- 1 - !"# $"% "" " & &'() & (( * ! "# $% & ' % & $ $' ( ! ) * + Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * # !'+ " % ) * # , # + # % # * + # * + - # # # & & '! # ## % %. *+ !% !$ .*+ % # %! # # / & 01 234567819 41565678 6: ;6<19 => 322?:19 70?:=389 389 68<3@: :11A68B C?3:068B 7; 501 4D7211968B: 418968B 68 7'! ;7D 7;;1821: 4?86:03=<1 ?891D 125678: % %. *+ !% !$ .*3+D139@650125678%7; - 3 - 01=D61;<>:535194D7:12?567823:13D13:?891D 1:4789185 791;3257 27E4<368385 @07 6: 501 @6;1 7; 415656781D 7322?:19 7 <79B19 3 27E4<3685 78 .!'! 3<<1B68B 5035 415656781D 7 :?=F12519 01D 57 6<<5D135E185 389 40>:623< 3::3?<5 96:4?568B5014351D865>7;501?8=7D8206<9@06<1:01@3: :56<< 23DD>68B 501 4D1B8382> 5 6: ;?D501D 3<<1B19 5035 415656781D 73<78B@65006:=D7501DE7501D389:6:51D G6:6519501D1:6918217;D1:4789185 750D135181901D 389 40>:623<<> 3=?:19 01D 3:19 78 501:1 3<<1B35678: 41D536868B 57 38 68269185 93519 !$! 3 27E4<3685 23E1 57 =1 D1B6:51D19 78 .!'! 2?<E683568B 68 D6E1 7%! 01 415656781D: 03G1 344D732019 506: 7?D5 :11A68BC?3:068B7;5014D7211968B:68D6E1 7%! 78 501 BD7?89 5035 501 :369 2D6E1 6: 875 E36853683=<1 68 G61@ 7; 501 4189182> 7; 4D7211968B: 68 7$$!! 3D6:68B 7?5 7; D6E1 7.! @0620 3227D968B 57 - 4 - 501E6:;7?891978501:3E1:157;3<<1B35678:13D819 27?8:1< 34413D68B ;7D 501 415656781D: @7?<9 :?=E65 5035 D1:4789185 7 03: 689?<B19 68 <79B68B E?<564<1 # : 68 D1:4125 7; 501 :3E1 E35D6E7863< 96:4?51 @0620 3E7?85: 5732<13D3=?:17;5014D721::7;<3@ % 1D 2785D3 <13D819 27?8:1< 34413D68B ;7D D1:4789185 7 78 D1;1D1821 57 501 D127D9: @7?<9 :?=E65503550127E4<3685<79B1968501>13D! 41D5368: 5740>:623<3::3?<52D?1<5>389383<<1B356787;3551E4557 27EE65 E?D91D => :15568B 501 D1:4789185 7 78 ;6D1 01 :369 3<<1B35678: <19 57 D1B6:5D35678 7; D6E1 7.! 389 501 :3E1 03: 2?<E683519 68 7$$!! @0620 6: 4D1:185<> 418968B 5D63< 1 @7?<9 501D1;7D1 2785189 5035 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685971: 875 3D6:1 7?5 7; 501 :3E1 722?DD1821 389 D1<351: 57 3 :143D351 389 96:56825 68269185 1821 501 D1B6:5D35678 7; D6E1 7%! 6: <1B3<<> 41DE6::6=<1 389 501 41565678 91:1DG1:96:E6::3< - 5 - 13D819 6B0 7?D5 7G1D8E185 <1391D 4<3268B D1<63821 78 501 <3@ <369 97@8 => 501 78H=<1 ?4D1E1 7?D5 68 8578> G 5351 7; 1D3<3 389 501D: @7?<9 :?=E65 5035 3 :12789 # 6: 6E41DE6::6=<1 78<>@01865D1<351:57501:3E1682691857D5D38:3256788 501 4D1:185 23:1 :6821 501 :12789 # 41D5368: 57 38 68914189185 389 96:56825 722?DD1821 87 6851D;1D1821 6: 23<<19;7D1@7?<9;?D501D:?=E655035656:78<>6823:1: @01D1 ;D1:0 68;7DE35678 D1<351: 57 501 :3E1 722?DD1821 50355018G1:56B3568B ;;621D6:D1C?6D195753A1D127?D:1 57125678'* +7;5017917;D6E683<D7219?D1 $ 3G68B013D9501<13D81927?8:1<34413D68B;7D 501 43D561: 506: 7?D5 03: =1:57@19 65: 38I67?: 278:691D3567857501203DB1:0115E351D63<:D1<3568B57501 13D<61D 68269185 @0620 6: 87@ 418968B 39F?96235678 68 7$$!! 