Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92841 (KAR)
MAHAMMED MAHEBOOB v. THE STATE THROUGH KALABURAGI TRAFFIC-II
CRL.A/200036/2022 · 2025-07-22
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92841 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92841 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #$" %
$&&
'(
')&*+
' ** ,
! !"#
$%& ' ( )
$ '' ''''' & ' ''' )
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
*
)
*)
"$ *)
+,-. -( ,/0,1 ,2+3 3+,-4+. 5674/+3 86- 20+ 9+2(2(64+- ,4. 3+,-4+. (:0 67-2 6;+-4<+42 3+,.+- 86- 20+-+/964.+42! 2,2+
' 0+ ,99+33,42 (/ 20+ ,557/+. =06 /788+-+. ,4 6-.+- 68 564;(52(64 (4 6$ '' >? 20+ 3+,-4+. ..(2(64,3 (/2-(52 ,4. +//(64/ )7.:+ ,3,>7-,:( .,2+. ''''',4./+42+45+.,/74.+-
! " #
$%&!' ( ) '
*
- 3 -
+ ,
" (-
#
$.&!)
)(
/+ 0 $ ,1 2
"
#
3
/+1"
"
"4
5
6
7
$ ,52/ (4 20+ 472/0+33 86- .(/96/,3 68 20+ 9-+/+42 ,99+,3,-+,/74.+-
$# 56<93,(42 5,<+ 26 >+ 36.:+. >? ++-+/0 6 0,4.-,1,42 ,.,/0+22? 5642+4.(4: 20,2 0(/ 4(+5+ +:0, <+2 =(20 , -6,. 2-,88(5 ,55(.+42 64 #'&'#@ 0+ =,/ 9-65++.(4:640+-/5662?!2=6=0++3+->+,-(4:6!$' ! %'& ,4. =0+4 /0+ 5-6//+. 20+ -(4: -6,. =0(50 =,/ 9-65++.(4: 8-6< ,< ,4.(- 26=,-./ ,:,4,0,33( 5-6// ,2 ,>672"$,</0+5,<+(45642,52=(20,/(513+=0(50=,/ 2-(+.26,=66.+4963+>+(4:5,--(+.>?20+5?53(/2,4.(2572 0+- 4+51 ,4. /0+ 8+33 .6=4 8-6< 20+ /5662? 0+ :+4+-,3 97>3(5 =06 ,-+ 64 3661+-/ :,20+-+. 20+-+ ,4. 56<93,(4,42
- 4 -
++-+/0 =,/ 9-65++.(4: (4 0(/ 5,- ,82+- -+27-4(4: 8-6< 0,4.-,1,42 ,2(3A/ /2,.(7< ,82+- 8(4(/0(4: 20+ /=(<<(4:
/,= 20+ :-679 68 9+693+ +(4: ,4B(67/ ,/ 26 =0,2 0,/ 0,99+4+.0+/2699+.0(/5,-,4./,=20,2+:0,0,.8,33+4 .6=4
$'
0+ (486-<,2(64 =,/ :(;+4 26 0(< ,>672 20+ (45(.+42>?>0(/0+1=06(/,5C7(22+.=(2020+56<93,(4,42 ,/+. 64 20+ /,(. (486-<,2(64 0+ 36.:+. 20+ 56<93,(42 26 -,88(5! 63(5+ 2,2(64 ,3,>7-,:( +:0, >+(4: /0(82+. 8-6< 20+ 93,5+ 68 (45(.+42 26 20+ 06/9(2,3 >72 +4-662 /0+ .(+. $$
