- 1 - !! "#$% &$ ! #% & !" # $ % & $ % ' (&& ! ! ) ! ) & # $ & )% Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & )* "! &$% ") "" & $ % !!+!" & & !" & ( , , $ ( , , % -./ 012./.34 516.6.34 74810 196.34/ )* 01:8 ;.6- "! 0./<.=18;.6-:50:>1063/16:/.816-1308103<1?6104@146 8:618 !!+!" A1:0.4B 3 ?6104 !" 5://18A>01/534814643 -101.41?6104.4B6-1516.6.3410<30: 510.38 3< 341 >1:0 <03@ !!+!" 63 !+! <03@ :=:A70:B../60.9663:@:4:B:0:./60.96 1:086-1=1:0418374/1=<306-15:06.1/ ) 16.6.3410 ;:/ /10218 ;.6- : /-3; 9:7/1 436.91 8:618 !!"!"A>01/534814643 -101.450353/.4B:96.3474810 196.34 3< 6-1 :04:6:C: 3=.91 96 +) $<30 /-306 D6-1 96E%40191.563<6-1/:@1 516.6.3410-:8/7A@.6618:015=> - 3 - 34 !!+!"-101:<610 :4.4F7.0>;:/-1=8A>01/5348146 43 :48 6-1 30810 .@57B418 ;:/ 5://18 34 !!+!" 1?6104.4B 6-1 516.6.3410 <30 : 510.38 3< 341 >1:0 <03@ !!+!" 1.4B :BB0.1218 A> 6-1 /:@1 6-./ 90.@.4:= 012./.34516.6.34./<.=18 " 1:0418374/1=<306-1516.6.3410/7A@.6/6-:66-1/-3; 9:7/1436.91.//718636-1516.6.34108.84369346:.44191//:0> @:610.:=430;:/6-1/:@1:993@5:4.18;.6-6-10153063<6-1 4/519630 3< 3=.91 0:@-:570 3=.91 6:6.34 :=:A70:B ./60.96 A:/1834;-.9- 5039118.4B/74810196.343<6-1 96;:/.4.6.:618:B:.4/66-1516.6.34101 6-101<301 /7A@.6/ 6-:66-101./2.3=:6.343<50.49.5=1/3<4:670:=G7/6.911<706-10 /7A@.6/6-:6516.6.3410-:/436A1149342.9618.4:4>9:/16.== 8:61 :48 6-1 :5501-14/.34 1?501//18 <30 .4.6.:6.34 3< 5039118.4B/ 74810 196.34 3< 6-1 96 ./ A:/1=1// 99308.4B=> -150:>/63:==3;6-1516.6.34 10 93460: =1:0418 -:/ :0B718 .4 /755306 3< 6-1 .@57B418 30810 :48 /7A@.6/ 6-:6 6-1 516.6.3410 ./ <:9.4B <.21 90.@.4:=9:/1/01B./61018<306-13<<1491/574./-:A=1748106-1 5032./.34/3<96 :48.4:88.6.34636-1/:@1 -1-:/6;3 - 4 - 36-10 90.@.4:= 9:/1/ 01B./61018 <30 6-1 3<<1491/ 574./-:A=1 748106-199308.4B=> /-150:>/638./@.//6-1516.6.34 + 196.34 3< 6-1 96 5032.81/ <30 01@32:= 3< 510/34/ :A3766393@@.63<<1491/:48196.343<6-1965032.81/<30 -1:0.4B 63A1B.214 A1<301:4 30810 ./ 5://18 74810 196.34/ " 30+3<6-196 * 196.343<6-19601:8/:/74810 H' ()*+,- . /( -+0(, /(*( ), *1(* +2 3)22(1 4,1(* 2(5.+, * 67 $ % 1<301 :4 3081074810/196.34" 30+./5://18:B:.4/6:4> 510/34 6-13<<.910:96.4B74810:4>3<6-1/:.8/196.34/ 30:4>3<<.910:A3216-10:4C3<:44/519630:76-30./18 A>6-:63<<.910/-:==.4<30@6-1510/34.4;0.6.4B3<6-1 B1410:= 4:6701 3< 6-1 @:610.:= :==1B:6.34/ :B:.4/6 -.@ :48B.21 -.@:01:/34:A=135530674.6>3<614810.4B:4 1?5=:4:6.34 01B:08.4B 6-1@ < /79- 510/34 @:C1/ :4 :55=.9:6.34 <30 6-1 1?:@.4:6.34 3< :4> ;.641// 50387918 A> -.@ 6-1 :76-30.6> 30 3<<.910 934910418 /-:==B0:46/79-:55=.9:6.34:481?:@.41/79-;.641// 74=1// <30 01:/34/ 63 A1 01930818 .4 ;0.6.4B 6-1 :76-30.6>303<<.910./3<35.4.346-:6/79-:55=.9:6.34./ @:81<306-157053/13<21?:6.343081=:>4>;0.6614 /6:61@146576.4A>/79-510/34/-:==A1<.=18;.6-6-1 019308 3< 6-1 9:/1 79- 510/34 /-:== A1 146.6=18 63 :551:0A1<3016-13<<.9105039118.4B748106-.