- 1 - !"!# $%"& %'' ( )()** + !""#$# % & ' # ( ( ) !""#$* + + ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !""#$" % & )#, - )+' ) #!&+') &' * +$+" #*$"+$+" - ( " +$+") ( ) ) )) +.&' +&' ##&+' #$.&#' "+ "#&+' ) &' +$+ &#'&/' &#'&0' &+'&1' ) &' #.. ) ) - ) - ( 2 - - 3 - "% & 2 - ' # 34/5 /6 167408 9:4;7<4/ :34/735 =;>703: ?;/ @83 4993::47@ /6 33/474A;>54 4:694@6: :34/735 6A8 ;>/@ ;13/7B37@ :3453/ ?;/ @83 ?6/0@ /309;7537@ 475 /6 -4<4 :34/735 =;>703: ?;/ @83 03=;75/309;7537@ + 860 49934: 60 ?6:35 >753/ 3=@6;7 #!&+' =835>:3540@30475@83=835>:35/6C30&/3137@6;7;? @/;=6@630'=@#.. D6@8@83?;::;D67A9/4E3/ !"#$%&%' ("$&'$%&%' )) * + ,- .- / $ '!$%&%' /0 1 + .- * 2 .- 3 4$ #%56 - 4 - #%66 ((7% (&5( #'% #'(% 8 + 8 + %&%# + #( #( #%3 +$+9 1 (575 - )) * + ,- .- - : ; < 834993::47@60@830;:34==>03567/3093=@;? ) C34/67A ;" +$+" 54@35 $$+$+" ?;/ @83 ;??37=30 9>76084C:3 >753/ 3=@6;70 +.&' +&' ##&+' #$.&#' "+ "#&+' ;? 84/4@6E4 E4E4 4786@4 &' +$+ 475 3=@6;7 &#'&/' &#'&0' &+'&1' ;? &;'=@#.. 60@ ;? @83 =;B9:467@ 413/B37@0 /3134:0 @84@ @83/3 D40 4 560=>006;7 C3@D337 @83 4993::47@ 475 @83 =;B9:46747@ 67 @83 8;>03 ;? @83 =;B9:46747@ D86=8 @>/735 67@; 4:@3/=4@6;7 D83/367 @83 4993::47@ 0465 @; 8413 4C>035 ;73 476<47@ 4@8;5 67 ?6:@8E :47A>4A3 CE @4<67A;>@860=40@374B3 - 5 - " ;B9:46747@ C367A @83 3B9:;E33 ;? @83 0465 476<47@4@8;5/3060@354756@604:0;4::3A35@84@8;>03 ;? @83 0465 476<47@ 4@8;5 60 54B4A35 CE @83 9/3037@ 4993::47@ 4035 ;7 0>=8 =;B9:467@ 8;D< ;:6=3 /3A60@3/35 @83 =403 475 4?@3/ 53@46: 67130@6A4@6;7 ?6:35 =84/A3!0833@ C3?;/3 @83 93=64: ;>/@ ;7 $$"+$+" 83/3 60 47 ;/53/ ;? 0@4E 940035 CE @83 ;!/5674@3 37=8 ;? @860 ;>/@ ;7 $$"+$+" 67 /: ;+$$$ +$+" * 7 @83 B347@6B3 4993::47@ 499/;4=835 @83 93=64: ;>/@ ?;/ A/47@ ;? 47@6=694@;/E C46: D86=8 D40 /3F3=@35CE@83:34/73593=64:->5A3;7@83A/;>75@84@ 3BC4/A;4060=;7@3B9:4@35>753/3=@6;7#;?@83=@ D;>:5 =;B3 67 @83 D4E ;? 37@3/@46767A @83 93@6@6;7 ?;/ 47@6=694@;/E C46: 83/34?@3/ 4993::47@ 60 C3?;/3 @860 ;>/@ - 6 - /6 167408 9:47;<4/ :34/735 =;>703: ?;/ @834993::47@=;7@37535@84@@833BC4/A;>753/3=@6;7 # ;? @83 =@ D;>:5 7;@ =;B3 67 @; 9:4E 67 @83 =403 ;7 8475 40 @83 4::3A35 4C>03 4/3 D6@867 @83 ?;>/ D4::0 ;? @83 8;>03 ;? @83 =;B9:46747@ @83/3?;/3 7;@ 67 @839>C:6=163D . 