Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92888 (KAR)
BISHOP ANILKUMAR SERVAND v. DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT
WP/203182/2025 · 2025-11-13
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92888 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92888 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%$&!$!$
'$(
!"#
$ %
& &
'(
&) *
+
+
&! ,
" $
#
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
$
*
&!&
,
"
$
#
+
$
) $
$
+ + -# + $
*
% &
$ $
$
& . +
* $
$ &) &
) &
.
+ * /# 0 $ + $ $ 0 $ $ * $ + 1 1 ' - 3 - " 1 '# 2343456278 9:5 -72 3:2 ;2<26;-638 46 5&) &=26;46>?5684;27-3456/2<5723:25@735<3:2 746?4=-A 4B4A @;>2 -6; $ 4;-7 ":27246-<327 72<2772;35-8C3:2374-A5@730<57/72B43D#-72/2<5723:48 5@73 /246> ->>742B2; /D 3:2 57;27 ;-32; ) & =-882;/D3:2374-A5@7356463274E-==A4?-345646 5 <4A2;@6;277;27%@A2-6;72-;943:82?3456&5< 5;2 5<4B4A 75?2;@72" # 9:4?: 48 ?56<47E2;/D 3:2 57;27 ;-32; & =-882; 46 5% & 56 3:2 <4A2 5< ;;43456-A 26457 4B4A @;>2 -6; $ 4;-7 ":27246-<327 72<2772; 35 -8 C3:2 <4783 -==2AA-32 5@730 <57 /72B43D# :2-/5B28@4346 5&) &48<4A2;/D3:2 =A-4634<<728=56;263 :27246 <57 72A42< 5< =27E-6263 46F@6?3456 72837-4646> 3:2 ;2<26;-638=2343456278 :27246 <75E ?-@846> 4AA2>-A 46327<2726?2 -6; 5/837@?34568 46 3:2 E-6->2E263 5< -463 -@A 23:5;483 :@7?: -6>-A=23 - 4 - 4;-7/D9-D5<=27=23@-A46F@6?3456?56326;46> 3:-3 =A-4634<< :-8 /226 -==54632; -8 48374?3 @=2746326;263 5< 4;-7 46 327E8 5< A23327 ;-32; & -6;:2:-8/226726;2746>827B4?2-88@?:<57 E572 3:-6 3:722 D2-78 :-3 3:272 48 - ;48=@32 /239226 ;2<26;-63 5-6;56248:5=/D6-E2 -7G-729:5 9-8957G46>-848:5=-326>-A@7@2>456-A46327E85< 57;275<23:5;483:@7?:5<6;4-;-32; &:-3 3:2=A-4634<<48957G46>@6;273:28-4;48:5= -7G-72 46?2 3:272 48 - ;48=@32 /239226 ;2<26;-63 5 -6; -7G-72 3:2 E-3327 9-8 ?-7742; 46 4B4A ==2-A 5& & /2<572 3:2 @=72E2 5@73 9:4?: /D 438 57;27 ;-32; ) & ;472?32; 3:2 =-73428 35 E-463-46 83-3@8H@5:-346B4295<3:28-4;57;27;2<26;-63 5 48 653 26343A2; 35 =-734?4=-32 46 3:2 E-6->2E263 5< -463 -@A 23:5;483 :@7?: -6>-A=23 4;-7 592B27 ;2<26;-63 5 :-8 46834>-32; ;2<26;-63 5 35 ?-@82 46327<2726?2463:2E-6->2E26326?23:28@43 - 5 - % A56> 943: 3:2 8@43 -6 -==A4?-3456 46 5 @6;27 7;27 % @A28 -6; 72-; 943: 2?3456 & 5< 48 <4A2; 724327-346> 3:2 ?5632638 5< 3:2 =A-463 822G46> 463274E57;275<46F@6?3456 2343456278-==2-72;-6;<4A2; 3:247 83-32E263 5< 5/F2?3456 35 3:2 -<5728-4; -==A4?-3456 ;48=@346> 3:2 B27D E-463-46-/4A43D 5< 3:2 8@43 -6; -A85 ;26D46> 3:2 ?A-4E 5< 3:2 =A-4634<< 5< :2 /246> 3:2 48374?3 @=2746326;2635<3:2:@7?: 348?5632632;3:-33:2=A-4634<<9-837-68<2772; 35 23:5;483 :@7?: @>;-A 46 5G-G 48374?3 56 &-8885?4-32 -8357592B27=A-4634<<72<@82; 35 F546 -3 3:2 37-68<2772; =A-?2 -6; :-8 <4A2; 3:2 =728263 8@4356<-A82=72E482348?56326;2;3:-3 -7G-729-8 =72B45@8AD 957G46> -8 - 48:5= 5< 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< 6;4-26>-A@7@72>456-6;:29-8E5723:-6) D2-785< ->2 :2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 5< 