- 1 - ! " # $$ % &%'$()&%(( * ! " " #$%$&'$ ! " () *!" ! )&$" ! + " '%'**'* " ''**'* + %**'&% " " "" )%#'," " + '*&**'*$ " - " + . " / Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - 0+ +# 0+ ! 1234567892:45524;314;;29<2=612389>7367898?612 4552;;496?8@6128??2932=5A97=14B;2A9:2@ 236789=)% 49:',8? 9:749294;8:2&%,' ?8@=18@6- .!49: 612 =2962932 7C58=2: 612@2A9:2@ BD 612 ;24@92: ::767894;7=6@73649: 2==789=+A:<27:4@ 76679<46 4=4>4E4;D49 BD FA:<C296 :462: '%'**'* 79 8%**'&% * 12 5@8=23A6789 34=2 79 B@72? 7= 6146 612 :2324=2:# 14964CC4 C4@@72: 612 4552;;496 4B8A6 ?8A@ )!D24@=5@78@686127937:2961238A5;24;;2<2:;D;7>2: 14@C8978A=;D ?8@ 4B8A6 )#$ C8961= 12@24?62@ 76 7= 4;;2<2: 6146 612 :2324=2: G4= =ABF2362: 68 51D=734; 49: C2964; 3@A2;6D 3A;C794679< 79 C7=34@@74<2 B8A6 6G8 *! D24@= 5@78@ 68 612 7937:296 =*% 68 ) 2;:2@=! C2:7462: 4 38C5@8C7=2 462@ 4552;;496 G8@E79< 4= 49 - 3 - 4A68 :@7>2@ 79 D:2@4B4: ;2?6 612 :2324=2: 46 *% A9764.= @2=7:2932 12@24?62@ 612 :2324=2: @26A@92:684=4>4E4;D496861218A=28?433A=2:8*79 =24@31 8? 612 4552;;496 6 7= 4;;2<2: 6146 612 4552;;496 4B49:892: 612 :2324=2: 49: C798@ 317;: 79 D:2@4B4: G7618A6 38CCA97346789 8@ =A558@6 ?8@4B8A6 &$:4D=9 61297<168?''*'&(612:2324=2:49:12@79?496317;: G2@2?8A9::24:794G2;;464=4>4E4;D49 @8=23A6789 2H4C792: & 68 % 49: 5@8:A32:H=&68$* ) & C8612@ 8? 612 :2324=2:! 14= 6A@92: 18=67;26861234=28?6125@8=23A6789*49:4;=8 6A@92: 18=67;2 G17;2 *( 68 B@84:;D =A558@62: 6125@8=23A6789 $ 12 @74; 8A@6 43IA7662: 433A=2: 8=* 49: 18;:79< 4B=2932 8? :7@236 2>7:2932 8? 4B26C296 BA6 389>7362:6124552;;496@24=8979<6146 - 4 - 7 2 ?47;2: 68 :7=314@<2 612 C4@764; 8B;7<46789 49: 4B49:892: 612 :2324=2: 49:317;:/ 77 2 ?47;2: 68 8??2@ =467=?4368@D 2H5;4946789 79 612 =6462C296 @238@:2: A9:2@ 236789 & 8? 612 8:2 8? @7C794; @832:A@2 &( ?8@ =18@6 -@.! 49: ?47;2: 68 4::A32@2BA664;2>7:2932/49: 777 = 612 =A737:2 833A@@2: G76179 =2>29 (! D24@= 8? C4@@74<2 5@2=AC56789 A9:2@ 236789&&8?612>7:293236852@462: G4@@49679< 389>736789 A9:2@ 236789= )%49:',8? , 12 4552;;496 12@279 7= 4==47;79< 612 FA:<C296 8? 389>736789 49: 8@:2@ 8? =2962932 54==2: BD 612 @74; 8A@6 ( 24@92: 38A9=2; 45524@79< ?8@ 612 4552;;496 @2762@4679<612<@8A9:=A@<2:7961245524;C2C8@49:AC 14=>212C296;D4@<A2:49:=ABC7662:6146C2@2?47;A@268 :7=314@<2 C4@764; 8B;7<46789 :8 986 79 76=2;? 389=676A62 - 5 - @2IA7=762 79<@2:7296= 8? 236789 ', 8? 