0+D7-(/.(52(64,3963(5+,82+--+:(/2+-(4:20+5,/+ (4;+/2(:,2+. 20+ <,22+- ,4. 8(3+. 20+ 50,-:+!/0++2 86- 20+ 688+45+974(/0,>3+74.+- +52(64$&68
$&
0+ 9-+/+45+ 68 20+ ,557/+. =,/ /+57-+. ,4. 50,-:+/ =+-+ 8-,<+. 0+ ,557/+. 93+,.+. 462 :7(32? 20+-+86-+2-(,3=,/0+3. - 5 -
$
0+ 9-6/+572(64 (4 ,33 +B,<(4+. @ =(24+//+/ 56<9-(/(4: 68 56<93,(4,42 /962 <,0,E,- (4C7+/2 <,0,E,- =(24+//+/ 20+ 6526- =06 564.752+. 20+ 96/2<6-2+< +B,<(4,2(64 ,4. 93,5+. 64 -+56-. ## .657<+42/ =0(50 ,-+ B0(>(2+. ,4. <,-1+. ,/ B# 26 B## 56<9-(/(4: 68 56<93,(42 90626:-,90/ /962 <,0,E,- (4C7+/2 <,0,E,- /+(E7-+ <,0,E,- -+96-2 4.+<4(2? >64. 6/2<6-2+< -+96-2
0+ 963(5+ ,3/6 /+(E+. 20+ 5?53+ >,<>66 ,4. 20+ /(513+=0(50=+-+/7>D+52<,22+-6820+(45(.+42,/#26 $
$F # -+(2+-,2+. 20+ 56<93,(42 ,;+-<+42/ ,4. /+(E7-+68#26$8-6<20+/962,4.,90626:-,90 =0(50 (/ 53+,-3? ;(/(>3+ =0(50 =673. :6 26 /06= 20,2 20+ ,557/+. =,/ 5,--?(4: , /(513+ 2(+.
26 20+ >,<>66 86- 20+ 97-96/+685633+52(646886..+->?:+22(4:20+3+,;+/,4.2-++ >-,450+/=(2020+0+396820+/,(./(513+2(+.2620+>,<>66 =,/ 5,--?(4: 20+ /,<+ (4 , <,44+- =0(50 =673. +4.,4:+- 20+620+-56<<72,2+/6820+-6,.,4.462462(5(4:20+/,<+ ,3368,/7..+420+.+5+,/+.5,<+(45642,52=(2020+/(513+ ,4.20+-+=,/,/+;+-+4+51(4D7-?-+/732(4:(40+-.+,20
- 6 -
$% +,-4+. 2-(,3 )7.:+ -(:023? ,99-+5(,2+. 20+ <,2+-(,3 +;(.+45+ 64 -+56-. ,4. 8674. 20,2 20+ <,2+-(,3 +;(.+45+,;,(3,>3+64-+56-.=,/462/788(5(+4226-+56-.,4 6-.+- 68 564;(52(64 86- 20+ 688+45+ 74.+- +52(64 $& ,4. 2-+,2+. ,/ ,4 ,55(.+42 ,4. 564;(52+. 20+ ,99+33,42 86- 20+ 688+45+74.+- +52(64$&!68
& +(4:,::-(+;+.>?20+/,<+20+9-+/+42,99+,3 0,/>++49-+8+--+.6486336=(4::-674./
6 8 #)$
9
*
(-0
:
(-0
(-%
/
"
(0 (%
"
,/+; 0 $"
0
"(<
- 7 -
(<
/+; '
$
,
/+ 0
"
'+
"
"
=
"
'+
7
-( ,/0,1 ,2+3 3+,-4+. 5674/+3 86- 20+ ,99+33,42-+(2+-,2(4:20+:-674./7-:+.(420+,99+,3<+<6 5642+4.+. 20,2 46 4+:3(:+45+ =,/ ,22-(>72,>3+ 26 20+ ,99+33,420+-+(4,4.<,2+-(,3+;(.+45+0,/462>++49-69+-3? ,99-+5(,2+.,4./67:0286-,336=(4:20+,99+,3