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< 6;4- 72E5B2; -7G-72 -6; 53:278 /D =-8846> - 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & :2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A -==54632; ;2<26;-63 5 -8 3:2 48:5= 5< 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< - 6 - 6;4- =273-4646> 35 -6>-A572 2>456 >>742B2; /D 3:2 8-E2 -7G-72-6;53:278:-B2<4A2;-8@43/2<5723:2 43D4B4A5@73-3@E/-4?:-AA26>46>3:28-4;7285A@3456 ;-32; % & =-882; /D 3:2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 5< 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< 6;4- 2 -A85 :-; <4A2; -6 463274E -==A4?-3456 822G46> 83-D 5< 3:2 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & 9:4?: 9-8 ;2?A462; 246> ->>742B2; -7G-72 =72<2772; - E48?2AA-625@8 <4783 -==2-A
/2<572 3:24>:5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 @E/-4 9:4?:>7-632; 3:2 463274E 57;27 ;-32; & % 83-D46> 3:2 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & =-882; /D 3:2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 23:5;483:@7?:5<6;4- & 2<26;-63 5-6;53:278463:28-4;8@43<4A2; -=2?4-A2-B2 2343456/2<5723:2=2I5@73->-46838-4; 57;27=-882;/D3:24>:5@735<@;4?-3@72@E/-4D 57;27 ;-32; ) & =-882; 46 4B4A ==2-A 5& & 3:2 =2I 5@73 ;472?32; ;2<26;-63 5 3:2724665335>4B22<<2?3353:27285A@3456=-882;/D3:2 2627-A56<2726?25<3:223:5;483:@7?:5<6;4--6; - 7 - ;472?32; 3:2 4>: 5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 @E/-4 35 =-88 57;2785648?2AA-625@8$4783==2-A5682H@2633:2725< 3:2 4>: 5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 @E/-4 /D 57;27 ;-32; & & & -AA592; 3:2 463274E -==A4?-3456 <4A2; /D -7G-72 >7-6346> 3:2 463274E =7-D27 -8 =7-D2; <57 246> ->>742B2; 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< 6;4- -6; 53:278 ?-7742; 3:2 8-4; 57;27 ;-32; & & & /2<572 3:2=2I 5@7346 5 &=2I5@7383-D2;3:28-4; 57;27348-33:48F@6?3@723:2=7282638@43:-8/226<4A2; :2 374-A 5@73 9:4A2 ?5684;2746> 3:2 463274E -==A4?-3456 <4A2; /D 3:2 =A-4634<< /D 438 57;27 ;-32; ) & 9:4A2 26?-=8@A-346> 3:2 <-?38 5< 3:2 ?-82 355G65325<3:2=26;26?D5<3:2E-3327/2<5723:2=2I 5@73 -6; 3:2 4>: 5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 -3 5E/-D :2 5/827B-3456 5< 3:2 374-A 5@73 46 3:2 57;27 ;-32; ) & <5@6; -3 =-7->7-=:8 & -6; -72 -8 @6;271 - 8 - ! " # # $ %&'()*)& "+, %-&./()*)& ! " #
*.*)*)& 0 1
0
& 2
3#2
! " #
# $ %&'()*)&
"+, %-&./()*)& ! #4
5 !"# *.*)*)& 6 # 7 6 # ! # 4 2
8 % 0 6#
! # 4 ! " #9
:@8 /-82; 56 3:2 -<5728-4; 5/827B-34568 3:2 374-A ?5@73 =-882;3:2<5AA5946>463274E57;271
- 9 -
: /'
)#,#
1
" , 3 # 3
1
! " # ! #4
# ! # ! " #29
) 246>->>742B2;/D3:2-<5728-4;463274E57;27 ;2<26;-638=2343456278 :27246 =72<2772; E48?2AA-625@8 -==2-A /2<572 3:2 <4783 -==2AA-32 5@73 $4783 -==2AA-32 5@73/D43857;27;-32; &D23->-463-G46>6532 5< 3:2 =26;26?D 5< 3:2 E-3327 /2<572 3:2 =2I 5@73 ;48E4882; 3:2 -==2-A ?56<47E2;3:257;27 =-882; /D 3:2 374-A5@73 ! :25/827B-345685<3:2<4783-==2AA-325@73-8 <5@6;-3=-7->7-=:8%-6;5<43857;27-72-8@6;271