2 G8A;: ?A@612@17<1;7<166146C8612@&2H4C792:4=&14= 6A@92: 18=67;2 2 G8A;: ?A@612@ 58796 8A6 6146 612 @74; 8A@614=>7@6A4;;DC7=@24: 236789',8? @2;4679<68 4B26C2968?=A737:22G8A;:=ABC766146612@2CA=6B2 5@88? 8? :7@236 8@ 79:7@236 436= 8? 296732C296 G1731 A;67C462;D;2:6838CC7==7898?=A737:22G8A;:389629: 6146 C2@2 4;;2<46789 8? 14@4==C296 G7618A6 612@2 B279< 49D58=767>24367895@8H7C4626861267C28?833A@@293289 61254@68?433A=2:8&G1731;2:8@38C52;;2:452@=89 68 38CC76 =A737:2 612 4552;;496 349986 B2 389>7362: ?8@ 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 ', 8? 2 =ABC76= 6146 79 612 4B=2932 8? 4367>2 436 14>79< 4 :7@236 92HA= 89 612 436789 A9:2@64E29 BD 612 :2324=2: 612 389>7367897=986=A=64794B;2 % ;24@92: 7<1 8A@6 8>2@9C296 ;24:2@ G8A;: 58796 8A6 6146 @252462: 14@4==C296 49: >7@6A4; 4B49:89C296 8? 4 D8A9< G7?2 G761 612 79?496 14= >7@6A4;;D :@7>29 612 :2324=2: 68 64E2 =A31 4 :@4=673 =625 - 6 - 49:612@2?8@2612@27==A??737296C462@74;G17315@8C562: 6128A@6B2;8G68389>7366124552;;496?8@6124?8@2=47: 8??2932= 49: 612@2?8@2 612 @24=89= 49: 3893;A=789= @238@:2: BD 612 8A@6 B2;8G 7= B4=2: 89 3@2:7B;2 49: 649<7B;2 C462@74; 49: 612@2?8@2 98 7962@?2@2932 7= G4@@4962: 4>79< 124@: 612 ;24@92: 38A9=2;= 617= 8A@6 14= 79:2529:296;D 4==2==2: 612 314@<2#=1226 C462@74;= 49:6122>7:2932;2:79BD6125@8=23A6789612?8;;8G79< 58796=G8A;:4@7=2?8@389=7:2@46789 ! " # $%& ' (%)! - 7 - * + ,- . (($ /, ! , " $($ ! ,-.,-/-$,-0%,( &' 18A<1 C8612@ 8? 612 :2324=2: 14: 986 =A558@62: 612 5@8=23A6789 34=2 49: 14= 6A@92: 18=67;2 *(# A9764 14= =A558@62: 612 5@8=23A6789 34=2 79:734679<6146612433A=2:=64@62:14@4==79<612:2324=2: 51D=734;;D49:C2964;;D49::A@79<612:2324=2:0==64D46 433A=2: 8*0= IA4@62@= 612 :2324=2: A=2: 68 8?629 62;; 617=G7692==4B8A661214@4==C296 1214=4;=8:258=2: 6146612:2324=2:@2=7:2:7912@18A=24;=8?8@=8C267C2 1214=4;=8:258=2:6146:2=5762:2324=2:.=4662C56=68 3896436 612 4552;;496433A=2: 612 4552;;496 G4= 986 4332==7B;2 68 612 :2324=2: 12 14= 4;=8 =58E29 4B8A6 ?8@37B;24B8@6789 - 8 - && 7C7;4@;D *%#412=1 G18 7= 612 B@8612@8? 612 :2324=2: 14= 4;=8 =6462: 6146 612 4552;;496 G4= 14@4==79<612:2324=2:89612<@8A9:6146=12G4=A94B;2 68 388E 5@852@;D 49: =12 G4= 986 43IA47962: G761 4<@73A;6A@4; 4367>7672= 2 14= 4;=8 :258=2: 6146 12 7962@>292:4;89<G76117=54@296=49:5437?72:49:4:>7=2: 612 4552;;496433A=2: 986 68 14@4== :2324=2:# 14964CC4 17= G7692== G4= 4;=8 2H629=7>2;D 3@8==# 2H4C792:BD612:2?2932 &* '# G4CD:4= 14= 4;=8 :258=2: 4B8A6 14964CC4 14>79< <86 389327>2: 49: ;462@ <86 4B8@62: :A26814@4==C29649:14=?A@612@:258=2:61461234C2 68E98G;462@6146 14964CC449:317;::72:49:12G4= =ACC892: 68 58;732 =646789 G12@2 12 7:2967?72: 14964CC4 49: 12@ =89#31796A 89 612 B4=7= 8? 