Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92879 (KAR)
SUDHA AND ANR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201698/2024 · 2025-11-17
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92879 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92879 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#& ##
#
'( ')* (' )) *+ # (
'( ')* (' ))
+
! "
#
$ %
&
& !'
(
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(!((
$
)* +('
"
#& , $ & (%
& + (
& # % ( & #*%
)
& - !(!((
' (!( #
(+!( (!((% # ( (!((%
&
&&
+ +(! + +' +' *
+ &
& & $ &
$
(*
+
*
$
$
+
$
+! ( $
$$
(
"
#
$ %
- 3 -
&
& !'
(
(!((
$
)* +('
"
#& , $ & (%
& + (
& # % ( & #*%
)
& - !(!((
' (!( #
(+!( (!((% ( (!((%
&
&&
+ +(! + +' +' *
+ &
& & $ &
$
&
*
. - 4 -
# . %
/010 234 567879:; <02727491 :60 2:=09 24>02/06 :1 2/0?:6079206;79=0@:9@2/0?:67104A24B2/0<64500@79>1 <09@79> 79 4( (!(( 943 9A8C060@ :1 4' (!( 60>712060@ B46 2/0 4BB09501 <A971/:C;0 A9@060527491++(!++'+'60:@372/052749 + 4B 2/0 9@7:9 09:; 4@0 ! <09@79> C0B460 2/0 097467D7;A@>0:9@&:9D7 ( /0 >712 4B 2/0 <67D:20 548<;:792 71 2/:2 2/0 <0272749061 79 2/010 234 <02727491 3/4 :60 1A6D0? :A2/4672701 :;;0>0@;? B46>0@ 2/0 17>9:2A601 4B 5062:79 ;:9@439061 79 601<052 4B ;:9@ C0:679> ?4+! 80:1A679>(:5601>A92:1271:;;0>0@2/:2A9@062/0 >A7104B549@A5279>:B601/1A6D0?2/0:55A10@B46>0@2/0 17>9:2A6014B490:99:6:99:3/43:1:@87220@;?942 <601092 @A679> 2/0 1A6D0?, 4B 490 79>:88: 3/4 /:@ <:110@ :3:? 79 (!, :9@ 4B 44;:<<: 4 6:99: #*(%:20:5/063/43:1494BB757:;@A2?:22/060;0D:92
- 5 -
<47924B278001<7202/076:C109502/0942750160EA760@ B46 549@A5279> 2/0 1A6D0? :60 :;;0>0@ 24 C0:6 2/076 17>9:2A601 92/010:;;0>:274914BB46>06?78<06149:2749 :9@5/0:279>:<67D:20548<;:792A9@06052749(!!4B2/0 4@0 4B 67879:; 6450@A60 5:80 24 C0 B7;0@ 79 4( (!((
/0 ;0:690@ :>7126:20 A<49 60546@79> 2/0 13469 12:2080921 4B :99: 6:99: 3/4 @71<A201 /71 17>9:2A60 :9@ 4B 44;:<<: 4 6:99: :9@ A<49 0F:87979> 2/0 @0:2/ 50627B75:20 4B 79>:88: 8:6=0@ :1 F <64500@0@ 24 2:=0 54>97G:950 4B 2/0 :;;0>0@ 4BB09501 :9@ 711A0@ 1A88491 24 2/0 :55A10@
/0 1:7@ 46@06711A79><64501171A9@065/:;;09>0792/010<02727491
+ 67879:; 0272749 4(!+ (!(+ 71 B7;0@ C? :55A10@ 4 2/0 11712:92 7605246 4B :9@ 0546@1 67879:; 0272749 4(! (!(+ 71 B7;0@ C? :55A10@ 41 :9@ ' 3/4 3060 BA95274979> :1 2/0 4D0698092 A6D0?46:9@A6D0?A<06D7146601<0527D0;? - 6 -
:D79> /0:6@ 2/0 ;0:690@ 54A910; B46 2/0 <0272749061 :9@ 2/0 ;0:690@ 7>/ 4A62 4D0698092 ;0:@06 B46 2/0 2:20 2/0 5460 711A0 2/:2 :67101 B46 54917@06:2749 71 3/02/06 :55A10@ 4 H2/0 11712:92 76052464B:9@0546@1:9@:55A10@41:9@'5:9C0 1ACI0520@24567879:;<64105A2749B462/0:;;0>0@4BB09501 C:10@ 14;0;?