- 10 -
)/ 2
"+, ;#< % 5'5()*)&
* *')*)& : = "+, ;#< % 5'5()*)&
0 #
! #4
# !"#2 !
#4 ) # 2$%
# 2$% #
!"#2 ! # 4 # $ #
$
8($
$ # 1 $ 2 , % ) 9
348->-46833:4857;273:2=7282639743=2343456
:2 A2-762; 26457 ?5@682A -==2-746> <57 3:2 =2343456278 3-G46> 3:48 5@73 2I32684B2AD 3:75@>: 3:2 72?57;8E572=-734?@A-7AD353:257;278;-32; ) &
- 11 -
=-882; /D 3:2 =2I 5@73 46 =2?4-A 2-B2 2343456 "# 5!&)% & -8 92AA -8 3:2 8@/82H@263 57;27 ;-32; & =-882; 46 =2?4-A 2-B2 2343456
"# 5 &8@/E4383:-33:2=2I5@73:-8-A72-;D 823-84;23:257;27=-882;/D3:24>:5@735<@;4?-3@72 -35E/-D9:4?::-;83-D2;3:25=27-34565<3:2;2?48456 5< 3:2 I2?@34B2 ?5@6?4A 46 3@76 83-D46> 3:2 B27D -==5463E2635<3:2;2<26;-638:27246:-3463:2A4>:35< 3:2 8-4; 57;27 :-B46> /226 823 -84;2 /D 3:2 =2I 5@73 3:272486572-856<573:2374-A5@73-6;3:2<4783-==2AA-32 5@733572837-463:2;2<26;-638:27246<75E?-77D46>5@3 3:247-;E464837-34B2<@6?3456846B4295<3:247-==5463E263 =@78@-63 35 3:2 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & :@8 :2 8@/E438 3:-3 3:2 <4783-==2AA-32 5@73 9-8 653F@834<42; 46 =-8846> 3:2 4E=@>62; 57;27 943:5@3 3-G46> 6532 5< 3:2 57;27=-882;/D3:2=2I5@7326?2822G8<57-AA5946> 5<3:2=2343456
,
3:2 A2-762; 26457 ?5@682A -==2-746><573:2728=56;263=A-4634<<-A56>943:74-47-F
- 12 -
@GG-B2:2E263AD8@/E433:-33:2B27D8@83-46-/4A43D5< 3:27285A@3456;-32;% &=-882;/D3:2I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 5< 3:2 23:5;483 :@7?: 5< 6;4- 48 /246> -;F@;4?-32; @=56 /2<572 3:2 4>: 5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 -3 @E/-4 :-3 @6A288-6; @634A3:28-4; 488@248 7285AB2;
=2343456278 9:5 37-?2 3:247 -==5463E263 35 3:2 8-4;
7285A@3456 ?-6653/2 =27E4332; 35 <@6?3456 :272<572 :2 8@/E438 3:-3 3:2 57;278 =-882; /D 3:2 374-A 5@73 ?56<47E2;/D3:2<4783-==2AA-325@73;56539-77-63-6D 46327<2726?2
2-7; 27@82;3:272?57;8
$75E3:272?57;8-6;3:28@/E4884568E-;2/D 3:2A2-762;26457?5@682A5<3:2=-7342843-==2-783:-3 3:2;48=@329:4?:488@/F2?3E-33275<3:2=75?22;46>846 3:2 43D 4B4A 5@73 -3 @E/-4 -74828 5@3 5< 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & =-882; /D 3:2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 5< 23:5;483:@7?:5<6;4-46?2-6463274E57;2783-D46> 3:28-4;7285A@34569-8;2?A462;3:2E-33279-8?-7742;46 - E48?2AA-625@8 <4783 -==2-A /2<572 3:2 4>: 5@73 5<
- 13 -
@;4?-3@725E/-D9:4?::-;46434-AAD>7-632;3:2463274E 57;27 ;-32; & % & 72837-4646> 653 35 >4B2 2<<2?3 35 3:2 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & :2 8-4; 57;27 9-8 ?-7742; 46 -==2-A /2<572 3:2 =2I 5@73 :2 =2I 5@73 56 ) &=-882;3:2<5AA5946>57;271 :8> + ? 1 @
" 0 #
2 0 6 #
#
, ;<
9
- 14 -
% @/82H@263 35 3:2 72E-6; /D 3:2 =2I 5@73 46 327E8 5< 3:2 57;27 ;-32; ) & 2I37-?32; -/5B2 3:24>:5@735<@;4?-3@72-35E/-D=-882;3:257;27 ;-32; & & & =-7->7-=:8 ) ! -6; 5< 9:4?: 72-;8-8@6;271
.
