! & 52367 689:42 ,#$ 4; 9<6 %4947 6<:8=6/ 89
- #<676:21;967 76;67763 94 1/ >9<6
89. ;47/<479$<1/?662;:=63?@9<68=1:A1298<1==62B:2B 9<6C53BA6291231D17331963-! ! E1//63?@9<6 33:9:421= 62:47 :F:= 53B6 123 %6A?67 % 4! :C1@1E571:2%4!& -! ! %* 4! - 52367 689:42 ,#$ 4; 9<6 %4947 6<:8=6/ 89
- #<676:21;967 76;67763 94 1/ >9<6
89. ;47/<479$<1/?662;:=63?@9<68=1:A129/8<1==62B:2B 9<6C53BA6291231D17331963-! ! E1//63?@9<6 33:9:421= 62:47 :F:= 53B6 123 %6A?67 % 4! :C1@1E571:2%4!&, -! ! *189/ B:F:2B 7:/6 94 9<6 ;:=:2B 4; 9<6 1EE61=/ ?7:6;=@ /91963 176 9<19 42 ! ! - 19 1?459 ! E!A! 9<6 :2C5763 8=1:A129 :2B121B4531 1=42B D:9< <:/ A49<67 36861/63 1@1/<766 :71317 D676 E748663:2B 42 1 A49478@8=6 ?617:2B 76B:/9719:42 4!( & G(, ;74A
- 5 -
:C1@1E571 94 1221= :==1B6! )<62 9<6@ 7618<63 2617 1221= <129:1B1774//
42:C1@1E571( 4=1E57741319 9<19 9:A6
1 817 ?617:2B 76B:/9719:42 4!( (& & D<:8< D1/ ?6:2B 37:F62 :2 1 71/< 123 26B=:B629 A12267 81A6 ;74A :31B523: /:36 123 31/<63 1B1:2/9 9<6 A49478@8=67:3362?@:2C57638=1:A129:2B121B4531!/1 76/5=9 4; 9<6 1;476/1:3 188:3629
?49< ;6== 34D2 123 /5/91:263 B7:6F45/ :2C57:6/ 123 D676 <4/E:91=:H63! 6861/63 1@1/<766 /5885A?63 94 9<6 :2C57:6/ 42 ! ! -! &! <6 8=1:A129/ ;:=63 1 E69:9:42 52367 689:42 4;
9<6 89 /66I:2B 84AE62/19:42 ;47 9<6 3619< 4; 9<6 36861/63 1@1/<766 1=42B D:9< :29676/9!
9 D1/ E=61363 9<19 9<6 :2C5763 8=1:A129 :2B121B4531 /E629 /:B2:;:8129 1A4529 94D173/ A63:81= 6JE62/6/
842F6@1286 8<17B6/ 123 49<67 76=1963 84/9/! 9 D1/ ;579<67 E=61363 9<19 9<6 188:362948857763/4=6=@4218845294;71/<12326B=:B629 37:F:2B4;9<64;;623:2BF6<:8=6?@:9/37:F67! - 6 -
! E42 /67F:86 4; 249:86
9<6 76/E423629 4/! 123 1EE61763 9<745B< 8452/6= 123 ;:=63 D7:9962 /9196A629 362@:2B9<61F67A629/A136:29<68=1:AE69:9:42! ! 2 9<6 ?1/:/ 4; 9<6 E=613:2B/ 4; 9<6 E179:6/
9<6 =1:A/7:?521=;71A639<6://56/1239<6761;967
76847363 9<6 6F:36286! <6 7:?521=
?@ :AE5B263 C53BA629 123 1D173<1/E179=@1==4D639<68=1:AE69:9:42123<6=39<19 9<6 8=1:A129 :2 %!4!& - :/ 629:9=63 94 1 84AE62/19:42 4; /!& ( 1=42B D:9< :29676/9 19 9<6 7196 4; K E!1! 123 8=1:A129/ :2 %!4!&, - 176 629:9=63 94 1 84AE62/19:42 4; /! ,& ( 1=42B D:9< :29676/9199<671964;KE!1!1233:7689639<62/571286 4AE12@9436E4/:99<684AE62/19:421A45291=42BD:9< :29676/9!6:2B1BB7:6F63
