- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %& ' ! " # $$% &&& &$% ' ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $%%%% ' ! # " " !# " " %% % " " # %% %% % " (%%%%%% $ " ) ) * # +,( -../-0 ,( 1,0/2 34 5+/ 60-,7-85( -9-,8(5 5+/ :297/85 2-5/2 %%%% .-((/2 ,8 0-,7 ..0,6-5,;8 ; %% % 34 5+/ -,0<-4 0-,7( =,3:8-0 !-89-0;=/ /86+# !1;= (+;=5 >5+/ 5=,3:8-0?# (//@,89 6;7./8(-5,;8 ;1 (%%%%%% $ -0;89 <,5+ ,85/=/(5 -5 5+/ =-5/;1A,85/=/(5 - 3 - 8/ -00-44- -9/2 % 4/-=( +-B,89 9/8/=-0 5,6@/5 3/-=,89 ;C 2-5/2 %%D <-( 5=-B/0,89 ,8 5+/5=-,8 1=;7 E$:03-=9- F +,55-.:= -,0<-4 5-5,;83:5-66,2/85041-00/82;<81=;75+/7;B,895=-,8,8 3/5<//8:0+-00,-82+,55-.:==-,0-4(-5&; $-82 (:66:73/2 5; 5+/ ,8G:=,/( ,( <,1/ 6+,02=/8 -82 .-=/85( 1,0/2 60-,7 ./5,5,;8 (//@,89 6;7./8(-5,;8 ;1 (%%%%%% $ 3/1;=/5+/5=,3:8-0+/5=,3:8-0-15/=6;8(,2/=,895+//85,=/ /B,2/86/;8=/6;=22,(7,((/25+/-..0,6-5,;8;85+/9=;:82 5+-5 5+/=/,( 8; /B,2/86/ =/9-=2,895+/ 1-65 5+-5+/<-( - 3;8-1,2/.-((/89/=-82,56-88;53/(-,25+-5+,(2/-5+<-( ;8 -66;:85 ;1 -8 :85;<-=2 ,86,2/85 <,5+,8 5+/ 7/-8,89 ;1 /65,;8!#!#;15+/-,0<-4(6599=,/B/2345+/(-,2 ;=2/=5+/60-,7-85(+-B/.=/1/==/25+/.=/(/85-../-0-82 7-,8046;85/82/25+-55+/5=,3:8-0+-(/==/2,8+;02,895+-5 +/ <-( 8;5 - 3;8-1,2/ .:=6+-(/= -( ./= 5+/ " 6+-=9/$ (+//5-82/B,2/86/;15+//4/<,58/(( +/2/6/-(/2-00-..-<-(5=-B/0,89,85+/5=-,8 -822,/22:/5;(:22/81-001=;75+/5=-,8+/5=,3:8-01-,0/2 5; -..=/6,-5/ 5+/ /B,2/86/ .=;./=04 -82 2,(7,((/2 5+/ - 4 - -..0,6-5,;8 -82 5+:( =/H:/(5/2 5; (/5 -(,2/ 5+/ ;=2/= :297/85 ;1 5+/ 5=,3:8-0 27,55/204 5+/ 2/6/-(/2 -00-..- <-( +-B,89 - 9/8/=-0 5,6@/5 5; (+;< 5+-5 +/ <-( 5=-B/0,89 1=;7 E$:03-=9- 5; +,55-.:= -,0<-4 5-5,;8 +/85+/5=-,8<-(7;B,891=;7:0+-00,5;+,55-.:==-,0<-4 (5-5,;8 -5 & ; $ +/ 1/00 2;<8 -66,2/85-004 -82 (:(5-,8/2 ,8G:=,/( -82 2,/2 (:3(/H:/8504 +/=/1;=/ 5+/ 60-,7 ./5,5,;8 <-( 1,0/2 34 5+/ 60-,7-85( +/ 2/6/-(/2 -00-..- <-( +;02,89 - B-0,2 9/8/=-0 5,6@/5 7;=/;B/= 5+/ =/(.;82/85$=-,0<-4-:5+;=,54+-(8;52,(.:5/25+/(-,21-65 +/=/1;=/5+/;3(/=B-5,;8;15+/5=,3:8-0=/9-=2,895+/1-65 5+-5 +/ ,( 8;5 - 3;8-1,2/ .