- 1 - !!" !#$# % $"&&" ""'' (&) * ! " "# $ ! # ! % &" & ! # %& '& () % & Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & %&* & '& & ()" $ ! # !# %" ( ' & & + $! ,-../01201 34516/07 -05 -8-95 5-7/5 :-;;/5<= /02>9 2?2.451/-05 (455/<2,-.!@>9 ;,>97+92<40-.+#20 0>%"7,2;-::/-.2;@2./5 92 ,-9-0-<-;-::- -72. ./-90/5 A>40;/. ;4<6277/5-::/-.8-;<=20;49/9A,-../01201-8-95>0.2-<2.27= -05 B4-0746 7 8-; ;4<6277/5 -8-95 26:410/5 ,/9/20 8-; :-;;/520A.-26:/7272>0@2./5405/9 /A72>0 >@A7 - 3 - AA499/0A/>@-AA25/0720?>.?20120;49/56>7>9A=A./ ./-52017>A.-26-07;4;7-20201203492/;2;0>72052;:47/78-; ;4<6277/5925/9>@6>7>9A=A./,-5<>99>8/527@9>6>80/97 8-; ;4<6277/5 -; :/9 A.-26-07 >0 CC 201-::- !925/9#-.>01827,-./::-!:2..2>0925/9#(A.-26-07,/9/208/9/ 925201 6>7>9A=A./ 0>*( ((CC) >0 */6<,-?2(40-;,-12 9>-5-0>7,/9?/,2A./A-6/@9>6>::>;27/529/A72>0209-;,-05 0/1.21/07 6-00/9 -05 5-;,/5 -1-20;7 A.-26-07D; 6>7>9A=A./ A-4;201-AA25/07@@/05201?/,2A./5250>7;7>:-05A.-26-07; 8/9/ 40-8-9/ -<>47 :-972A4.-9; 0 ;-25 -AA25/07 A.-26-07 ,/9/20 ;4;7-20/5 192/?>4; 203492/; -05 -56277/5 7> ,>;:27-. /;:27/ 79/-76/07 ,/ -../1/5 7> ,-?/ ;4;7-20/5 :/96-0/07 52;-<2.27= -05 .>;; >@ /-90201 A-:-A27= -05 @2./5 A.-26 :/7272>0 405/9 /A72>0 >@A725/9(201-::-;4;7-20/5@-7-. 203492/; -05 52/52; ./1-. 9/:9/;/07-72?/; @2./5 A.-26 :/7272>0 -.;> 405/9 /A72>0 >@ A7 -05 ;-6/ 8/9/ A.4<</5 7>1/7,/9 " 0 ;/9?2A/ >@ 0>72A/ >80/9 >@ 20;49/5 ?/,2A./ 525 0>7 -::/-9 -05 8-; :.-A/5 0;49/9 >::>;/5 A.-26 :/7272>0;>0?-92>4;19>405; - 4 - 7 8-; A>07/05/5 7,-7 925/9 >@ 6>7>9A=A./ ,26;/.@ 8-;0/1.21/07209252016>7>9A=A./-05>0.=7>@-;7/0.2-<2.27=>0 20;49/9 A>6:.-207 8-; @2./5 -1-20;7 40E0>80 ?/,2A./ 7 8-; -.;> -../1/5 7,-7 925/9 >@ 6>7>9A=A./ 525 0>7 ,-?/ ?-.25 -05 /@@/A72?/592?201.2A/0A/ -;/5 >0 :./-5201; 792<40-. @9-6/5 2;;4/; -05 9/A>95/5 /?25/0A/ 7,/9 A.-26-07; -05 A.-26-07 ,/9/20 8/9/ /F-620/5 -; ; -05 -05 F,2<27; 7> 8/9/ 1>7 6-9E/50;49/9/F-620/527;>@@2A2-.-;-051>76-9E/5 F,2<27;-05 0 A>0;25/9-72>0 792<40-. ,/.5 -AA25/07 ,-5 >AA499/554/7>4;/>@20;49/5?/,2A./-05A.-26-07,/9/20,-5 ;4;7-20/5203492/;>8/?/927-8-95/51.><-.A>6:/0;-72>0>@ ;%( -05 ,/.5 20;49/9 .2-<./ 7> :-= ;-6/ 1192/?/5 20;49/98-;20-::/-. ) 78-;@29;7.=;4<6277/5925/9>@6>7>9A=A./8-;0>7 ,>.5201 ?-.25 -05 /@@/A72?/ 592?201 .2A/0A/ -05 7,>41, ;:/A2@2A A>07/072>0 491/5 7,-7 A.-26-07; >9 >80/9%925/9 @-2./5 7> :9>54A/592?201.2A/0A/20;49/9A>4.50>7</6-5/.2-<./78-; @497,/9 A>07/05/5 A>6:.-207 -1-20;7 7,295 :-97= ?/,2A./ 8-; - 5 - 0>7 ;4<;7-072-7/5 -; :>.2A/ -@7/9 20?