3=;75:E @83 4::3A35 54B4A3 60 E3@ @; C3 30@4C:60835 475 6? 4@ 4:: 54B4A3 840 @4<37 9:4=3 @; @83 0465476<47@4@8;5@8376@6083D8;D40/3G>6/35@; :;5A3 @83 =;B9:467@ 475 7;@ @83 3B9:;E33 ;? @83 0465 476<47@4@8;5@8>0830;>A8@?;/4::;D67A@8349934: #$ 1 /6 33/47A;>54 4:694@6: :34/735 6A8;>/@;13/7B37@:3453/475/6-4<4:34/735 =;>703: ;99;03 @83 49934: A/;>750 CE =;7@37567A @84@ 3BC4/A;>753/3=@6;7#;?@83=@60499:6=4C:3@;@83 =403;78475 ## 83E D;>:5 4:0; =;7@375 @84@ 067=3 @83 4993::47@ 565 7;@ =;!;93/4@3 D6@8 @83 67130@6A4@6;7 - 7 - 4C0=;7567A=84/A3!0833@60?6:35475@83/3?;/349934:;? @834993::47@=477;@C34::;D35 #+ 4167A834/5@834/A>B37@0;7C;@806530@860 ;>/@93/>035@83B4@3/64:;7/3=;/5B3@6=>:;>0:E # 70>=893/>04:;?@83B4@3/64:;7/3=;/56@60 =/E0@4:=:34/@84@@83=;7@37@0;?@83=;B9:467@D;>:57;@ 4@@/4=@ @833BC4/A; >753/ 3=@6;7# ;?@83 =@?;/B;/3@847;73/340;7 # )6/0@:E4060/6A8@:E=;7@37535;7C384:?;?@83 4993::47@@834::3A354C>0304/3D6@867?;>/D4::0;?@83 8;>03 ;? @83 =;B9:46747@ 475 @83/3?;/3 6@ 60 7;@ 67 @83 9>C:6=163D #" 3=;75:E6?@8354B4A30;==>//35@;@838;>03 ;? 0465 476<47@ 4@8;5 @83/3 D40 7; B4@3/64:30@4C:608@84@;7:ED6@84767@37@6;7@;=4>03?34/ 90E=834B;7A@83=;BB>76@E4@:4/A3?;/D86=8@830465 - 8 - 476<47@4@8;5C3:;7A0@;@834=@840C337=;BB6@@35 CE@834993::47@ # 7ED4E6@60?;/@83:34/735/64:->5A3@;?;/B 47;9676;74?@3/@83?>::?:35A35@/64:67@84@/3A4/5 #* 1 ?;/ @83 9>/9;03 ;? ?67567A ;>@ D83@83/@833BC4/A;>753/3=@6;7#;?@83=@D;>:5 C3499:6=4C:3@;@83=403;/7;@@860;>/@6004@60?635@84@ @83 4::3A4@6;70 67 @83 =;B9:467@ 475 @83 =84/A3!0833@ B4@3/64:0 D;>:5 7;@ C3 0>??6=637@ 37;>A8 @; 671;<3 @83 3BC4/A;>753/3=@6;7#;?@83=@ # 4167A 0465 @8>0 @83 73H@ =;7@37@6;7 @84@ 60 @4<37;7C384:?;?@83/309;7537@0@;;99;03@8349934: 60@84@4==>0356008;D740474C0=;7567A4==>035 #. @607;5;>C@@/>3@84@@83=84/A3!0833@=4B3 @; C3 ?6:35 ;7 $$"+$+" C3?;/3 @83 :34/735 93=64: ->5A3 D83/367 :34/735 93=64: ->5A3 840 56/3=@35 @83 - 9 - ;??6=3 @; 13/6?E @83 =84/A3!0833@ 9493/0 475 9>@ >9 @83 B4@@3/?;/@4<67A=;A76I47=3 +$ 5B6@@35:E @83 4993::47@ D40 7;@ 4146:4C:3 @; @8367130@6A4@67A4A37=EC3?;/3@83=84/A3!0833@60?6:35 >@ 8;D 475 >753/ D84@ =6/=>B0@47=30 4 93/0;7 @; C3 @3/B35404C0=;7567A4==>035607;:;7A3/ - +# 4@374 ;? F>56=64: A/;>750 D;>:5 04E @84@ @83 B3/34C037=3;?