Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92849 (KAR)
K JAGANNATH RAO v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
WP/203445/2025 · 2025-11-10
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92849 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92849 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%$& $ $
'( )
! ! "
#
"$$ %
&
'
$
"$($
! "$($
"$$$
%
&
'
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
!!* !! ) )
)
)
+ $$)
), $!)!(
$ ( $*)
)
-
& - '
./0/012.3 04 5.613. /704 183/ 4..902: 61;;1<02: =03.>/012 ?448. @ <30/ 16 A@2=@A84 =03.>/02: /7. 3.4B12=.2/4/1>1240=.3/7.B./0/012
@BB;0>@/01260;.= 5C /7. B./0/012.3 @4 B.3 22.D83. $ @2= $ 613/7<0/7 @2= 02>13B13@/. /7. 2@A. 16 B./0/012 02 >1;8A2 14,@2=$!16 C1!(
$A.@48302: ( @>3.4 $* :82/@4 16 .E@=83:@ E0;;@:. .E@=83:@ @;89@ @0>783=04/30>/02@/0A.5182=A@22.3F
! 7. >@4. 16 /7. B./0/012.3 04 /7@/ 704 6@/7.3 7..A@>7@30 <@4 /7. 1<2.3 02 B144.44012 16 /7. ;@2= A.@48302: (* @>3.4 !" :82/@4 16 ;@2= 02 C1!(
$ 40/8@/.= @/ .E@=83:@ 0;;@:. .E@=83:@ 15;0
- 3 -
.E@=83:@ @;89 7@/ /7.3. @3. >.3/@02 .2>31@>7A.2/4 02>;8=02: /7. >124/38>/012 16 G8@3/.34 5C /7. 3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4
7. B./0/012.3 <@4 .@3;0.3 .AB;1C.=02/7.1E.32A.2/.B@3/A.2/@448>77.<@4 21/ @5;. /1 /@9. >@3. 16 /7. B31B.3/C 7@/ 704 6@/7.3 B@44.= @<@C 02 /7. !($" 7. B./0/012.3 7@= A@=. @ 3.G8.4/ 613 3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4 /1 483E.C /7. ;@2= <70>7 04 02 704 B144.44012 @2= /1 .2/.3 /7. 2@A. 16 /7. 4@0= .D/.2/ 12 >1240=.3@/012 16 /7. 4@0= 3.G8.4/ >124/3@02.=/7.B./0/012.3/1@BB31@>7/704183/5C60;02: 1!(!*"$
!(!" 704 183/ 5C 13=.3 =@/.= !!$$!(!"7@4=04B14.=16/7.4@0=<30/B./0/012=03.>/02:
/7.3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4/1@==3.44/7.:30.E@2>.16/7. B./0/012.3 >1240=.302: 704 3.B3.4.2/@/0124 =@/.= ((,!(! @2= ((!(!" 718:7 /7. 4@0= 13=.3 <@4 0448.= =8. /1 512@60=. A04/@9. /7. B./0/012.3 7@= A.2/012.=/7@/7.<@402B144.440121612;C!":82/@416 ;@2= 6/.3 /7. =03.>/012 0448.= 5C /7. 183/ 02 /7. 4@0= <30/ B./0/012 /7.3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4 7@= >1A./1 /7. - 4 -
4B1/@2=A.@483.=/7.B31B.3/C@2=6182=B./0/012.3/15. 02B144.4401216":82/@416;@2=7.3.613.7.485A0/4 /7@/ B./0/012.3 7@4 A@=. 3.B3.4.2/@/0124 /1 3.4B12=.2/ @8/7130/0.47.5.02:02B144.4401216($@>3.$":82/@416 ;@2= &" :82/@4 16 ;@2=' @2= 3.G8.4/.= /7. 3.4B12=.2/ @8/7130/0.4/1A8/@/.7042@A./1/7.4@0=.D/.2/7@/02 683/7.3@2>. 7. A@=. /7. 3.G8.4/ @4 B.3 /7. 3.B3.4.2/@/012 B31=8>.= @/ 22.D83.4 @2= 4.30.4 /1 /7. B3.4.2/ <30/ B./0/012 12 >1240=.3@/012 16 /7. 4@0= 3.B3.4.2/@/0124>124/3@02.=/7.B./0/012.3/1@BB31@>7/704 183/12>.@:@02 .2>.4..94613@;;1<02:/7.B./0/012
.@32.= ==0/012@; 1E.32A.2/ =E1>@/. <71 /@9.4 21/0>. 613 3.4B12=.2/ 14$ /1 485A0/4 /7@/ /7. B./0/012.3 7@4 /1 02=.B.2=.2/;C .4/@5;047 704 30:7/ @2= B144.440121E.3/7.B31B.3/CB@3/0>8;@3;C02/7.;0:7/16704 @=A044012 16 /7. B13/012 16 /7. B31B.3/C 7@E02: 5..2 @>G803.=
.2>31@>7.= 8B12 0/718/ /7. 4@0= =./.3A02@/012 /7. 3.G8.4/ 16 /7. B./0/012.3 >@221/ 5. >1240=.3.=
- 5 -
" ./0/012.3 >;@0A.= /1 7@E. 027.30/.= /7. B31B.3/C 02 C1!(
$ 631A 704 6@/7.3 7..A@>7@30 1824.; 613 /7. B./0/012.3 3.6.34 /1 22.D83. 3.>13=4 16 30:7/ 02 /704 3.:@3= .384@; 16 4@0= =1>8A.2/ <18;= 02=0>@/.
