- 1 - !" #$% %% & '() * ! " "# $%"& ' (( ""&" ($'( $%"&' (') "$ '%&*'&'' ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (( "*"!( ( '+&*'&'" "'' '&"+( ( (*''& $ ( , , - $ " ./0122314/05/436789.3:41/;1<91=1/<099.3 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 61936 '+&*'&'" 210036 78 9.3 66/9/B<143</BA/C/4?6=31<61417?A1=/D5BA 0.BA9 EA/7?<14FG /< B"'' '&"+ 033H/<= 3<.1<:3;3<9B5:B;23<019/B< ' .3 /<>?A36 :41/;1<9 1=36 I 831A0 ;39 @/9. 1< 1::/63<9 B< &'&#'&"+ 1<6 0?091/<36 =A/3CB?0 /<>?A/30 .3 :41/;1<9 5/436 :41/; 239/9/B< 735BA3 9.3 A/7?<14 033H/<= :B;23<019/B< B5 0"&&&&& $ .3 A/7?<14 1593A :B<0/63A/<= 9.3 3<9/A3 3C/63<:3 B< A3:BA6 1@1A636 9.3 :B;23<019/B< B5 0'+**+ $ @/9. /<93A309 - 3 - 19#J23A1<<?;5AB;9.36193B5239/9/B<9/44A314/K19/B< 1<66/A3:936A302B<63<9B'$<0?A1<:3B;21<89B218 9.3 :B;23<019/B< ==A/3C36 78 9.3 01/6 1@1A6 9.3 1223441<9$:41/;1<9.102A353AA369./0122314 31A6 1A=?;3<90 B5 7B9. 9.3 21A9/30 1<6 23A?0369.3;193A/1401C1/41743B<A3:BA6 I 31A<36:B?<034 5BA 9.31223441<9 :41/;1<9 .10 :B<93<6369.199.3:B;23<019/B<1@1A636789.3A/7?<14 /0 /<163L?193 9 /0 :B<93<636 9.19 :41/;1<9 0?091/<36 5A1:9?A3 B5 4359 A16/?0 1<6 ?4<1 1<6 74?<9 9A1?;1 < 0?22BA9B5.3A:1030.3=B93M1;/<369.3B:9BA10 ' @.B /00?36 M* N /017/4/98 3A9/5/:193 100300/<= '*J 6/017/4/98 9B 9.3 @.B43 7B68 7?9 9.3 A/7?<14 .10 91H3< B<48 +J 6/017/4/98 9 /0 5?A9.3A :B<93<636 9.19 0.3 @10 31A</<= 0"&&& $ 23A ;B<9. 7?9 9.3 A/7?<14 :B<0/63A369.3<B9/B<14/<:B;3190"'& $23A;B<9. @./:. /0 B< 9.3 4B@3A 0/63 .3A35BA3 A3L?30936 5BA 3<.1<:/<= 9.3 :B;23<019/B< /< .3A 51CB?A @/9. "'J /<93A30923A1<<?; - 4 - 9 /0 0?7;/9936 78 9.3 431A<36 :B?<034 5BA A302B<63<9 B' N <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 9.19 9.3 :B;23<019/B<1@1A636789.3A/7?<14/0>?091<62AB23A 1<6<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3 # .3 1223441<9 .10 0?091/<36 9@B =A/3CB?0 /<>?A/30 "! 4?<9 A1?;1 4359 5BA31A; 1<6 '! 5A1:9?A3 B5 4359 A16/B?0 1<6 ?4<1 ' $ B:9BA /00?36 M* N/017/4/98 3A9/5/:193 9B 9.3 :41/;1<9 0919/<='*J 6/017/4/98 9B 9.3 @.B43 7B68 1<6 9.3 A/7?<14 :B<0/63A/<= 9.3 01;3 .10 A/=.948 91H3< " B5 '*J /3 +J 10 5?<:9/B<146/017/4/98@./:.<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3 * .B?=. 9.3 :41/;1<9 091930 9.19 0.3 @10 31A</<=0"&&& $23A;B<9.0.3.10<B92AB6?:361<8 6B:?;3<9 9B 2ABC3 9.3 01;3 0 9.3 1::/63<9 /0 B5 9.3 831A '&"+ 10 23A 9.3 :.1A9 2A321A36 78 9.3 1A<191H1 9193 3=14 3AC/:30 ?9.BA/98 9.3 A/7?