06: 7?D5 03: 3<:7 23D1;?<<> 1I3E6819 501 3<<1B35678: E391 68 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685 <79B19 => 50191;325727E4<3683851;7D139G1D568B57501E1D65:7; 501 D6G3< 2785185678: 506: 7?D5 911E: 65 344D74D6351 57 - 6 - 1I5D325501D1<1G38547D56787;50127E4<3685@0620D139: 3:?891D !" #$ %" & '( )*+, - # ( ./ 01234 &.5 ++,6 7 $,8 "9* - $:( ;<8 = >? &8$ #, "9* $:( @, $! A #$= "9* $:/B #- $> "BC , DE%'F "" +'( GHI 7 $,8= J+ +? & )$ 7$; KK ? .L M 31+?N !L&8"+? J+ +?"7&8OP @, &8 3? -%+ > Q +!= %'F ! +?+!7 +#8G #+%R , 7> :P$ ")* $+#8= - 7 - N01$ST++U;<&()$ P7$; ++++,67 $= -%R$"LV++,67 $,8 %R$" G <9$2 DE $;7)$ 7$; @/Q8;)=01ST&8= W>? 7$;= !.L # 01ST++ U +> /"#8 & G 7XE8 &> W 7XE.? 7$#8 3 )*YZ/(, !"> + ? Y< A #$= ++,6 "7 . $+? ", #$ "+ - J++ "L %*$+ # 7++ < )$& ++,6"7 . $+?& -%+> 76< = &[ ( P? XE")$ *S +!8 = (; 7$;38$= &> "+Y \ )$ $ $; ( - 8 - ++,6 0DE 7 $ " 0'3.? 7$; = P+L ! L L <( "9>I "XE8= %'S$ "#8= 7$; P.? + . 7. &8$ 3 ]K^]K "+ "+> _` aK ( 7 $ bc7 &+: 7L [ L Q7% 6 c d$"L %*$+ 7L [ L Q7% 6 ae <$+L )$ 7 f Q7% 6 gc 7f 7 [ Q7%R6& >? ! 6)Lh 77 5S76 -%+)$ GA+ &>?38 # ( % # + # 7$;8 = ( # (; \ N # + # = N $H1 )*+3 , & 3 bi=K_=K VVj kS XE #$= N86 ++ ' # ( Bj, Vj kS XE #$O N86 ++ ' #( Bj, - 9 - # $. 6$+ : ,<)$ ?Y< A #$= ' 8323D1;?<D13968B7;5013<<1B35678:E39168 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685 65 2<13D<> 1E1DB1: 5035 875@650:538968B 501 4189182> 7; 501 1::678: 3:1 3B368:5 415656781D 70?:=389 501D1 34413D: 57 03G1 =118 3 D1?8678 =15@118 501 :47?:1: 9?D68B 501 41D679 389 415656781D 7 6: 3<<1B19 57 03G1 D1:?E19 2703=6535678 @650 D1:4789185 791;3257 27E4<368385 01 B181:6: 7; 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685 34413D: 57 =1 501 :?=:1C?18591863<7;4351D865>=>415656781D 727?4<19 @6505013<<1B19682691857;3::3?<593519!$!56: 78501=3:6:7;506::4126;62:?=:1C?18538968914189185 68269185503550127E4<368523E157=1<79B19@062003: 2?<E68351968D1B6:5D356787;D6E1 7%! 8327E43D356G13892<7:1D1I3E68356787;501 27E4<3685 <79B19 68 501 >13D ! 389 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685 506: 7?D5 6: 7; 501 278:691D19 G61@ 5035 =750 - 10 - 27E4<3685:41D5368575@796;;1D185722?DD1821::143D3519 68 47685 7; 56E1 835?D1 7; 3<<1B35678: 389 ;325?3< ;7?89356780113D<61D27E4<3685D1<351:573<<1B19325:7; 2D?1<5> 389 38 3551E45 57 27EE65 E?D91D @0620 03: 2?<E683519 68 7$$!! @01D13: 501 4D1:185 27E4<3685 3D6:1: 7?5 7; 38 68914189185 23?:1 7; 325678 =3:19 78 501 3<<1B19 68269185 93519 !$! 01D1;7D1 501 =3D 3B368:5 E?<564<1 # : 3: <369 97@8 => 50178H=<1?4D1E17?D5@7?<9875344<>57501;325:7; 5014D1:18523:178:1C?185<>D1:4789185 7@3:@1<< @6506801D<1B3<D6B0557E3685368501:12789# @06206: 87@ 501 :?