51868 =18G9BD6128;732 & G187=48;732??732@49:4;=8@2=7:79< 79 612 IA4@62@= =7932 *'&( 14= 4;=8 :258=2: 6146 612 - 9 - 4552;;4964;89<G761612:2324=2:G4=@2=7:79<46433A=2: 8*0= IA4@62@= 8G2>2@ 17= =6462C296 7= 6146 12 34C2 68E98G6146B234A=28?14@4==C296BD612433A=2:612 :2324=2:4;89<G761612317;:38CC7662:=A737:2 &) 7C7;4@;D $#4;;79461 G18 G4= 4;=8 =64D79< 79 612 IA4@62@= 14= :258=2: 4B8A6 612 5@2=296 4552;;496IA4@@2;;79<G76117=G7?2 14964CC4462@12 34C268E98G6146612@24@2:24:B8:72=8?612;4:D49: 612317;:?8A9:79612G2;;=76A462:924@ 4=645A@ 17>4@4 &$ 9 <879< 61@8A<1 612 2>7:2932 8? 612 5@8=23A6789G7692==2=617=8A@67=8?612>72G6146612@2 7==8C2C462@74;89@238@:68B@79<18C2612<A7;68?612 4552;;496?8@6128??29325A97=14B;2A9:2@ 236789)%8? 122>7:29328?=7B;79<=49:4;=86128;73289=64B;2 =64D79< 46 612 IA4@62@= 38A5;2: G761 =A@@8A9:79< 37@3AC=64932= 3;24@;D 2=64B;7=1 6146 :A@79< 612 =AB=7=629328?C4@@74<2G1731;4=62:?8@=2>29 (!D24@= 612:2324=2:G4==ABF2362:68=8C251D=734;49:C2964; - 10 - 3@A2;6D 12 389=7=6296 62=67C89D 8? C462@74; G7692==2= 6124B=29328?49D5;4A=7B;2:2?293249:6124:C7662:?436 6146612G7?24;89<G76112@79?496317;:38CC7662:=A737:2 BDFAC579<79684G2;;=524E6861246C8=512@28?612@2 B279<=8C214@4==C296 &, 12 @74; 8A@6 612@2?8@2 @2?2@@79< 68 612=2 2>7:2932= 14= @7<16;D 38C2 68 612 3893;A=789 6146 612 4552;;496 7= <A7;6D 8? 14@4==79< 17= G7?2 12 @74; 8A@6 14= @7<16;D @238@:2: 612 ?79:79< 6146 612 5@8=23A6789 14= 2=64B;7=12:6129232==4@DC49:462A9:2@ 236789)%8? 12@2?8@2612?79:79<@238@:2:BD612@74;8A@679 @2=5236 8? 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 )% 8? :82=986G4@@49649D7962@?2@2932338@:79<;D58796 8 7!7=49=G2@2:79612 ,-.,-/-$,-01%,,(0%,2( &( 2?8@2 617= 8A@6 2H4C792= G12612@ 612 79<@2:7296=8? 236789',8?612 4@2C4:28A679612 5@2=296 34=2 76 7= 9232==4@D 68 4:>2@6 68 612 <8>2@979< - 11 - ;2<4; 5@79375;2= 6146 :2?792 612 38968A@= 8? 4B26C296 68 =A737:2 12 A5@2C2 8A@6 14= 389=7=6296;D 12;: 6146 C2@2 14@4==C296 8@:794@D :8C2=673 :7=38@: 8@ <292@4; 92<;2364=5237?735@8H7C46249:4367>24368?79=67<46789 8@ 7962967894; 47: :82= 986 =467=?D 612 @2IA7@2C296 8? 