@2 .D/.2/ 16 (* @>3.4 !" :82/@4 16 ;@2= 5.02:
471<2 H102/;C 02 /7. 2@A. 16 7..A@>7@30 @2= G8@3/.34 1824.; 613 /7. B./0/012.3 683/7.3 485A0/4 /7@/ @6/.3 .D>;8=02: /7. .2>31@>7.= B13/012 B./0/012.3 04 02 B144.4401216($@>3.$":82/@416;@2= 1<.E.312/7. .@3;0.3 3182= 16 3.B3.4.2/@/012 @2= /7. <30/ B./0/012 B./0/012.3 82=.3 512@60=. A04/@9. 7@= >;@0A.= /1 5. 02 B144.44012 16 12;C !" :82/@4 16 ;@2= . 485A0/4 /7@/ 02 /.3A4 16 .>/012 $! /1 /7. @2= .613A4 >/ /7. 3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4 @3. =8/C 5182= /1 >12=8>/ /7. 483E.C@2=02>13B13@/./7.2@A.16/7.B./0/012.3 .2>. /7.<30/B./0/012
.@3=.384.=/7.3.>13=4 * =A0//.=;C B./0/012.3 04 21/ 02 B144.44012 16 .2/03. .D/.2/ 16 (* @>3.4 !" :82/@4 16 ;@2= <70>7 7. - 6 -
>;@0A47046@/7.3<@4/7.1<2.316./0/012.370A4.;67@4 @=A0//.= /7@/ /7. 4854/@2/0@; .D/.2/ 16 ;@2= 04 1>>8B0.=
.2>31@>7.= 8B12 02>;8=02: >124/38>/012 16 G8@3/.34 /7.3.12 @2= 12;C ($ @>3. $" :82/@4 16 ;@2= 04 @E@0;@5;.1.DB;@2@/01204B31E0=.=613@2C@>/0127@E02: 5..2/@9.25CB./0/012.36133.A1E@;16/7..2>31@>7A.2/ 1 =./@0;4 04 B31=8>.= .0/7.3 @4 3.:@3=4 <7./7.3 /7. >124/38>/012 16
G8@3/.34 5C /7. 3.4B12=.2/ @8/7130/0.4 <@4 B8348@2/ /1 @>G8040/012 16 ;@2= 82=.3 /7. ;@< 5;@29./ =03.>/012 =03.>/02: /7. 3.4B12=.2/4 /1 A.@483./7.E@>@2/;@2=@2=/1A8/@/./7.4@A.02/7.03 2@A.A@C;.@=/1@21A@;18440/8@/012B@3/0>8;@3;C<7.2 /7.B./0/012.370A4.;6@=A0//7@/7.0421/02B144.4401216 /7.;@2=
1<.E.3 /7. 3.4B12=.2/@8/7130/0.4 47@;; .D@A02./7.>@4.16/7.B./0/012.302@>>13=@2>.<0/7;@< @2= 5@4.= 12 /7. 3.>13=4 @2= /7. 6@>/8@; 40/8@/012 @E@0;@5;. @/ /7.03 7@2= 7.C 47@;; @;41 .D@A02. 06 /7. >124/38>/012 16 G8@3/.34 04 12 /7. ;@2= 16 /7. - 7 -
B./0/012.3@4>;@0A.=13/7.3.7@45..2@2C@>G8040/01216 /7.4@A.6/.3:0E02:1BB13/820/C16B.3412@;7.@302:/1 /7. B./0/012.3 <0/7 3.:@3= /1 704 >;@0A 1E.3 /7. ;@2= A.@48302: ($ @>3. $" :82/@4 <70>7 7. >;@0A4 /1 5. 02 B144.44012@=./@0;.=13=.302/7043.:@3=47@;;5.B@44.= @4=03.>/.=<0/702@218/.3;0A0/16/73..A12/74631A/7. =@/.163.>.0B/16>.3/060.=>1BC16/70413=.3
30/B./0/01204
*( '$ $) &
04/1$;1$*