49 2/0 548<;:792 ;4@>0@ C? * :99: 6:99:
946@0624@020687903/02/062/0549279A:2749 4B<64500@79>1:>:7912:55A10@4124 71IA127B70@7271 905011:6? 240F:8790 2/0>712 4B 2/0 :;;0>:274918:@0 79 2/0 548<;:792 5546@79>;? 2/0 60;0D:92 <462749 4B 2/0 548<;:792710F26:520@/060A9@06
!"#$
%
& ' ( )
*% + % ' ++ ' ' , -
- 7 -
++ -.(/0 0/ *
'
* ' '
'' ' # 1'
23 %
*% +
%
'
*
"
" % )
"4"5
3%
%
+
++' ,- 6/6/'
%
++ , - * *4 ++ , - *
'
'"
$
"-
' 7 7 8 #++ 7
66 *' ++ ' ' % * +
+ 4
, - ' ' +
*
+
% '' 4
9
9 4 ' +
'
+++
*%
+
+ ' 7
2 1'' ' *%
- 8 -
' '*
+
' ! ' + 7 7
*
*%
+ ++ , - *
:'
'
* 4 ' %
''
' '
+
*% +
+ ' 7 2 1'''*%;
' /71 4A62 :;14 @0081 72 B72 24 0F26:52 2/0 60;0D:92 <462749 4B 2/0 <67D:20 548<;:792 B7;0@ 79 4( (!(( 9 * 7
66 '*'++ ' '%
*
+
+ 4
, - ''+
*
+
%
''
4
' +
9
+
4'+
'
+++ < ' 4 +
% '+
+
+
" <
- 9 -
"+
' < 2 + +
' +
+ + ' %
+
'4 + ': =* !+ ' ,92 *% + ' *%
'
'*
+
' +
' ! ' +
77
*
*%
+ ++ , - *
:'
9 * %
-
%
'' := *
' +
"
- %
' ' +
*
+ ' +
=
'! +
*
+
0 *
- / ( %
+ '
'
4 % * ++
' +
' ! ' ' '* ,1236 *
-(%
- 10 -
'' ' +
'
'
/714A62:;14@008172B72240F26:522/013469 12:208092 4B * 548<;:79:92 60546@0@ C?
2/0 4A62 C0;43
!" # $ % &'( ! " # ) &*+ &, - $)*. /0
1234*. " # $ 56
,7 &8 $ ) &9 :;< =
>?? $ &8 $ @0A B C:
-
D - ) ;E9>>F >?2 >>A? $ % &9 GH
2 @23&I
J&E9 $ 5 &8 $ )>> % -D &<
>?? $ * &
>* &
) K>>7> &?A $ ) >? 7
F
:;
LA MN :;>
&9 &! E %? O- &P7
>? ) 7 56 )
- 11 -
>?? " Q
R => F $ 5A> S@@ $
>K" $6> T 5 U%;
>2
L A $ L> ) " $6$ > T A
6$" $V$ - DAE9 MN 5 6$" $V$ A
K>>7> WA
K>>7> F ;F ) A $ A ) 2 , MN ) %A$ " ,:< $ (!> D> )%A$"X" ,:< $
$ 56 $ ?2 C: - ) JY9A N7 L
B( $4&* @0AC:
- ) &?A $
" $6$ > T %? &, &?A $ ) %A$ " ,:< $ 6$" $V A
A ) &?A $ ) %A$ "
,:< $ T P@ - ) &?A $
R - ) G#9F %A$ " ,:< $ T ASJ,> ) &?A $
R - )G#9F%A$ " ,:< $ &*+ &, - ) &?A $
R - )
F %A
" ,:< $&7 B8 &J?0J7
&
>* &
) &?A $ ) %A$ "
,:< $J?0JEA: ) &?A $ )
,:< $ &8 J?0J 7 ) &?A $ ) %A$ " ,:< $ 1 - ) &?A $
R - ) G#9 %A$ " ,:< $
- 12 -
* &
>* &
) &?A $ ) %A$ "
,:< $ 5M56 M
' -Z7 $[
9 : 5;410 156A279? 4B 2/0 :;;0>:27491 79 2/0 548<;:7922/714A62B79@12/:2:;2/4A>/:55A1:274914B: 10674A1 9:2A60 :60 ;0D0;;0@ :>:7912 :55A10@ 4 #4D0698092 A6D0?46% :55A10@ 4' #A6D0? A<06D7146%:9@:55A10@4 #11712:9276052464B:9@ 0546@1% 2/0 548<;:792 5492:791 49;?