4B26C29612@2CA=6B243;24@49:;7>2;79EB26G229612 389:A36 8? 612 433A=2: 49: 612 2>296A4; :237=789 8? 612 :2324=2: 68 38CC76 =A737:2 4= 2;A37:462: 79 ! 12 89.B;2 52H 8A@6 79 "# $ % & '! ?A@612@ 2C514=7J2: 6146 4B26C296 79>8;>2= 4 C2964; 5@832== 8? 79=67<4679< 8@ 7962967894;;D 47:79< 612 38CC7==789 8? =A737:249:6146G7618A6458=767>2436466@7BA64B;268612 433A=2: 4 389>736789 A9:2@ 236789 ', 349986 B2 =A=64792: 7C7;4@;D79() & )*+ ,-!7614=B229@2762@462:6146 6125@8=23A6789CA=62=64B;7=1612@2IA7=762C29=@2449: =18G6146 612 436= 8? 612433A=2: G2@2 8?=A31 79629=76D - 12 - 49:7CC2:743D6146612:2324=2:G4=;2?6G76198856789 BA66864E26122H6@2C2=625/=6@4DA662@4932=8@@2C862 7937:296= ?4;; =18@6 8? 617= 61@2=18;: 12 2==29674; 79<@2:7296= 8? 612 8??2932 14>2 B229 =A337936;D =ACC4@7J2: 79 % ( ' .!94C2;D 7!612?436AC8?=A737:2/ 77!4B26C2964= :2?792: A9:2@ 236789 &'( / 49: 777! 796296789 89 612 54@6 8? 612 433A=2: 68 47: 8@ 79=67<462 612 436 12 5@79375;2=;47::8G979%& % & / 0/! 49: % % 1) 2& 00! 4;=8 @279?8@32 612 @2IA7@2C296 6146 4B26C296 CA=6 B2 3;24@;D2=64B;7=12:61@8A<138<29649:5@8H7C462389:A36 &% 9 612 ;7<16 8? 612 2==29674; 79<@2:7296= =ACC4@7J2: BD 612 89.B;2 52H 8A@6 79 612 @258@62: FA:<C296=3762:=A5@4617=8A@6922:=682H4C7924=68 G12612@6128A@6B2;8GG4=FA=67?72:7979>8E79< 236789 &&8?612>7:293236G17312C514=7J2=:7=3@267894@D 5@2=AC56789389:767892:895@88?8?3@A2;6D - 13 - & 12 5@2=AC56789 A9:2@ 236789 && 8? 612 >7:2932367=9864A68C467312;49<A4<27=IA7623;24@ G1731 =4D= 6146 612 8A@6 C4D 5@2=AC2 89;D A589 5@88? 6146612G8C4938CC7662:=A737:2G76179=2>29 (!D24@= 8? C4@@74<2 49: 6146 =12 G4= =ABF2362: 68 3@A2;6D A9:2@ 236789)%8? *' 18A<1G17;249=G2@79<587968 7!617=8A@6 14= 12;: 6146 612@2 G4= =8C2 :2<@228? 14@4==C296 49: 3@A2;6D BA6 612 IA2=6789 7= G12612@ 612 3@A2;6D G4= 8? =A31 4 :2<@22 6146 76G8A;: 14>2 :@7>29612:2324=2: 68 38CC76 =A737:2 6@4D 8@ @2C862 7937:296= :8 986 =A??732 49: 4;;2<46789= @2<4@:79< 4B26C296 A9:2@ 236789 ',8? CA=6B25@8>2:B2D89:@24=894B;2:8AB6>29<@4>2 C462@74;79:7=3@26789=G7618A63;24@5@88?8?3@A2;6D:@7>79< 612 G8C49 68 =A737:2 G7;; 986 BD 612C=2;>2= 466@436 236789',8? *& 12C8612@&G187=61238C5;47949614= 6A@92: 18=67;2 49: 14= 986 =A558@62: 612 34=2 8? 612 - 14 - 5@8=23A6789 2@ 3@8==#2H4C7946789 8? 14@4==C296 ?8@ 4B8A6 ?8A@ D24@= 24@;72@ 7= >4<A2 49: 62C58@4;;D @2C862 ?