Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92898 (KAR)
TALUKA SHIKSHANA PRASARAK SAHAKARA MANDALI AND ORS v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
WP/201728/2024 · 2025-12-08
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92898 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92898 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#& # #
'() *
! +'()
*
! " #
$ %
! Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
$ %
! $ %
! $ %
'
$ %
$ %
$
$ %
- 3 -
(
# $ %
$ %
$ %
" )
$ %
&
$ %
$ %
- 4 -
$ %
'
$ %
$ %
$
$ %
(
$ %
$ %*+
- 5 -
$ %
"
$ %
&
$ %
$ %
) $ %
'
$ %
- 6 -
$ %
$
$ %
"( $ %
"
$ %
" )
$ %
""
)
$ %
- 7 -
"&
$ %
"
$ %
"
$ %
"' )
$ %
" $ %
"$
$ %
- 8 -
&( ) )
$ %
& )
$ %
&
$ %
,
-
. /
- 9 -
. /
)
) (((
. /
) ((
"
) ((
&
&
((
)
((($
- 10 -
0
) (( 0
-
. 1
"1
&1
/
) ' / ),
& ((
0 ((
"
0 ( &(& (
0
)
(
)
"
, /
)
2
- 11 -
!*
+
"
$ %
("
&
) $ %
(""
)
$ %
("&
- 12 -
#
$ %
("
'
$ %
("
$ %
("'
$
$ %
(&(
(
$ %
(&
- 13 -
$ %
(&
$ %
(&"
"
$ %
(&
&
$ %
(&
$ %
(&'
- 14 -
)
$ %
(&
'
$ %
(&$
$ %
((
$ )
$ %
(
(
$ %
(
- 15 -
$ %
((
$ %
(
"
$ %
(&
&
$ %
(
$ %
('
- 16 -
$ %
(
' )
$ %
($
,
. /
. /
)
) (((
. - 17 -
/
) ((
"
) ((
&
&
((
0
) (( 0
. 1
"1
&1
/
- 18 -
)
/ )
" . /
"& 0
)
)
/
)
2
)
%
% ! 3+4+45637* 873 93:573 +;4* 5<7+ *33=46> :5??5@46> 73?43:*%
*
% /
!
"#$
% ! "#$
&$'
! "#(
&&
)"*+
"
,-
+ %. &&
&
/
-
01& . 2
- 19 -
!*
+
/
% 34560+/
- - % #
&
& &
! &&
-
2 - /
-
01& . -
2
( ;3>743A86B3 5:+;3 C3+4+45637* 4*+;8+ :57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 (( 86D ( 9F 86 57D37 D8+3D (73*C56D36+5;8DD3B?463DC37E4**456:57 +8=46> 8DE4**456 5: *+<D36+* :57 B5<7*3 @4+; &( <6D37>78D<8+3*38+*56+;3C73E4*35:656B5EC?486B35:
+;3 73G<473E36+* B56+3EC?8+3D <6D37 +;3 C75A4*456* 5: 6D4863D4B8?36+78?5<6B4?B+./B+$'(
(" 8*3 5: +;3 C3+4+45637* 4* +;8+ D<746> +;3 ($ C86D3E4B 65 46*C3B+456* @373 B56D<B+3D
5@3A37 56 ((( 86D ($(( +;3 8+4568? 5<6B4? 5: 6D486 F*+3E 5: 3D4B463 . / ;8D B56D<B+3D*<7C74*346*C3B+45686D;8D*<9E4++3D73C57+5:
- 20 -
656B5EC?486B3 +5 +;3 ;3 C3+4+45637* +;3 5??3>3 ;8D *<9E4++3D +;3 B5EC?486B3 73C57+ D8+3D (( @4+; 8?? 63B3**87F D5B<E36+* 8?56> @4+;