9<6E76/6291EE61=/<1F6?662 ;:=63! )
'&) ,+( ,! <6 =617263 8452/6= ;47 9<6 8=1:A129 <1/ 71:/63 9<6 ;4==4D:2B8429629:42/
- 7 -
1$ *:7/9=@
9<6 8=1:A129 1//679/ 9<19 <6 D1/ 6172:2B /! ( E67 A429< ?@ D47I:2B 1/ 844=:6 123 1B7:85=957:/9!'4D6F67
9<67:?521=<1/67763:291I:2B9<6 :284A61/A676=@1//! (E67A429<! ?$ 68423=@
9<6 8=1:A129 <1/ 6J1A:263 9<6 348947 1/ )(!<67:?521=52367F1=5639<68=1:A1290/D<4=6(?43@ 3:/1?:=:9@ 19K
8429713:89:2B 9<66F:36286 4; 9<6 348947 9<199<68=1:A129/5;;6763& K3:/1?:=:9@94=6;9=4D67=:A?! 8$ 1/9=@
356 94 9<6 188:3629
9<6 8=1:A129 <1/ /5/91:263B7:6F45/:2C57:6/!'6D1/97619631/:2E19:629;47 1 E67:43 4; 31@/! F62 1;967 3:/8<17B6 ;74A 9<6 <4/E:91=
<6D1/249:21E4/:9:42943:/8<17B6<:/76B5=17 D47I! '6 <1/ /5;;6763 =49 4; E1:2 357:2B 97619A629! 42/:367:2B 9<6 /1A6
9<6 4F671== 84AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@9<67:?521=:/429<6=4D67/:36! ):9< 9<6 1?4F6 8429629:42/
9<6 =617263 8452/6= /45B<9941==4D9<61EE61=! - 8 -
! 2 9<6 49<67 <123
9<6 =617263 8452/6= ;47 9<6 2/571286 4AE12@ <1/ 71:/63 9<6 ;4==4D:2B 8452967( 8429629:42/ 1$ *:7/9=@
9<61//679:424;8=1:A1299<19<6D1/6172:2B /! ( E67 A429<
76A1:2/ 52/5?/9129:1963 356 94 =18I4;3485A62917@6F:36286!29<61?/62864;E744;4;
:284A6
9<6 7:?521= <1/ 7:B<9=@ 1 63 9<6 :284A6 4;
9<68=1:A129249:421==@! ?$ 68423=@
9<6 7:?521= 842/:367:2B 9<6 :2C57:6/ /5/91:263?@9<68=1:A1291236F:362864;9<6348947
<1/ 7:B<9=@1 639<6D<4=6?43@3:/1?:=:9@19K! 8$ <:73=@
842/:367:2B 9<6 :2C57:6/ /5/91:263 ?@ 9<6 8=1:A129 123 842/:367:2B 9<6 1B6 123 1F4819:42 4; 9<6 8=1:A129
9<6 4F671== 84AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521= :/ C5/9 123 761/421?=6 123 :9 346/ 249 D177129 :2967;676286! ):9< 9<6 1?4F6 8429629:42/
9<6 =617263 8452/6= /45B<9943:/A://9<61EE61=! - 9 -
-! '6173 9<6 =617263 8452/6= ;47 9<6 E179:6/ 123 E675/639<6C53BA6291231D1734;9<67:?521=! ! 9 :/ 249 :2 3:/E596 9<19 9<6 8=1:A129 <1/ /5/91:263 :2C57:6/:29<67413971;;:8188:36294885776342! ! - 3569471/<12326B=:B62937:F:2B4;9<64;;623:2BF6<:8=6 ?@:9/37:F67! ! <68=1:A1298=1:A/9<19<6D1/6172:2B/! ( E67 A429<! 59 <6 <1/ 249 E7435863 12@ 3485A629/ 94 /5?/9129:196<:/8=1:A!<676;476
:29<61?/62864;E744;
4; :284A6
249:421= :284A6 <1/ 94 ?6 1 63!