@8C 612 =A737:2 =* 49: 14>2 4;=8 6A@92: 18=67;2 12 @2C47979< G7692==2= =*( 68 =524E B@84:;D 4B8A6 5@78@ :7=38@: 49: 4 38C5@8C7=2 6G8 D24@= B2?8@2 612 833A@@2932 8? 612 7937:296 8 G7692==2= :2=3@7B2: 4 =5237?735@8H7C46249:38962C58@4928A=4368?3@A2;6D8@ 79=67<46789=18@6;DB2?8@2''*'&( ** 12 5@8=23A6789 34=2 179<2= 89 612 4;;2<2: 4B49:89C296 BD 612 4552;;496 ?8@ 4 52@78: 8? &$ 5;A= :4D= 12 5@8=23A6789 4==2@6= 6146 612 4552;;496 ;2?6 612 :2324=2: 49: 612 317;: G7618A6 3896436=A558@6 ?8@ 8>2@ &$ :4D= >29 4==AC2: 92<;236 612@2 7= 98 649<7B;2 2>7:2932 G1731 14= :@7>29 612 :2324=2: 68 64E2 =A31 4 :@4=673=625=@252462:;D12;:C2@292<;2368@?47;A@268 :7=314@<2 C4@764; 8B;7<46789= G7618A6 C8@2 :82= 986 389=676A62 4B26C296 A9:2@ 236789 ', 8? 49: G8A;: 986=467=?D79=67<467898@7962967894;47:A9:2@ 236789&'( 8? 49:612@2?8@2C4D986389=676A62494B26C296 - 15 - * 9 A9=467=?4368@D 49=G2@ 79 612 =6462C296 @238@:2: A9:2@ 236789 & 8? @ 349986 =AB=676A62 6125@8=23A67890=BA@:29685@8>26122==29674;79<@2:7296= 8? 8??2932 8 5@8>2 612 2==29674; 79<@2:7296= 8? 612 8??29325A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 ', 8? 49 4:>2@=2 79?2@2932349986BD76=2;??8@C4389>736789?8@4B26C296 12=AB=6@46AC8?79=67<4678947:G761C29=@24CA=6?7@=6 B279:2529:296;D2=64B;7=12: *) 12@2?8@2 79 612 ;7<16 8? 612 C8612@ 6A@979< 18=67;2 617= 8A@6 922:= 68 2H4C792 G12612@ 612 @74; 8A@62@@2:7979>8E79< 236789&&8?612>7:293236 C2@2;D B234A=2 =A737:2 833A@@2: G76179 =2>29 D24@= 8? C4@@74<2 49: B234A=2 612 4552;;496 4;;2<2:;D 4B49:892: 612 :2324=2: 17= 455@8431 4338@:79< 68 617= 8A@6 7= ;2<4;;D79?7@C125@8=23A6789.=2>7:2932618A<1=A??737296 68 389>736 612 4552;;496 ?8@ 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 )% 8? 18G2>2@ ;43E= 3@2:7B;2 2>7:2932 68 389>7366124552;;496A9:2@ 236789',8? 12314@<2 - 16 - =1226C462@74;=49:6122>7:29328?612G7692==2=:8986 :2C89=6@4626146612389:A368?6124552;;496G4=8?=A31 4946A@2614676:@2G612:2324=2:6838CC76=A737:2 *$ 55;D79<612 4B8>2 5@79375;2=612@238@:= ;43E 5@88?8?79=67<46789389=57@43D8@7962967894;47:12@27= 9858=767>2436BD6124552;;4965@8H7C46268612=A737:2 12 5@8=23A6789 14= 986 =18G9 612 @2IA7=762 C29= @24 12 @74; 8A@6.= 79?2@2932 6146 4B49:89C296?47;A@2 68 :7=314@<2 C4@764; 8B;7<46789= 75=8 ?4368 4C8A96= 68 4B26C2967=:7@236;D3896@4@D68612;4G;47::8G9BD612 89.B;2 52H 8A@6 79 612 34=2 8? 3 43 3# . . ! 338@:79<;D 58796 8= 77! 68 7>! 4@2 49=G2@2:795-3/40,235 *, -6781,- 4! 