Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92906 (KAR)

M/S DATTA @ COMPANY v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/201893/2025 · 2025-07-16

M I Arun

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"!#$#% & '$"' ()"* ! "#$ % & "!" ' ! !! " ""# Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !! )* ! " ""#+ " " ( ( % & !,""!' - " # + " ' " - " - - ( # + (" ' " - " - " + !! ( & '"$#+ ) * " - ". - 3 - . / ," " ! &. / ," "' 0121234052667281390750:2610508;7514056<2;=25> 748 21 <76 9004 :574108 ?2@0460 9A B@260 0;751>041 3= 1<0 1710 13 5C4 50172? ?2DC35 9C624066 <500;05634647>0?A&2'5276E757117150A7>97876 &22' 447 73 06<>CE< &222' 52 7>06< F050 1<0 ;75140563=1<0=25><7G24:76<7503=$H#H748H 506;0@12G0?A 24 1<0 ;7514056<2; 1 26 6C9>21108 1<71 52 7>06< 8208 748 1<0 ;7514056<2; :31 50@346121C108 9A 7??3@7124:1<06<7503=H90?34:24:137>06<24=7G3C5 3= 340 I7A 7117157A 76E75 748 1<0 80172?6 3= 1<0 ;506041;7514056<2;2676=3??3F6. ?3 7>03=1<0751405 7123 76E757117157A>97876 $H 44757306<>CE< #H I7A7117157A76E75 H - 4 - <0 =25> <76 50DC06108 =35 5040F7? 3= ?2@0460 =35 1<0 A075 # 3F0G05 43 7@1234 <76 900417E04341<067>09A1<0506;348041604@01<0 ;506041F521;012123426=2?08 <0 @760 3= 1<0 ;012123405 26 1<71 21 26 7 50:2610508 =25> 748 21 @74 6C0 748 90 6C08 24 216 3F4 47>0 1 26 =C51<05 @34104808 1<71 1<0 =25> F76 :574108 ?2@0460=351<0A075748C;348071<3=340 3= 1<0 ;7514056 21 <76 9004 50@346121C108 9A 248C@124: 7431<0540F;05634748<0<761<06<7503=1<080@07608 ;05634F<2@<26H34?A7481<05061+H263F4089A 1<0075?205;7514056 0?274@0 26 ;?7@08 34 C?0 +& ' 3= !754717E7 B@260 &04057? 348212346 3= 2@04@06' C?06 76 7>04808241<0A075C?0+& '&'5078676C4805. + ,-./0,1230.302.450,3-/0/ &'31F21<6174824:74A1<24:@3417240824C?0 ?2@04@06266C08 - 5 - &2'=35 7?0 3= 48274 2DC35 &31<05 1<74 7557@E'353502:42DC3535931<2435> 3 &-<3?067?0 ?2@04@0' 35 &50172? 6<3; ?2@04@06' J # &175 310? 2@04@0'K 35 + &310? 748 375824: 3C60 2@04@06' =35 + &310? 748 375824: 3C60 2@04@06 3F408 9A 1<0 ;0563490?34:24: 13 @<08C?08 76106 35 @<08C?08 52906'K35 $&0=506<>041 533> & 75' 2@04@0 C4805 1<0 !754717E7 B@260 &7?0 3= 48274 748 3502:4 2DC356'C?06$#L35 &22' =35 67?0 3= 005 C4805 1<0 !754717E7 B@260 &0760 3= 2:<1 3= 0172? 048 3= 005'C?06$+#L <0 0;C1A 3>>26623405 >7A 34 74 7;;?2@712349A1<0?2@04600748J6C9I0@113;7A>041 3= 15746=05 =00 0DC2G7?041 13 1F2@0 1<0 744C7? ?2@04@0 =00K 6;0@2=208 24 C?0 3= 1<0 !754717E7 B@260 &7?0 3= 48274 748 3502:4 2DC356' C?06 $# 35 C?0 3= 1<0 !754717E7 B@260 &0760 3= 2:<1 3= 0172? 