- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## # '( ')*+ ' ** , !!!! " #$$ % & !' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ & !!!! " #$ ( !!)! &% ) #% ) & ! ! # &% *!& $ $ !! *! & $ $ & !! $ !! & + !'! , + &( - 3 - - $ " # - $ % ./0123456/72/3434564894:/7;67/</03456)</17 =43. /03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@ ;<1@8.1 16.431 ! 18814:46? 3./ 0560;<</63 5<7/<8 59 3./ 5;<38 A/:5= </B/0346? 2/343456/<-8 122:4013456 94:/7 ;67/< /03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@ ;<1@8.1 16.431 ! 8//@46? 463/<4C 0;8357> 59 3./ 835:/6 ?5:7/6 5<61C/638 8/4D/7 46 <4C/ 5*! </?483/</7 95< 3./ 599/60/ 59 3./93 ./ 122:4013456 48 </B/03/7 56 3./ ?<5;67 3.13 46E540/8A4::8 2<57;0/7 A> 3./ 2/343456/< 75 6539;::>31::>=43.3./7/80<4234568593./</0/4E/71<340:/8 ;<8;163 35 1 05C2:1463 :57?/7 A> 56/ .1<13 ;C1< 1 018/ 01C/ 35 A/ </?483/</7 46 <4C/ 5*! 56 !! 95< 3./ 599/60/8 2;648.1A:/ ;67/</034568*#%167)#%593./.1<134>1>1>1 16.431!;<46?3./05;<8/5946E/834?134560/<3146 - 4 - ?5:7 5<61C/638 =/</ </05E/</7 167 8/4D/7 ;67/< 3=5 8/21<13/ <52/<3> 5<C8 A/1<46? 5F!! 167 5F! ./ 2/343456/< =.5 48 56/ 59 3./ 122:401638 167 1 2<58/0;3456 =436/88 94:/7 16 122:4013456 8//@46? 463/<4C 0;8357> 59 3./ 8/4D/7 5<61C/638 ./ :/1<6/7 1?483<13/ .5=/E/< </B/03/7 3./ 8147 122:4013456 56 3./ ?<5;673.133./2;<0.18/A4::82<57;0/7A>3./2/343456/< 747 653 05<</82567 =43. 3./ 7/80<423456 59 3./ </05E/</7 43/C81673.1385C/593./1<340:/8=/</6538;225<3/7A> 16>750;C/631<>2<559 6 3./ 2</8/63 2/343456 43 48 0563/67/7 3.13 =.4://G/<04846?25=/<8;67/</034568167'593./ 57/ 59 <4C461: <50/7;</ F' 3./ 5;<3 48 56:> </H;4</735/68;</2<52/<167819/0;8357>593./2<52/<3> 2/6746?3<41:167653350560:;84E/:>7/3/<C46/5=6/<8.42 5<343:/3489;<3./<;<?/73.133./056346;/7</3/6345659 ?5:7 5<61C/638 46 3./ 0;8357> 59 3./ 25:40/ 8/<E/8 65 ;8/9;: 2;<258/ 167 3.13 3./4< 463/<4C </:/18/ 35 3./ - 5 - 2/343456/<8;AB/03358;431A:/0567434568=5;:7819/?;1<7 3./463/</8359A53.3./2<58/0;34561673./2/343456/< 3./:/1<6/7 4?.5;<35E/<6C/63 :/17/< 122/1<46? 95< 3./ 313/ 8;225<38 3./ 4C2;?6/7 5<7/< 167 8;AC438 3.13 3./ 7480</2160> A/3=//6 3./ 46E540/82<57;0/7A>3./2/343456/<1673./21<340;:1<859 3./</05E/</75<61C/6380</13/88/<45;875;A3</?1<746? 