D3+84?* 5: +;733 8DD4+4568? 63@ +38B;46> *+8:: 43 7 ;3+86 8++8+73F8 <?8=8764 7 8+4*; 8+;5D 86D 7 3368=*;4 8D8A8668A87 :57 +;3 C<7C5*3 5: >786+46> C37E4**456 :57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 (( ;8+ 56 ((( +;3 C3+4+45637* B5??3>3 ;8D 8CC3873D 86D 73G<3*+3D +5B56*4D37+;347D3+84?3D73C57+:57>786+ 5:B56D4+4568?C37E4**456:578B8D3E4BF387(;8+ @4+;5<+86FC745746+4E8+45657:<7+;37B?874:4B8+4565786F 65+4B3573A36@4+;5<+C75A4D46>86FC37*568?;38746>+;3 73*C56D36+5*+784>;+8@8F73H3B+3D+;3C37E4**456:57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 ( 9F 57D37 D8+3D ( 86D((D36F46>+;3C37E4**456:578DE4**456+5 F387 B5<7*3 8+ C3+4+45637 5 B5??3>3 :57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 ( 8* C37 663I<73* 86D ;3738:+37+;3C3+4+45637*C73:3773D868CC38?93:573+;3 73*C56D36+546+37E*5: 3B+456$ <9?8<*3./5:
- 21 -
+;3 B+ ;3 73*C56D36+ 5 A4D3 57D37 D8+3D (B56:47E46>+;357D37C8**3D9F+;373*C56D36+ 5 D4*E4**3D +;3 8CC38? 346> 8>>743A3D +;3 C3+4+45637*87393:573+;4*5<7+
(& 38763D B5<6*3? 8CC38746> :57 +;3 C3+4+45637* +8=46> +;4* 5<7+ +;75<>; +;3 73B57D* *<9E4+* +;8+ 8:+37 4**<86B3 5: B5EE<64B8+456 8+ 663I<73 D8+3D ( 9F +;3 73*C56D36+ 5 C546+46> 5<+ +;3 *;57+B5E46>*+;3C3+4+45637JB5??3>3;8D4**<3D873C?F 9746>46> +5 4+* 65+4B3 +;3 B5EC?486B3 E8D3 9F +;3 46*+4+<+456* 3*<9E4+*+;8++;3D3+84?*5:+;3B5EC?486B3 73C57+ *<9E4++3D @5<?D 46D4B8+3 +;8+ 8* 8>846*+ +;3 D3:4B436BF 46 +;3 73G<473D 6<E937 5: *+8:: +;373 @373 *<9*+86+48?
B5EC?486B3 +5 +;3 3::3B+ 5: (K 5: +;3 *+8::* 9346> 46 C?8B3 3 *<9E4+* +;8+ 3A36 D<746> +;4* C3745D +;3 73*C56D36+ 8<+;574+43* ;8D 4**<3D 65+4:4B8+456 73?8I46> +;3 73G<473E36+ 5: B5EC?486B3 @4+; +;3
- 22 -
73><?8+456* C75A4*456* 5: +;3 B+ ;8+ +;3 C3+4+45637* @373 65+ 3A36 >4A36 5CC57+<64+F :57 C73*36+46> +;3 B8*3 C37*568??F86D+;357D37*;8A39336C8**3DE3B;864B8??F @4+;5<+ +8=46> 46+5 B56*4D378+456 +;3 C3745D @4+;46 @;4B; +;3*38??3>3D*;57+B5E46>*@373C546+3D5<+ 3*<9E4+* +;8+ E5*+ 5: +;3 +38B;46> :8B<?+F 86D +;3 *+8:: @373 5<+*4D37*86DD<3+5$C86D3E4BC3745D+;3F@373 73?43A3D 86D 4+ +55= +4E3 :57 +;3E +5 73H546 A36 +;3 46*+4+<+456* 8?*5 ;8D +5 >78CC?3 @4+; +;3 *4+<8+456 5:
73B7<4+46> +;3 63@ *+8:: 6 86F 3A36+ +;3 73?8I8+456 C75A4D3D 9F +;3 73*C56D36+ 8<+;574+43* 5<>;+ +5 ;8A3 9336 =3C+ 46 E46D 9F 73*C56D36+ 5* 86D 93:573 C8**46>+;34EC<>63D57D37 36B3*33=*:578??5@46>5: +;3C3+4+456
