- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! "# $ ! % &! " "' $( $ )((( " * (($ ( $ $ !"$" $ ! % &! "(+ ", ) ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( &' ( " ( ) ! ( ) ! " $ ! " * ( ( ( ) " -! # & -! ' ./0123./0456.7289:;./07.1<9578.;:90=92323. >/02?.8 3?8 />>./; ?8 :?;.1 /4/?782 23. @5146.72 /71 /A/019:23.0?=57/;?7"9*1/2.1 >/88.1=B23. 11?2?97/;.7?90?C?;514.$/;/=50/4? 3.:/<289:23.</8./0.23/297*/2 /=952 23. />>.;;/72 A/8 49?74 7./0 !96=/B :57<2?973/;;$/;/=50/4??73?869290<B<;.223/22?6./ 69290<B<;. =./0?74 0.4?820/2?97 9$)** </6. - 3 - ?73?438>..1/710/83/717.4;?4.726/77.0/711/83.1 29 23. />>.;;/72 15. 29 A3?<3 23. />>.;;/72 8582/?7.1 ?7@50?.8/7183?:2.129$/6/0.11B98>?2/;:9020./26.72 , 7@50.1<;/?6/72A/8/4.1B./08A90D?74/8 / <96>52.0 9>.0/290 . 6.2 A?23 /7 /<<?1.72 97 * /71 :?;.1 / <;/?6 >.2?2?97 <;/?6?74 <96>.78/2?97 9: 8 A?23 ?72.0.82 3. 0?=57/;<978?1.0?74.72?0..C?1.7<.970.<90140/72.1/7 /69572 9: 8 A?23 ?72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: *E :0961/2.9:>.2?2?972?;;23.1/2.9:>/B6.72 440?.C.1 =B 23. 8/?1 901.0 23?8 />>./; ?8 >0.:.00.1?7A3?<3?2?8 <972.72.123/223./>>.;;/72A/8 20./2.1?723.$/6/0.11B98>?2/;:90/>.0?919:1/B8 8 >.0 F 23. 1?8/=?;?2B ?8 /88.88.1 /8 E 29 23. A39;. =91B =52 23. 0?=57/; 3/8 .0097.958;B 2/D.7 23. 8/6. /8 *E /71 6./4.0 /695728 /0. 40/72.1 :90 /22.71/72 <3/04.8 /71 <97C.B/7<. <3/04.8 239543 3. 8582/?7.1 :0/<250.8?7@50?.8 358 0.G5.82.1 :90 .73/7<.6.72 - 4 - * 3. />>.;;/72 3/8 :?;.1 3?8 8/;/0B <.02?:?</2. /2 F ,/7123583?88/;/0BA/82/D.7/88 *>.0 69723 /8 3. A/8 /4.1 B./08 A90D?74 /8 / <96>52.0 9>.0/290 ?7 /7?83 /7 9A.0 4.7<B F ?8 23. />>9?726.72;.22.023.0.:90.23?8<9502:?718790./89729 ?72.0:.0.A?233?88/;/0B 3. />>.;;/72 3/8 .F/6?7.1 ) ) /88.88.13?81?8/=?;?2B/8E2923.A39;.=91B/71/;89 2923.5>>.0;?6=!5223.0?=57/;3/89=8.0C.123/223. 1?8/=?;?2B ?8 /88.88.1 2A?<. /71 2358 792 0.;?.1 5>97 23. .C?1.7<.9: )/71F /71<978?1.0.1*E1?8/=?;?2B 29 23. A39;. =91B >>.;;/72 3/8 8582/?7.1 6/;57?2.1 :0/<250. 9: 6?183/:2 9: 0/1?58 /71 5;7/ /71 23. A9571 <.02?:?</2./711?8<3/04.</01A.0./;890.:.0823/23.3/8 0.820?<2.1 /2 ;.:2 .;=9A /71 0?432 A0?82 /71 0.15<.1 >9A.09:658<;.8/0957123.;.:2.;=9A/71;.:2A0?82/71 23.0. A/8 / :0/<250. A?23 ?6>;/728 ?7 8?25 )?23 23.8. ) /88.88.1 23. 1?8/=?;?2B /8 E 3?8 <9502 :?718 ?2 - 5 - 0./897/=;.292/D.019:23.8/?11?8/=?;?2B?./2E <<901?74;B23.;9889::5250.?7<96.<96.829 *FF*FEH ,* 3. /69572 40/72.1 571.0 23. 3./1 6.1?</; .F>.78.8?88 823.0.?8791?8>52.0.4/01?74 23./69572?27..1879?72.0:.0.7<. .A/8398>?2/;?I.1:90/>.0?919:1/B8/71 3. 3/8 792 A90D.1 :90 /7923.0 1/B8 23.0.:90. 23?8 9502 :?718 ?2 0./897/=;. 29 40/72 /7 /69572 9: 8:90>/?7/7185::.0?748:90;9889: /6.7?2?.8 /71 8 :90 20/78>902/2?97 .F20/ 7950?836.72/71/22.71/72<3/04.8 3. 0?=57/; /;89 40/72.1 8 * 29A/018 ;988 9: ?7<96. 150?74 20./26.72 /71 ?2 7..18 79 ?72.0:.0.7<. 7 /;; 23. 292/; <96>.78/2?97 A95;1 <96.8 29 8* A?23 ?72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: *E :096 23. >.2?2?972?;;0./;?I/2?97 - 6 - 3./A/01>/88.1=B23.0?=57/;?8691?:?.1/8 571.0 )*+, -./01/, 9889:?7<96. ,* /?7/7185::.0?74 9889:/6.7?2?.8 ,.1?</;.F>.78.8 0/78>902/2?97 .F20/ 7950?836.72 /71 /22.71/72 <3/04.8 * 9889:./07?74150?7423.;/?1 5>>.0?91 * 0*2 3 <<901?74;B 23. />>.;;/72 ?8 .72?2;.1 :90 / 292/; <96>.78/2?97 9: 8* ?. .73/7<.1 <96>.78/2?979:8 , 723.0.85;223.:9;;9A?74901.0?8>/88.1 ?' 3./>>./;?8 ??' 3. />>.;;/72 ?8 .72?2;.1 :90 / 292/; <96>.78/2?97 9: 8* /;974 A?23 ?72.0.82/2*E>/:09623.1/2.9:>.2?2?972?;; 0./;?I/2?97 - 7 - ???' 3. 7850/7<. <96>/7B 3/8 /;0./1B 1.>98?2.1 23. /A/01 /69572 9: 23. 0?=57/; 23.0.:90. 0.8>971.72 9 ?8 1?0.<2.1 29 1.>98?2 23. .73/7<.1 <96>.78/2?97 9: 8 , A?23 ?72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: *E A?23?7 97. 69723 :09623.1/2.9:23?8901.0 ?C' 7 85<3 1.>98?2 23. />>.;;/72 ?8 >.06?22.1 29 A?2310/A23..72?0./69572/;974A?23?72.0.82 /<<05.197?2 ,+3 %$ ' # ?829;9 $