<6 7:?521= <1/ 7:B<9=@ 1 63 A429<=@ :284A6 4; 9<6 8=1:A1291//! (! ! /E67D45238679:;:8196
9<68=1:A129<1//5/91:263 859=18671963D45234F67=6;98=18125A
=6;9D7:/9123=6;9 17A! <6 A5=9:E=6 1?71/:42 4F67 =6;9 ;449
=6;9 /<45=367 36;47A:9@4F67=6;9;6A57!:/91==6;99:?:112396236726// 123 1=/4 ;71895764;=6;9 9:?:1
123 1=/4 ;71895764; =19671= ?473674;/81E5=1!<6348947:2<:/6F:36286<1/36E4/63
- 10 -
9<19 8=1:A129 <1/ /5;;6763 & K 3:/1?:=:9@ 94 =6;9 =4D67 =:A?!1I:2B:294842/:36719:429<636E4/:9:424;9<6348947 123:2C57:6/A629:4263:29<6D45238679:;:8196
D61764;
9<6 4E:2:42 9<19 9<6 D<4=6 ?43@ 3:/1?:=:9@ <1/ 94 ?6 1 6319&K!<68=1:A129:/1B631?459 @617/19 9<6 9:A6 4; 9<6 188:3629 123 A5=9:E=:67 1EE=:81?=6 94 <:/ 1B6 B745E :/ >.! <5/
9<6 8=1:A129 :/ 629:9=63 ;47 84AE62/19:424;-"")#/! LLL&K$ 4218845294;0=4//4;;59576:284A60! ! <6 219576 4; :2C57:6/ :23:8196/ 9<19 9<6 8=1:A129 A5/9<1F6?6625236776/912397619A629;471E67:434;
A429</! 42/6M5629=@
9<6 8=1:A129 :/ 629:9=63 ;47 84AE62/19:42 4; -+"
) #/! L A429</$ 523679<6<613>=4//4;:284A6357:2B=1:35EE67:43.! &! <6 8=1:A129 D1/ <4/E:91=:H63 1/ 12 :2E19:629 ;47 A476 9<12 31@/ :2 9<6 <4/E:91= 123 /5?/6M5629=@ 7686:F63 ;579<67 97619A629! <6 8=1:A129 :/ 629:9=63 ;47
- 11 -
84AE62/19:42 4; -,") 94D173/ >*443 2457:/<A629
842F6@1286123996231298<17B6/. ! 56 94 9<6 188:3629
9<6 8=1:A129 <1/ /5;;6763 B7:6F45/:2C57:6/1231=/452367B426/57B67@!42/:367:2B 9<6 E74=42B63 E1:2 357:2B 97619A629 1/ D6== 1/ 9<6 E67A12629 3:/1?:=:9@ 8679:;:63 ?@ 9<6 348947
D6 176 :28=:263 94 62<1286 9<6 84AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521= 52367 9<6 <613 4; 0E1:2 123 /5;;67:2B/0 ;74A /! (94-")1231=/4629:9=63;470=4//4; 1A62:9:6/019-")
! 42/:367:2B9<62195764;:2C57:6/
9<684AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521= 52367 49<67 <613/ :/ C5/9 123 761/421?=6! ,! <5/
9<6 8=1:A129 :/ 629:9=63 94 9<6 ;4==4D:2B 84AE62/19:42
- 12 -
./01-234151607 6407013026- -2827606 9:3;0 749512< '-( -2827606 9:3;4- 573 '-( 1:2123/5;;67:2B/
& %63:81=123:28:36291= 6JE62/6/
*443
2457:/<A629 842F6@1286123 1996231298<17B6/ (
4//4;:284A6357:2B =1:35EE67:43
-
, 4//4;;595766172:2B/ 1231A62:9:6/ ,
& & 32<
""+
"" 51606
""
""
+, )
'&
) ,+(
! <6=6172638452/6=;479<68=1:A129/<1/71:/639<6 ;4==4D:2B8429629:42/ 1$ *:7/9=@
9<6 8=1:A129/ 1//679 9<19 9<6 36861/63 D1/ 1B631?459& @617/199<69:A64;9<6188:3629123<131 A429<=@ :284A6 4; /! ( ?@ D47I:2B 1/ 844=:6 123
- 13 -
1B7:85=957:/9!'4D6F67
9<61 A6294;A429<=@:284A6 4; 9<6 36861/63 19 /! ( ?@ 9<6 7:?521= :/ 52C5/9:;:6312367742645/! ?$ 68423=@
1/ E67 9<6 =1D =1:3 34D2 ?@ 9<6 '42.?=6 5E76A6 4579 :2 9<6 81/6 4; =>#! ? , ,
@" :2 81/6/
D<676 9<6 36861/63 D1/ /6=;( 6AE=4@63477686:F631;:J63/1=17@
12133:9:424;& K4;
9<6 6/91?=:/<63 :284A6 94D173/ >;59576 E74/E689/.
