- 1 - !!"!#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($) * ! "#$"%% ! #&&'() * ! ! ' ! !! )( +! !! #&&" ! !! + !! + #&$(((' * !! +, ( '' ( '!++ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! + + '")' + ! ! + ! ($ ($ ('- ! + $-('$ ! + ! ! ! .! &! /012/ 3/4 566457 89 78934: ;0< 5:=89980> ?83/ 3/4 @0>94>3 0; 745<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 65<3849 83 89 35A4> 16 ;0<;8>57:8960957 /89 566457 89 ;874: 5258>93 3/4 B1:2=4>3 5>: 5?5<::534:($ ($ ('-65994:CD3/44>80<8E871:24 +5>:4?5<288> 0 $-0;('$ ) /4@758=5>3=43?83/5>5@@8:4>30>'& (& ('& 5>:919358>4:2<84E0198>B1<849 /4<4;0<4/4;874:5@758= 6438380> C4;0<4 3/4 <8C1>57 @758=8>2 @0=64>95380> 0; 9 '%(((((# % /4<8C1>57@0>98:4<8>23/44>38<44E8:4>@40> <4@0<: 2<5>34: @0=64>95380> 0; 9 '%$(((# ?83/ - 3 - 8>34<49353$F6 5 ;<0=3/4:5340;6438380>3877<457895380> 5>: :8<4@34: <4960>:4>3 0 '#:<8E4<#@1=#0?>4< 0; 3/4 0;;4>:8>2E4/8@7430:4609833/495=4 & 22<84E4:CD3/4958:B1:2=4>35>:5?5<:3/4 8>B1<4: @758=5>3 /59 6<4;4<<4: 3/89 566457 8> ?/8@/ 83 89 @0>34>:4: 3/53 /4 /59 919358>4: ;<5@31<4 0; 7534<57 =47783190;74;3;8C1755>:;<5@31<40;3/5>:-3/<82/3<8C9 5>:?59/0968357894:;<0=' (& ((30 (& (( !4 4G5=8>4:3/4:0@30<59 5>:3/4:0@30<5994994:3/4 :895C8783D53'FC133/4<8C1>57/5935A4>83590>7D"F 30 3/4 ?/074 C0:D !4 ?59 5 @00784 5>: 45<>8>2 9 '&(((# 64< =0>3/ C13 3/4 <8C1>57 /59 35A4> 3/4 8>@0=40>7D539 &&((#64<=0>3/ /4<8C1>5789>03 B1938;84: 8> ;8G8>2 3/4 785C8783D 0> 3/40?>4< 0; 3/4 E4/8@74 0> 3/42<01>: 3/53 3/4:<8E4<0;3/4E4/8@74/59 >0 E578: 5>: 4;;4@38E4 :<8E8>2 78@4>@4 G % 6<0:1@4: CD 3/4 <4960>:4>3 83947; 9/0?9 3/53 /4 ?59 /5E8>2 78@4>@4 30 :<8E4 0>#3<5>960<3C133/4<489>04>:0<94=4>330 :<8E43/43<5>960<3E4/8@74 /4E4/8@74?59/5E8>264<=83 - 4 - ;<0=') ( ((30' ( (')C133/45@@8:4>30@@1<<4: 0> '& (& ('& 5>: 3/19 3/4<4 89 64<=83 E8075380> /4D <4H14934:;0<4>/5>@4=4>30;@0=64>95380> $ !45<:3/45<21=4>390;C03/98:49 " /012/ 3/4 5664775>3 93534: 3/53 /4 ?59 45<>8>29 '&(((#64<=0>3//4/59>036<0:1@4:5>D 8>@0=4 6<00; /4<4;0<4 59 3/4 5@@8:4>3 89 0; 3/4 D45< ('& 59 64<3/4218:478>49 0;3/4 5<>535A5 35344257 4<E8@49 13/0<83D /89 >0380>57 8>@0=4 89 30 C4 35A4> 53 9 (((# 64< =0>3/ /4 :0@30< 5994994: 3/4 :895C8783D 53'F303/4?/074C0:DC13/489>0353<4534::0@30< 9 64< G %#?01>: @4<38;8@534 3/4 5664775>3 /59 919358>4:5C<5980>5770E4<3/4C5@A5C<5980>5770E4<3/4 7534<57 5964@3 0; <82/3 742 :446 5C<5980> ?83/ 9A8> 7099 0E4< 3/4 7534<57 5964@3 0; 74;3 5>A74 ;<5@31<4 0; 7534<57 =577407190;74;3;8C1755>:;<5@31<40;I-3/<82/398:4: <8C9 964<G %'#:895C8738D@4<38;8@5343/45664775>3/59 919358>4: ;<5@31<4 0; 7534<57 =57740719 0; 74;3 5>A74 B08>3 ;<5@31<40;3/5>:-3/<8C90><82/398:45>:/4?593<4534: - 5 - @0>94<E538E47D /4<4;0<43/8901<3;8>:983<4590>5C7430 35A4 3/4 :895C8783D 53 '(F 8>9345: 0; "F 35A4> CD 3/4 <8C1>57 /4 =17386784< 0;J'K5:0634: CD3/4 