Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92894 (KAR)
AMBARAYA AND ORS v. MAHADEVI AND ORS
RFA/200060/2017 · 2025-12-12
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92894 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92894 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $"
# $$%
""
&"'"( )
! " #
$%
" #&
! ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" #&
$
$
" #&
"
" #&
%
"'
(
) %$%
%$ *
"'
" #&
%
"' ! " #&
+
- 3 -
(
"' $
" #&
,
"'
"'
" #&
)
"
"'
" #&
+
" #&
!$
" #&
!$
" #&
- 4 -
! !! " #& -
"
"
)
" " #&
.,+
$$
/" #&
.,+! ! "
!)
/" #&
.,+! $ '
!%
/" #&
.,+! - 5 -
!! /" #&
.,+! % *
'
$
"
(
,
"
+
) '
+
+ '
+
"
- 6 -
"
" $,
0
" %
" #
%+
" # .,!+
! "
,
" .,+$
$ '
1$$
" #&
1 -
- 7 -
"
21
"2
!1
"2
$ 22
2
2 )% 2
' +!+(
" '
!! +! 2
22 2' #
2
2 '
"
3' 45 3'
'"
$ 3'
678 99:; 78 <7;:5 0= >6: 5:<:454> ?8 >? ! @45:A :B>7?4 )% ?< >6: ?5: ?< 7C7; A?B:5@A:
B6;;:4D74D >6: E@5DF:4> 45 5:BA:: 5>:5 +!+( 988:5 0= >6: 55; :47?A 7C7; '@5D: > ;0@AD7 74 ?!! +!G6:A:0=>6:8@7><7;:50=>6:9;74>7<<8<?A 9A>7>7?4458:9A>:9?88:887?4G89A>;=5:BA::5
- 8 -
2?A>6:8H:?<B?4C:47:4B:>6:9A>7:8A:A:<:AA:5 >?89:A>6:7AA4H74D80:<?A:>6:
A7;?@A> ! 6: 9;74>7<<8 <7;:5 ?!! +! D748> >6:
5:<:454>88::H74D9A>7>7?4458:9A>:9?88:887?4
6:
;:A4:5'@5D:?<>6:
A7;?@A>C75:E@5DF:4>455:BA::
5>:5 +!+( 68 9A>;= 5:BA::5 >6: 8@7> :74D DDA7:C:50=>6:8F:5:<:454>?8>?!6C:<7;:5 >67899:; $ <>:A 8:AC7B: ?< 4?>7B: >6: 9A>7:8 6C: 99:A:5 >6A?@D6 >6:7A A:89:B>7C: B?@48:; 45 6C: <7;:5 ?F9A?F78::>7>7?4@45:AA5:A**@;:!?<?5:?< 7C7;A?B:5@A:6:A:74<>:AA:<:AA:5>?8IJ<?A86?A>
6:B?4>:4>8?<>6:B?F9A?F78:9:>7>7?478:K>AB>:5 6:A:740:;?G L
!" "" !#
- 9 -
$% ! & ' ('') ( & *
"" &''(+ " #
% '" + %$ '' , ' - & . / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% %$.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9 " !''* ( '! " - ! !#
# &'' &
% $ 9 #
"+ & '
*% %$.2 &''
& /'' %$ $ # *% %$: !# *%%$.; 6*% %$.0
% '" + % 2 '' , ' - & 0$ / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% % $.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+
5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9
" !''* ( <( '!
" - ! !#
*%%$:= 9 &'' &
% $
* %$: ! & *%% $.2 &''
& %: $0
;% '" + %: $0 '' , ' - & 0$ / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% % $.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+
5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9
- 10 -
" !''* ( + '! " - ! !#
*%%$:= 9 &'' &
%$
& *% % $.2 &''
& % 2 ! & *% %$.2 &'' &
%$$>? 6 >? 2% '" + %$$>? 6 >? '' , ' - & 0$ / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% %$.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9 " !''* ( 1 '! " - ! !#
*%%$:= 9 &'' &
%$
& *%%$.2 &''
& %: $0 ! & *% % $.2 &''
& %$
@% '" + % $ '' , ' - & 0$ / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% %$.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9
" !''* ( , '! " - ! !#
*%% $:= 9 &'' &
% $
&''
- 11 -
& %$$>? 6 >? ! & *% %$.2 &''
& %$%
:% '" + %$ '' , ' - & 0$ / 00 1! ! & 0 +! *% %$.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9
" !''* ( A''( '! " - ! !#
*%%$:= 6 $.0 9 &'' &
%$
&'' &
% $ ! *% % $.0
.% '" + /'' %$ $ B'* '' , ' - & $: / 1! ! & 0 +! *% %$.2 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+% &" 9 " !''* ( <'! '! " - ! !#
&'' &
%$ 9 * %$@ $=; 6 $.@
*% %$: ! *% % $.;
/ ' *% %$:=
/ "!+ $: / . 1! ! 3+'3!
