- 1 - ! " #!$ %! # $ &'(&)*+,'-&** % ! "# ! $%& ! &'%()%&' )*)%&* &$)%& $"(+ Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! , ! ORAL ORDER (PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.VISHWAJITH SHETTY) -./ 012./.34 516.6.34 74810 196.34 "# 01:8 ;.6- $%&3<0./<.=18://:.=.4>6-1?78>@146:48308103< :9A7.66:=5://18BC6-137063<0.49.5:=1//.34/78>1 .?:C:570 <30 /-306 D551==:61 3706 .4 0.@.4:= 551:= 3)*)%&*8:618&'%()%&' ) 1:086-1=1:04189374/1=<306-15:06.1/ 1/5348146 -101.4 ;:/ 9-:0>1 /-11618 <30 6-1 3<<1491/ 574./-:B=1 74810 196.34 $"( *%$ ) *$ *%'01:8;.6-196.34$3<6-148.:414:=381&"(% <30/-306DE:=34>;.6-6;336-10/997/183/&63 ;101 60.18 <30 6-1 9-:0>1 /-11618 3<<1491/ B1<301 6-1 ?70./8.96.34:=37063<:>./60:61.43&$)%&4 6-1 /:.8 9:/1 6-1 =1:0418 :>./60:61 BC ?78>@146 :48 30810 8:618 %*)%&* 9342.9618 :997/18 3& <30 6-1 - 3 - 3<<1491 574./-:B=1 74810 196.34 $"( 3< ;-.=1 :9A7.66.4>-.@<3036-109-:0>1/-116183<<1491/1:0418 :>./60:61 -:8 :9A7.6618 :997/18 3/) :48 <30 :== 6-1 3<<1491/<30;-.9-6-1C;1019-:0>1/-11618 $ 1.4>:>>0.1218BC 6-1 ?78>@1463< 9342.96.34 :48 30810 3< /1461491 5://18 BC 6-1 =1:0418 :>./60:61 9342.96.4>:997/183&<306-13<<1491574./-:B=174810 196.34$"(3<:48/146149.4>-.@6374810>3/.@5=1 .@50./34@146 <30 : 510.38 3< /.F @346-/ :48 5:C <.41 3< /&%%%%+ :48 .4 81<:7=6 63 74810>3 /.@5=1 .@50./34@146<30:510.383<341@346-:997/183&-:8 <.=18 0.@.4:= 551:= 3)*)%&* B1<301 6-1 3706 3< 0.49.5:=1//.34/78>1.?:C:570;-.9-;:/:==3;18BC 6-1 551==:61 3706 2.81 .@57>418 78>@146 :48 30810 8:618 &'%()%&' //:.=.4> 6-1 /:@1 6-1 6:61 ./ B1<3016-./3706.46-./012./.34516.6.34 * 1:0418 .>- 3706 32104@146 =1:810 :551:0.4> <30 6-1 6:61 /7B@.6/ 6-:6 6-1 551==:61 3706 -:/ 10018 .41F6148.4> 6-1B141<.63< :9A7.66:=:/:>:.4/6 - 4 - :997/183&34=C<306-101:/346-:6:997/183/):48 ;101 :9A7.6618 BC 6-1 0.:= 3706 -1 /7B@.6/ 6-:6 12.81491 3<!&!):48!*-:/436B114 503510=C :55019.:618BC6-1551==:613706;-.9--:/01/7=618.4 5://.4>3<6-1.@57>418?78>@146:48308103<:9A7.66:= 99308.4>=C/-150:C/63:==3;6-1012./.34516.6.34 ' 1:0418 9374/1= :551:0.4> <30 6-1 01/5348146 /7B@.6/6-:6551==:613706-:/0.>-6=C:9A7.6618:997/18 3& /.491 6-1 :==1>:6.34/ @:81 BC :== 6-1 ;.641//1/ :>:.4/6 :997/18 3/& ) :48 :01 /.@.=:0 1 /7B@.6/ 6-:6 6-101 :01 43 /519.<.9 :==1>:6.34/ :/ :>:.4/6 :997/18 3& :48 6-101<301 6-1 551==:61 3706 ;:/ ?7/6.<.18 .4 :9A7.66.4>:997/183&99308.4>=C-150:C/638./@.// 6-1012./.34516.6.34 # 03/1976.34 63 /7B/6:46.:61 6-1 :==1>:6.34/ @:81 :>:.4/6 :997/18 510/34/ -:8 1F:@.418 614 ;.641//1/:/!&63!&%B1<3016-10.:=3706:48-:8 >36@:0G18<.218397@146/:/F/&63*4B1-:=<3< - 5 - 6-1 81<1491 43 8397@146/ ;101 @:0G18 430 ;:/ :4C 81<149112.81491=18 ( !& !) :48 !* :01 6-1 ;.641//1/ ;-3 -:21@:81:==1>:6.34/:/:>:.4/6:997/18510/34/F& ./6-1935C3<6-1<.0/6.4<30@:6.34/7B@.6618BC!&4 F& .6 ./ /6:618 6-:6 !& ;:/ .==+601:618 .4 -10 @:60.@34.:= -37/1 <30 6-1 01:/34 6-:6 /-1 8.8 436 G43; 933G.4>:48/-1;:/B=:9G.493=3706./:=/3:==1>186-:6 /-1 ;:/ .==+601:618 .4 -10 @:60.@34.:= -37/1 <30 >.2.4> B.06- 63 6;3 >.0= B:B.1/ 3;1210 870.4> 6-1 9370/1 3< 8153/.6.34 !