( 74 33C8= 878D +;3 ?38763D B5<6*3? 8CC38746> :57 +;3 73*C56D36+ 5 8+ +;3 5<+*3+ *<9E4+* +;8+ +;373 B8665+ 93 86F 73?8I8+456 @4+; 73>87D +5
- 23 -
B5EC?486B35:+;373G<473E36+5: 3B+456"./5:6D486 3D4B8?36+78?5<6B4?B+$'( 3:<7+;37*<9E4+*3A36 8**<E46> +;3 C3+4+45637* ;8D B5EC?43D @4+; +;3 D3:4B436B43*C546+3D5<++;3*84DB5EC?486B3;8A46>9336 E8D3@8F*<9*3G<36++5+;3C3745D5:73G<473E36+B8665+ 93>4A3673+75*C3B+4A33::3B+ 3*<9E4+*+;8++;373@373 (& D3C87+E36+* @;373 +;3 73*C56D36+ 5 ;8D C546+3D 5<+ +;3 *;57+B5E46>* 5: +;3 +38B;46> *+8:: ;3 *84D D3C87+E36+* 873 ./ 74F8 ;87337 ./ 5>64D;86 ."/ @8*+;8A74++8 86D 5>8 .&/
78*<+4 86+78 86D <E87 ;74+F8 J 8?8 5>8 3 *<9E4+* +;8+ +;3 D3+84?* 5: +;3 :8B<?+43* :<764*;3D 9F +;3 C3+4+45637* D4D 65+ 3A36 E33+ +;3 E464E<E 73G<473E36+ B56+3EC?8+3D <6D37 +;3 3><?8+456 B;3D<?3 373?43*<C56+;3H<D>E36+5:+;3 C3I 5<7+ 46 +;3 B8*3 5: ! " # 73C57+3D 46 $ % & ' 73:37746> +5 C878>78C; " 5: +;3 *84D H<D>E36+ ;3 46*4*+* +;8+ +;3
- 24 -
C37E4**456>786+3D:57+;3*<9*3G<36+F387*B8665+36<73 +5+;39363:4+5:+;3C73A45<*8B8D3E4BF387*@;373+;373 @8* 8 D3:4B436BF 46 :<?:4??E36+ 5: +;3 B74+3748 3 *<9E4+* +;8+ *<B; B5EC?486B3 ;8* +5 93 93:573 +;3 36D 5:
"(57+;3C73A45<*8B8D3E4BF387;8+4646*+86+ B8*3 +;3 8DE4**456* @373 E8D3 :57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 ((**<B;+;3B5EC?486B34:86F5<>;++5;8A3 9336 E8D3 56 57 93:573 "(( 86D +;3 46:57E8+456 :<764*;3D 9F +;3 C3+4+45637* 73>87D46> +;3 C<7C57+3D B5EC?486B3 4* 5: +;3 F387 ( ;373:573 8CC?F46> +;3 ?8@?84DD5@69F+;3C3I5<7+4+B8665+93B56*+7<3D8* B5EC?486B3 36B3*33=*:57D4*E4**8?5:+;3C3+4+456*
( 38763D 3C<+F 5?4B4+57 36378?
5: 6D48 8CC38746> :57 +;3 73*C56D36+ 5 *<9E4+* +;8+ 8:+37 B5E46> 46+5 :57B3 5: 8+4568? 5EE4**456 5: 6D486 F*+3E5:3D4B463B+((8*3B56D8CC38?4*C75A4D3D <6D37 3B+456 $./ 86D +;3 C3+4+45637* ;8A3 3I;8<*+3D +;3*84D73E3DF86D46+;389*36B35:C3+4+45637*C546+46>
- 25 -
5<+ 86F 4??3>8?4+F +;3 *84D 57D37 B8665+ 93 73A4*4+3D
5@3A37 ;3 :847?F *<9E4+* +;8+ *46B3 +;3 C3+4+45637* 873 B?84E46> +5 ;8A3 B5EC?43D @4+; +;3 73G<473E36+ 46 :<7+;3786B3 +5 +;3 73?8I8+456 5: <?3* 8* 4**<3D 9F +;3 5A376E36+ 5: 6D48 464*+7F 5: F<*; 46 4+* B5EE<64B8+456 D8+3D ("( 86D (&( 4: +;3 C3+4+45637* E8=3 8 :73*; 73C73*36+8+456* C75A4D46> +;3 D3+84?* 5: +;3 B5EC?486B3 *5 B?84E3D +5 ;8A3 9336 E8D3 86D 4: +;3F :8?? @4+;46 +;3 C878E3+37* 5: 73?8I8+456 C75A4D3D+;3*8E3@4??9373B56*4D373D