F 32+-4,2(;+3? -( ,/0,1 ,2+3 =673. 5642+4. 20,2 0,;(4: -+:,-. 26 20+ /+C7+45+ ,4. +;+42/ 20,2 0,;+ 2,1+4 93,5+ 20(/ 67-2 <,? /+2 ,/(.+ 20+ (<9-(/64<+42 68 2=6 ?+,-/ 86- 20+ 688+45+ 74.+- +52(64 $&! >? +40,45(4:8(4+,<6742-+,/64,>3? % (
3+,-4+. (:0 67-2 6;+-4<+42 3+,.+- 6996/+/ 20+ ,99+,3 :-674./ ,4. /7996-2/ 20+ (<97:4+. )7.:<+42 + =673. 87-20+- 5642+4. 20,2 ,.<(22+.3? 20+ >,<>66 2(+. =(20 20+ /(513+ =,/ 5,--(+. >? 20+,99+33,426420+>(5?53+,4.,3368,/7..+40+36/220+
- 8 -
>,3,45+,4.20+>,<>6627-4+.06-(E642,33?=0(3+<6;(4:64 20+>(5?53+
0+.+5+,/+.=06=,/<6;(4:64,2=6=0++3+- 5673.462,42(5(9,2+/750,20(4:=673.0,99+4,4.5,<+(4 5642,52=(2020+/,(./(513+,4./7/2,(4+.:-(+;67/(4D7-?64 20+4+51-+:(64-+/732(4:(407:+0+<6--0,:+,4.,3/6.(+. +4-6622620+06/9(2,3
" 0+-+86-+ 4+:3(:+45+ (/ ,22-(>72,>3+ 26 20+ ,99+33,42 (4,/<750 ,/ 0+ 5673. 462 0,;+ 5,--(+. /750 , .,4:+-67/=+,9646420+97>3(5-6,.20,2266=0(3+-(.(4: 20+ >(5?53+
0+-+86-+ 20+ 564;(52(64 ,4. /+42+45+ 68 2=6 ?+,-/4++./46(42+-8+-+45+>?20(/67-2(420(/,99+,3,4. /67:0286-.(/<(//,36820+,99+,3(42626
@ ,;(4: 0+,-. 20+ ,-:7<+42/ 68 >620 /(.+/ 20(/ 67-29+-7/+.20+<,2+-(,364-+56-.<+2(57367/3? # 4 /750 9+-7/,3 68 20+ <,2+-(,3 64 -+56-. 86336=(4:96(42/=673.,-(/+86-564/(.+-,2(64 ! -
#
$%&'()>
- 9 -
! -
6
> ! -
> ! - >
-./)012.&1234/20
## 4 20+ 5,/+ 64 0,4. 20+ ,55(.+42,3 .+,20 68 +:0, =06 (/ 20+4(+5+ 68 20+ # /2,4./ +/2,>3(/0+. >? 93,5(4:4+5+//,-?6-,3,4..657<+42,-?+;(.+45+64-+56-. 90626:-,90 9-6.75+. 64 >+0,38 68 20+ 9-6/+572(64 /788(5(+423? .+9(52/ 20,2 86- , 364: 963+ , /(513+ 0,/ >++4 2-(+. =(20 20+ 0+39 68 , -69+ 2(:023? 0+ ,99+33,42 =,/ <6;(4:64,>(5?53+063.(4:20+/,(.>,<>662(+.=(20/(513+ ,4.36/220+>,3,45+,4.,3368,/7..+420+>,<>6627-4+. 06-(E642,33?6420+-6,./(.+
#' 0+ .+5+,/+. 7486-274,2+3? 5673.