=F125 E3551D 7; 203<<18B1 68 501 4D1:185 41565678 . 8:7;3D 3: 501 278568?35678 7; 4D7211968B: 3B368:5 415656781D 7: 57 % 6: 27821D819 506: 7?D5 4D72119: 57 1I3E681 5016D D7<1 6896G69?3<<> 15656781D 7322?:19 7 @07 6: 501 E3DD619 :6:51D68<3@ 7; D1:4789185 7 389 6: 39E65519<> D1:6968B 35 01D E35D6E7863< 07E1 03: =118 3DD3>19 3: 38 322?:19 => - 11 - 355D6=?568B G3B?1 B181D3< 389 7E86=?: 3<<1B35678: @6507?5 :4126;>68B 38> 43D562?<3D 7G1D5 325 9351 7D E3881D7;68G7<G1E1856E13893B368506:7?D53:@1<< 3: 501 78H=<1 41I 7?D5 03G1 278:6:5185<> 23?567819 3B368:5 501 5189182> 7; 6E4<623568B 3<< D1<356G1: 7; 501 0?:=38968E35D6E7863<96:4?51:78501=3:6:7;:@11468B 3<<1B35678: ?8<1:: 501 27E4<3685 96:2<7:1: :4126;62 68:53821: 91E78:5D3568B 5016D 3256G1 43D5626435678 68 501 3<<1B197;;1821: 8323D1;?<41D?:3<7;50127E4<3685389 501 203DB1:0115 E351D63<: 506: 7?D5 ;689: 5035 87 :?20 :4126;623<<1B35678:3D1;7D5027E68B3B368:5415656781D 7 :7 3: 57 F?:56;> 01D 4D7:12?5678 78568?35678 7; 4D7211968B: 3B368:5 01D @7?<9 501D1;7D1 3E7?85 57 38 3=?:17;5014D721::7;<3@ ! 8:7;3D 3: 415656781D 7% 6: 27821D819 501 27E4<3685 971: 96:2<7:1 :4126;62 7G1D5 325: 355D6=?519 57 06E43D562?<3D<>3<<1B35678:7;50D1351868B501D1:4789185 73:6:1G69185;D7E501:1278943B17;50127E4<3685 1I5D32519 01D1683=7G1 01501D :?20 3<<1B35678: 3D1 - 12 - ?<56E351<>4D7G196:3E3551D5035D1C?6D1:344D126356787; 1G6918219?D68B3;?<<;<19B195D63<38935506::53B1506: 7?D5 238875 ?891D53A1 3 E1562?<7?: 1I3E6835678 7; 501 5D?50;?<81:: 7; 507:1 3<<1B35678: @06<1 1I1D26:68B F?D6:9625678?891D125678% 7;D 6E6<3D<> @650 D1B3D9 57 415656781D 7E7501D68<3@501D13D12351B7D623<3<<1B35678:5035 :01 G6:6519 501 07?:1 7; D1:4789185 7 3<78B @650 415656781D 7 389 3=?:19 01D 68 ;6<50> <38B?3B1 389 6::?1950D135:01:13<<1B35678:507?B096:4?519238875 =1 =D?:019 3:691 35 501 50D1:07<9 01D1;7D1 1I2145 415656781D 7501D1E36868B415656781D:3D187518565<19 5738>689?<B182135506:F?825?D1 #7D 501 ;7D1B768B D13:78: 506: 7?D5 4D72119: 57 43::501;7<<7@68B *6+01415656786:3<<7@196843D5 - 13 - *66+ 01 2D6E683< 4D7211968B: 418968B 68 7'! *3D6:68B 7?5 7; D6E1 7%!+ 78 501 ;6<1 7; 501 1867D 6G6< &?9B1 389 061; &?96263< 3B6:5D351 39B6D6 ;7D 501 7;;1821: 4?86:03=<1 ?891D 125678: % %. !% !$ .*3+ D139 @650 125678 % 7; 501 89638 183< 791 3D1 01<9 57 =1 E36853683=<1389D1:4789185 76:18565<19574D7:12?51 501:3692D6E683<23:13B368:5501322?:1941D:78: *666+ 7@1G1D 501 4D7211968B: 68 7'! 3D1 01D1=> C?3:019 68:7;3D 3: 415656781D 7322?:19 73<7816:27821D819 *6G+56:2<3D6;61950355017=:1DG35678:E39101D168 3D1 278;6819 78<> 57 501 278:691D35678 7; 501 4D1:185 41565678 ?891D 125678 % 7; D 389 :03<< 875 68;<?1821 501 D63< 7?D5 @06<1 39F?9623568B 501 23:1 78 E1D65:3B368:5501D1E36868B322?:19 +) & ""( % 6:5 7< 7