048 3= 005 C?06 $+# 76 1<0 @760 >7A 90 748 F21< 1<0 ;5235 7;;53G7? 3= 1<0 B@260 3>>26623405 15746=05 6C@< ?2@04@0 24 =7G3C53=74A;0563447>089A6C@<?2@04@02=6C@< ;05634 26 0?2:29?0 =35 :5741 3= 7 ?2@04@0 C4805 1<0 !754717E7 B@260 @1 $# 35 1<0 5C?06 >780 1<050C4805. - 6 - J53G28081<7124@7603=72@04@0:57410824 35> +&310?748 375824:3C602@04@06'13 7 ;05634 90?34:24: 13 1<0 @<08C?08 76106 6<7?? 90 15746=05508 34?A 13 7 ;05634 90?34:24: 13 1<0 @<08C?08 761067481<02@04@0:5741082435> + 13 7 ;05634 90?34:24: 13 1<0 @<08C?08 52906 6<7?? 90 15746=05508 34?A 13 7 ;05634 90?34:24:131<0@<08C?0852906761<0@760>7A 9041<0@7603=7514056<2;25>7??1<0;7514056 6<7?? 90?34: 13 1<0 @<08C?08 76106 35 1<0 @<08C?0852906761<0@760>7A9041<0@760 3= 7 3>;74A 24@35;357108 C4805 1<0 3>;74206 @1 7?? 1<0 250@1356 6<7?? 90?34: 13 1<0 @<08C?08 76106 35 1<0 @<08C?08 52906 76 1<0 @760>7A90 <0 =3??3F24: 7>048>041 <76 9004 241538C@08 241<0A075=351<067>0 60.760.4 810 4 5C?0 + 3= 1<067285C?06L &'7=1056C95C?0&'1<0=3??3F24:;53G2623466<7?? 902460510847>0?A. M53G28081<71241<0@7603= 7514056<2;=25> 74A @<74:0 24 1<0 @346121C1234 3= ;7514056<2; 1<71 F2??506C?1242>;?2080==0@12G0@<74:03=@34153?748 >747:0>041 3= 1<0 6728 ;7514056<2; =25> 20 2= =2=1A ;05@041 35 >350 3= 216 617E0 24 1<0 ;53=21 6<7524: 57123 @<74:06 <7486 748 0B26124: 61504:1< - 7 - 3=:53C; 3=;7514056 ?3606=2=1A;05@04135>350 3= 1<01317?617E03=@041;05@0411<046C@<7@<74:0 24 1<0 @346121C1234 3= ;7514056<2; =25> F2?? 71157@1 1<0;7A>0413=15746=05=00C4805C?0+ <0 ;53G263267;;?2@79?0=3507@<@<74:01<71<7617E04 ;?7@0241<0;7514056<2;=25>7=105+. 53G2808 =C51<05 1<71 2= @<74:06 24 1<0 ;7514056<2; =25> 26 90?3F =2=1A ;05@041 1<04 6C@< @7606 F2?? 431 71157@1 1<0 ;7A>041 3= 15746=05 =00 C4805 C?0 + = 1<0 3G057?? @<74:06 24 1<0 ;7514056<2; =25> 7=105 + 50>7246 F21<24 =2=1A ;05@0413=216617E0241<0 ;53=216<7524:57123 7480B26124:61504:1<3=:53C;3=;75140568306431 =2=1A ;05@041 35 >350 3= 1<0 1317? 617E0 3= @041 ;506041 1<04 6C@< 7 @<74:0 24 1<0 @346121C1234 3= ;7514056<2; =25> 6<7?? 431 71157@1 1<0 ;7A>041 3= 15746=05=00C48055C?0+ &2' <0 @<74:0 3= =2=1A ;05@041 35 >350 F2??9050@E3408F21<50=0504@0131<0 0B26124:B@260?2@04@0@3>;36212343= =25> 748 15746=05508 B@260 ?2@04@0 C4805 5C?0 + 748 71 1<0 0G05A 617:0 3= =2=1A ;05@041 35 >350 3= @<74:03=617E09A0B217480415A3= ;7514056 24 1<0 =25> 21 6<7?? 