Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92835 (KAR)

NATU v. NEMU

WP/203484/2025 · 2025-11-10

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"#!$%& ' &("&"& )&* ! " !# ! ! "$ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % &# ' ( ) ! $# *!$ # ! *!$ # # *!$ # ' + % + + ) + ,*+ #&#! + &"# #!- ) + ,*+ "##! + &"# #!- ) - 3 - + + + + . ! ( . ) /010123/4 562 17 89:1301;; 13 2 &"#2; #! 23 06/ ;19/ 2; 06/ 413<18:9 1=19 >?@/ :0 1A:B:8>4: C6/4/13:;0/44/;/44/? 02 :706/ D41:92>40E;24F4/=10BG17 F/;24/ 0617 2>40 F/13@ :@@41/=/? FB 06/ 24?/47 ?:0/? #&#!:3?"##!FB561<606/41:92>406:7 23107253842<//?/?02:882130:2>402HH177123/402 =1710 06/ 7>10 8428/40B :3? 02 4/8240 06/ 2>40 23 06/ 13704><01237177>/?06/4/>3?/4 /:43/?<2>37/9;2406/8/010123/477>FH10706:0 06/7>101723/;24?/<9:4:0123:3?13A>3<0123:3?06/41:9 2>406:?@4:30/?130/41H24?/42;0/H824:4B13A>3<012313 ;:=2>4 2; 06/ 8/010123/47 4/704:1313@ 06/ ?/;/3?:307 ;42H - 4 - <23704><013@2=/406/7>107<6/?>9/8428/40B:3B704><0>4/ :7 76253 13 06/ 6:3? 7I/0<6 /:43/? <2>37/9 ;>406/4 7>FH107 06/4/:;0/4 06/ 41:9 2>40 5619/ 6/:413@ 06/ :8891<:0123 13 2 >3?/4 4?/4 ,,, , >9/ :3? 2?/ 2; 1=19 42</?>4/ 23 #&#! 6:? 2813/? 06:0 F/;24/8:7713@:3B24?/4723 27:3?105:7A>70 :3? 3/</77:4B 02 :882130 : 2>40 2HH177123/4 02 :7</40:13 06/ :<0>:9 710>:0123 13 06/ 7>10 8428/40B :3? :<<24?13@9B :882130/? 06/ 2>40 2HH177123/4 6/ 41:9 2>40:;0/406/7:1?24?/4?14/<0/?8:401/702;19/H/H22; 13704><01237 6/ 89:1301;;7 ?1? 320 ;19/ H/H2 2; 13704><01237 25/=/4 06/ ?/;/3?:307 ;19/? 06/ H/H2 2; 13704><01237 6/ 41:9 2>40 :;0/4 6/:413@ 06/ 8:401/7 ;4:H/? 06/ 13704><01237 :3? ?14/<0/? 06/ 2HH177123/4 5625:7:882130/?02;19/:4/82401306174/@:4? /:43/?<2>37/9;2406/8/010123/47>FH10706:0 06/70:@/2;06/842<//?13@17239B<2371?/4:01232;130/41H :8891<:0123 :3? 06/ 7>10 17 23/ F/13@ ;24 ?/<9:4:0123 :3? 13A>3<0123 51062>0 4/<24?13@ /=1?/3</ 06/ 41:9 2>40 - 5 - 2>@60 320 02 6:=/ =/30>4/? >823 :88213013@ 06/ 2HH177123/4 / 7>FH107 06:0 06/ 70:@/ :0 561<6 06/ 41:92>4017/J/4<1713@107?17<4/01231756:006/8/010123/4 17:@@41/=/?2;:3?6/3</7//I7;24130/4=/30123 " /:4?/4>7/?06/4/<24?7 ! 6/ 41:9 2>40 6:7 ;2>3? 06:0 06/ 8/010123/47 :4/ <9:1H13@ 06/ 7>10 9:3? 13 B2 K H/:7>413@ :<4/ 710>:0/? :0 6>0:3:9 199:@/ :9>I 1I20: 17041<0 1A:B:8>402F/06/:@41<>90>4:99:3?5619/06/?/;/3?:307 :4/ <230/3?13@ 06/ 7>10 9:3? 02 F/ 323*:@41<>90>4:9 9:3? <23717013@2;62>7/77<62297:3?206/4<23704><012372=/4 06/ 7:1? 8428/40B 0 17 >3?/4 06/7/ <14<>H70:3</7 06/ 41:9 2>40 /=/3 :0 06/ 70:@/ 2; 6/:413@ 06/ :8891<:0123 6:7;2>3?10:8842841:0/02:88213006/2HH177123/46/ 41:92>40:08:4:@4:86*!2;06/24?/46:74/;/44/?0206/ 24?/4 2; 06/ 2*24?13:0/ /3<6 2; 0617 2>40 8:77/? 13 1306/<:7/2; 56/4/1306172>406:? - 6 - 2F7/4=/?06:0L M 0 17 F:7/? 23 06/ :;24/7:1? 827101232;9:506/41:92>406:7842<//?/?028:7706/ 24?/4 4?/4 ,, >9/ & 2; 2?/ 2; 1=19 42</?>4/ 4/:?7:7>3?/4 ! " # $ ! " # $ - 7 - % 89:13 4/:?13@ 2; 06/ 842=17123 H:I/7 10 <9/:4 06:006/2>4023107253H:B7//I:4/8240;248428/4 :884/<1:0123 2; 06/ 177>/7 13 <23042=/47B 2 70:@/ 2; H:I13@ :3 :8891<:0123 17 78/<1;1<:99B842=1?/? 06/4/>3?/4 6/24?/48:77/?0206/2*24?13:0//3<62;06172>4013 4/;/44/? 02 :F2=/ 52>9? H:I/ 10 <9/:4 06:01;06/4/824017/77/301:9;24/9><1?:013@06/H:00/413 ?178>0/1017?/714:F9/;2492<:91378/<0123:0:3B70:@/2; 842<//?13@7 /=/3 5619/ 6/:413@ 06/ :8891<:0123 F/;24/ <2HH/3</H/302;041:9 $ /06:0:71017 01706/7/009/?827101232;9:5 06:006/2HH177123/4.74/8240<2>9?F/8:402;06/4/<24? :3? 8422; 24 206/4517/ 2; 06/ 7:H/ 17 7>FA/<0 02 206/4 <2442F24:013@/=1?/3</ 017:95:B728/3;2406/8/010123/4 02<230/7006/2HH177123/4.74/8240:3?02842=/617<:7/ 13?/8/3?/309B /4/ :882130H/30 2; 2HH177123/4 :3? 06/4/8240;19/?<:3320F/06/729/F:717;24<23<9>71232; 06/041:96/041:9177019902F/<2HH/3</?:3?842<//?/? 13:<<24?:3</51069:5 0239B52>9?4/?></06/=29>H/2; - 8 - /=1?/3</ 4/N>14/? 02 F/ 842?></? FB 06/ 8:401/7 1; 06/ <2HH177123/4E74/824017:<</80/? & 3 06:0 =1/5 2; 06/ H:00/4 0617 2>40 ?2 320 ;13? :3B 4/:723 02 130/4;/4/ 5106 06/ 1H8>@3/? 24?/4 <<24?13@9B06/8/01012317 "+, )&"&* (! 170292"