- 1 - !" #$% &%'!%!% (%) ! " #$ $ % & % ! " #$ $ % $ ' %' ! " #$ $ % ( ) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * !$$ % !+ !&,, $$ #$ $ % & $!+ !+ ! )$ #$ $ % ' $#! $* % !+ &'$ % ( #)+- )%&&&' $ ++ ! +$ $&&,+ + ! + ! . )$ # # + ) + /&, * ) && + $ ! 0$ # $ - 3 - 0$ # $ 1232345167 861 91:461 2;37 4<62 9135=8==631>1?9@ 2;146?16 ?821? && A8771?35 + 4/&,45 2;1 :3B1 4: 15346 3>3B #<?=1 85? # + 1>8?<6=8 :46 7;462C2;1638B4<62D 35216E74:F;3G;2;1638B4<62 ;87 8GG1A21? 2;1 61A462 4: $ 1>8?<6=8 F;4 F87 8AA43521? 87 8 4EE37734516 85? A4721? 2;1 E82216 :46 :<62;16 721A7 :46 ?3>37345 4: 2;1 A64A162@ 35 216E7 4: 2;1 61A462 & ;1 G871 4: 2;1 A123234516 37 2;82 2;1 617A45?1527;16135;8?:3B1?87<32354''&/B? 4%&& 711H35= 61B31: 4: A86232345 85? 71A86821 A477177345 35 617A1G2 4: B85? 918635= 3 @4%/ E187<635=8G617=<528733 @4%/E187<635= 8G617 ' =<5287 333 @4%, E187<635=& 8G617& =<5287 4<2 4: 8G617 8BB 732<821? 35 899<6 >3BB8=1 I 14?<6=837283G;<6;822;1783?7<32F87?1G611?35 216E7 4: J<?=E152 85? ?1G611 ?821? &'&&, 7 - 4 - 8=83572F;3G;A1232345167;8?A61:1661?8AA18B91:4612;37 4<62 35 + 4&'&, ;1 783? 8AA18B F87 ?37E3771?G45:36E35=2;1J<?=E15285??1G611A8771?9@ 2;1 638B 4<62 >3?1 46?16 ?821? /&&' ;1618:216 2;1 617A45?152 4 ;16135 35;16321? 2;1 8:461783? :358B ?1G611 A64G11?35= 35 + 4/&, ;1 4EE37734516 F87 8AA43521? 9@ 2;1 638B 4<62 24 A86232345 85? ?3>3?1 2;1 7G;1?<B1 A64A162317 87 A16 2;1 A61B3E3586@ ?1G611 <67<8522;1614:2;14EE377345167<9E3221?2;161A462 ;1 =631>85G1 4: 2;1 A1232345167 37 2;82 2;1 61A462 7<9E3221?9@ 2;1A123234516 37 542 35 8GG46?85G1 F32; 2;1 A61B3E3586@ ?1G611 85? 2;1 78E1 37 7<9E3221? F32;4<2 1>15 61:1615G1 24 2;1 7<9J1G2 E82216 4: 2;1 A61B3E3586@ ?1G611 ' $18651? G4<571B :462;1 A1232345167 6132168235= 2;1=64<5?7 <6=1? 7<9E327 2;822;1 4EE3773451661A462 A64?<G1? 82 551K<61 24 2;1 F632 A1232345 61:167 24 8 ?3>37345 E8?1 35 617A1G2 4: B85? 35 @4%, 85? 7<9E3221? 2;82 783? B85? F87 542 1>15 7<9J1G2 E82216 4: - 5 - 2;1A61B3E3586@?1G61123745B@@4%,F;3G;F87 7<9J1G2 E82216 4: 2;1 A61B3E3586@ ?1G611 1 :<62;16 7<9E327 2;82 2;4<=; 2;1 783? 87A1G2 4: 2;1 E82216 F87 964<=;2242;15423G14:2;1638B4<6282 868=68A;4/ 4: 2;1 72821E152 4: 49J1G23457 A64?<G1? 82 551K<61 2;12638B4<62;875428?>1621?242;178E117<9E327 2;82 3: 2;1 61A462 87 7<9E3221? 9@ 2;1 4EE37734516 37 8GG1A21?85?A64G11?1?2;1A64A162@F;3G;375427<9J1G2 E82216 4: 2;1 A61B3E3586@ ?1G611 F3BB 91 7<9J1G21? 