6 612 8A6=26 617= 8A@6 ?79:= 6146 612 ;24@92:@74;+A:<214=5@8322:2:89492@@8928A= A9:2@=649:79< 8?612 =3852 49: 79<@2:7296= 8? 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 ', 8? 612 - 17 - 12389>7367897=5@7C4@7;D?8A9:2:896125@2C7=2 6146 612 4552;;496 ?47;2: 68 :7=314@<2 17= C4@764; 8B;7<46789= 49: 14: 4;;2<2:;D 4B49:892: 612 :2324=2: 49: 6127@ C798@ 317;: A31 @24=8979< 618A<1 @2?;2367>2 8? 4 C8@4; :7=455@8>4; 8? 612 4552;;496.= 389:A36 :82= 986 =467=?D 612 =646A68@D @2IA7@2C2968?4B26C2964=:2?792:A9:2@ 236789 &'( B=296 5@88? 8? 79=67<46789 7962967894; 47:8@4367>254@673754678938A5;2:G761C29=@24 C2@2 92<;236 8@ 4B=2932 ?@8C 612 C46@7C8974; 18C2349986B22;2>462:68612;2>2;8?4B26C296 8?=A737:2 B! 12 @74; 8A@614= ?47;2: 68 7:2967?D 49D 58=767>25@8H7C4628@:7@2364368961254@68?612 4552;;496G173138A;:14>238C52;;2:8@793762:612 :2324=2: 68 38CC76 =A737:2 12 2>7:2932 89 @238@: :82= 986 :7=3;8=2 49D 8>2@6 436 G8@:= 8? 5@8>8346789 61@246= 8@ 389679A8A= 14@4==C296 7CC2:7462;D 5@232:79< 612 7937:296 9 3@7C794; FA@7=5@A:2932 54@673A;4@;D 79 5@8=23A6789= A9:2@ 236789', 612@2CA=62H7=64;7>249::7@236 92HA=B26G229612389:A368?612433A=2:49:612 436 8? =A737:2 12 ?79:79<= @238@:2: BD 612 @74; 8A@6 4@2 389=573A8A=;D =7;296 89 617= 2==29674; - 18 - @2IA7@2C296 49: @2=6 5A@2;D 89 79?2@2932 49: 389F236A@2 3!12@74;8A@614=5;432:A9:A2@2;74932 894;;2<46789=8?14@4==C296=47:6814>2833A@@2: 924@;D?8A@D24@=5@78@686127937:296G1731G2@2 4:C7662:;D?8;;8G2:BD438C5@8C7=2B26G229612 54@672=6G8D24@=B2?8@2612:24618?612:2324=2: A31 =64;2 49: @2C8624;;2<46789= 79 612 4B=2932 8? 2>7:2932 =18G79< 6127@ 389679A46789 8@ @23A@@2932793;8=25@8H7C76D68612=A737:2349986 389=676A62612B4=7=?8@4389>736789A9:2@ 236789 ', 12;4GC49:462=6146612389:A36@2;72: A589CA=6B28?=A31<@4>76D49:7CC2:743D4=68 ;24>2612>7367CG761988567892H32566864E2612 2H6@2C2=625 :! =2@78A= ;2<4; 79?7@C76D 4@7=2= ?@8C 612 C23149734; 79>8346789 8? 612 5@2=AC56789 A9:2@ 236789&&#8?612>7:29323612@74;8A@6 14=5@2=AC2:4B26C296=8;2;D89612<@8A9:6146 612 =A737:2 833A@@2: G76179 =2>29 D24@= 8? C4@@74<2 9 612 5@2=296 34=2 612 ?8A9:467894; ?436= 9232==4@D 68 466@436 =A31 5@2=AC56789 14>2 986 B229 5@8>2: @29:2@79< 612 455;7346789 8? 236789&&#G18;;DA9=A=64794B;2 - 19 - 2! 12 @74; 8A@6 14= ?A@612@ 2@@2: 79 :@4G79<494:>2@=279?2@29324<479=66124552;;496 89612<@8A9:614612?47;2:688??2@4=467=?4368@D 2H5;4946789 79 17= =6462C296 A9:2@ 236789 & @ 8@ 68 ;24: :2?2932 2>7:2932 6 7= G2;;# =266;2: 6146 612 BA@:29 68 5@8>2 612 <A7;6 8? 