@834==>0354@@83@6B3;?67130@6A4@6;7 D;>:57;@C3@3/B3540474C0=;7567A4==>035674A6137 =403 ++ 83 4993::47@ 845 499/;4=835 @83 60@/6=@ ;>/@ ?;/ A/47@ ;? 47@6=694@;/E C46: B>=8 C3?;/3 @83 =84/A3!0833@60?6:35 + )>/@83/D837 860 /3G>30@ D40/3F3=@35 C3?;/3 @83 93=64: ;>/@ 83 845 499/;4=835 @860 ;>/@ 67 / ;+$$$ +$+"4754=;!;/5674@3C37=8;?@860;>/@67 >BB3/ 4=4@6;7 ! +$+" CE ;/53/ 54@35 $$"+$+" - 10 - 9400354767@3/6B;/53/ 40@83;??37=304::3A35@; &'=@ + 4<67A7;@3;?@83034093=@0;?@83B4@@3/@83 56??3/37=3 C3@D337 @83 940067A ;? 67@3/6B ;/53/ 475 @83 ?6:67A;?=84/A3!0833@C3?;/393=64:;>/@60;7:E54E0 @860;>/@60;?@83=;70653/35;9676;7@84@6?@834993::47@ 60 56/3=@35 @; 0>//3753/ C3?;/3 @83 7130@6A4@67A ??6=3/ 4754:0;49934/C3?;/3@8393=64:;>/@@833750;?@83 F>0@6=3D;>:5B3@ +" )>/@83/ 6? @83 4993::47@ F;670 67130@6A4@6;7 CE 49934/67AC3?;/3@837130@6A4@67A??6=3/;7494/@6=>:4/ 54@3475>753/A;:6B6@3593/6;5;?=>0@;564:67@3//;A4@6;7 475 6? 47E 67=/6B674@67A B4@3/64:0 4/3 ?;>75 67 0>=8 67@3//;A4@6;7 93/B6@@67A @83 9/;03=>@6;7 @; ?6:3 4556@6;74: 0>99:3B37@4/E =84/A3!0833@ D;>:5 B33@ @83 3750;?F>0@6=3 + ==;/567A:E@83?;::;D67A - 11 - 6' 8349934:604::;D35 66' 993::47@6056/3=@35@;49934/C3?;/3@83 7130@6A4@67A ??6=3/ 9;06@613:E ;7 +"$*+$+"4@#$$$4B 666' 83 7130@6A4@67A ??6=3/ 60 4@ :6C3/@E @; @4<3 @83 4993::47@ @; =>0@;5E 475 =;B9:3@3 @83 =>0@;564: 67@3//;A4@6;7 ;7 @8304B354EC3?;/3$$9B4754?@3/ =>0@;564:67@3//;A4@6;7@834993::47@084:: C337:4/A35;7C46:CE@4<67A493/0;74: C;75 ?;/ 4 0>B ;? 0"$$$$ ! D6@8 ;73 0>/3@E?;/@83:6<30>B 61' ? 47E >03?>: B4@3/64: 60 3:6=6@35 67 @83 =>0@;564: 67@3//;A4@6;7 @83 67130@6A4@67A 4A37=E 60 4@ :6C3/@E @; ?6:3 4556@6;74: 0>99:3B37@4/E=84/A3!0833@ 1' 993::47@ 084:: =;!;93/4@3 D6@8 @83 7130@6A4@67A??6=3/674::/3093=@0 16' 993::47@ 084:: 7;@ @8/34@37 @83 9/;03=>@6;7D6@7300306747EB4773/ - 12 - 166' 993::47@084::4@@375@83;>/@/3A>:4/:E 1666' 993::47@ 084:: 7;@ :3413 @83 F>/6056=@6;7 ;? @83 4:4C>/4A6 60@/6=@ D6@8;>@ 9/6;/ 93/B6006;7 6H' 6;:4@6;7 ;? 47E ;73 ;? @83 =;756@6;70 D;>:5 37@6@:3@839/;03=>@6;7@;033< ?;/ =47=3::4@6;7;?@83C46: 5 ! )&* " 60@;#:;#$