:/ D17712963 D<62 9<6 36861/63 D1/ ?6=4D 9<6 1B6 4; & @617/! <6 /1:3 E7:28:E=6 :/ 7:B<9=@ 1EE=:63 94 9<6 E76/629 81/6! 8$ <:73=@
1/E679<6C53BA6294;9<6'42.?=6 5E76A6 4579:29<681/64; =& ? , %
@
618< 4; 9<6 8=1:A129/:/629:9=639484AE62/19:424;/!&& (52367 9<6<6134;>=4//4;=4F61231;;689:42123842/479:5A.! - 14 -
3$ 1/9=@
842/:367:2B 9<6 1B6 123 1F4819:42 4; 9<6 36861/63
9<6 4F671== 84AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521=:/:2136M5196123429<6=4D67/:36! ):9< 9<6 1?4F6 8429629:42/
9<6 =617263 8452/6= /45B<9941==4D9<61EE61=! -! 2 9<6 49<67 <123
9<6 =617263 8452/6= ;47 9<6 2/571286 4AE12@ <1/ 71:/63 9<6 ;4==4D:2B 8452967( 8429629:42/ 1$ *:7/9=@
1=9<45B< 9<6 8=1:A129/ 8=1:A 9<19 9<6 36861/63 D1/ 6172:2B /! ( E67 A429<
9<6@ <1F6 ;1:=63 94 /5?/9129:196 9<6:7 8=1:A D:9< /5EE479:2B 3485A629/! 42/6M5629=@
9<6 7:?521= <1/ 8477689=@ 1 639<6:284A64;9<636861/63249:421==@! ?$ 68423=@
/:286 9<6 8=1:A129/ <1F6 249 6/91?=:/<63 9<6 :284A6 4; 9<6 36861/63
9<6@ 176 249 629:9=63 ;47 84AE62/19:4294D173/>;59576E74/E689/.! 8$ <:73=@
42 1EE768:19:42 4; 471= 123 3485A62917@ 6F:36286 123 842/:367:2B 9<6 1B6 123 1F4819:42 4; 9<6
- 15 -
36861/63
9<6 4F671== 84AE62/19:42 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521=:/C5/9123761/421?=6! ):9< 9<6 1?4F6 8429629:42/
9<6 =617263 8452/6= /45B<9943:/A://9<61EE61=! ! '6173 9<6 =617263 8452/6= ;47 9<6 E179:6/ 123 E675/639<6C53BA6291231D1734;9<67:?521=! ! 9 :/ 249 :23:/E596 9<1936861/63 1@1/<766 :71317 3:63 :2 9<6 7413 971;;:8 188:3629 48857763 42 ! ! - 3569471/<12326B=:B62937:F:2B4;9<64;;623:2BF6<:8=6 ?@:9/37:F67! ! <6 8=1:A129/ 8=1:A 9<19 36861/63 D1/ 6172:2B /! ( E67 A429<
?59 ;1:=63 94 E743586 /5EE479:2B 3485A629/94/5?/9129:1969<6:78=1:A!29<61?/62864; E744;4;:284A6
9<6249:421=:284A6<1/94?61 63! 42/:367:2B 9<6 6F:36286 4; )! D6 176 4; 9<6 4E:2:42 9<19 9<6 A429<=@ :284A6 4; 9<6 36861/63 <1/ 94 ?6 1 6319/! (!49<61;476/1:3:284A6
7:?521= <1/ 7:B<9=@ 13363 & K 42 1884529 4; ;59576 E74/E689/ :2
- 16 -
F:6D4;9<6=1D=1:334D2?@9<642/9:959:42628<4;9<6 5E76A6 4579 :2 A#! B #/5E71$! <5/
9<6 A429<=@:284A684A6/94/! (! :2869<676176 36E623629/
:9:/1EE74E7:19694363589 734;9<6:284A6 4;9<636861/6394D173/E67/421=6JE62/6/12376A1:2:2B 1A4529<1/94?691I621/<:/84297:?59:42949<6;1A:=@! <636861/63D1/1B631?459& @617/199<69:A64;9<6 188:3629123A5=9:E=:671EE=:81?=694<:/1B6B745E:/>.! <5/
9<6 8=1:A129/ 176 629:9=63 94 84AE62/19:42 4; -
",") #/! LLL $ 42 1884529 4;
>=4//4;36E623628@.! ! 2 133:9:42
9<6 7:?521= <1/ 7:B<9=@ 1 63 9<6 84AE62/19:42 4; -,") 42 1884529 4; >=4// 4;
6/9196. 123 84AE62/19:42 4; -,") 42 1884529 4;
>;52671=6JE62/6/.! &!
