- 1 - !" #$% %% & '() * !"# $ % & '' (##" ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) !"# $ % '* )#" #" )#)+ & '' ,+%&' ' # #+ )#)) +!)#" - ' ,+(# ". #### ). ' / / 0 $ 1234556472382769:;<16=742>4?<4@42?3<<16 AB9@>6?< 4?9 4C4D9 94<69 # #+ )#)) 543369:; <16 992<2E?47 23<D2=< 4?9 6332E?3 B9@6 4?9 6>:6D - 2A4;45BD4 F8ED 31ED< GD2:B?47HI 2? E +!)#"366J2?@6?14?=6>6?<E8=E>56?34<2E? - 3 - ) 16 2?ABD69 =742>4?< 4@69 + ;64D3 >6< C2<1 4? 4==296?< E? )# # )# 4?9 3B3<42?69 @D26KEB3 2?ABD263 16 =742>4?< 82769 =742> 56<2<2E? :68ED6 <16 D2:B?47 366J2?@ =E>56?34<2E? E8 3 #### 16 D2:B?47 48<6D =E?3296D2?@ <16 6?<2D6 6K296?=6 E? D6=ED9 4C4D969 <16 =E>56?34<2E? E8 3 "+!# C2<1 2?<6D63< 4<".56D4??B>8DE><1694<6E856<2<2E?<277D6472L4<2E? EC6K6D <16 D2:B?47 1679 =E?<D2:B<ED; ?6@72@6?=6 4< #. E? <16 9D2K6D3 E8 :E<1 <16 K612=763 #. E? =742>4?< 4?9 #. E? <16 9D2K6D E8 D635E?96?< E 4?992D6=<69D635E?96?<E <E54; #. E8 3 "+!# ,+(# 47E?@ C2<1 2?<6D63< 4==DB69E?2< @@D26K69:;<1634294C4D9<164556774?< =742>4?<23:68ED6<123 EBD< + 64D9 4D@B>6?<3 E8 :E<1 <16 54D<263 4?9 56DB369<16>4<6D24734K4274:76E?D6=ED9 <23<16>42?=E?<6?<2E?E8<16764D?69=EB?367 8ED <16 4556774?<=742>4?< <14< <16 D2:B?47 6DD69 2? 1E792?@ ?6@72@6?=6 E? <16 9D2K6D3 E8 :E<1 <16 K612=763 4< - 4 - #.6K6?<1EB@1<<166?<2D6?6@72@6?=623E8<169D2K6DE8 D635E?96?<E <238BD<16D=E?<6?969<14<<16D2:B?47 143 ?E< 4C4D969 4?; 4>EB?< <EC4D93 7E33 E8 8B<BD6 64D?2?@ =454=2<; 4?9 8ED 8B<BD6 >692=47 6M56?363 < 23 473E=E?<6?969<14<=E>56?34<2E?4C4D969<EC4D93E<16D 16493 23 E? <16 7EC6D 3296 4?9 <1B3 D6NB63<69 8ED 6?14?=2?@<16=E>56?34<2E?2?12384KEBD < 23 3B:>2<<69 :; <16 764D?69 =EB?367 8ED D635E?96?< E O ?3BD4?=6 E>54?; <14< <16 D2:B?47 143 D2@1<7; 1679 <14< 9D2K6D3 E8 <16 :E<1 <16 K612=763 4D6 6NB477;D635E?32:768ED<164==296?<4?9<16=E>56?34<2E? 4C4D969 :; <16 D2:B?47 23 AB3< 4?9 5DE56D C12=1 ?6693 ?E2?<6D86D6?=6 " ? <16 4==296?< =742>4?< 3B3<42?69 8D4=<BD6 <E 123 768< 86>BD 4?9 2?ABD; <E 123 768< 6;6 4?9 473E 36K6D6 1649 2?ABD; ? 3B55ED< E8 123 =436 16 6M4>2?69 <16 E=<ED 43 ) 16 D2:B?47 E:36DK69 <14< <16 ) E=<ED C43 6M4>2?69 48<6D 82K6 ;64D3 E8 4==296?< 4?9 16?=6?E<=E?3296D69<169234:272<;3<4<69:;12> 356D - 5 - M O EB?9 6D<282=4<6 =742>4?< 3B3<42?69 <16 8E77EC2?@2?ABD263/ ) 48<6D >692=477; 6M4>2?2?@ <16 =742>4?< 143 E:36DK69 E56D4<69 3=4D >4DJ3 5D636?< EK6D 768< >69247 <12@1 >2?2>47 3C6772?@ 5D636?< EK6D <16 768< 125 D6@2E? 768< 125 4?9 J?66 >EK6>6?<3 4D6 542?8B7 4?9 D63<D2=<69 4?9 <16 =742>4?< 23 B?4:76 <E 32< ED 3NB4< 4?9 16 C47J3 C2<172>5E?768<3296 6473EE:36DK69<14<4356D-D4; 768< 567K23 31EC3 >47B?2<69 8D4=<BD6 E8 768< 86>BD ?6=J C2<12>574?<2?3296 ==ED92?@7;1643363369#<E . 9234:272<;D674<2?@<E768<7EC6D72>: 16D68ED6<123 EBD< 82?93 2< AB3< 4?9 D643E?4:76 <E <4J6 +D9 E8 # <E . 9234:272<;43363369:;<16E=<EDC12=1=E>63<E . , 1EB@1 =742>4?< 3<4<63 <14< 16 C43 64D?2?@ 3 ### 56D >E?<1 16 143 ?E< 5DE9B=69 4?; - 6 - 9E=B>6?< <E 5DEK6 <16 34>6 3 <16 4==296?