462 ,42(5(9,2+ 20,2/750,20(4:=673.0,99+4,4.,3368,/7..+45673.462 /269 0+- 2=6 =0++3+- ,4. 5,<+ (4 5642,52 =(20 20+ /(513+ 20,2 =,/ 2(+. 26 20+ >,<>66 / , -+/732 /0+ /7/2,(4+. - 10 -
(4D7-? 64 0+- 4+51 -+:(64 =0(50 =,/ :-(+;67/ +467:0 ,4. 20+-+=,//788(5(+4236//68>366. #$ +693+:,20+-+.,220+93,5+68(45(.+42(4537.(4:
>0(/0+1 0+39+. (4 /0(82(4: (4D7-+. +:0, 26 20+ 06/9(2,3 6=+;+-.7+2636//68>366.+4-672+2620+06/9(2,3+:0, /7557<>+.2620+(4D7-? #& # (/ , 50,45+ =(24+// =06 0,/ /9622+. 20+ :-679 68 9+693+ 4+,- E64 ,?672 =0(3+ -+27-4(4: 8-6< 0,4.-,1,42,2(3A//2,.(7<,82+-8(4(/0(4:0(//=(<<(4:/ ,4643661+-0+9++9+.(42620+:-679689+693+,4.8674. 20,2 , ?674: :(-3=,/ 3?(4: 64 20+ -6,.=(20 9663 68 >366. +- 2=6 =0++3+-=,/ ,3/6 8674. 4+,- 20+ 93,5+ 68 (45(.+42 /6,3/620+5?53+,4.>,<>662(+.=(20/(513+
# 4 +4C7(-? =(20 0(/ ,5C7,(42,45+ 4,<+3? >0(/0+10+5,<+26146=20,220+(4D7-+.=,/464+620+- 20,4 0(/ 6=4 4(+5+ ,4. 0+ (.+42(8(+. 0+- ,4. (<<+.(,2+3? 2661/2+9/26/0(8220+(4D7-+.2620+06/9(2,3720(/+886-2/ =+42(4;,(4
0+,557/+.=06=,/8674.4+,-20+93,5+68 (45(.+42=,/2,1+42620+63(5+ 2,2(6420+63(5+3+20(<64
- 11 -
>,(30,;(4:-+:(/2+-+.20+ 86-20+688+45+74.+- +52(64 $&!68
#F 4;+/2(:,2(64 =,/ 87-20+- 564.752+. ,4. 50,-:+! /0++2 5,<+ 26 >+ 8(3+. 86- 20+ 688+45+ 974(/0,>3+ 74.+- +52(64$&68
#% 0+<,2+-(,3+;(.+45+64-+56-.#>+(4:462 ,4+?+=(24+//2620+(45(.+42720+5673.>+2-+,2+.,/, =(24+//74.+- +52(64F6820+4.(,4;(.+45+52.(.462 0,;+ ,4? 9-+;(67/ ,<+4(2? 6- ,4(<6/(2? 26 .+96/+ 8,3/+3? ,:,(4/220+9-+/+42,99+33,42
#" 6-+6;+-20+9-+/+42,99+33,42=,/2,1+42620+ 963(5+/2,2(64>?20+:-679689+693+/664,82+-20+(45(.+42 =0(50 /06=/ 20,2 20+ >(5?53+ =,/ -(..+4 >? 20+ ,99+33,42 ,4. 20+ >,<>66 2(+. =(20 /(513+ =,/ >+(4: 5,--(+. >? 20+ ,99+33,42 ,2 20+ 2(<+ 68 (45(.+42 ,4. (2 5,<+ (426 5642,52 =(20 20+ .+5+,/+. 64 ,99+33,42 366/(4: 20+ >,3,45+ ,4. >,<>6627-4(4:06-(E642,33?26=,-./20+-6,. - 12 -
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
'# 0+ -+,/64(4: ,//(:4+. >? 20+ 2-(,3 )7.:+ 8-6< /5,3(4:.6=420+688+45+8-6< +52(64$&6826 +52(64 $&!68(/462643?/674.>72,3/636:(5,3
'' 0+-+86-+ 20(/ 67-2 .6+/ 462 8(4. ,4? 3+:,3 (48(-<(2?6-9+-;+-/(2?(4-+56-.(4:6820+8(4.(4:6820+:7(32 6820+,99+33,4286-20+688+45+74.+- +52(64$&!68
- 13 -
'$ 4 ;(+= 68 20+ 86-+:6(4: .(/57//(64 96(42 6/# ,4.',-+,4/=+-+.(420+4+:,2(;+
-./)012.&123
'& -(,/0,,2+33+,-4+.5674/+35642+4.+.20,2 20+,99+33,42(/,:+.?+,-/,4.0,;(4:,8,<(3?0+(/, ;+-?966-9+-/64,4./63+>-+,.+,-4+-2620+8,<(3?80+(/ /+42+45+. 26 74.+-:6 (<9-(/64<+42 86- , 9+-(6. 68 2=6 ?+,-/ 0(/ +42(-+ 8,<(3? =673. >+ 3+82 (4 37-50 ,4.
