- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( !"# !"# $ % & ' !"#! ( ' "### $ % ') "#(# & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' *(%& ' ' ###( ' +## ' ' , # -./0 12- ./345-617 89 :-./6-0 ;8467-: 98/ <812 12- =./1>-7 2>7 .==-.: >7 =/-9-//-0 .3.>671 12- .?./0 89 12- /><46.:>68+##0.1-0###(=.77-0<@12- 84/1 89 00>1>86.: -6>8/ >A>: 403- .60 >B.@.=4/. ( 2- 9.;17 89 12- ;.7- ./- 12.1 86 #"## .1 ./8460 (# =5 ?2-6 12- =-1>1>86-/ ?.7 >6 12- ;.5=47 89 8A-/65-61 .66.0. ;288: >6 .5.6C-/> >::.3- 89 >B.@.=4/. 12- />0-/ 89 12- 5818/;@;:- <-./>63 -3>71/.1>86 8 ! !#;.5->6.2>327=--0/>0>63>6./.72.60 - 3 - 6-3:>3-61 5.66-/ .60 0.72-0 18 12- .==-::.61 7 . /-74:1 .==-::.617471.>6-09/.;14/-7.6072>91-018.6B--A>6>87=>1.: >B.@.=4/.98/1/-.15-61 >68/<8@.3-0#@-./75-1?>12.6.;;>0-6186 #"##.60.;:.>5=-1>1>86>79>:-0<@2>79.12-/;:.>5>63 ;85=-67.1>86 89 7###### ?>12 >61-/-71 2- /><46.: ;867>0-/>63 -61>/- -A>0-6;- 86 /-;8/0 3/.61-0 7"#( =-/ 58612 ?>12 >61-/-71 .1 12- /.1- 89 "D 9/85 12- 0.1- 89 =-1>1>861>::/-.:>E.1>86 33/>-A-0<@12-7.>08/0-/12>7.==-.:>7=/-9-//-0 >6 ?2>;2 >1 >7 ;861-61-0 12.1 12- .==-::.61 7471.>6-0 7?-::>63 .60;/-=>147.15>00:-.7=-;189/>321:-3)=46;14/-?84608A-/ (/0 89 5>00:- .7=-;1 89 />321 :-3) ;/472 ?8460 8A-/ />321 .6C:- /-3>86 .</.7>86 8A-/ />321 .6C:- /-3>86 .60 812-/ >6B4/>-72843212-08;18/8=>6-0812-/>6B4/>-7./-3/>-A847 >6 6.14/- 12- /><46.: 3/.61-0 5-.3-/ .58461 460-/ 12- 2-.0 .>6.60499-/>63--F.5>6-0G 8;18/.602- .77-77-0 12- 0>7.<>:>1@ .7 !D /-3./0>63 />321 :8?-/ :>5< <41 12-/><46.:2.71.C-686:@(D1812-?28:-<80@0>7.<>:>1@.60 3/.61-07##### 284322-7=-617#####18?./07 - 4 - 5-0>;.: -F=-67-7 12- /><46.: 3/.61-0 7##( 2- /><46.:2.7681.?./0-0.6@.5846118?./07:87789>6;85- 04/>63 12- =-/>80 89 1/-.15-61 .60 68 .584617 ?-/- 3/.61-0 98/ :877 89 ;4:14/.: .;1>A>1>-7 5.//>.3- =/87=-;17 :877 89 -04;.1>86.609414/-5-0>;.:-F=-67-7.6012->61-/-71>718<- -62.6;-0 18 +D >671-.0 89 "D .60 1247 /-H4-71-0 98/ 580>9>;.1>868912-8/0-/ " F >7 12- 0>7.<>:>1@ ;-/1>9>;.1- .77-77-0 <@ 12- 8;18/>6?2>;2>1?.771.1-012.112-=-1>1>86-/?.77499-/>63 9/85 0>7 1><>. .60 9><4:. 0>7=:.;-0 9/.;14/- 7.5- 2.0 <--6 1/-.1-0 ?>12 ;:87-0 /-04;1>86 >61-/6.: 9>F.1>86 ?>12 1>1.6>45 -:.71>; 6.>:>63 .77-77-0 12- 181.: =-/5.6-61 0>7.<>:>1@ /-3./0>63/>321:8?-/:>5<.1!D612-I /.@-6;:87-018>1>1 ?.7 71.1-0 12.1 12-/- >7 . 5.:46>1-0 9/.;14/- 681-0 .1 5>0 72.91 89 9><4:. 2-/-98/- 12>7 84/1 9>607 12.1 >1 >7 B471 .60 /-.786.<:- 18 1.C- 12- 0>7.<>:>1@ 89 12- 5>68/ ;2>:0 .7 #D >671-.0 89 (D .7 =-/ 12- ;>1.1>86 /-=8/1-0 >6 %#& (+" <-1?--6 '>607 >1 /-.786.<:- 18 3/.61 .6 .58461 89 7(##### 98/ 12- - 5 - >6B4/>-77471.>6-0>612-.;;>0-612-=-1>1>86-/?.7.3-0# @-./7 .60 2- 5-1 ?>12 .6 .;;>0-61 >6 12- @-./ # .60 2>7 9.12-/ ?.7 ?8/C>63 .7 .6 .3/>;4:14/>71 2-/-98/- 12>7 84/1 9>607>1/-.786.<:-181.C-2>7>6;85-.77### =-/58612 18?./07:87789>6;85-18=./-617 * 2- =./-617 5>321 2.A- 1.C-6 ;./- 89 12- ;2>:0 .1:-.71 98/ . =-/>80 89 12/-- 586127 .7 2- 7471.>6-0 9/.;14/- >6B4/>-7 12-/-98/- 12>7 84/1 9>607 >1 /-.786.<:- 18 3/.61 .6 .58461897### %###F(&98/:87789>6;85-1812- =./-6178912-5>68/=-1>1>86-/?285-1?>12.6.;;>0-61 ! 6 .:: 12- 181.: ;85=-67.1>86 ;85-7 18 7"#( ?>12>61-/-71.1"D=-/.66459/8512-0.1-89 =-1>1>861>::/-.:>E.1>86 + 2-.?./089;85=-67.1>86=.77-0<@12-/><46.: >7580>9>-0.7460-/ )*+, -./01/, 87789>6;85-18=./-617 ### 87789>6;85-04-18=-/5.6-61 =2@7>;.: 0>7.<>:>1@ .60 :877 89 .5-6>1>-7 (### (-0>;.:.60>6;>0-61.:-F=-67-7 ##( 0*2 34 - 6 - ;;8/0>63:@ 12- ;:.>5.61 >7 -61>1:-0 98/ . 181.: ;85=-67.1>86 89 7"#( >- 98/ .6 -62.6;-0 ;85=-67.1>86897(#### # 612-/-74:112-98::8?>638/0-/>7=.77-0 >& 2-.==-.:>7! >>& 2- /-7=860-61 8 674/.6;- 85=.6@ .:/-.0@0-=87>1-012-.58461.?./0-0<@12- /><46.: 2-6;- /-7=860-61 8 >7 0>/-;1-0 18 0-=87>1 7(#### -62.6;-0 ;85=-67.1>86?>12 >61-/-71.112-/.1-89"D ?>12>686-586129/8512-0.1-8912>78/0-/ >>>& 6 74;2 0-=87>1 12- 9.12-/ 89 12- >6B4/-0.==-::.61 ./- =-/5>11-0 18 ?>120/.? 12--61>/-.58461.:863?>12>61-/-71.;;/4-0 86>1 ,+4 %$ ' # >718:8++