Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92878 (KAR)
SRI SALEEM MOHINUDDIN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201201/2025 · 2025-09-15
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92878 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92878 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#" $ ""
"
%
& %'() &% (( )*
"
%
& %'() &% ((
"
%
& %'() &% ((
)
*
! " ! # $
%! %
#
! !!! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
& %
'
&&()
%*)
! "+
! ,
! # &$
! & ! "
$ & "%$ ! %
! -
&.&&
(&&
% ! % #
+
! /)"&$))))/"&$)) ))/")$ )"$
&&)
! ! !! ! )
*
! " ! # $
- 3 -
%! %
#
! !!! &
( )/)
% %
0
! "+
! ,
! # &$
! & ! "
$ & "%$ ! %
! -
.&&
(&&
% ! % #
+
! &/.( & ! ! ! !! ! - 4 -
)
*
! " ! # $
%! %
#
! !!! & # & ! &&))
! "+
! ,
! # &$
! & !"
$ & ! %
! -
.&& (&& % ! %
#
+
! & / . (
& ! ! ! - 5 -
!! ! ! %
1+
""
"! 1+$
23 435656*738 67 86967:; !35656*7 *&&&& <367=:>>?@3A*/678693*(&&*B:6>2?8%3@5 !*;6>3 5:56*7 437A67= *7 523 B6;3 *B 523 ;3:873A # AA656*7:; + :6>2?8 83=6@5383A B*8 523 *BB37>3@ 4?76@2:<;3 ?7A383>56*7@ / )"&$ )) ))/"&$ )) ))/")$)"$*B5232:8:56C:C:C::7265:&&)DB*8 @2*85 E523 &&)FG 6@ @33H67= 5* I?:@2 523 >86967:; 48*>33A67=@67656:53A:=:67@5269
23 435656*738 67 86967:; !35656*7 *&&&& <367=:>>?@3A*)678693*(&&*B:6>2?8%3@5 !*;6>3 5:56*7 437A67= *7 523 B6;3 *B 523 ;3:873A # AA656*7:; + :6>2?8 83=6@5383A B*8 523 *BB37>3@
- 6 -
4?76@2:<;3?7A383>56*7@&/.(& *B 523 7A6:7 !37:; *A3 / DB*8 @2*85 E523 !FG 6@ @33H67=5*I?:@2523>86967:;48*>33A67=@67656:53A:=:67@5 269
23 435656*738 67 86967:; !35656*7 *&&/&& <367=:>>?@3A*)678693*(&&*B:6>2?8%3@5 !*;6>3 5:56*7 437A67= *7 523 B6;3 *B 523 ;3:873A # AA656*7:; + :6>2?8 83=6@5383A B*8 523 *BB37>3@ 4?76@2:<;3?7A383>56*7@&/.(& *B 523 !
6@ @33H67= 5* I?:@2 523 >86967:; 48*>33A67=@ 67656:53A:=:67@5269
&
3:8A 86 9335 ?9:8
3@24:7A3 ;3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 :443:867= B*8 86 :73@2 :;<?8=6 ;3:873A >*?7@3; B*8 523 435656*738 :7A 86 +:9:A:8 2:2:<?AA67;3:873A 6=2*?85*J3879375!;3:A38B*8 83@4*7A375 * 0 5:53 86 :2:753@2 !:56; ;3:873A >*?7@3; B*8 83@4*7A375 *& !38?@3A 523 9:5386:;@ *7 83>*8A@
- 7 -
) 3:873A376*8AJ*>:53B*8523435656*73867:;;
523 52833 >:@3@ >*7537A3A 52:5 523 435656*738 67 :;; 523 52833>:@3@6@523?<3=6@58:867523 BB6>3*B523?< 3=6@58:8 :6>2?8 2833 A6BB38375 >86967:; >:@3@ K383 83=6@5383A :=:67@5 J:86*?@ :>>?@3A 67>;?A67= 523 435656*738 9:H67= <:;A :7A =3738:; :;;3=:56*7@ *B >*7@468:>C :7A 83=6@53867= 523 A*>?9375 438965567= 69438@*7:56*7*7523<:@6@*BB:H3A*>?9375@
3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 2:@ 83B3883A 5* 523 A3>6@6*7 *B 523 **8A67:53 <37>2 *B 526@ *?85 67 ! "#$!%$&& &'
$ ( )$ 5* >*7537A 52:5 83;C67= *7 523 A3>6@6*7 *B 523
6J6@6*7 37>2 *B 526@ *?85 >86967:;
48*>33A67=@ 67 523 @:93 >:93 5* <3 I?:@23A <C 2*;A67= 52:5 67J63K*B 523 48*J6@6*7@ *B7A6:73=6@58:56*7 >5 523 ?<3=6@58:8 6@ 7*5 :?52*86L3A 5* =* 675* 523 =37?67373@@ *8 *5238K6@3 *B 523 A*>?9375@ 483@3753A
- 8 -
<3B*83269:7A6B523A*>?9375@:83<*=?@:7AB:;@3523 4:85C:BB3>53A<C65K6;;2:J352386=255*67656:53<*52>6J6;
:7A >86967:; 48*>33A67=@ 5* 48*@3>?53 523 4:85C K2* >*996553A 523 *BB37>3 ?5 523 ?<3=6@58:8 >:77*5 3M483@@26@*4676*7:<*?5523=37?67373@@*8*5238K6@3*B 523A*>?9375@?7;3@@>:;;3A?4*7<C523*?85*B;:K
3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 2:@ :;@* 83B3883A 5* 523 A3>6@6*7 *B 523 **8A67:53 <37>2 *B 526@ *?85 67 * $+ ! ,-$.'