& -:/ 436 @:81 :4C :==1>:6.34 :>:.4/6 :997/18 510/34/ 6-:6 /-1 ;:/ B1.4> .==+601:618 .4 6-1 @:60.@34.:=-37/1<306-101:/346-:6/-1-:8>.214B.06- 63 6;3 >.0= B:B.1/ 4 6-1 36-10 -:48 5107/:= 3< 6-1 8153/.6.34 3< !& ;37=8 >3 63 /-3; 6-:6 /-1 -:/@:81 3@4.B7/ :==1>:6.34/ :>:.4/6 :== 6-1 :997/18 510/34/ :48 /519.<.932106+:96;-.9-;37=8:660:966-1:==1>183<<1491 74810196.34$"(3<:/:>:.4/6:997/183&./436 @:81 BC -10 214 !) :48 !* -:21 436 @:81 :4C - 6 - /519.<.9 :==1>:6.34 :/ :>:.4/6 :997/18 3& ;-.9- ;37=8 :660:966-13<<1491574./-:B=174810196.34$"(3< ==1>:6.34/@:81BC !&!):48!* :/ :>:.4/6:== 6-1:997/18510/34/:013@4.B7/.44:6701 " 34/.810.4>6-1:<301/:.8:/5196/3<6-1@:6610 6-1=1:0418:>./60:61-:8:9A7.6618:997/183/):48 B76-:89342.9618:997/183&<306-13<<1491574./-:B=1 74810196.34$"(3<;-.=1-1;:/:9A7.6618<306-1 36-10 9-:0>1 /-11618 3<<1491/ 48./57618=C 6-1 ?78>@146 :48 30810 3< :9A7.66:= 3< :997/18 3/) :48 -:/ 436 B114 A71/6.3418 BC6-1 6:61 30BC 6-181+<:963 93@5=:.4:46!& -1 /:.8 ?78>@146 :48 30810 3< :9A7.66:= 5://18 .4 <:2370 3< :997/18 3/) :48 -:/ :66:.418<.4:=.6C &% -1 551==:61 3706 -:2.4> :55019.:618 6-./ :/51963<6-1@:6610-:/-1=86-:66-10.:=3706;:/436 ?7/6.<.18 .4 9342.96.4> :997/18 3& ;-.=1 :9A7.66.4> :997/18 3/) :48 /.491 6-1 :==1>:6.34/ @:81 BC 6-1 ;.641//1/ .1 !& !) :48 !* :/ :>:.4/6 6-1 - 7 - :997/18510/34/;10193@@34:4843/519.<.9:==1>:6.34/ :01 @:81 :>:.4/6 :997/18 3& ;-.9- ;37=8 :660:96 6-1 :==1>183<<1491574./-:B=174810196.34$"(3<4 :88.6.34 63 6-1 /:@1 .6 ./ :=/3 436.918 6-:6 .4815148146 ;.641//1/1F:@.41834B1-:=<3<6-1503/1976.34-:21436 /75530618 6-1 9:/1 3< 6-1 503/1976.34 :48 6-1C ;101 601:618 :/ -3/6.=1 ;.641//1/ 36-.4> @:610.:= -:/ B114 1=.9.618 <03@ 6-1 @376- 3< 6-1/1 -3/6.=1 ;.641//1/ 1214 6-37>- 6-1C ;101 903//+1F:@.418 BC 6-1 7B=.9 03/197630 && -1551==:613706:=/3-:/436.9186-:66-101 ./ :4 :==1>:6.34 @:81 :>:.4/6 :997/18 3& 6-:6 -1 -:8 @:00.18 :436-10 =:8C :<610 !& ;:/ /146 376 3< 6-1 @:60.@34.:= -37/1 -101<301 .6 :551:0/ 6-:6 !& -:8 6:G14 /-1=610 .4 -10 5:0146/ -37/1 :48 /-1 -:8 :5503:9-18 6-1 53=.91 34=C :<610 :997/18 3& -:8 :==1>18=C 93460:9618 :436-10 @:00.:>1 -101<301 .6 ./ :55:0146 6-:6 6-101 ./ : 81=:C .4 :5503:9-.4> 6-1 53=.91 :48 43 1F5=:4:6.34 ;-:6/31210 -:/ B114 3<<1018 BC 6-1 - 8 - <.0/6.4<30@:46<306-1/:@1-1551==:613706-:2.4> 6:G14 .463 934/.810:6.34 :== 6-1/1 :/5196/ 3< 6-1 @:6610 -:/:9A7.6618:997/183&;-101:/6-10.:=3706-:/ 9342.9618 :997/18 3& <30 6-1 3<<1491 574./-:B=1 74810 196.34 $"( 3< 6-37>- 5107/:= 3<6-18153/.6.34/3< 6-1;.641//1/;.==>363/-3;6-:693@@34:==1>:6.34/:01 @:81:>:.4/6:==6-1:997/18510/34/ &) 4810 6-1 9.097@/6:491/ :@ 3< 6-1 934/.81018 35.4.34 6-:6 6-1 551==:61 3706 ;:/ <7==C ?7/6.<.18 .4 /166.4> :/.81 6-1 ?78>@146 3< 9342.96.34 :48 30810 3< /1461491 5://18 BC 6-1 0.:= 3706 .4 3&$)%& 8:618 %%*)%&* :48 :9A7.66.4> :997/18 3& <30 6-1 3<<1491 574./-:B=1 74810 196.34 $"(3<-101<30183436<.48:4C>338>0374863 146106:.4 6-./ 012./.34 53/.6.34 99308.4>=C 6-1 /:@1 ./ 8./@.//18 .+ &$ %! * ! SRT List No.: 1 Sl No.: 58 CT:PK