- 1 - ! "#$% &$'!!!$ $ $ () (*+, )(!!++ - ! ! " # $ % &'& ! ! ' "" & ' ' (%% ' ! & Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " "%% & ' % % & !% ' ! && " & ' %#$ ) & ! ! %#$%%#$ ) & ! *& # ' ' ') ' & '$ " (%" + & & & + * & # , '$ - 3 - & ) ! ) &#$ ) #$ & & & - & & ( & ) ) ) ' ) ) & ) ) ' & ' ) & ) . #& . $ /01234567083045456759:5;08<=4/0304545670>9900?57@ 3>64014567 6>80> A780> 014567 B67042>= >0;50: A780> 01456716B307924567A780>0145672785740>5B>0;50: A780> 014567 " 6: 4/0 &>64014567 6: 6B07 :>6B 6B09451 '56;071014#:6>9/6>4C4/0'14D$&04545670> 6 59 4/0 B64/0>57;2E 6: 4/0 >093678074 278 304545670> 6946 2>094240846<08594274>0;245F09 02>708 16A790; :6>4/0 304545670>9 >0540>2457@ 4/0 @>6A789A>@08574/030454567E6A;816740784/244/030454567 :5;08A780>0145676:4/0'1486097641674257 - 4 - 27= 93015:51 6> 9A<942745F0 2;;0@245679 2@25794 4/0 3>09074 304545670>9=8>2E57@4/06A>4D9244074567464/0>0;245679/53 6: 304545670> 69 46 F59GF59 4/0 /A9<278 278 4/0 >09367807416B3;2572749/09A<B5494/24304545670>6946 2>0 28B54408;= 8594274 >0;245F09 E/6 >09580 9032>240;= 278 86 764 9/2>0 2 86B09451 >0;245679/53 E54/ 4/0 >093678074 4 59 :A>4/0>36574086A44/240F07B2>>50895940>957;2E>095857@57 85::0>074 154509 /2F0 <007 2>>2=08 29 32>4509 278 >0;50: /29 <007 96A@/4 2@25794 4/0B A780> 014567 6: 4/0 ' 14 E54/6A427=:6A78245672;3;02857@9 " /2F0/02>84/0;02>70816A790;:6>4/0304545670>9 /0>0 /29 <007 76 >03>0907424567 67 <0/2;: 6: 4/0 >09367807416B3;257274674/03>0F56A94E6824096:/02>57@ F074682=767023302>9:6>4/0>093678074 ! 0:6>0 28F0>457@ 46 4/0 >5F2; 16740745679 54 59 7010992>= 46 0H4>214 4/0 >0;50:9 96A@/4 57 4/0 30454567 :5;08 A780> 014567 6: 4/0 ' 14 /0 3>2=0> 1;2A90 >028929:6;;6E9 - 5 - ! " # $ %&' $ ())))*+ %,' $ -))))*+ . $ $ -/ ! 0 & 1))/ ! ' " " " . $ -/)))*+ " ' 2 $ " $ " " " # - 6 - %' ! -3 1) 11 4 1( ! 0 & 1))/ %' $ $ -/ * 11 ! 0 & 1))/ %' ! . 5 1( %' ! 6 %' /596A>42;961679580>954233>63>52404628F0>446 4/0 2F0>B0749 57 32>2@>23/ ( 6: 4/0 30454567 E/0>057 4/0 304545670>9/2F0:A>759/0880425;9>0@2>857@4/0>0;245679/536: 304545670> 69 46 E54/ 4/0 /A9<278 278 4/0 >09367807482A@/40>57;2E 45923369540460H4>21432>2@>23/ (6:4/030454567E/51/>028929:6;;6E9 7 2 8 1 3 " " " 9 " 5 1%' 1%' & - 7 - $ * 8 1 8 - 8 ( + + , & " 8 : 8 / " + + 8 ; 8 < + + 8 3 8 < " . . 5 1( %' ! 