- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) * ! " # $ % $ & ' % % ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # )# !! ) $ % $)*"! & ' % + ( , '( % % $ ,)!)! % $ )%% $ % ,,! $ - $ % . $ - 3 - % /01 233425 01 60547 282091: :/4 2;2<7 09 % =,,! 72:47 ,!! 321147 >? :/4 =@<: =6 <09A0325490=<0B05$@784297)%2:%0C2?23@<2'6=< 1/=<:D:/4<0>@925E( 94 @564F2< /40F/ G4: ;0:/ 29 2AA0749: =9 ! !297704701G=:/4<;064297A/057<49605472 A520G34:0:0=9A520G0981!!!!!!)/4<0>@92526:4< A=91074<09849:0<4G2:4<025=9<4A=<78<29:47292G=@9: =6 1*!"*!!) ;0:/ 09:4<41: 2: :/4 <2:4 =6 H 34< 299@G6<=G72:4=634:0:0=9:055<425012:0=9 88<04B47 >? :/4 1207 2;2<7 :/4? 3<464<<47 :/01 233425 09 ;/0A/ 0: 01 G2095? A=9:49:47 :/2: @564F2< /40F/ ;21 2 :4A/90A029 297 42<9098 1#!!!!) 34< G=9:/ @::/4<0>@925/214<<4709:2F098/0109A=G421 1 ");/0A/01=9:/45=;4<1074@<:/4<:/45=11 =6 A=91=<:0@G 01 9=: 8<29:47 := 255 :/4 34<1=91 297 :/4 2G=@9:1 8<29:47 @974< 6@94<25 =>14I@041 A4<4G=9? 297 - 4 - A=9B4?29A4 297 5=11 =6 41:2:4 2<4 =9 2 5=;4< 1074 /4<46=<4<4I@41:476=<49/29A4G49:297G=7060A2:0=9=6 :/4=<74< # 42<7:/42<8@G49:1=6>=:/10741 * J01:/41252<?A4<:060A2:4=6:/474A42147 :1/=;1/018<=111252<?211 ")297:/4<0>@925 /21 <08/:5? :2F49 :/4 12G4 @<:/4< :/4 <0>@925 A=91074<098:/462A::/2:/4;212847 *?42<1*!H;21 27747 :=;2<71 6@:@<4 3<=134A:1 297 747@A:47 #:/ :=;2<7134<1=9254J34914121:/4<42<46=@<74349749:1 297 :2F49 G@5:03504< 21 DE 297 A25A@52:47 :/4 5=11 =6 74349749A?2:*!*!"")297:/01=@<:609719=<421=9 :=09:4<64<4;0:/:/41207=<74<>@::/01=@<:3<=A4471:= 277!H41A252:0=9@974<A=9B49:0=925/4271 AA=<70985? :/4 23345529: = 01 49:0:547 6=< 605025A=91=<:0@G=61##!!!)3345529:=0149:0:547 6=< 13=@125 A=91=<:0@G =6 1##!!!) 3345529: =1 297#2<449:0:5476=<32<49:25A=91=<:0@G=6##!!!42A/ - 5 - 297 251= :/4? 2<4 49:0:547 6=< 1 !!!) @974< A=9B49:0=925/4271 , 9 255 :/4 :=:25 A=G34912:0=9 A=G41 := 1*#!"")21282091:1*!"*!!)2;2<747>?:/4 <0>@925 " /42;2<7321147>?:/4<0>@92501G=70604721 @974< +,-. /01231. =11=64349749A? *!*!"") =11=6=91=<:0@G'605025 13=@12529732<49:25A=91=<:0@G( ,!!!) =11=641:2:42975=11=6 6@94<254J349141 !!!) 2,4 # #5 AA=<70985? :/4 A520G29:1 2<4 49:0:547 6=< 29 49/29A47 A=G34912:0=9 =6 1 "K"") 04 49/29A47 6<=G1*!"*!!):=1*#!"") K 9:/4<41@5::/46=55=;098=<74<01321147 0( /423342501 - 6 - 00( /4 A520G29:1 2<4 49:0:547 6=< 2 :=:25 A=G34912:0=9 =6 1*#!"") 25=98 ;0:/ 09:4<41: 2: H 34< 299@G 6<=G :/4 72:4 =6 34:0:0=9 :055 <4250L2:0=9 =;4B4< 21 34< :/4 =<74< 72:47 !!* :/4 A520G29:1 2<4 9=: 49:0:547 6=< :/4 7452?47 34<0=7 =6 72?1 09 6055098:/4233425 000( 413=9749: = ) 91@<29A4 A=G329? /21 25<427? 743=10:47 :/4 2G=@9: 2;2<747 >? :/4 <0>@925:/4<46=<4<413=9749:=0170<4A:47 := 743=10: :/4 49/29A47 A=G34912:0=9 =6 1 "K"") ;0:/09 =94 G=9:/ 6<=G :/4 72:4 =6:/01=<74< 0B( 9 1@A/ 743=10: 23345529: =;064 =6 :/4 74A42147 01 34<G0::47 := ;0:/7<2; :/4 49:0<4 2G=@9: .-5 '&!! ) % 01:=5=