&'& 5* >*7537A52:5523>86967:;48*>33A67=@67656:53A:=:67@5523 435656*738 5238367 K:@ :;@* I?:@23A <C 523 *?85 <C *<@38J67= 52:5 523 ?<3=6@58:8 6@ 7*5 83I?683A 5* 67J3@56=:53 675* 523 565;3 *B 523 4:8563@ 3M3>?567= 523 A*>?9375@7*8656@*4375*2695*83B?@383=6@58:56*7*B A*>?9375 ?7;3@@ 523 483@375:56*7 52383*B 6@ *<N3>53A 5* *7523=8*?7A93756*73A?7A38?;3.)*B523:87:5:H: 3=6@58:56*7?;3@(/
- 9 -
/ 3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 2:@ 83B3883A 5* 523 A3>6@6*7*B523 *7F<;343M*?8567/0 . , + $# ) K238367 523 N?A=9375 4:@@3A <C 523
6J6@6*7 37>2 *B 523 6=2 *?85 *B :A8:@ K:@ >2:;;37=3A<3B*8352343M*?85K238367?;3*B523 3=6@58:56*7 ?;3@ ?7A38 523 3=6@58:56*7 >5 ( K:@ A3>;:83A:@ 2343M*?852:@23;A52:5523 83=6@53867= *BB6>38 6@ 7*5 >*7>3873A K652 523 565;3 23;A <C 5233M3>?5:75:7A232:@7*:AN?A6>:5*8C4*K385*A3>6A3 K2352385233M3>?5:752:@:7C565;3
. !;:>67= 83;6:7>3 ?4*7 523@3 A3>6@6*7@ 523 ;3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 >*7537A3A 52:5 K237 <:;A :7A =3738:; :;;3=:56*7@ :83 9:A3 :=:67@5 :;; 523 :>>?@3A 67 =3738:;523435656*738<367=523?<3=6@58:8>:77*5<3 23;A 83@4*7@6<;3 5* B:>3 >86967:; 48*>33A67=@ 3:873A 376*8AJ*>:53:;@*4;:>3@83;6:7>3*7523>68>?;:8A:53A ).(((6@@?3A<C523 BB6>3*B5237@43>5*83738:; *B 3=6@58:56*7 :7A *996@@6*738 *B 5:94@ 523
!"#!
- 10 - *J3879375 *B :87:5:H: 5* >*7537A 52:5 523 3=6@58:56*7 >5 @586H3@ *7;C :5 523 A*>?9375 :7A 7*5 :5 523 58:7@:>56*7 23 ?<3=6@58:8 K6;; 7*5 2:J3 :7C N?86@A6>56*7 5* 37I?683 675* 523 83>65:;@ 67 523 A*>?9375@ 483@3753A B*8 83=6@58:56*7 6@ A?5C 6@ ;69653A 5* @:56@BC 269@3;B:<*?55233M3>?5:75*B523A*>?9375C4;:>67= 83;6:7>3 *7 526@ >68>?;:8 ;3:873A 376*8 AJ*>:53 :;@* >*7537A3A52:5523?<3=6@58:82:@:J38C;69653A8*;3 5* 4;:C 67 83=6@58:56*7 *B 523 A*>?9375@ B : K6573@@ 6A3756B63@ 523 3M3>?5:75 *B 523 A*>?9375 :7A 6B 65 5?87@ *?5 5* <3 : B:;@3 6A3756B6>:56*7 523 ?<3=6@58:8 >:77*5 <3 9:A3 ;6:<;3 7A38 523@3 >68>?9@5:7>3@ ;3:873A 376*8AJ*>:53>*7537A3A52:5523>86967:;48*>33A67=@ 67656:53A:=:67@5523435656*738:83;6:<;35*<3I?:@23A ;3:873A>*?7@3;B*883@4*7A375*& :7A ;3:873A 6=2 *?85 *J3879375 !;3:A38 B*8 83@4*7A375 * *44*@67= 523 435656*7@ @?<96553A 52:5 @43>6B6> :7A @386*?@ :;;3=:56*7@ :83 9:A3 :=:67@5 :;; 523 :>>?@3A67=3738:;:7A:=:67@5523435656*738674:856>?;:8 - 11 - B*8 2:J67= >*996553A 523 *BB37>3@ 4?76@2:<;3 ?7A38 3>56*7@/)"&$))))/"&$))))/")$)"$*B &&) 5 6@ @43>6B6>:;;C @5:53A 52:5 :;; 523 :>>?@3A 67>;?A67= 523 ?<3=6@58:8 >*;;?A67= K652 *73 :7*5238 4;:>3A83;6:7>3*7523B:H348*4385C6A3756B6>:56*7B:H3 :52: B:H3 <?6;A67= ;6>37>3 35> %237 @?