6 %' /596A>42;961679580>954233>63>52404628F0>446 4/0 2F0>B0749 57 32>2@>23/ ( 6: 4/0 30454567 E/0>057 4/0 304545670>9/2F0:A>759/0880425;9>0@2>857@4/0>0;245679/536: 304545670> 69 46 E54/ 4/0 /A9<278 278 4/0 >09367807482A@/40>57;2E 45923369540460H4>21432>2@>23/ (6:4/030454567E/51/>028929:6;;6E9 7 2 8 1 3 " " " 9 " 5 1%' 1%' & - 7 - $ * 8 1 8 - 8 ( + + , & " 8 : 8 / " + + 8 ; 8 < + + 8 3 8 < " . " " & 9 # 9 % 7B0451A;6A90H2B57245676:4/02F0>B0749B280 574/016B3;257454590F580744/244/0>09367807416B3;257274 /28B6F086A46:4/0B24>5B6752;/6B0574/0=02>()6> >028= >0:0>0710 4/0 >0;0F274 36>4567 6: 4/0 16B3;2574 59 - 8 - >0IA5>08 46 <0 0H4>21408 116>857@;= @>6A78 6#>$ 59 >03>68A108/0>057<0;6E 1%' 2 -<*)/*1)-7 8 - " + 2 $ 8 - " " 7 0H2B5757@ 4/0 0H4>21408 36>45679 6: 4/0 3;02857@9 54 <016B09 2<A78274;= 1;02> 4/24 6E57@ 46 B24>5B6752; 85916>8 4/0 >09367807416B3;257274 ;0:4 4/0 B24>5B6752; /6B0 57 4/0 =02> ( /24 59 8003;= 85916710>457@ 59 4/24 4/0 >093678074 /29 1/6907 46 2>>2= 30>9679E/62>05776B2770>167701408E54//0>86B09451;5:0 - 9 - 6> B24>5B6752; 2::25>9 /0 B240>72; @>278B64/0> 6: 4/0 /A9<278E/659/0>90;:25;57@J2B2>>50895940>57;2E>095857@ 278 E6>?57@ 57 07@2;A>A E54/ B2K67J 2 :>5078 6: 4/0 /A9<278J 2 8594274 >0;245F0 6: 304545670> 6B64/0>57;2EJ 4/0B240>72;A71;06:4/0/A9<278J4/0<>64/0>6:4/0B240>72; @>278B64/0>J 2780F07 4/0@>27882A@/40> 6: 304545670> 6 /2F0 2;; <007 5B3;02808 E54/6A4 27= :6A78245672; 2;;0@245679 /0903;02857@9674/0:2106:54>0:;01427578591>5B57240278 9E00357@ >6357@ 57 6: 0H407808 :2B5;= B0B<0>9 E/6 28B54408;= >09580 9032>240;= 278 E/6 9/2>0 76 86B09451 >0;245679/53 29 07F592@08 A780> 0145679 #:$ 278 #9$ 6: 4/0 '14 /0 &>64014567 6: 6B07 :>6B 6B09451 '56;0710 14592>0B0852;9424A40574078084692:0@A2>8E6B07 :>6B 86B09451 F56;0710 2 96152; 0F5; 4/24 59 A780752<;= E58093>028 6E0F0> 4/0 9424A46>= 3>64014567 59 764 A7<6A7808 /0 14 16740B3;2409 5740>F074567 67;= E/07 2 E6B27 59 2<;0 46 80B6794>240 4/24 9/0 /29 <007 9A<L014084686B09451F56;0710244/0/27896:/0>/A9<2786> /59>0;245F09 016@75K57@4/243>6901A4567A780>014567!