2F:6D4;9<6=1D=1:334D2?@9<6 5E76A64579:2 9<6 81/6 4; A B #/5E71$
- 17 -
8=1:A1294/!123
8<:=37624;9<636861/63176629:9=63 ;4784AE62/19:424;-")618<523679<6<6134;
>=4//4;E176291=842/479:5A.! ! <5/
9<6 8=1:A129/ 176 629:9=63 94 9<6 ;4==4D:2B 84AE62/19:42 ./01-234151607 6407013026- -2827606 9:3;0 749512< '-( -2827606 9:3;4- 573 '-( 4//4;36E623628@ ,
*52671=6JE62/6/
4//4;6/9196
176291=842/479:5A &
%63:81=JE62/6/ ,- ,- 32< ,"
"
",",
51606 ,"
"
",",
! 29<676/5=9
9<6;4==4D:2B47367:/E1//63
1$ <61EE61=/1762<<80641/273! - 18 -
?$ <6 C53BA629 4; 9<6 =1:A/ 7:?521= :/ A43:;:63! 8$ 2 %*!4! &
#% 4!& -$
9<68=1:A129:/629:9=63941 9491= 84AE62/19:42 4; -"") 1/ 1B1:2/9 /!& ( 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521=! 3$ 2 %*!4! -
#% 4!&, -$
9<68=1:A129/176629:9=6394 19491=84AE62/19:424;-
",", )1/ 1B1:2/9 /! ,& ( 1D17363 ?@ 9<6 7:?521=! 6$ <6 2/571286 4AE12@ :/ 3:768963 94 36E4/:9 9<6 84AE62/19:42 1A4529 1=42B D:9< :29676/9 N K E!1! ;74A 9<6 3196 4;
;:=:2B 4; 9<6 8=1:A E69:9:42 9:== 9<6 3196 4;
761=:H19:42
D:9<:2 1 E67:43 4; /:J D66I/ ;74A 9<6 3196 4; 7686:E9 4; 1 84E@ 4; 9<:/ C53BA629! - 19 -
;$ <6 1EE479:42A629
36E4/:9 123 76=61/6 4;
1A4529 /<1== ?6 A136 :2 1884731286 D:9< 9<6967A/4;9<61D1734;9<67:?521=! B$ 2 %*!4! &
#% 4!& -$
9<6 7:?521= :/ 3:768963 94 76=61/69<6629:7684AE62/19:421A4529:2 ;1F457 4; 9<6 8=1:A129 1;967 356 :3629:;:819:42123F67:;:819:42! <$ 2 %*!4! -
#% 4!&, -$
:2 F:6D 4; 9<6 47367 31963 -!! E1//63 ?@ 9<:/ 4579
9<6 8=1:A129/ 176 249 629:9=63 ;47 :29676/9 42 9<662<1286384AE62/19:42;479<636=1@63 E67:434;&31@/:2;:=:2B9<61EE61=! 6) '# ( %
6) '!%&!( % ' :/94! =4!