Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92778 (KAR)

YASHWANT v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/201749/2025 · 2025-11-17

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## # '( ')*+ (' ** , !" ## # $! % # & '''$ ! # $(!$ # ''' ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %! # &( ' $' ( ' * + # , )# # # )# # # # ('% * + , ) ( ) + , ( ) +, ) (%') # #) )) % ) + ''!, !!(+ ,"'%) ) ) ) # ) - # - 3 - + - # , ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 0229/5: ;<=0./5: 46 3.2 1>4?228/5:0 /5 >/@2 4(%' 64> 3.2 46625?2 1<5/0.=A72 <582> 2?3/45 % 46 +/:=>23320 =58 43.2> 4A=??4>48<?30?3''!,=58<582>2?3/45! !(+ , "' % 46 '! 1258/5: 45 3.2 6/72 46 72=>52825/4>/B/7<8:2=58).=79//8=> )=?3072=8/5:343.2?=02=>2=0<582>C 5 '"' 3.2 47/?2 <A5012?34> >2?2/B28 ?>28/A72/564>@=3/45>2:=>8/5:/772:=73>=5014>3=3/45461=5 @=0=7==5843.2>34A=??41>48<?30?3/5:<1453.20=/8 /564>@=3/45 3.2 /5/3/=328 B2./?72 ?.2?90 =58 8<>/5: 3.2 1>4?200 /532>?21328 3.2 B2./?72 A2=>/5: >2:/03>=3/45 4 $ ' 145 25;</>D /3 E=0 >2B2=728 3.=3 3.2 B2./?72 E=0 A2/5: <028 64> /772:=7 3>=5014>3=3/45 46 1=5 @=0=7= =58 43.2> 34A=??4 1>48<?30 E./?. =772:287D A2745:28 34 3.2 123/3/452>0 4502;<2537D = ?>/@2 E=0 >2:/032>28 - 4 - ! 2=>528 ?4<5027 64> 3.2 123/3/452>0 >2/32>=3/5: 3.2:>4<580<>:28/53.2123/3/45.=08>=E53.2=33253/45 46 3./0 4<>3 34 B=>/4<0 84?<@2530 1>48<?28 =745: E/3. 3.2123/3/45 .202/5?7<823.22>3/6/?=32462:/03>=3/4546 >=82@=>9/00<28AD3.2 4B2>5@2534658/=3.>4<:.3.2 >=82@=>902:/03>D2:/03>=3/452>3/6/?=320/5)4>@ '$ 2B/825?/5: 3.=3 3.2 6/>@ F# >48<?30G /0 8<7D >2:/032>28 <582> 3.2 7=E0 =58 3.2 8D=@ 2:/03>=3/45 2>3/6/?=32 203=A7/0./5: 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452>0H 6/>@ /0 25:=:28 /5 3.2 @=5<6=?3<>2 46 3.2 B2>D 1>48<?3 3.=3 .=0 A225 02/I28 AD 3.2 >201458253=<3.4>/3/20 88/3/45=77D 3.2 123/3/452>0 .=B2 1>48<?28 3=J /5B4/?20 >27=3/5: 34 3.2 :4480 /5 3>=50/3 =58 = >=82@=>9 /?25?2 :>22@253 ??4>8/5: 34 72=>528 ?4<5027 3.202 84?<@2530 ?4772?3/B27D 82@4503>=32 3.2 7=E6<7 @=5<6=?3<>2 =58 A<0/5200 412>=3/450 46 3.2 123/3/452>0H 6/>@ 262>>/5: 34 3.2 =64>20=/8 @=32>/=7 72=>528 ?4<5027E4<786<>3.2>?4532583.=33.2:4480/532>?21328 - 5 - =5802/I28AD3.2=<3.4>/3/20A2=>=8/03/5?314<?.820/:5 =58 =>2 8<7D ?4B2>28 <582> = >2:/032>28 3>=82@=>9 /5 =??4>8=5?2E/3.3.2 >=82@=>90?3"""3/00<A@/3328 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452>0H 6/>@ @=5<6=?3<>20 0?25328 34A=??4 1>48<?30 @=>92328<582>3.2A>=585=@2 KH<582> = B=7/87/?25?2/00<28AD3.2?4@123253=<3.4>/3D=58/06<77D ?4@17/=53 E/3. >2:<7=3/450 5 3./0 A=?9:>4<58 /3 /0 =>:<283.=33.2B2>D>2:/03>=3/45463.2)=772:/5:/772:=7 3>=5014>3=3/45 46 1>4?20028 34A=??4 1>48<?30 /0 E.477D @/0?45?2/B28=58<50<03=/5=A722=>528?4<50270<A@/30 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452>0 A2/5: 72:/3/@=32 @=5<6=?3<>2>0 =58 3>=82>0 .=B2 A225 <552?200=>/7D 8>=::28 /534 ?