D:>A0 :9@ C:;@ :110627491 :>:7912 2/08
/0 548<;:79:92 8060;? :;;0>01 949D067B75:2749 4B 2/0 7@09272? 4B 2/0 <061491 3/4 <A6<4620@;? 17>90@ 2/0 9427501 711A0@ C? 2/0 ;750910@ 1A6D0?46 :55A10@ 4 0;?79> A<49 2/010 >0906:; :;;0>:274912/0;0:690@:>7126:20/:1<64500@0@242:=0 54>97G:950 372/4A2 7@0927B?79> :9? 1<057B75 4D062 :52 :2267CA2:C;024:55A10@4124
! /060546@1/430D0660D0:;2/:27271:55A10@ 42/0:A2/467G0@;750910@1A6D0?463/479@0<09@092;? 5:6670@ 4A2 2/0 1A6D0? :9@ 4C2:790@ 17>9:2A601 49 2/0
- 13 -
9427501 711A0@ A9@06 &468#5%
/0 09@461080921 :<<0:679> :2 2/0 B442 4B 2/0 1:7@ 9427501 5;0:6;? 79@75:20 2/:249;?:55A10@43:1<601092:22/01<42@A679>2/0 1A6D0? :9@ 2/:2 72 3:1 /0 3/4 105A60@ 2/0 17>9:2A601 /060 71 94 8:2067:; 49 60546@ 24 @0849126:20 2/0 <6010950 4B <0272749061 :55A10@ 41 24 46 24 79@75:20 2/:2 2/0? <;:?0@ :9? 64;0 79 105A679> 2/0 @71<A20@ 17>9:2A601
/0 90F2 EA012749 2/:2 905011:67;? :67101 B46 54917@06:2749713/02/06792/0:C109504B1:952749A9@06 052749'4B2/04@04B67879:;6450@A602/0;0:690@ :>7126:20 3:1 548<02092 24 2:=0 54>97G:950 4B 2/0 :;;0>0@ 4BB09501 :>:7912 2/010 <0272749061 3/4 :60 :@87220@;?<AC;75106D:921
( 27194279@71<A202/:2:55A10@4124 :60 <AC;75 106D:921 4 1:952749 :1 8:9@:20@ A9@06 052749 ' 4B 6 /:1 C009 4C2:790@ <6746 24 2:=79> 54>97G:950
/060B460 2/0 54>97G:950 2:=09 C? 2/0
- 14 -
;0:690@ :>7126:20 :>:7912 2/010 <0272749061 12:9@1 D727:20@B463:924B2/060EA71720<67461:952749
D09498067212/08:2067:;4960546@@401942 @715;410 :9? 79567879:279> 5765A812:950 24 1/43 2/:2 :55A10@4124 3060<601092:22/027804B2/01A6D0? 46 2/:2 2/0? <:62757<:20@ 79 46 B:57;72:20@ 2/0 :;;0>0@ 105A679>4B17>9:2A6014B:@050:10@<06149462/0:;;0>0@ B46>79> 4B 17>9:2A601 4B ;:9@439061 3/4 3060 :@87220@;? 942 <601092
/0 8060 B:52 2/:2 :55A10@ 4 /4;@1 2/0 <412 4B 11712:92 7605246 4B :9@ 0546@1 :9@ :55A10@ 41:9@':604BB757:;14B2/0A6D0?0<:6280925:9942 C? 7210;B B468 2/0 C:171 B46 2/076 <64105A2749 9 2/0 :C10950 4B :9? 2:9>7C;0 8:2067:; 012:C;71/79> 2/076 79D4;D08092792/0:524BB46>06?4678<06149:27491:7@24 /:D0 455A660@ @A679> 2/0 1A6D0? A9@062:=09 C? :55A10@ 4 567879:; <64500@79>1 5:9942 C0 1A12:790@ :>:7912 2/08
- 15 -