<14 .10 A/=.948 91H3< 9.3 <B9/B<14 /<:B;3 19 0"'& $ 23A ;B<9.1<6 1@1A636 0"%#&& $ 9B@1A60 4B00 B5 5?9?A3 31A</<= :121:/98@./:.<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3789./0B?A9 - 5 - % .3:41/;1<9@1016;/9936/<9.3.B02/9145BAI 6180B<0/63A/<=9.323A/B6B5.B02/914/K19/B<<19?A3B5 /<>?A/30 1<6 B9.3A A343C1<9 51:9BA0 9./0 B?A9 5/<60 /9 A310B<1743 9B 1@1A6 1< 1;B?<9 B5 0&&&& $ 5BA 21/< 1<6 0?553A/<= 0'&&& $ 5BA 4B00 B5 1;3</9/30 1<6 0&&&& $ 5BA 9A1<02BA919/B< 3M9A1 <B?A/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1A=30 (?A9.3A 6?3 9B /<>?A/30 9.3 :41/;1<9 ;/=.9<B9.1C31993<6361<8@BAH19431095BA123A/B6B5I ;B<9.0 .3<:3 9./0 B?A9 5/<60 /9 A310B<1743 9B 1@1A6 0&&& $ 5BA 4B00 B5 /<:B;3 6?A/<= 41/6 ?2 23A/B6 B@3C3A 9.3 :B;23<019/B< B5 0I" $ 1@1A636 78 9.3A/7?<145BA;36/:143M23<030<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3 + (?A9.3A /9 /0 0?7;/9936 9.19 9.3 :41/;1<9 .10 ?<63A=B<3 0?A=3A8 5BA A3;BC14 B5 9.3 /;241<90 .3A35BA39./0B?A95/<60/9>?091<6A310B<17439B1@1A6 0'&&& $9B@1A605?9?A3;36/:143M23<030 "& .3 :B;23<019/B< 1@1A636 78 9.3 A/7?<14 /0 ;B6/5/3610?<63A, - 6 - 4 B 3160 @1A6789.3 A/7?<14 @1A6789./0 B?A9 " 1/<1<60?553A/<= 0&&&& $ 0&&&& $ ' 36/:14M23<030 0I" $ 0I" $ B00 B5 5?9?A3 31A</<=:121:/98 0"%#&& $ 0"%#&& $ I A1<02BA919/B< 3M9A1 <B?A/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1A=30 0"&&&& $ 0&&&& $ B00B51;3</9/30 0"&&& $ 0'&&& $ # B00 B5 /<:B;3 6?A/<= 41/6 ?2 23A/B6 0"'& $ 0&&& $ * (?9?A3 ;36/:14 3M23<030 $$ 0'&&& $ B914 0'+**+ $ 0I"'I $ .3A3@/44733<.1<:3;3<9B50""I*& $ "" 302B<63<9 B' N <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 .10 14A3168 632B0/936 9.3 :B;23<019/B< 1;B?<9 1@1A636 78 9.3A/7?<14 "' <9.3A30?499.35B44B@/<=BA63A/0210036, - 7 - /! 22314/0 //! .3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 5BA 9.3 3<.1<:36 :B;23<019/B< B5 0""I*& $ @/9. /<93A309 19 #J 23A 1<<?; 5AB; 9.3 6193 B5 239/9/B<9/449.36193B5A314/K19/B< ///! 302B<63<9 B' N <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 /0 6/A3:936 9B 632B0/9 9.3 15BA301/6 :B;23<019/B<1;B?<914B<=@/9./<93A309@/9./< B<3;B<9.5AB;9.36193B59./0>?6=;3<9 /C! < 0?:. 632B0/9 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 23A;/99369B@/9.6A1@9.33<9/A31;B?<914B<= @/9./<93A3091::A?36B</9 +& '%) $ /09B,"4B,I ,