-((/89/= 6-88;5 3/ -66/.5/2 27,55/2045+/2/6/-(/2-00-..-1/001=;75+/7;B,895=-,8 -82 (:66:73/2 5; 5+/ ,8G:=,/( +/=/1;=/ 5+/ 2/-5+ ,( ;8 -66;:85;1:85;<-=2,86,2/85-(./=/65,;8!#!#;15+/ -,0<-4( 65+/ 5=,3:8-0 1-,0/25; -..=/6,-5/ 5+/ /B,2/86/ .=;./=04-822,(7,((/25+/-..0,6-5,;8+/=/1;=/5+,(;:=5 1,82( ,5 =/-(;8-30/ 5; (/5 -(,2/ 5+/ ;=2/= .-((/2 34 5+/ 5=,3:8-0 +/ 2/6/-(/2 -00-44- <-( -9/2 % 4/-=( +/ 0/-=8/2 6;:8(/0 1;= 5+/ 60-,7-85( =/0,/2 :.;8 - :297/85 - 5 - .-((/2 34 5+/ ;8?30/ :.=/7/ ;:=5 ;1 82,- ,8 ,B,0 ../-0 ;% % 3/5<//8 ;0, -8, -+- ( 8,;8 ;1 82,- 8 5+/ (-,2:297/85,5 <-( +/02 5+-5 I8 ,8- /B, !(:.=-# - 5<;$:29/ /86+ ;1 5+,( ;:=5 6;8(,2/=/2 5+/ H:/(5,;8;15+/.-=54;8<+,6+5+/3:=2/8;1.=;;1<,000,/,8 6-(/( <+/=/ 5+/ 3;24 ;1 5+/ 2/6/-(/2 ,( 1;:82 ;8 =-,0<-4 .=/7,(/(+,(;:=5+/025+-55+/,8,5,-03:=2/8<;:023/;8 5+/60-,7-85<+/8+/2,(6+-=9/(5+/(-7/,5(+,15(5;5+/ =-,0<-4( /=/ -3(/86/ ;1 - 5,6@/5 <,5+ (:6+ ,8G:=/2 ;= 2/6/-(/2<,008;58/9-5,B/5+/60-,75+-5+/<-(-3;8-1,2/ .-((/89/= 5.-=-9=-.+;%,85+/-1;=/(-,2:297/85,5 ,(+/02-(:82/=) !" ! # $% & ! # $% & ! '(( # ) $% &# !'((*+ , -"''./$0& 1'.& - 6 - 27,55/204 ,8 5+,( 6-(/ +/ <-( 5=-B/0,89 ,8 5+/ 5=-,8-822,/22:/5;1-001=;75+/5=-,8+/=/1;=/5+,(;:=5 1,82( ,5 =/-(;8-30/ 5; 9=-85 - (:7 ;1 (%%%%% $ -( ./= 6+/2:0/ ;1 5+/ -,0<-4 66,2/85( !;7./8(-5,;8# :0/( CC% -( -7/82/2 34 5+/ -,0<-4 66,2/85( -82 85;<-=2 86,2/85(!;7./8(-5,;8#7/827/85:0/(CCD 66;=2,89045+/1;00;<,89;=2/=) !,# +/-../-0,(-00;</2,8.-=5J !,,# +/ 60-,7-85( -=/ /85,50/2 5; 5;5-0 6;7./8(-5,;8 ;1 (%%%%% $ 1=;7 5+/ =/(.;82/85$-,0<-4-:5+;=,54J !,,,# +/60-,7-85;(-82-=/.-=/85(;1 5+/ 2/6/-(/2 -00-..- -=/ /85,50/2 5; <,5+2=-< - (:7 ;1 (D%%% $ /-6+J -82 5+/ 60-,7-85 ; 3/,895+/7,8;=9:-=2,-8;160-,7-85;(5;,( ./=7,55/2 5; <,5+2=-< 5+/ =/7-,8,89 6;7./8(-5,;8J !,B# +/ =/(.;82/85 F =-,0<-4 -:5+;=,54 ,( 2,=/65/2 5; 2/.;(,5 5+/ 6;7./8(-5,;8 ;1 (%%%%% $ <,5+,8 5+=// 7;85+( 1=;7 5+,( 2-4 - 7 - 1-,0,89 <+,6+ 5+/ =/(.;82/85$=-,0<-4 -:5+;=,54 ,( 0,-30/5;.-4,85/=/(5-55+/=-5/;1A./=-88:7 ()* %$& # ,(5;)0;) )