3<8C1>5789 B193 5>: 6<064< /19 3/4 7099 0; ;131<4 45<>8>29 @0=49 30 9 (((G'G'G'(FL9 '"((# /4<8C1>575?5<:4:5>5=01>30;9 '(((# 30?5<:9=4:8@574G64>9495>:83>44:9>08>34<;4<4>@4 - /4 5664775>3 ?59 5:=8334: 8> 3/4 /0968357 ;0< (& :5D9 0>98:4<8>23/4>531<4 0;8>B1<8495>:64<80:0; /0968357895380> 3/89 01<3 ;8>:9 83 <4590>5C74 30 2<5>3 5> 5=01>30;9 &((((#;0<658>5>:91;;4<8>29 &(((# ;0< 7099 0; 5=4>83849 5>: 9 )((((# ;0< 3<5>960<35380> 4G3<5>01<89/=4>35>:5334>:5>3@/5<249 '( /4 5664775>3 =82/3 >03 /5E4 5334>:4: 5>D ?0<A 53 74593 ;0< 5 64<80: 0; ;01< =0>3/9 :14 30 3/4 8>B1<849919358>4: /4<4;0<43/8901<3;8>:983<4590>5C74 - 6 - 302<5>35>5=01>30;9 )(((#9 (((G%;0<7099 0;8>@0=4:1<8>2758:1664<80: '' !4>@43/45664775>3894>38374:;0<3/4=0:8;84: @0=64>95380>1>:4<:8;;4<4>3/45:959C470? 58>5>:91;;4<8>2 9 &((((# 4:8@574G64>949 9 '(((# 0990;;131<445<>8>29 9 '"((# 0990;8>@0=4:1<8>2758:1664<80: 9 )(((# <5>960<35380> 4G3<5 >01<89/=4>3 5>:5334>:5>3@/5<249 9 )((((# 0990;5=4>83849 9 &(((# +,- . / /193/45664775>3894>38374:;0<30357@0=64>95380> 0;9 )"((#?83/8>34<49353$F64<5>>1= ' 9 3/4<4 ?59 >0 :<8E8>2 78@4>@4 5>: 64<=83 E8075380> 3/4 785C8783D ?59 ;5934>4: 0> <4960>:4>3 0 '# 0?>4< 5>: 3/4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D ?59 4G0>4<534: ;<0= 65D8>23/4785C8783D ') 45<>4: @01>947 ;0< <4960>:4>3 0 M >91<5>@40=65>D 91C=8334: 3/53 3/4<4 ?59 >0 :<8E8>2 78@4>@4 5>: 5790 3/4<4 ?59 >0 64<=83 53 3/4 38=4 0; - 7 - 5@@8:4>3 991@/835=01>3930E8075380>0;3/4@0>:8380>9 0;3/46078@D5>:3/193/4>91<5>@40=65>D89>03785C74 3065D3/4@0=64>95380> '% 983895@5940;>0:<8E8>278@4>@45>:64<=83 E8075380> 3/89 01<3 ;8>:9 83 <4590>5C74 30 <47D 160> 3/4 B1:2=4>39 0; 3/4 !0>KC74 64G 01<3 8> 5>:5790 E9 ! 25>:0<:4<;0<65D5>: <4@0E4<D 30 3/4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D /4<4;0<4 <4960>:4>3 0 # >91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 :8<4@34: 30 :460983 3/4 30357 @0=64>95380> 0; 9 )"((# ?83/ 8>34<49353$F6 5 ?83/78C4<3D30<4@0E4<3/495=4;<0= <4960>:4>3 0 '#0?>4<0;3/4E4/8@74 '& >3/4<491733/4;0770?8>20<:4<8965994: 8 66457895770?4:8>65<3 1 (2018) 3 SCC 208 2 ('"&& - 8 - 88 /4 5664775>3@758=5>3 89 4>38374: ;0< 3/4 30357 @0=64>95380> 0; 9 )"((# ?83/ 8>34<493 53 $F 64< 5>>1=;<0=3/4:5340;6438380>38773/4:5340;<457895380> !0?4E4<5964<0<:4<:534:'( ( (&3/45664775>389 >03 4>38374: ;0< 8>34<493 ;0< 3/4 :475D4: 64<80: 0; ( 8> ;878>23/4566457 888 4960>:4>3 0 #>91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 :8<4@34: 30 :460983 3/4 5;0<4958: @0=64>95380> 5=01>3 ?83/8> 0>4 =0>3/ ;<0= 3/4 :534 0; 3/89 B1:2=4>3 !0?4E4< 3/4>91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 53 78C4<3D 30 <4@0E4< 3/495=4;<0=<4960>:4>3 0 'M0?>4< 8E > 91@/ :460983 3/4 5664775>3 89 64<=8334: 30 ?83/:<5? 3/4 4>38<4 5=01>3 570>2 ?83/ 8>34<493 5@@<14: 0>83 .0/ ('""!) &! 893 0 '7 0 )(