//196.34 A>:=1B:=50:96.6.3410<306-157053/1/3<614810.4B-./ - 5 - 1?5=:4:6.34 :48 1?:@.4.4B 6-1 ;.641//1/ 50387918 A> -.@ $%-1:76-30.6>303<<.9105039118.4B74810/7A /196.34 $ % @:> <30 6-1 57053/1 3< /1970.4B 6-1 :66148:491 3< :4> 510/34 :B:.4/6 ;-3@ :4> 30810 ./ 50353/1863A1@:8174810/196.34" 30+01F7.01 /79- 510/34 63 :551:0 A1<301 -.@ :48 63 <704./- : /1970.6> A348 ;.6- 30 ;.6-376 /7016.1/ <30 /79- :66148:491 870.4B 6-1 .4F7.0> < 6-1 510/34 <:.=/ 63 <704./-6-1/1970.6>A348:/01F7.01830<:.=/63:551:0 A1<3016-13<<.91030:76-30.6>870.4B6-1.4F7.0> .6/-:== A1=:;<7=636-13<<.91030:76-30.6>635039118;.6-6-1 .4F7.0>:486-1017534/79-30810:/;:/50353/1863A1 5://18:B:.4/6-.@@:>A15://18I 4 6-1 501/146 9:/1 /-3; 9:7/1 436.91 .//718 831/ 436 5032.816-15:06.97=:0/3<6-1:==1B1890.@.4:=9:/1/01B./61018 :B:.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 430 ;:/ 6-1 53=.91 015306 ;-.9- -:8 01/7=618.4.//7.4B6-1/-3;9:7/1436.9193461@5=:6.4B:96.34 74810196.343<6-196<30;:0818636-1516.6.3410 /3:/ 6314:A=1-.@63B.21:/7.6:A=1015=>636-1/-3;9:7/1436.91 01:8.4B3<196.343<6-196@:C1/.69=1:06-:66-1 :76-30.J18 3<<.910 /-:== .4<30@ 6-1 510/34 :/ :B:.4/6 ;-3@ :96.34 ./ 50353/1874810 196.34/ " 30 + 3< 6-1 96 .4 ;0.6.4B3<6-1B1410:=4:67013<6-1@:610.:=:==1B:6.34/:B:.4/6 - 6 - -.@ :48 B.21 -.@ : 01:/34:A=1 35530674.6> 3< 614810.4B :4 1?5=:4:6.3401B:08.4B6-1@ ! 46-1501/1469:/1 6-1/:.801F7.01@1463<=:;:551:0/ 63 -:21 436 A114 93@5=.18 :/ 6-1 436.91 =:9C/ 4191//:0> 5:06.97=:0/ :A376 6-1 :==1B:6.34/ @:81 :B:.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 430 ;:/ 6-1 015306 A:/18 34 ;-.9- 6-1 /-3; 9:7/1 436.91 50353/.4B:96.34:B:.4/66-1516.6.341074810196.343<6-1 96;:/149=3/18-1308105://1874810196.343<6-196 -:/:41<<1963<9706:.=.4B6-10.B-6B7:0:46118636-1.48.2.87:= 7481006.9=1 3<6-134/6.676.343<48.: :486-:6A1.4B/3 ;.6-376 <3==3;.4B 6-1 A:/.9 50.49.5=1/ 3< 4:670:= G7/6.91 :4 3081074810196.343<6-1969:4436A15://18 4 6-1 9:/1 34 -:48 .6 :551:0/ 6-:6 6-1 516.6.3410 ;:/ 436B.21450351035530674.6>6381<148-./9:/1-1@:610.:= :==1B:6.34/@:81:B:.4/6-.@./43601<=19618.46-1/-3;9:7/1 436.91.//71863-.@430;:/6-1935>3<6-10153063<6-153=.91 A:/1834;-.9-:96.34:/5032.81874810196.343<6-196 ;:/ 93461@5=:618 ;:/ <30;:0818 63 6-1 516.6.3410 :48 6-101<301 .6 9:4436 A1 /:.8 6-:6 6-1 516.6.3410 ;:/ B0:4618 - 7 - 503510 35530674.6> 63 614810 -./ 1?5=:4:6.34 01B:08.4B 6-1 :==1B:6.34/@:81:B:.4/6-.@ -1 @:610.:= 34 019308 ;37=8 :=/3 B3 63 /-3; 6-:6 6-1 516.6.3410 -:/ 436 A114 9342.9618 .4 :4> 9:/1 6.== 8:61 :48 01/5348146 43 -:/ 436 01930818 : <.48.4B 6-:6 :96.34 74810 196.343<6-196./74:23.8:A=1 :48.46-1:A/14913</79- : <.48.4B 6-1 30810 .@57B418 937=8 436 -:21 A114 5://18 99308.4B=>6-1<3==3;.4B30810 ) -1 012./.34 516.6.34 ./ :==3;18 -1 30810 A1:0.4B 3 ?6104 !" 8:618 !!+!" 5://18 A> 01/5348146 43 1?6104.4B 6-1 516.6.3410 <30 : 510.38 3< 341 >1:0<03@!!+!"63 !+!<03@:=:A70:B../60.9663 :@:4:B:0:./60.96 ./-101A>/16:/.81 18 9% &$ !: $