/;721-72>0 ,-; @2./5 G D 9/:>97,4;-AA25/0720B4/;72>0,-5>AA499/554/7>9-;,-05 0/1.21/07925201>@6>7>9A=A./<=27;925/9-0520;49/98>4.50>7 </ .2-<./ 7 8-; ;4<6277/5 -8-95 >@ ;%( -; 1.><-. A>6:/0;-72>0 20 A.-26 :/7272>0 @2./5 405/9 /A72>0 >@ A7 827,>47 /F-620201 -0= >A7>9 8-; /FA/;;2?/ -05 A-../5 @>9 207/9@/9/0A/ 0 -<>?/ 19>405; ;>41,7 7> -..>8 -::/-. C 0 >7,/9 ,-05 92 -9;,-?-95,-0 -.2:-72. ./-90/5 A>40;/. @>9 A.-26-07 ;4<6277/5 7,-7 :>.2A= 2;;4/5 7> 20;49/5?/,2A./8-;A>6:9/,/0;2?/:>.2A=-05A.-26-07,/9/20 8-;:2..2>0925/9,/9/@>9/20;49/9A-00>7/;A-:/.2-<2.27=/?/0 2@ 27 8/9/ 7> </ :9/;46/5 7,-7 925/9 525 0>7 ,-?/ ?-.25 -05 /@@/A72?/ 592?201 .2A/0A/ -; :/9 5/A2;2>0 >@ >0D<./ 4:9/6/ >49720A-;/ 9/:>97/520 7 8-; 0/F7.= ;4<6277/5 .2-<2.27= >@ 20;49/9 20;>@-9 -; :2..2>0 925/9 8,> 8>4.5 </ 7,295 :-97= 8>4.5 </ ;7-747>9= -05 40.2627/5 -05 A,-../01/ >0 B4-0746 8>4.5 0>7 </ - 6 - ;4<;7-072-7/5/?/020A.-26:/7272>0@2./5405/9 /A72>0 >@ A70;-2519>405;;>41,7@>952;62;;-.>@-::/-. /-95 ./-90/5 A>40;/. -05 :/94;/5 26:410/5 34516/07-05-8-95 9>6 -<>?/ >AA499/0A/ >@ -AA25/07 20?>.?201 20;49/5?/,2A./-05A.-26-07;4;7-2020120349=2;0>72052;:47/ 56277/5.= A.-26 :/7272>0 2; @2./5 405/9 /A72>0 >@ A7 ,/9/@>9/ 7,/9/ 8>4.5 </ 0> 0//5%>AA-;2>0 @>9 792<40-. 7> ;:/.. >0 0/1.21/0A/ 7 8>4.5 ;4@@2A/ 2@ ?2A726 ,-; ;4;7-20/5203492/;>47>@4;/>@20;49/5?/,2A./ 0;>@-9 -; A,-../01/ >0 .2-<2.27= 27 2; ;//0 7,-7 A.-26-07,/9/208-;:2..2>0925/98,>8>4.5</7,295:-97=-05 /?/0 2@ 27 8/9/ 7> </ /;7-<.2;,/5 -<>47 925/9 0>7 :>;;/;;201 ?-.25 -05 /@@/A72?/ 592?201 .2A/0A/ -; :/9 5/A2;2>0 >@ >0D<./ 4:9/6/ >49720 A-;/!;4:9-#20;49/9A-00>7/;A-:/ .2-<2.27= " 0;>@-9-;B4-07467,>41,272;A.-26:/7272>0@2./5 405/9 /A72>0 >@A7-;0>7/5<=792<40-.9/@/992017> F(8>405 A/972@2A-7/ A.-26-07 ,/9/20 ,-5 ;4;7-20/5 - 7 - @9-A749/; -05 203492/; 8/9/ 192/?>4; 20 0-749/ 56277/5.= -AA25/07>AA499/5:92>97>>62;;2>0>@ A,/54./>@A7 7 8>4.5 :9>?25/ ;%( 7>8-95; G:-20 -05 ;4@@/9201D @>9 192/?>4; 203492/; -05 -8-95 >@ ;%( 7>8-95; 6/52A-. /F:/0;/; -05 -:-97 @9>6 ;-6/ 7,/9/ 8>4.5 </ :9>?2;2>0 @>9 G.>;; >@ 20A>6/ 549201 .-25 4: :/92>5D ?/0 2@ :/92>5 >@ 6>07,;2;7-E/0-;.-=>@@-;A.-26-07,/9/20;4;7-20/5@9-A749/ -05 ,/ 6-=<//0727./5 @>9 6>9/ A>6:/0;-72>0 7,-0 -8-95/5 <= 792<40-. ,/9/@>9/ -::/-. >0 B4-0746 8>4.5 0>7 </ 34;72@2/5 /0A/ 0> 19>405 7> 207/9@/9/ >0;/B4/07.= @>..>8201& ! !2# ::/-.2; H-05 !22# 6>407205/:>;272;>95/9/57></79-0;6277/5 7>792<40-.@>9:-=6/07>8/?/9272;A.-92@2/5 7,-752;62;;-.>@7,2;-::/-.8>4.50>7A>6/20 8-=>@20;49/9491201>7,/919>405;20-::/-. @2./5-1-20;7-8-9520 0> %" "+, (&&") $! 2;7>& .>&