612 433A=2: B2D89: @24=894B;2 :8AB6 4;G4D= @2=6= A589 612 5@8=23A6789 49: :82= 986 =17?6 C2@2;D B234A=2 612 433A=2: @2C479= =7;296 8@ ?47;= 68 4::A32 2>7:2932 2?73729372= 79 612 5@8=23A6789 34=2 349986 B2 3A@2: BD :@4G79< 4:>2@=2 79?2@2932=?@8C612433A=2:.=2H5;4946789 ?! 12 @24=8979< 4:8562: BD 612 @74; 8A@6 =A??2@= ?@8C 7962@94; 79389=7=6293D 17;2 433A=2: 8=* 49: G2@2 43IA7662: 89 612 <@8A9: 6146 612@2 G4= 98 2>7:2932 8? 79=67<46789 8@ 4B26C296 6124552;;4964;89214=B229389>7362:G7618A649D 4::767894;8@:7=679<A7=179<C462@74;68:2C89=6@462 4 17<12@ :2<@22 8? 3A;54B7;76D @7C794; ;74B7;76D A9:2@ 236789 ', 7= 52@=894; 49: 349986 B2 ?4=6292:=8;2;D89612B4=7=8?C4@764;@2;46789=175 8@5@2=AC2:@2=589=7B7;76D8?6121A=B49: <! 72G2: 3ACA;467>2;D 612 7C5A<92: FA:<C296 @2>24;= 6146 612 389>736789 7= ?8A9:2: - 20 - C8@2 89 C8@4; 4==AC56789= 49: =DC54612673 389=7:2@46789= @4612@ 6149 89 =6@736 ;2<4; 5@88? 8? 612 2==29674; 79<@2:7296= 8? 4B26C296 12 455@8431 4:8562: BD 612 @74; 8A@6 :7;A62= 612 =266;2::7=67936789B26G229C46@7C8974;:7=38@:49: 3@7C794; 4B26C296 8? =A737:2 G1731 612 ;4G 14= 389=7=6296;D<A4@:2:4<479=6 1!"8@4;;6124?8@2=47:@24=89=617=8A@67= 8?612389=7:2@2:85797896146612?79:79<=@238@:2: BD 612 @74; 8A@6 A9:2@ 236789 ', =A??2@ ?@8C 52@>2@=76D C7=455;7346789 8? ;2<4; 5@79375;2= 49:989#455@237467898?C462@74;2>7:2932612@2BD G4@@49679< 7962@?2@2932 89=2IA296;D 612 389>736789 49: =2962932 7C58=2: 89 612 4552;;496 A9:2@',4@2;74B;268B2=264=7:2 *( "8@612?8@2<879<@24=89=617=8A@654==2=612 ?8;;8G79< 7 1245524;7=4;;8G2:7954@6 77 12 FA:<C296 8? 389>736789 :462: '%'**'* 49: 8@:2@ 8? =2962932 :462: ''**'*54==2:BD ::767894;7=6@736 - 21 - 49: 2==789= +A:<2 7:4@ =76679< 46 4=4>4E4;D49 79 8%**'&% 389>73679< 612 4552;;496 ?8@ 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 )% 8? 7= 389?7@C2: 777 8G2>2@ 612 7C5A<92: FA:<C296 8? 389>73678949:8@:2@8?=296293254==2:BD 612 @74; 8A@6 389>73679< 612 433A=2: ?8@ 6128??29325A97=14B;2A9:2@ 236789',8? 7==264=7:2124552;;4967=43IA7662: ?8@ 612 8??2932 5A97=14B;2 A9:2@ 236789 ',8? 7> 12 52@78: 8? 7C5@7=89C296 4;@24:D A9:2@<892 BD 612 4552;;496 7= 12@2BD =26 8??4<479=6612=29629327C58=2:A589612 433A=2:7962@C=8? 236789)*%8?@ > 12@2=68?612=29629327=4??7@C2: .) % ( # 7=68* ;8)$