(' ;3*84D*<9E4**456+8=365673B57D
( 387D
37<*3D+;373B57D*
($ ;3 ?38763D B5<6*3? :57 +;3 C3+4+45637* ;8* :<764*;3D 8 +89<?8+456 *;5@46> +;3 B5EC?486B3 E8D3 8* 8>846*+ +;3 D3:4B436B43* C546+3D 5<+ @;4B; 4* 3I+78B+3D ;373<6D37:57+;34EE3D48+3C37<*8?%
- 26 -
7")68"79 :70 4$5"4; 79 .9*'8".$ 9< ;$<.$.$+ '97$; 967", .9*'8".$ 4$'947
'
.&&= +
.&
7 + =
;
>
&
&& %
&
'
.&&
& %
%
? @ *+4?9 - '
.&&
(
& ) ! *( & #"#! 7 ! % 8
' 7
! " &# &
?% % *
" ! % 8
;
'
7 - A &
8
0 &
;
' 7
B59- *
",6+0 C
&
8 %$'3/ ?% &#
'&
"+6 D + .&&
.9C;> '
E
A & && &&
& &
&
! ;" "&
",4)F3;
4 / & @ 8
&& && &' 4$";$4
4
"@4
","7%?3;
"7 / &@ 8 && && & ' 4$";$4
"7
- 27 -
.;A! *4
",+A? 3;
+&@7 /"8 && &
4$";$4
; + )! @
",4 F% 3;
4 / " 8 && &
4$";$4 %
:
:
& @
& ';- 9';
. & 4
9
&& 3 &
/ ! & @ 3
=
* &"&&; 4 2/D
=
* &4 2
&';-9';. &4
7 & .+*
0
-
0 . ! &&
+ #! , "#-+#! , ./"#),0"#1#" &+ ;
-
'
.&&& 7:9050$4<".687$+ ;+ 4 D;C@ &&&7-
0 <
&
! ;+ 4$";$47-
&
& && 0 <
&
! ;
&
( ;<*8BB57D46>+5+;3C3+4+45637*8*8>846*++;3 +;733 4+3E* 5: *;57+B5E46>* C546+3D 5<+ 9F +;3 73*C56D36+* +;373 ;8* 9336 *<9*+86+48? B5EC?486B3 8*
- 28 -
65+3D 895A3 ;8+ @4+;5<+ 8CC73B48+46> +;3 *8E3 +;3 8CC38?:4?3D9F+;3C3+4+45637*;8*9336D4*E4**3D9F+;3 73*C56D36+5@4+;5<+8CC?4B8+4565:E46D ;373?3A86+C57+4565:+;357D37C8**3D9F+;3 73*C56D36+ 5 @;4?3 D4*E4**46> +;3 8CC38?
:4?3D 9F +;3 C3+4+45637* <6D37 3B+456 $./ C75D<B3D 8+ 663I<73 738D*8*<6D37% L./ 9*37A8+456 5: 36+78? 5A376E36+% 6 3I8E4646> +;3 *<9E4**456 E8D3 9F +;3 B5??3>3 8+ +;3 +4E3 5: +;3 *3B56D 8CC38?86DD5B<E36+*73B34A3D:75E +;359*37A8+4564* 8*<6D37% 7
&& & 2
! & &
! &
0
& 7
&&
;A ' A-8
;
A +
; C@ * &&&
+ C
D , '
% ; + )! @ 4
4
-
"4& %
*
. & . & 3 *
"! &&
0 &/ 4& -?G4 * +
G3/ 3/ 7 "! .&& &
%" #
%. "
& && & &
&
&
%
;
! @
-
- 29 -
3/ 7 . & . & && ! .&&
# HG ! !- &
&& % ; 7- &
&
", 4 0 <
& 30</4*+-?= 0<
?65 4*+- ? 0!- &
-<
3
&#
+ D ' 7 / ! &&7- & &&
< - ! & ! &&
;
A + - 4 "! C @
C - + ! -
A
0
-
0
&
& ! &# &
*
" ?% .&& ! & &# &
;
' + & 0! 5! - *
" &
8 %%$'3/ ?%
G<
! & &# 0 <
& -
&# & &
& &
+
&C3'
!/ *
. & . &34 *
"!+ 6 .&&
0 &/ 4& ?&& &
&
G 0
- ! !-
&&
7- &
0
&
&& -! .+* 0 ! 0 . <
"&
< - %% (
. ! &
"&>- 0I&+. &
=
- 30 -
G & &&-
4& %3/3/
? 4& && ! "! .&& & + %" #
+ %. "
& && & &&
&
4&
% ;
!