( - 10 - 6:4/0 &2;670E29579A::51507457288>09957@B27=:6>B96: 86B094512<A904/00@59;24A>007214084/0'14463>6F580 <>6280> 278 B6>0 5BB085240 15F5; >0B08509 571;A857@ 3>640145676>80>9>095807106>80>9278B67042>=>0;50:9 ( /5;04/0 14860930>B54272@@>50F08E6B2746 3>61008 764 67;= 2@25794 4/0 /A9<278 <A4 2;96 2@25794 /59 >0;245F09 278 2:40> 4/0 2B078B074 0F07 2@25794 2 :0B2;0 >0;245F04/09424A46>=91/0B03>09A3369094/244/03;02857@9 BA948591;69024 ;029496B0:6>B6:2<A906>4/>024E/04/0> 3/=9512;90HA2;F0><2;0B645672;6>01676B51/01459764 8095@708 46 <0 57F6?08 B01/27512;;= 6> 29 27 5794>AB074 6: /2>299B074 /59 6A>4 /29 6<90>F08 E54/ 16710>7 27 571>02957@ 4>078 E/0>057 8093540 4/0 E5:0 /2F57@ 28B54408;= B6F086A46:4/0B24>5B6752;/6B0;67@2@6278>095857@E54/ /0> 32>0749 304545679 A780> 014567 2>0 :5;08 2:40> 2 1679580>2<;0 ;2390 6: 45B0 578591>5B57240;= 2>>2=57@ 0F0>= B0B<0> 6: 4/0 /A9<278D9 0H407808 :2B5;= 5>>0930145F0 6: E/04/0>286B09451>0;245679/530F0>0H59408 /0 3>09074 1290 59 2 1;29951 5;;A94>24567 6: 9A1/ B59A90 /0 >093678074 /29 764 67;= 3>6100808 2@25794 4/0 - 11 - /A9<278 <A4 /29 @670 46 4/0 0H4074 6: 5B3;512457@ @>278B64/0>9 8594274 >0;245F09 :>50789 16;;240>2; >0;245F09 278 0F07 @>2781/5;8>07 6: 8594274 >0;245F09 6: 4/0 /A9<278 7670 6: E/6B /2F0 27= >6;0 6> 3>6H5B54= 46 4/0 B2>542; 85916>8 7 4/0 2<90710 6: 93015:51 2F0>B0749 1679454A457@ 86B09451 F56;0710 278 57 F50E 6: 4/0 28B54408 :214 4/24 4/0 /A9<278 /29 95710 329908 2E2= 4/0 167457A24567 6: 3>6100857@9 A780> 014567 6: 4/0 ' 14 2@25794 4/090 304545670>9 E6A;8 2B6A74 46 9/00> 2<A90 6: 3>61099 /0 304545670>9 <057@ 0;80>;= 30>9679 8594274 >0;245F09 278 5785F58A2;9 >095857@ :2> 2E2= 127764 <0 16B30;;08 46 A780>@6 4/0 6>802; 6: 3>6;67@08 B5910;;2706A9 3>6100857@9 E/07 4/0 16B3;2574 5490;: :25;9 46 8591;690 27= 86B09451 >0;245679/53 6> 2145672<;0B591678A14;;6E57@9A1/3>6100857@946167457A0 E6A;876467;=12A90A78A03>0LA8510<A42;9680:0244/0F0>= 6<L014 6: 4/0 14 E/51/ 59 46 3>64014 @07A570 F5145B9 >24/0> 4/2746:215;54240F0H2456A9;545@24567 7 4/0 1679580>08 6357567 6: 4/59 6A>4 4/0>0:6>0 4/0 3>6100857@9 29 2@25794 4/0 304545670>9 2>0 E/6;;= - 12 - A79A942572<;0 57 ;2E 278 2>0 ;52<;0 46 <0 IA29/08 46 3>0F074 B5912>>52@06:LA945102782F658A77010992>=/2>299B074 )6> 4/0 :6>0@657@ >029679 4/59 6A>4 3>610089 46 32994/0:6;;6E57@ #5$/03045456759" #55$ /0 3>6100857@9 57 >5B572; 591 6 (307857@674/0:5;06:4/0 88545672;5F5; A8@0278)2;2<A>2@5575452408A780>014567 6: 4/0 &>64014567 6: 6B07 :>6B 6B09451 '56;0710 14 5796:2> 29 4/090 304545670>9 2>0 16710>7082>0/0>0<=IA29/08 !., (!!$ $+ ' 5946;6 495