71157@1 1<015746=05=006C4805C?0+ &22' <0 6728 ;53G2636 750 431 7;;?2@79?0 13 1<0 @7606 24 F<2@< 74A @<74:06 1<71 <78 3@@C5508 24 1<0 0B26124: - 8 - ;7514056<2; =25> ;5235 13 +46C@<@76061<0?2@0460026 93C48 13 ;7A 1<0 15746=05 =00 25506;0@12G0 3= 74A @<74:0 24 ;05@0417:0 3= 617E0 24 1<0 ;7514056<2;=25>3561504:1<3=:53C; 3=;75140563531<05F260 53G28087?631<71 1<015746=05=00 C4805C?0 + 267?637;;?2@79?0241<00G0413=@34G0562343= ;7514056<2;=25>24137;53;520175A@34@05435G2@0 G0567 25506;0@12G0 3= =2=1A ;05@041 35 >350 3= @<74:0246<750352431<05F35860==0@12G0@34153? 3=1<0;7514056<2;=25> &' 7=105 6C95C?0 &' 1<0 =3??3F24: 6C95C?0 6<7?? 902460510847>0?A. M&'4A@<74:0624@?C824:8071<3=;75140535 50@346121C1234 3= ;7514056<2; =25> 6<7?? 90 953C:<1 131<04312@03=1<00;C1A 3>>266234053=B@260 F21<24 =351A =2G0 87A6 =53> 1<0 8710 3= 1<0 3@@C5504@03=8071<35@<74:03550@346121C12343= ;7514056<2; =25> 35 @34G056234 3= ;7514056<2; =25> 2413 7 ;53;520175A @34@054 35 G2@0G0567 =72?24: F<2@<1<07C1<3521A:574124:1<0?2@04@06<7??<7G0 826@50123413@74@0?1<0?2@04@0352>;3607=240 53G28081<717?2@04@06<7??43190@74@0??0835 436C@<=2406<7??90?0G208C4?066743;;351C421A3= 9024: <0758 26 :2G04 13 1<0 ?2@04600 35 1<0 ?0:7? - 9 - <025<02563=1<080@07608?2@04600351<0:C758274 3=1<0?0:7?<025N # <0 ?075408 88212347? 3G054>041 8G3@710 =725?A6C9>2161<717>048>041<7624800817E04;?7@013 C?0 +& ' 3= !754717E7 B@260 &04057? 348212346 3= 2@04@06'C?06748F<0503403=1<0;75140568208 748 1<050 F76 50@346121C1234 3= ;7514056<2; =25> F<04 6C@<740G04183064317?105>3501<74H3=6<750624 1<0 075?205 ;7514056<2; 24 1<71 0G041 21 8306 431 71157@1 15746=05=000=C51<056C9>2161<711<0;7;056;538C@08 7?34: F21< 1<0 F521 ;0121234 8306 431 6<3F F<01<05 1<0 ;012123405 <76 ;728 1<0 31<05 7>3C416 76 50DC2508 C4805 ?7F35431F21<247612;C?710812>0<050264339I0@1234 24 7??3F24: 1<0 F521 ;0121234 6C9I0@1 13 ;012123405 ;7A24: 1<0 31<05 8C06 24 7@@35874@0 F21< ?7F 748 6C9I0@1 13 ;012123405 @3>;?A24: F21< 31<05 105>6 748 @348212346 76 50DC2508C4805?7F + 04@01<0=3??3F24:. - 10 - 06;3480416 750 8250@108 13 :2G0 1<0 9040=21 3= 0@1234 +& ' 3= !754717E7 B@260&04057? 3482123463= 2@04@06' C?06 13 1<0 ;012123405 9A 431 80>74824: 1<0 15746=05 =00 748 @3462805 1<0 @760 3= 1<0 ;012123405 =35 5040F7? 3= ?2@0460 24 7@@35874@0 F21< ?7F 748 7;;53;52710 358056 6<3C?8 90 ;76608 F21<24 7 ;05238 3= =3C5F00E6=53>1<087103=50@02;13=@0512=208@3;A3=1<26 35805 <0F521;012123426826;36083=7@@35824:?A O "79 ('* $! 2613.?3.+ .