24 ?3>3734515G1711H7:468BB4F35=4:2;1A1232345 % ;4<=;5423G14:2;37A1232345;879115716>1? 2;161375461A617152823454591;8B:4:617A45?1527 868=68A; 4/ 4: 2;1 72821E152 4: 49J1G2345 :3B1?9@2;1A123234516618?787<5?16- L/ ;37 17A45?152 7<9E327 2;82 8:216 =435= 2;64<=; 2;1 G1623:31? G4A317 4: 2;1 4<62 4EE37734516 1A462 32 F87 B18651? 2;82 2;1 4EE37734516;8??3>3?1?2;1G;1?<B1A64A162@ 85?:<6537;1?2;17H12G;242;374509B1G4<6232 377<9E3221?2;822;14EE37734516F32;4<285@ 8AAB3G82345 4: E35? ;8? ?3>3?1? 2;1 A64A162@ @4%,F;3G;37542828BB2;17<9J1G2E82216 - 6 - 4: 2;1 <32 G;1?<B1 64A162@ 2 37 7<9E3221? 2;822;121E4%4:2;1<32G;1?<B1 64A162@ 37 @4%, F32; 85 1K2152 4: & G617 & <5287 4<2 4: F;3G; G61 732<821? 82 899<6 >3BB8=18B<H1>?<6=837283G;<6<5?162;1 894>1G36G<E7285G172;1@4%,F;3G;37542 82 8BB 7<9J1G2 E82216 4: 2;1 <32 G;1?<B1 64A162@2;14EE37734516F32;4<28AAB3G823454: E35? ?3>3?1? 2;1 G;1?<B1 64A162@ @4%, F;3G;37542828BB351K37215G1<5?162;1894>1 G36G<E7285G17 2;1 4EE37734516 61A462 37 B389B1 2491712873?1M / 5 2;1 3EA<=51? 46?16 A16<78B 4: 2;1 3EA<=51?46?1635?3G8212;822;1638B4<622;4<=;28H17 5421 4: 2;1 49J1G2345 :3B1? 9@ A123234516 F;4 F87 617A45?15242;16135;875428?>1621?242;3787A1G24: 2;1 E82216 ;1 ?1G611 A8771? 35 4''&/ B? 4%&& A64?<G1? 82 551K<61 61:167 24 B85?7 35@47%/%/85?%,;161375461:1615G1F32; 61=86? 24 A64A162@ 918635= @4%, ;1 61A462 4: 2;1 $4<62 4EE37734516 A64?<G1? 82 551K<61 87 F1BB872;17H12G;:46E35=A8624:2;1783?61A46235?3G8217 2;82 ;1 ;87 28H15 3524 G4573?1682345 B85? 918635= L@4%,M 357218? 4: L@4%,M 8B45= F32; 42;16 - 7 - 7<6>1@ 5<E9167 GB186B@ 2;161 37 85 16646 85? 3BB1=8B32@ 35 4EE37734516 A61A8635= 2;1 61A462 F;3G; ;87 542 9115 28H15 3524 G4573?1682345 9@ 638B 4<62 1>15 F;3B1 8GG1A235=2;161A462 , 52;82>31F4:2;1E822162;1:4BB4F35=- 8 ;1A1232345378BB4F1? 9 ;1 46?16 3EA<=51? ?821? && A8771?35+ 4/&,452;1:3B14:15346 3>3B#<?=185?# +1>8?<6=837712873?1 242;11K21524:B85?35@4%, G 82216 37 61E3221? 24 2;1 638B 4<62 :46 61G4573?1682345 4: 2;1 61A462 45B@ 24 2;1 1K21524:B85?35@4%, ? 2 37 E8?1 GB186 2;161 37 54 G;85=1 46 8B21682345 46 >86382345 E8?1 35 617A1G2 4: 61A462 A16283535= 24 42;16 321E7 35 2;1 A64A162317 - 8 - 1 ;12638B4<627;8BBB44H35242;1854E8B@35 2;1 61A462 85? A877 8AA64A63821 46?16 3: 61I<361? 8AA4352 2;1 4EE37734516 :46 2;1 A<6A471 4: 3?1523:3G82345 85? ?3>37345 4: B85? 35@4%,4:2;17<327G;1?<B1A64A162@ !*+ (%!%) ' $3724B4/