>2 @43>6B6> :;;3=:56*7@ :83 9:A3 <C 523 67B*89:75 :=:67@5 523 435656*738 :7A *5238 :>>?@3A 65 6@ 4839:5?83 5* B*89 :7 *4676*7 52:5 523 435656*738 2:@ 7*5 4;:C3A :7C 8*;3 67 >*9965567= 69438@*7:56*7 *7 523 <:@6@ *B 523 B:H3 :7A B:<86>:53A A*>?9375@ 5 6@ *7;C :B538 523 B?;;B;3A=3A 586:; 65 >*?;A <3 B*?7A *?5 :<*?5 523 8*;3 4;:C3A <C 523 435656*738 >>*8A67=;C 523C 48:C B*8 A6@96@@:; *B 523 435656*7@ ( 23 A3>6@6*7 83;63A *7 <C 523 ;3:873A 376*8 >*?7@3; B*8 523 435656*738 26=2;6=25@ 52:5 523 435656*738 <367= 523 ?<3=6@58:8 6@ 7*5 A?5C <*?7A 5* J386BC 523 =37?67373@@*B 523 A*>?9375@4;:>3A<3B*83 269 B 523 K6573@@ 2:@ 6A3756B63A 5233M3>?5:75*B 523A*>?9375 23 - 12 - >:748*>33A5*83=6@538523A*>?9375?567523483@375 >:@352383:83@43>6B6>:;;3=:56*7@52:5:839:A3:=:67@5 :;; 523 :>>?@3A 67>;?A67= 523 435656*738 67 :;; 523 52833 435656*7@:H3<?6;A67=;6>37>3B:H3:A2:8:8AB:H3 H:52: 35> K383 @:6A 5* 2:J3 <337 ?@3A :@ 438@*7:; >:8A@:7A52383K:@69438@*7:56*7B*883=6@58:56*7*B523 @:;3 A33A@ 5 6@ @5:53A 52:5 52383 K:@ >*7@468:>C <35K337 :;; 523 :>>?@3A 67>;?A67= 523 435656*738 67 >*7>*>567=523A*>?9375@:7A<:@3A*7@?>2A*>?9375@ @:;3A33A@K3833M3>?53A<C@3;;67=52348*438563@%237 @?>2@386*?@:;;3=:56*7@:839:A3656@4839:5?835*B*89 :7*4676*752:5523435656*7382:@7*54;:C3A:7C8*;3*8 67*5238K*8A@23K:@7*54:85C5*523>*7@468:>C:7A2:@ 7*5 >*7>*>53A :7C A*>?9375@ 23 8*;3 4;:C3A <C 523 435656*7386@5*<3B*?7A*?5*7;C:B538B?;;B;3A=3A586:;5 6@7*5523@5:=3B*82*;A67=:967637I?68C*89676586:;5* B67A *?5 523 58?52 *8 *5238K6@3 67 523 :;;3=:56*7@ 9:A3 :=:67@5523435656*73823435656*7386@:4?<;6>@38J:75 :7A 6B 65 6@ :;;3=3A 52:5 23 2:@ >*7@4683A K652 523 *5238 - 13 - :>>?@3A 67 83=6@53867= 523 A*>?9375@ <:@3A *7 523 B:H3 :7A B:<86>:53A A*>?9375@ 23 6@ 83I?683A 5* @:56@BC 523 86:; *?85 :<*?5 523 ;3=:;65C *B 26@ :>56*7@ B 523 >*753756*75:H37<C523;3:873A376*8AJ*>:536@5*<3 :>>3453A67523;6=25*B523@43>6B6>:;;3=:56*7@9:A365K6;; ;:CA*K7:<:A483>3A3755*2*;A52:5523?<3=6@58:86@ 7*5A?5C<*?7A5*J386BC523:?523756>65C*B523 >:8A@ 6A37565C *B 523 3M3>?5:75@ :7A =37?67373@@ *B 523 A*>?9375@48*A?>3A<3B*83269:7A23K6;;2:J3>*94;353 699?765C:=:67@548*@3>?56*7 7J63K*B523@43>6B6>:;;3=:56*7@9:A3<C523 67B*89:7567:;;52352833>:@3@:9*B523*4676*752:5 523 435656*738 6@ 7*5 37565;3A B*8 :7C 83;63B 67
523@3 435656*7@ >>*8A67=;C :7@K38 523 :<*J3 4*675 67 523 73=:56J3:7A48*>33A5*4:@@523B*;;*K67= 23>86967:;435656*7@:83#1# - 14 - 7 J63K *B A6@96@@:; *B 523 9:67 435656*7@ 437A67= :44;6>:56*7@6B:7C:;@*@5:7AA6@96@@3A +) %""( $ % 6@5*;* !