78
> #
078 &.* > # 8 %55) 4 # 18%55)
A B&3)*)&
-2$ ;<C ;< ,
$ # / 4 )*)& ;> > ,<
)) D )*)&
# / 4)*)&9
' % B #
- 15 -
!$#.$)*)& !$# B0 7 6 # )- $ )*)&3)*)&
9
23 ->-46 /246> ->>742B2; /D 3:2 -<5728-4;
57;273:2E-33279-8 ?-7742;353:2=2I5@73/D<4A46> 8=2?4-A A2-B2 =2343456 46 "#
5 & =2I 5@7356 &=-882;3:2<5AA5946>1 :8> +
7 8 ;8< 6# 4# ? BEB 2 # , &) $2278;< >,/-. $22 B;< $ 7 #? 7:FFF2F
- 16 -
)##, ''- 0 7
7
0
$
# ? 0 #
, ;< 9
& 27@8-A 5< 3:2 -<5728-4; 57;27 A2-;8 65 ;5@/3 3:-33:2=2I5@73:-8823-84;23:2463274E57;27;-32;
& & & >7-632; /D 3:2 4>: 5@73 5< @;4?-3@72 -3 5E/-D 83-D46> 3:2 7285A@3456 5< 3:2 I2734B2 5@6?4A 2-646> 3:272/D 3:-3 3:2 7285A@3456 ;-32; % & =-882; /D 3:2 I2?@34B2 5@6?4A 48 5=27-34B2 -6; 48 46 <57?2:2<@73:275/827B-3456E-;2/D3:2=2I5@7335 3:2 2<<2?3 3:-3 3:2 57;27 =-882; /D 3:2 =2I 5@73 8:-AA 653 :-B2 -6D /2-746> 56 3:2 -==2-A =26;46> /2<572 3:2 4>: 5@73 ?-6653 /2 72-; 35 E2-6 3:-3 3:2 7285A@3456
- 17 -
;-32;% &8@/F2?3E-33275<3:2;48=@32463:28@43 /2<5723:243D4B4A5@73@E/-4-6;3:2E48?2AA-625@8 <4783-==2-A/2<5723:24>:5@735<@;4?-3@72@E/-448 =@356:5A;57<@73:2783-D2;
74-A 5@73 46 3:2 ?-82 56 :-6; =-882; 3:2 4E=@>62;57;2756 ) &9:4?:48E@?:=7457353:2 57;27;-32; &=-882;/D=2I5@73 ) 592B273:28-4;57;275<3:2=2I5@739-8 E-;2 -B-4A-/A2 9:26 3:2 <4783 -==2AA-32 5@73 9-8 ?5684;2746> 3:2
5% & 23 3:2 <4783 -==2AA-32 5@73:-86533-G263:28-4;57;274635?5684;27-3456 ! 6B4295<3:2-<5728-4;57;27;-32; & =-882;/D3:2=2I5@7346 "#
5 &3:48 5@73 ;5 653 822 -6D 72-856 35 ?56346@2 3:2 4E=@>62;
463274E 57;27 >7-632; /D3:2 374-A 5@73 9:4?: 4382A< 9-8 8@/F2?3 35 3:2 57;278 35 /2 =-882; /D 3:2 =2I 5@73 ??57;46>AD=234345648
- 18 -
E=@>62; 463274E 57;27 ;-32; ) & =-882; /D 3:2 374-A 5@73 56
5 46
5&) & -6; 3:2 57;27 ;-32; & =-882; /D 3:2 <4783 -==2AA-325@7346
5% &83-6;8823-84;2
!)* '$!$( &
483
51A
51& 1