Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92907 (KAR)

BASAVARAJ S/O CHANDRAKANT BIRADAR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER BIDAR

WA/200024/2022 · 2025-08-20

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$! "#$# !! %& ! " #$$ %&& ' $& ( $ && ! " #$ %& ( $$' ' $ ' ) *"*"**$ $ *"* +*"* Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & $ , $ $ ' $ ' , $$ & ' & & & -& $ -& & ' $# %$ -& & '( ./0/1234 5632477849/0:/98;61;838<2/515:2.8 431424=4 />. 5632 <2 + <499/1> /1 ?6802/51 2.8 53;83 ;428; *"*"** /1 $5*"* +*"* 74008; @A 2.8 984318; /1>98 6;>8 B.838 2.8 782/2/51 B40 ;/07508; 5: .59;/1> 2.42 2.8 53;83 74008; 61;83 118C638 /0 4 0607810/51 53;83 781;/1> 81?6/3A 41; 782/2/5183 B569; @8 >/D81 41 57753261/2A 25 762:532. ./0 04A/12.8E42283006<..89;2.422.853;83B4074008; 781;/1>81?6/3A;580152<499:5341A/1283:8381<840/2/0 15206::83/1>:35E41A783D830/2A - 3 - * 843;3/.34D41=6E43&42.984318;<561089 477843/1> :53 3/ $38824E 869>451=43 984318; <561089 :53 782/2/5183 41; 3/ &499/=43F61 4038;;A 984318; 5D831E812;D5<428:53380751;8122428 $83608;2.8812/38477849747830 84318;<5610893/.34D41=6E43&42.24=/1> 2./0 56322.356>.118C638 B569;06@E/22.42/1283E0 5: 2.8 53;83 74008;@A 2.8 /38<253428 5: &61/</749/2A 51 *"*"* 4 ;/38<2/51 .40 @881 /0068; 25 2.8 8762A 5EE/00/5183/;4325.59;4773573/428;/0</79/143A4<2/51 4>4/102 2.8 477899412 422.8/3 98D89 /1 283E0 5: 8:8381<8 549822835:2.85D831E81241;06@E/22.838753225 51)@98 5=4A6=24 41; 252.8 5D831E81205 4905 252.8 &61/</749 /38<253428:532.B/2..8384:28340.5B<4608 152/<804/;25.4D8@881/0068;40783118C638;428; G*"** @A 2.8 $35F8<2 /38<253 /023/<2 3@41 8D8957E812 899 /;43 .838/1 2.8 04/; 0.5B <4608 152/<8/12.89402:5639/1800242802.422.8083D/<805:2.8 - 4 - 477899412 /0 152 042/0:4<253A 0 06<. .8 .40 25 0.5B <4608B.A.80.499152@8389/8D8;:35E2.8083D/<8 .8 477899412 3879/8; 25 2.8 04/; 0.5B <4608 152/<8 40 783 118C638' ;428; **"* 24=/1> 4 <512812/512.42.8/0;/0<.43>/1>./0083D/<80B/2.56241A @98E/0.8/0406@53;/14285::/<8325./006783/5341;.8 .40 25 B53= 40 783 2.8/3 ;/38<2/51 41; ./0 14E8 B40 152 :561; /1 2.8 <5E794/12 >/D81 25 51)@98 5=4A6=24 41; 38?68028; 25 <510/;83 ./0 <408 51 .6E41/243/41 >3561; 5B8D83 40 783 118C638 2.8 8762A 5EE/00/5183 /;43 74008; 41 53;83 ;428; ***"* B.838@A 2.8 380751;812 8762A 5EE/00/5183 ;/0<512/168; 2.8 083D/<80 5: 2.8 477899412 .8 04/; 53;83 B40 <4998; /1 ?6802/51 @8:538 2.8 984318; /1>98 6;>8 /1 $5*"* +*"* .838/1 2.8 984318; ;;/2/5149 5D831E812 ;D5<428 42 7434>347. 5 .4; 06@E/228; 2.42 2.8 380751;812 462.53/2A .40 =872 ./E 61;83 0607810/51 781;/1> 81?6/3A 0 06<. 2.838 /0 15 /E78;/E812 :53 2.8 380751;812 462.53/2A 25 <51;6<2 - 5 - 81?6/3A /1 4<<53;41<8 B/2. 