< 23 E8 <16 ;64D)# 4356D<16=14D<233B69:;<164D?4<4J4<4<6 6@47 6DK2=63 B<1ED2<; <123 EBD< 966>3 2< 455DE5D24<6 <E 433633 <16 2?=E>6 E8 <16 =742>4?< 4< 3 !### 56D >E?<1 <<16<2>6E84==296?<<16=742>4?<C434@69+ ;64D3 4?9 455DE5D24<6 >B7<25726D 45572=4:76 <E 123 4@6 @DEB523G"H ==ED92?@7;<16=742>4?<236?<2<7698ED7E33 E88B<BD664D?2?@43B?96D/ 3 !###M)M"M .P3 )+### ! 16 =742>4?< C43 49>2<<69 2? <16 1E352<47 8ED 94;3 E?3296D2?@<1656D2E9E81E352<472L4<2E??4<BD6 E8 2?ABD263 4?9 E<16D D676K4?< 84=<ED3 <123 EBD< 82?93 2< D643E?4:76 <E 4C4D9 4? 4>EB?< E8 3 #### 8ED 542? 4?9 3B886D2?@ 3 ) ### 8ED 7E33 E8 4>6?2<263 4?9 3 +#### 8ED <D4?35ED<4<2E? 6M<D4 ?EBD231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?< =14D@63 'BD<16D 9B6 <E 2?ABD263 <16 =742>4?< >2@1<?E<14K64<<6?9694?;CEDJ4<7643<8ED456D2E9E8 >E?<13 16?=6 <123 EBD< 82?93 2< D643E?4:76 <E 4C4D9 3 +)### 8ED 7E33 E8 2?=E>6 9BD2?@ 7429 B5 56D2E9 - 7 - EC6K6D <16 4>EB?< E8 3 !"+!# 4C4D969 :; <16 D2:B?478ED>692=476M56?363?6693?E2?<6D86D6?=6 ( 16 =E>56?34<2E? 4C4D969 :; <16 D2:B?47 23 >E92826943B?96D/ 7 E 6493 C4D9:;<16 D2:B?47 C4D9:;<123 EBD< 42? 4?9 3B886D2?@ 3 +#### 3 #### ) 692=47 M56?363 3 !"+!# 3 !"+!# + E33 E8 8B<BD6 64D?2?@=454=2<; 3 )+### D4?35ED<4<2E? 6M<D4 ?EBD231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?< =14D@63 3 )#### 3 +#### E33 E8 4>6?2<263 3 ) ### " E33 E8 2?=E>6 9BD2?@ 7429 B5 56D2E9 3 #### 3 +)### E<47 3 "+!# 3 +,!# 16D6C277:66?14?=6>6?<E83 +#,## - 8 - # 635E?96?< E ) O ?3BD4?=6 E>54?; 143 47D649; 965E32<69 <16 =E>56?34<2E? 4>EB?< 4C4D969 :; <16D2:B?47 !43=E?<D2:B<ED;?6@72@6?=623=E?=6D?69 ?E9EB:< =14D@63166< 2382769 4@42?3<<169D2K6DE8:E<1 <16K612=763 16D2:B?47E:36DK69<14<=742>4?<C43?E< 14K2?@K4729D2K2?@2=6?364?92<23K2E74<2E?E86=<2E?+ E8<16E<ED612=763=<433B=1<16D2:B?4743363369 =E?<D2:B<ED; ?6@72@6?=6 E8 #. E? <169D2K6D3E864=1E8 <16K612=763 ) < <123 3<4@6 764D?69 =EB?367 8ED <16 =742>4?< 14382769DEB@13J6<=1C2<1123<ED;E84==296?< 123 EBD< 143 @E?6 <1DEB@1 <16 34>6 E?3296D2?@ <16 6?<2D6 >4<6D2474K4274:76E?D6=ED94?9<1684=<<14<=14D@63166< 23827694@42?3<<169D2K6D3E8:E<1<16K612=763<123 EBD< 82?9323D643E?4:76<E1E79)#.=E?<D2:B<ED;?6@72@6?=6E? <1654D<E8<16=742>4?<4?9!#.E?<169D2K6DE8 - 9 - B3 ==ED92?@7;D635E?96?<E O 23724:76<E 54;!#.E8<16<E<47=E>56?34<2E? + ?<16D63B7<<168E77EC2?@ED96D23543369/ %2& 5564723 %22& 16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<769 8ED <16 6?14?=69 =E>56?34<2E? E8 3 +,!# C2<1 2?<6D63< 4< ". 56D 4??B> 8DE> <16 94<6 E8 56<2<2E? <277 <16 94<6 E8 D6472L4<2E? 43 4@42?3< 3 "+!# %222& 635E?96?< E O 23 92D6=<69 <E 965E32< !#. E8 3 +,!# C2<1 2?<6D63< F6M=7B92?@ 2?<6D63< 8ED )!# 94;3 <16 9674; =4B369 2? 8272?@ <16 455647I 4?9 473E 6M=7B92?@<164>EB?<47D649;965E32<69:68ED6 <16D2:B?47C2<12?E?6>E?<18DE><1694<6E8 <123AB9@>6?< - 10 - %2K& ? 3B=1 965E32< <16 =742>4?< 23 56D>2<<69<EC2<19D4C<166?<2D64>EB?<47E?@ C2<12?<6D63<4==DB69E?2< +,& '%) $ 23<E /7E /# /