86- ,4 74+B9+52+. (45(.+42 20,2 0,/ 6557--+. 20+ ,99+33,42 0,/ +B9-+//+. -+<6-/+ ,4. 0+ (/ 9-+9,-+. 26 9,? ,-+,/64,>3+ ,<6742 ,/ 56<9+4/,2(64 26 20+ <620+- 68 20+ ;(52(< ,4. /++1//+22(4:,/(.+6820+(<9-(/64<+429+-(6. ' +,-4+. (:0 67-2 6;+-4<+42 3+,.+- 06=+;+-6996/+.20+/,(./7><(//(64
'F ,1(4: 462+ 68 20+ 8,52 20,2 20+ (45(.+42 (/ ,4 ,55(.+42,4.,>/6372+3?20+-+=,/46(42+42(6420,25673.>+ ,22-(>72+. 26 20+ ,99+33,42(4 20+36// 68 3(8+ 68+:0, 20(/ 67-2 (/ 68 20+ 564/(.+-+. 69(4(64 20,2 (8 20+ ,99+33,42 (/
- 14 -
.(-+52+. 26 74.+-:6 /(<93+ (<9-(/64<+42 86- 20+ .,? 2(33 -(/(4:6820+67-2>?+40,45(4:20+8(4+,<6742(4,/7<68 /' ! =0(50 5673. >+ 9,(. ,/ 56<9+4/,2(64 26 20+ <620+- 68 +:0, (4 ,..(2(64 26 20+ /7< 68 /' ! ,/ 6-.+-+.>?20+3+,-4+.2-(,3)7.:++4./68D7/2(5+=673.>+ <+2556-.(4:3?96(426$(/,4/=+-+.(420+,88(-<,2(;+
-./)012.&123
'% 4;(+=6820+8(4.(4:6820(/67-26496(426/# 26$,/,>6;+20+86336=(4:6-.+-(/9,//+. ( 0+,99+,3,336=+.(49,-2G
(( 0(3+<,(42,(4(4:20+564;(52(646820+ ,99+33,42 86- 20+ 688+45+ 74.+- +52(64 $&! 68 20+ /+42+45+ 6-.+-+. >? 20+ 2-(,3 )7.:+ (/ <6.(8(+. >? .(-+52(4: 20+ ,99+33,42 26 74.+-:6 /(<93+ (<9-(/64<+42 86- 20+ .,? 2(33 -(/(4: 68 20+ 67-2 >? +40,45(4: 20+ 8(4+ ,<6742 (4 , /7< 68 /' ! (((
(<+ (/ :-,42+. 86- 9,?<+42 68 +40,45+.8(4+,<67422(33$#"''G
- 15 -
(; ,(37-+ 26 9,? 20+ +40,45+. 8(4+ ,<6742 20+ ,99+33,42 /0,33 74.+-:6 /(<93+ (<9-(/64<+4286-,9+-(6.682=6?+,-/,/6-.+-+. >?20+2-(,3)7.:+G
; 82+- 20+ .+96/(2 20+ +40,45+. 8(4+ ,<6742 68 /' ! (/ 26 >+ 9,(. ,/ 56<9+4/,2(64 26 =06 (/ 20+ <620+- 68 20+ .+5+,/+.;(52(<!:(-3,/56<9+4/,2(64G
;( 88(5+ (/ .(-+52+. 26 -+27-4 20+ 2-(,3 67-2 -+56-./ =(20 569? 68 20(/ 6-.+- 86- 20+ 97-96/+68(//7,45+68<6.(8(+.564;(52(64=,--,42
0+ '% *
"
(/26# 36F'