@
&
& &
@
&
7
& &&
% ;
& < #&-
@
@
%-
!& &&
% ; &
&&
&
& &&
&&G
8A46>59*37A3D8*895A3+;373*C56D36+5 ;8* 73H3B+3D +;3 *3B56D 8CC38? A4D3 57D37 D8+3D (8+663I<735C4646>+;8++;3*;57+B5E46>* 86D D3:4B436B43* E36+4563D 46 4+* 57D37 73?8+46> +5 656 8A84?894?4+F5:+;373G<473D+38B;46>*+8::. 4>;378B<?+F/ 73*<?+46>46656:<?:4??E36+5:+;373G<473E36+:57>786+46> +;3C37E4**456:57+;38B8D3E4BF387((5<>;++5 ;8A39336B5EC?43D@4+;C7457+5"((
" ;3734*65D4*C<+356+;3:8B++;8+73*C56D36+ 5 ;8D C546+3D 5<+ B37+846 D3:4B436B43* 46 B5EC?486B3
- 31 -
@4+; +;3 73G<473E36+ 5: +;3 73><?8+456* @4+; 73*C3B+ +5 46:78*+7<B+<73* :57 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387* ($ ($ (( 86D ((( @;4B; ;8D B56*+78463D +;3 C3+4+4563746*+4+<+456 +5 8CC758B; +;4* 5<7+ 9F :4?46> )
5(('"$ ( )
5("' ($ 86D )
5&'$&$ (73*C3B+4A3?F;4*5<7+9F57D37 D8+3D ('(( 86D ((( 8* 65+3D 895A3 ;8D D473B+3D +;3 C3+4+4563746*+4+<+456 +5 B5EC?F @4+; +;3*84D D3:4B436B43* 86D +5 *<9E4+ +;3 73C73*36+8+456
3+4+45637 46*+4+<+456 B?84E3D +5 ;8A3 B5EC?43D @4+; +;3 *84D 73G<473E36+ 86D ;8* 8?*5 E8D3 73C73*36+8+456* +5 73*C56D36+ 5* 86D " ;3 73C73*36+8+456* ;8A3 65+ 9336 B56*4D373D 34+;37 9F 73*C56D36+ 5 57 9F 73*C56D36+5" & ;5<>; ?38763D B5<6*3? 8CC38746> :57 73*C56D36+573:3773D+5+;357D375:+;3C3I5<7+46 +;3B8*35:.*<C78/ 86D+5+;357D375:+;3557D468+336B;5:+;4*5<7+46 !*
86D 5+;37 B5663B+37 E8++37*
- 32 -
73?3A86+ 8+ +;4* H<6B+<73 +5 65+3 +;3 5C378+4A3 C57+456 5: +;357D37C8**3D9F+;3557D468+336B;5:+;4*5<7+46 !*
@;4B;738D*8*<6D37% 3 / 7
&&
3 / 7 . &
& &
>- > - ! "#.-
"#" "#" :'F- :'%???>
:'%>>
!&-
& & 3 / 7
&&&&
&&
"
>- >- &&
0!-
@
&
+ 3/3/
& . + *
" - 3 !/ 9
&
I
&&
- && && @
# - &! &
3!/ ! &
! &
& -
& -
& - &
-
&&
4 -- 7 &&
A @ +
8& +! "
-
&&
&
3! / . &&
@
& &&
.
J
- 33 -
?387?F +;5<>; +;3 557D468+3 36B; 5: +;4* 5<7+ ;8D +8=36 *3745<* 3IB3C+456 +5 +;3 46*+4+<+456* 7<6646> +;3 B5??3>3* +8=46> 8DE4**456 B56+787F +5 +;3 73><?8+456* B56*4D3746> +;3 46+373*+ 5: +;3 *+<D36+* ;8D D473B+3D +;3 C3+4+45637*B5??3>3 +;37346 65+ +5 D4*+<79 +;3 *+<D36+* @;5 873 4??3>8??F 8DE4++3D +5 +;3 8B8D3E4B F387 ($($((86D((( 63 C3B<?487 :8B+ @;4B; 4* B5EE56 46 +;3*3 C3+4+456*86D+;357D37C8**3D9F+;357D468+336B;
5: +;4* 5<7+ 73:3773D +5 895A3 4* +;8+ +;3*3 8??3>3D D3:4B436B43*;8A39336C546+3D5<+:57+;3C3745D(+5 (;4*@8*+;3C3745D@;373657E8??4:3>?598??F;8D >563 ;8F@473 56 8BB5<6+ 5: ($