+ ;2/4A>/ ;0:690@ 54A910; B46 2/0 548<;:79:92 /:@ 0:6;706 549209@0@ 2/:2 : ;750910@ 1A6D0?46 5:9942 :5548<;71/1A6D0?346=79@0<09@092;?372/4A22/0:7@46 1A<06D71749 4B 2/0 11712:92 7605246 4B :9@ 0546@1 46 42/061A6D0?4BB757:;1A<49C079>EA0670@C?2/04A62/0 3:1A9:C;024<47924A2:9?<64D71749A9@062/0:69:2:=: :9@0D09A052462/06A;012/060A9@061A<<46279>1A5/ :<64<4172749412:2A246?C:6/:1C009@0849126:20@24 1/43 2/:2 : ;750910@ 1A6D0?46 5:9942 549@A52 : 1A6D0? 372/4A22/0<60109504B2/010<0272749061
92/71C:5=>64A9@72C0548015;0:62/:28060 /706:65/75:; 1A<0674672? 46 @0<:628092:; 5499052749 372/ :55A10@ 4 5:9942 IA127B? 2/0 <64105A2749 4B :55A10@ 41 24 B46 4BB09501 60;:279> 24 5/0:279> :9@ B46>06? /076 :;;0>0@ 567879:; 792092 46 548<;7572? 8A12 C0 1A<<4620@ C? 54956020 1<057B75 :9@ 560@7C;0 8:2067:; 9 2/0:C109504B1A5/8:2067:;2/010<02727490615:9942C0 @6:>>0@7924 567879:; <64500@79>18060;?49 2/0 C:1714B 549I052A60
- 16 -
549I479260:@79>4B2/0<67D:20548<;:792:9@ 2/0 13469 12:208092 4B 2/0 548<;:79:92 #0F:8790@ :1 *% 60D0:; 2/:2 2/060 71 942 0D09 : 3/71<06 4B :;;0>:2749@0849126:279> :9?
:524648711749 49 2/0<:62 4B :55A10@ 4124 2/:2 54A;@ :226:52 567879:; ;7:C7;72? 01<720 2/0 548<;:79:92 <64@A579> 10D06:; @45A80921 94904B2/0854990522/010<0272749061242/0:;;0>0@:521 4B B46>06? :2267CA20@ 24 :55A10@ 4 5546@79>;? 2/71 4A62714B2/054917@060@D7032/:20D09498067212/060 71 :C14;A20;? 94 8:2067:; 3:66:9279> 2/0 549279A:2749 4B 567879:;<64500@79>1:>:79122/010<0272749061
' &A62/0684607271:9:@87220@<41727492/:22/0 @71<A20@ 1A6D0? 549@A520@ C? :55A10@ 4 /:1 :;60:@? C009 102 :17@0 C? 2/0 <<0;;:20 A2/4672? A9@06 2/0 :69:2:=: :9@ 0D09A0 52
/0 >670D:9501 4B 2/0 548<;:79:92 2/A1 12:9@ 1AC12:927:;;? 60@60110@ 79 2/0 12:2A246? :<<0;;:20 <64500@79>1 9 1A5/ 5765A812:9501 549279A:2749 4B 2/0 <601092 567879:; <64500@79>1 :>:7912
- 17 -
:55A10@ 41 24 106D01 94 <A6<410 :9@ 5:9942 C0 ;0>:;;?1A12:790@
&46 2/0 B460>479> 60:1491 2/71 4A62 <64500@1 24<:112/0B4;;4379>
#7% 42/2/067879:;02727491:60:;;430@ #77% /046@064B54>97G:950@:20@!(!((:9@ 092760567879:;<64500@79>1794' (!( #4;@ 4(+!( (!((% #4( (!((% 60>712060@ B46 2/0 4BB09501 <A971/:C;0 A9@06 0527491 + +(! + +' +' 60:@ 372/ 052749 + 4B 2/0 9@7:9 09:; 4@0 ! <09@79>C0B4602/0097467D7;A@>0:9@& :9D7:60EA:1/0@:>:7912:55A10@4124
,* ' ##) &
( (