3./2/343456/<+85=6/<8.423483./</95</0563/67/73.13 3./ 8/4D/7 5<61C/638 8.5;:7 056346;/ 35 </C146 46 3./ 0;8357>593./6E/834?1346?9940/<;634:0560:;8456593./ 3<41: 6 :4?.3 59 3./ <4E1: 0563/634568 3./ 95::5=46? 2546381<48/95<056847/<13456 - 6 - * /95</ 17E/<346? 35 3./ 91038 59 3./ 2</8/63 018/ 43 48 6/0/881<> 35 653/ 3.13 /03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@;<1@8.1 16.431! /C25=/<8 3./ <4C461:5;<3835C1@/122<52<413/5<7/<895<3./2<52/< 0;8357> 2</8/<E13456 167 </:/18/ 59 2<52/<3> 460:;746? 835:/61<340:/82/6746?46H;4<>5<3<41: ' ./ 56+A:/ ;2</C/ 5;<3 46 !" .18 013/?5<401::> ./:7 3.13 E1:;1A:/ 1<340:/8 167 2<52/<34/8 8.5;:7 653 A/ @/23 46 25:40/ 0;8357> 95< 16 ;67;:>:56?2/<4571673.135;<388.5;:7/G/<048/25=/<8 ;67/</03456'593./57/59<4C461:<50/7;</F' #161:5?5;8 35 /03456 ! 59 3./ !% 35 5<7/< </:/18/ 59 8;0. 2<52/<3> 193/< 2</21<46? 1 7/314:/7 2160.61C1 31@46? 2.535?<12.8 167 5A314646? 122<52<413/A56785<;67/<31@46?835/68;</2<57;0345659 3./2<52/<3>7;<46?3<41: - 7 - ) ./ ;67/<:>46? 5AB/03 59 /03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@ ;<1@8.1 16.431 ! 48 35 /68;</ 2<52/<0;8357>1672</8/<E13456592<52/<3>2/6746?3<41: =43.5;3/63/<46?463510560:;84E/7/3/<C461345659343:/5< 5=6/<8.42./813489103456</H;4</7;67/<3./2<5E4845648 56:> 1835 /6343:/C/63 35 2588/8845605;2:/7 =43. 17/H;13/ 819/?;1<78 35 2</8/<E/ 3./ /E47/6341<> E1:;/593./2<52/<3>0560/<6/7 F 6 018/8 46E5:E46? 3./93 59 B/=/:<> 43 48 653 ;605CC56 3.13 0/<3146 43/C8 C1> A/ 5:7 5< </C17/ 5<61C/638 :10@46? 0563/C25<1<> 2;<0.18/ 46E540/8 167 3./ 7/84?68 5< =/4?.38 C1> E1<> 7;/ 35 =/1< </214< 5< </7/84?6 /05E/<> C1.1D1<8 ?/6/<1::> 2<5E47/ A<517 7/80<4234568 ./</95</46848346?56 1 83<403 43/C3543/C 05<</:13456 A/3=//6 3./ </05E/</7 5<61C/638 167 3./ 2;<0.18/ A4::8 =5;:7 7/9/13 3./ E/<> 5AB/03 167 824<43 59 /03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@ ;<1@8.1 16.431 ! =.40. 48 463/67/7 35 /68;</ 819/ A;3 2<103401: 0;8357><13./<3.163517B;74013/2<52<4/31<><4?.38 - 8 - ! 6 3./ 2</8/63 018/ 3./ 2/343456/< 1:56? =43. 53./<05C2:1461638481?5:7=.5:/81:/<167481:85043/7 18 1 2<58/0;3456 =436/88 .48 0<;041: 182/03 C/<438 7;/ 056847/<13456=.4:/7/04746?3./122:4013456;67/</03456 ! 59 3./ .1<134>1 1?1<4@ ;<1@8.1 16.431 ! 