86D3E4B 36+78?5A376E36+4+*3?:;8D975<>;+46C5?4B43*73?8I46> +;3*+74B+B5EC?486B35:B37+846C75A4*456*5:?8@A3646 +;346*+86+B8*3*+;3A37F8+4568?5EE4**456:576D486 3D4B8? B436B3* 8?*5 ;8D 4**<3D B37+846 65+4:4B8+456* :57 73?8I46>5:B37+846B56D4+456*;4*@5<?D56?F46D4B8+3+;8+ *+74B+ B5EC?486B3 5: 73G<473E36+ D<746> +;4* C3745D @8*
- 34 -
73?8I3D5@;8+3I+36++;8+73?8I8+456@8*3I+36D3D86D +5@;8+3I+36++;346*+4+<+456*;8DB5EC?43D@4+;+;3*84D 73G<473E36+ 4* 8 E8++37 5: :8B+ ;4* 5<7+ B8665+ 93 59?4A45<* +5 +;3 :8B+ +;8+ +;3 E5E36+ +;3 B56B3C+ 5:
73?8I8+456 @8* 975<>;+ 46 4+ 56?F >8A3 8 D4*B73+45687F C5@37 +5 +;3 36:57B46> 8<+;574+43* +5 +8=3 46+5 B56*4D378+456+;38B+<8?:8B+*4+<8+4565:+;3E8++37@;4B;
4* @4+;46 +;347 *<9H3B+4A3 *8+4*:8B+456 6D37 +;3 C3B<?487 :8B+ *4+<8+456 46A5?A3D 46 +;3 C73*36+ E8++37 +;8+ +55 D<746> ($
86D3E4B C3745D @;3+;37 *+74B+ B5EC?486B3+5+;3C75A4*456*5:?8@65+3D895A3B5<?D93 3IC3B+3D 57 +;3 *8E3 B86 93 73?8I3D 4* 8 E8++37 :57 B56*4D378+4569F+;373*C56D36+5 ' 5D8F +;46>* 9346> 657E8? +;3 8:573*84D C75A4*456*5:?8@E8F8CC?F@4+;:<??:57B386DA4>57<+ +;34**<35:656B5EC?486B35:+;373G<473E36+*5:?8@9F +;3C3+4+45637B5??3>3E8F;8A3+59373B56*4D373D+8=46> 46+5 8BB5<6+ +;3 C37*C3B+4A3 @;4B; C73A84?3D D<746> $C86D3E4BC3745D
- 35 -
;3 895A3 59*37A8+456 4* E8D3 C?8B46> 56 73B57D +;3 *<9E4**456 5: +;3 ?38763D B5<6*3? :57 +;3 C3+4+45637 @;5 3IC3B+* 86D ;5C3 +;8+ 73*C56D36+ 5* 86D@4??=33C46E46D+;3*4+<8+456+;8+C73A84?3DD<746> +;3*84DC3745D@;4?3B56*4D3746>+;373C73*36+8+456E8D3 9F +;3C3+4+4563746*+4+<+456 C<7*<86+ +5+;357D37 C8**3D 9F +;4* 5<7+ 46 +;3 8:573*84D )
5(('"$ ( )
5("' ($ 86D )
5&'$&$ ( A4D357D37D8+3D('((86D(((
$ 6 +;3 ?4>;+ 5: +;3 895A3 C3+4+456* 873 -! )
( ;3 57D37 D8+3D ( C75D<B3D 8+ 663I<73+5+;3@74+C3+4+456873G<8*;3D
;3 E8++374* 73E4++3D +5 +;373*C56D36+5 +5 73B56*4D37 +;3 *3B56D 8CC38? :4?3D 9F +;3 C3+4+45637* <6D37 3B+456$./5:+;38+4568?5EE4**456:576D486 F*+3E 5: 3D4B463 B+ (( +8=46> 46+5 B56*4D378+456 +;359*37A8+456E8D38*895A3
- 36 -
7D37*46+;4*73>87D*;8??93C8**3D@4+;4686 5<+37?4E4+5:(D8F*:75E+;3D8+35:73B34C+5:B37+4:43D B5CF5:+;4*57D37
" ;3 B5EC?486B3 *;8?? 93 73C57+3D +5 +;4* 5<7+ 565793:573"("(
& 6+;3?4>;+5:+;38:573*84D57D37*73*C56D36+ 5&
*;8??
8665<6B3 +;3 73*<?+* 5: +;3 3I8E468+456* 8?738DF +8=36 <C 9F +;3 C3+4+45637* D<746> +;3E56+;5:<><*++5 3C+3E937(
,* '# #) &
4*+5% ?5% %