- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '#( ) !" # $ % & ""' !"( ( & !()) *+ , * !" # $ + * - ++ (% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ')$% & + &""'(" + (("! + . +& / + % 012345012678094:;<=;45:>30: ( 5>:1??01@>:<>@03161>9:44501A123;<4502>=791@ >9 ;(("! 31403 ""'(" ?1::03 =B 450 33>4>;91@ 09>;2>C>@+736019333@14>312$<;2:5;24 D4502>=791@E% ) 9F7203G@1>8194 A1: 1603 " B012: 3;>96 162>G7@4720 193 13C;G1GB 0 804 A>45 19 1GG>3094 ;9 !"("'193<>@031G@1>8?04>4>;9G@1>8>96G;8?09:14>;9;< :'!(""" 50 2>=791@ 1<402 G;9:>302>96 094>20 0C>309G0 ;9 20G;23 6219403 19 18;794 ;< :!! A>45 >94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< H ?02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< ?04>4>;9 4>@@ 201@>:14>;9 - 3 - 662>0C03=B 450 :1>3;2302 45>: 1??01@ >: <>@03 >9 A5>G5>4>:G;940930345144501??0@@19451::7:41>90362>0C;7: >9F72>0: 1@@ ;C02 450 =;3B 193 0I18>903 450 3;G4;2 0 A1: 0129>96 :)"""" ?02 8;945 50 3;G4;2 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>@>4B1:H=744502>=791@51:9;4G;9:>30203450:180 ;945062;7934514>4A>@@9;41<<0G45>:;GG7?14>;94>:<724502 G;9409303 4514 450 18;794 6219403 79302 ;4502 5013: 120 80160245020<;2020J70:403<;209519G08094 0<74>96 450 :7=8>::>;9;< 450 @012903 G;79:0@ <;2 450 1??0@@194 450 G;79:0@ <;2 450 20:?;93094 51: G;9409303 4514 450 2>=791@ 51: 2>654@B G;9:>30203 1@@ 450 1:?0G4: 1: :7G5>4>:4;=0G;9<>2803193:;76544;3>:8>::4501??01@ 5;765 G@1>8194 51: :41403 4514 50 >: ?21G4>G>96 13C;G140 50 51: 9;4 <>@03 19B 204729: 0 804 A>45 19 1GG>3094 ;9 !"("' 509G0 1: ?02 450 67>30@>90: ;< 450 *129141K1 4140061@ 02C>G0:745;2>4B4509;4>;91@>9G;80 ;<:"(">:4;=041K09:50A1:1603"B012:450 87@4>?@>02 >: 4; =0 41K09 1: DE 0 0I18>903 3;G4;2 &( &( >: 19 ;245;?03>G :7260;9 193 50 4201403 450 1??0@@194 G;9:02C14>C0@B 193 50 :41403 4514 45020 A1: 1 81@79>403 - 4 - <21G4720 ;< G@1C>G1@ @14021@ )23 A>45 3>:?@1G08094 193 81@79>;9 ;<(93193)232>=:193501@:;9;4>G031=;7481@79>403<21G4720 ;< 5013 ;< ?2;I>81@ ?51@B9I @>44@0 <>9602 193 45020 >: 1 81@1@>698094 ;< 8041G12?;?51@19601@ F;>94 193 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>@>4B;<2>6547??02@>8=4;190I4094;<H502>=791@ 51: 9;4 G;9:>30203 450 3>:1=>@>4B ;9 450 62;793 4514 >4 >: 9;4 5723@0 4; 450 1??0@@194 >9 G;94>97>96 45>: ?2;<0::>;9 09G0 45>:;724G;9:>302>9645081@79>403<21G4720:193160;<450 G@1>8194 <>93: 201:;91=@0 4; 41K0 450 3>:1=>@>4B 1: H GG;23>96@B450@;::;<<747200129>96G1?1G>4BG;80:4; "("I(IIHL:"" ' :?02I((4502>=791@51:62194031918;794 ;< :'! 4;A123: 803>G1@ 0I?09:0: 193 >4 9003: 9; >9402<0209G0 ! 50 G;8?09:14>;9 6219403 79302 450 5013: ?1>9 193 :7<<02>96 >: 4; =0 09519G03 4; :'""" 193 @;:: ;< 1809>4>0: 4; :(""" 193 :)"""" >: 4; =0 6219403 4;A123: 4219:?;2414>;9 0I421 9;72>:58094 193 144093194 G51260: 193 :""" >: 4; =0 6219403 <;2 20?1>2 ;< 450 C05>G@0 - 5 - 0 8>654 9;4 51C0 14409303 5>: 374B 14@01:4 <;2 1 ?02>;3 ;< 45200 8;945: 45020<;20 :)"'" $"("I)% >: 6219403793024505013@;::;<>9G;80372>96@1>37??02>;3 " 9 1@@ 450 4;41@ G;8?09:14>;9 G;80: 4; :))'!A>45>94020:414H?0219978<2;84503140;< ?04>4>;94>@@4503140;<201@>M14>;9 50 G;8?09:14>;9 1A12303 =B 450 2>=791@ >: 8;3><>031:79302 *+,- ./0120- ;::;<>9G;80 "" (1>9193:7<<02>96 '""" );::;<1809>4>0: (""" 03>G1@0I?09:0: '! 219:?;2414>;9 0I421 9;72>:58094 193144093194G51260: )"""" ;:: ;< 0129>96 372>96 @1>3 7? ?02>;3<;2)8;945: )"'" '0?1>2;<450C05>G@0 """ 1+3 44 5 GG;23>96@B 450 G@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 <;2 1 4;41@ G;8?09:14>;9 ;< -44 5 >0 09519G03 G;8?09:14>;9 ;<: 65 - 6 - ( 945020:7@4450<;@@;A>96;2302>:?1::03 >% 501??01@>: >>% 50G@1>8194>:094>4@03<;214;41@G;8?09:14>;9;< :))'! A>45 >94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< H ?02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< ?04>4>;9 4>@@ 450 3140 ;< 201@>M14>;9 >>>% 0:?;93094 9:7219G0 G;8?19B 51: 1@2013B 30?;:>403 450 18;794 1A12303 =B 450 2>=791@ 509G0 0:?;93094 ;( >: 3>20G403 4; 30?;:>4 450 09519G03 G;8?09:14>;9 ;< :(!"" A>45 >94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< H ?1 A>45>9 ;90 8;945 <2;84503140;<45>:;2302 >C% 9 :7G5 30?;:>4 450 1??0@@194 >: ?028>4403 4; A>45321A 450 094>20 18;794 1@;96 A>45 >94020:4 1GG2703;9>4 -,5 '&!! ( % >:4; @;(