60/ 43 48 3./ 82/04940 018/ 59 3./ 2<58/0;3456 3.13 3./ 1::/?/73./93500;<</79<5C3./0;8357>593./2/343456/< 3./</4865B;8349401345695<1<5E46?/6H;4<>46355=6/<8.42 5< 343:/ 13 3.48 831?/ /60/ 3./ 946746? 59 A53. 5;<38 A/:5=7/0:4646?463/<4C0;8357>C/</:>563./?<5;6759 C48C130.5946E540/848;68;831461A:/46:1=005<746?:> 5463 5 48 168=/</7 46 3./ 167 3./ 4C2;?6/7 5<7/<8 =1<<163 463/<9/</60/ 95< 653 .1E46? 2<52/<:>122</0413/73./8052/1675AB/0359/03456! 593./.1<134>11?1<4@;<1@8.116.431! 5< 3./ 95</?546? </18568 3.48 5;<3 2<50//78 3521883./95::5=46? - 9 - #4% ./<4C461:/343456481::5=/7 #44% ./ 5<7/< 713/7 !! 2188/7 A> 3./ 77434561:483<403167/884568$;7?/140.;< 843346? 13 467.16;< 46 <4C461: /E48456 /343456 5!! 05694<C46? 3./ 5<7/< 713/7 !! 2188/7 A> 3./ <460421: 4E4: $;7?/ 167 $ 467.16;< #1<4846? 5;3 59 <4C/ 5*! 59 467.16;< 5=6 5:40/ 313456%48./</A>H;18./7 #444% ./:/1<6/7 1?483<13/4874</03/735</:/18/3./ 8/4D/7?5:75<61C/638353./2/343456/<8;AB/03 353./95::5=46?0567434568 #1% ./ 6E/834?1346? 9940/< 8.1:: =43.46 8/E/6 #'% 71>8 2<57;0/ 3./ 8/4D/7 5<61C/638 A/95</3./:/1<6/7 1?483<13/95<2</21<13456 59 1 9</8. 43/C‑=48/ 46E/635<> 65346? 7/80<423456=/4?.3#?<5886/3% - 10 - #A% ./ 5;<3 8.1:: 01;8/ .4?.‑</85:;3456 2.535?<12.859/10.43/C35A/31@/6#9<563 A10@847/%167=./</9/184A:/E47/5?<12.> 59 3./ :53 ./ 46E/635<> 167 2.535?<12.8 8.1::A/84?6/7A>3./ 1?483<13/2/343456/< #0% 256 05C2:/3456 59 0:1;8/8 #1%I#A% 3./ 5<61C/6388.1::A/</:/18/7353./2/343456/< 8;AB/03353./2/343456/</G/0;346?1A56746 1 8;C /H;4E1:/63 35 3./ 3531: C1<@/3 E1:;/ 182/<3./E1:;13456</25<3=43.56/85:E/63 8;</3> 95< :4@/ 8;C ;67/<31@46? #% 35 2<57;0/ 3./ 5<61C/638 A/95</ 3./ 5;<3 18 167 =./6 74</03/7 #% 653 35 1:3/< 1:4/613/ 5< 21<3 =43. 2588/88456 2/6746? 3<41: #7% 9 7;<46? 3<41: 47/6343> 59 16> 43/C 48 7482;3/7 3./ 3<41: 5;<3 8.1:: 7/047/ 8;0. - 11 - 7482;3/ A> 8/0;<46? </:/18/7 5<61C/638 5< 56 3./ A1848 59 3./ 46E/635<> 2.535?<12.8 E1:;13456</25<3=436/883/834C56>16716> 53./< 17C4884A:/ /E47/60/ =43.5;3 A/46? 469:;/60/7A>3./2</8/635<7/< #/% 53.46? 46 3.48 5<7/< 8.1:: A/ 05683<;/7 18 16/G2</88456563./C/<438595=6/<8.425< 56 3./ ?;4:346650/60/ 59 16> 100;8/7( 1:: 488;/8 1</ :/93 52/6 35 A/ 17B;74013/7 13 3<41: -+ ' ##* & 4835:5