94B 4>4/102 2.8 477899412782/2/5183 + .8984318;/1>986;>8.4D/1><510/;838;2.8 04/;06@E/00/51.89;2.422.853;8342118C638/0F602 40607810/5153;8341;15206::83/1>:35E41A783D830/2A 2.42 255 B.81 /2 /0 74008; 781;/1> 81?6/3A 0 06<. ;/0E/008;2.8782/2/512/02./053;835:2.8984318;/1>98 6;>8 /0 <4998; /1 ?6802/51 /1 2./0 /1234 5632 477849 <<53;/1>9A056>.2254995B2.8477849 G 8:62/1>2.806@E/00/5105:984318;<561089:53 2.8 477899412H 984318; 5D831E812 ;D5<428 3/&499/=43F61 4038;;AD8.8E8129A06@E/202.420/1<8 2.8477899412B404B53=8324=8151<5124<2@40/0519A:53 518 A843 380751;812462.53/2A 4:283 /006/1> 4773573/428 152/<8;/0<512/168;./0083D/<8B./<./0/14<<53;41<8B/2. 94B 41; ;580 152 06::83 :53E 41A /1:/3E/2A 53 783D830/2A <<53;/1>9A 056>.2 25 ;/0E/00 2.8 477849 41; 25 <51:/3E 2.853;8374008;@A2.8984318;/1>986;>8 - 6 - ! 4D/1> .843; 2.8 984318; <561089 :53 2.8 7432/80 519A 2.8 75/12 2.42 B569; 43/08 :53 563 <510/;8342/51/0 I.82.83 2.8 53;83 42 118C638 B569; @8<5102368;40F6024153;835:0607810/5141; 152 41 53;83 283E/142/1> 2.8 083D/<80 5: 2.8 477899412JK 63410B83252.84@5D875/12:53<510/;8342/51 /0/118>42/D8:532.8:5995B/1> " .8 53;83 42 118C638 <98439A /1;/<4280 2.42 2.8782/2/5183477899412.838/1.40@881;/0<512/168;:35E 083D/<8 2 18D83 06>>8020 2.42 /2 /0 F602 41 53;83 5: 0607810/51781;/1>81?6/3A006<.2.8;649<512812/510 @A 2.8 984318; 5D831E812 ;D5<428 518 @8:538 984318; /1>986;>840/2/0F6024153;835:0607810/5141;@8:538 2./0 56322.422.853;8374008;;/0<512/16/1>2.8083D/<80 /0 F602/:/8; 438 /1<51>36812 06@E/00/510 <<53;/1>9A B8 - 7 - .59; 2.42 2.8 53;83 74008; /0 25 @8 <5102368; 40 F602 41 53;83 5: =887/1> 2.8 782/2/5183 61;83 0607810/51 .8 53;83<4E825@874008;51**"*B./<./00/>18;51 "*"*5BB8438/1*"* .5B8D8306@08?681225 ;/0E/00495:2.8B3/2782/2/51/12./04778492.838B4041 53;83 024A/1> 2.8 53;83 74008; @A 2.8 380751;812 462.53/2A1283E05:024A5:2.853;832.8782/2/5183.40 49384;A@88124=8143598 5B /2 /0 06@E/228; @A @52. 2.8 477899412)0 <56108940B89940984318;5D831E812;D5<4282.422.8 477899412782/2/5183/0<512/16/1>/1083D/<8:2.42@805 414773573/428;/0</79/143A4<2/51/1283E05:118C638 @8.89;4>4/102./E/2.2.429/@832A2./0 B3/2477849/0 ;/07508;5: * .8;/0</79/143A81?6/3A/025@8735<88;8;:35E 2.8 024>8 5: 2.8 3879A 25 152/<8 B./<. .40 49384;A @881 06@E/228; @A 2.8 477899412 25 2.8 0.5B <4608 152/<8 B/2.562 @8/1> /1:9681<8; @A 41A2./1> /1 2.8 0.5B <4608 - 8 - 152/<8.8384051@8/1>/2/049384;A@88102428;/12.8 0.5B<4608152/<82.422.8083D/<80/0152042/0:4<253A2.8 ;/0</79/143A 462.53/2A .40 25 <510/;83 2.8 <408 /1;8781;8129A @A >/D/1> 57753261/2A 25 @52. 2.8 7432/80 B/2./14783/5;5:2.388E512.0 '( %!& $ '( %#& $ /02595*!