4''+ 5# 6 7# 8'!+ 3! %$=: 6 $=. ' - " 0C - ;0C ! 3+'3! 4''+
5# 6 7# 8'!+ 3! + %$$)=0
/$ ! 7+1'' 1+
- 12 -
+ <"! 5% 6 7 8'!+ - '! %
=% '" "+ ! * % & ' * %$.2 - & $: / 1!>- '!+ $ / '' & %$ $? ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 6 7# 8'!+
' * %$:=
/ "!+ $: / . 1! ! 3+'3! 4''+
5# 6 7# 8'!+ 3% % $=: $=. "!+ 0 - ;0 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 67# 8'!+6 3! + %$$)=0
/$ ! 7+1'' 1+ + <"! 5% 678'!+ '' &'' & /'' %$ $%
$0% '" /'' * + '" ' ! * 3% %$$)=0
/$ ! 7+1'' 1+ + <"! 8'!+ ( '* ' " %
$$% % '5! &! & %2
$% &! + ' /'' '' )
"!+ ! '
" ++ ! "" %
$% /'' !, * ('' & ' & ! ''
"" %
$;% %$ $ + '5! ! %* %$.2 - & $: / 1!>- '!+
$ / ''
- 13 -
%$ $? ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 6 7# 8'!+ ' * %$:=
/
"!+ $: / . 1! ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5# 6 7# 8'!+ 3% % $=: 6 $=. "!+ 0 - ;0 ! 3+'3! 4''+ 5 6 7# 8'!+%
$2%
%$
$
& ''* + * '' '" * + ! - '' " % & $ / ' *% % $.2 & 3+'3! 4''+ 5% 6 7% 8'!+ ( * '' * + '" &"'* %
$@% /'' 6 %$ $ + * '' '" *
"* + % + (* ' '' /'' %$ $%
$:%
"" * ( & ('' (! * & &!%
$.%
" - "" '" " & "" %
$=% /''6 !" * * '" + ! * ! * %$; /' + %$; C !
& %
0% '&& '' ( %
!"'* * * 3C' ! "* ' ! - 14 -
" & "" & B! 5!*%
7# $
$
2 ' # 8'!+
/''D
% 6: 9A>7:8 A: 9A:8:4> 0:<?A: >678 ?@A> 45 >6:= 6C: 87D4:5 >6: B?F9A?F78: 9:>7>7?4
6:= 45 >6:7A 87D4>@A:86C:0::475:4>7<7:50=>6:7AA:89:B>7C:;:A4:5 B?@48:;
6:= 8@0F7> >6> >6:= 6C: :4>:A:5 74>? >6:
8:>>;:F:4> <>:A <@;;= @45:A8>4574D >6: >:AF8 ?< >6: B?F9A?F78:9:>7>7?4 ( 6: B?F9A?F78: 9:>7>7?4 87D4:5 0= >6: 9A>7:8 45 >6:7AA:89:B>7C:B?@48:;78>H:4?4A:B?A5 , 678 ?@A> <>:A 8>78<=74D G7>6 >6: >:AF8 ?< >6: B?F9A?F78:9:>7>7?4988:5>6:<?;;?G74D
6: 99:; 78 74 >:AF8 ?< >6: B?F9A?F78:9:>7>7?4
- 15 -
0 6: B?F9A?F78: 9:>7>7?4 <7;:5 @45:A A5:A **@;:!?<78?A5:A:5>?0:>A:>:58 9A>459AB:;?<>678?A5:A B 6: :D78>A= 78 57A:B>:5 >? 5AG >6: <74; 5:BA::74>:AF8?<>6:B?F9A?F78:9:>7>7?4
*' &"( $
*' &$%( $
78>? ;? $