>/@/5=7 1>4?228/5:0=583.2>264>2?453/5<=3/45463.21>402?<3/45 E4<78 =@4<53 34 =A<02 46 1>4?200 46 7=E E=>>=53/5: 2J2>?/02 46 /5.2>253 14E2>0 <582> 2?3/45 ( 46 3.2 '! 2> ?453>= 3.4<:. 3.2 72=>528 /:. 4<>3 4B2>5@25372=82>.=0=332@132834L<03/6D3.2/5/3/=3/45 46 ?>/@/5=7 1>4?228/5:0 =632> 2J=@/5/5: 3.2 84?<@2530 - 6 - 17=?2845>2?4>83./04<>36/5800<A03=53/=7@2>/3/53.2 ?453253/45 46 3.2 123/3/452>0 .2 =88/3/45=7 84?<@2530 1>48<?28?72=>7D203=A7/0.3.=33.2123/3/452>0H6/>@.4780= B=7/83>=82@=>97/?25?264>3.21>48<?3/5;<203/45=58/0= 52E7D>2:/032>28253/3D=<3.4>/02834@=5<6=?3<>2=580277 3.2 02/I28 :4480 .2 02/I<>2 =112=>0 34 .=B2 A225 2662?328 E/3.4<3 3=9/5: /534 ?450/82>=3/45 3.2 03=3<34>D ?4@17/=5?20=7>2=8D6<76/7728AD3.2123/3/452>0 $ .25 3.2 123/3/452>0H 6/>@ /0 82@4503>=A7D = 8<7D >2:/032>28 @=5<6=?3<>/5: 253/3D .4780 3.2 >2;</0/32 7/?25?20 =58 3.2 @=32>/=70 1>/@= 6=?/2 /58/?=32 03>/?3 ?4@17/=5?2E/3. 54>@03.2B2>DA=0/064>>2:/03>=3/45 46?>/@2=772:/5:/772:=73>=5014>3=3/454634A=??41>48<?30 A2?4@20 <5325=A72 .2 >2?4>8 8420 543 8/0?7402 =5D ?4:253 @=32>/=7 4> 64<58=3/45=7 6=?30 /58/?=3/5: ?4@@/00/45 46 =5D ?4:5/I=A72 46625?2 .2 02/I<>2 =58 >2:/03>=3/45 46 3.2 ) =112=> 34 A2 E/3.4<3 =<3.4>/3D 46 7=E=58/53.2=A025?246=5D/5?>/@/5=3/5:@=32>/=7 - 7 - % ./0 4<>3 .=0 @23/?<74<07D 2J=@/528 3.2 =772:=3/450 ?453=/528 /5 3.2 ) =0 E277 =0 3.2 03=3<34>D 1>4B/0/450 /5B4928 3.2>2/5 5046=> =0 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 /:=>23320=583.2> 4A=??4>48<?30?3''!+ , /0?45?2>5283.20=/81>4B/0/451>4./A/303.2@=5<6=?3<>2 0=72 8/03>/A<3/45 4> 3>=82 46 34A=??4 1>48<?30 2J?213 /5 3.2@=552>=58E/3.3.2.2=73.E=>5/5:01>20?>/A28<582> 3.2 ?3 .2 @=32>/=7 17=?28 45 >2?4>8 .4E2B2> ?72=>7D 82@4503>=320 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452>0H 6/>@ /0 = 7/?25028 @=5<6=?3<>2> 6<77D ?4@17/=53 E/3. 1=?9=:/5: 54>@0 03=3<34>D 82?7=>=3/450 =58 >2:<7=3/450 =58 3.2>2 /0 54 =772:=3/45 @<?. 7200 @=32>/=7 34 /58/?=32 3.=3 3.2 02/I28 1>48<?30 ?453>=B2528 =5D 1=?9=:/5: 4> 7=A277/5: >2;</>2@2530 <582> /92E/02 3.2 /5B4?=3/45 46 2?3/450!!(+ ,"'=58%463.2.=>=3/D= D=D= =5./3= '! /0 E.477D @/0?45?2/B28 2?3/45 ! 12>3=/50 34 =8<732>=3/45 4> 01<>/4<0 :4480 ?=<0/5: .=>@ A<33.2)8420543=772:2=8<732>=3/4501<>/4<0;<=7/3D 4>=5D3.>2=3341<A7/?.2=73.2?3/45!(+ ,E./?.82=70 - 8 - E/3./772:=74><5=<3.4>/0280=724>3>=5014>346>2:<7=328 /32@0?=5543A21>20028/53402>B/?2E.253.2123/3/452>0 =>2=A72 34 1>/@= 6=?/282@4503>=32 3.=33.2 :4480E2>2 7=E6<77D @=5<6=?3<>28 <582> = B=7/8 7/?25?2 =58 E2>2 =??4@1=5/28 AD /5B4/?20 =58 3>=5014>3 84?<@2530 /@/7=>7D2?3/45"'>27=3/5:346>=<8<72534>8/0.45203 >2@4B=7 4> 3>=5014>3 46 :4480 34 2B=82 8<3D 4> 7=E6<7 ?.=>:2 03=580 2J?7<828 E.2>2 3.2 84?<@2530 45 >2?4>8 0.4E 6<77 3=J ?4@17/=5?2 2?3/45 % E./?. 200253/=77D ?45?2>50 1400200/45 4> 3>=5014>3=3/45 46 :4480 E/3.4<3 =<3.4>/3D/0=704>2582>28/5=117/?=A72=03.2123/3/452>0H 6/>@ .4780 =77 >2;</0/32 03=3<34>D =11>4B=70 /5?7<8/5: 3>=82@=>9 >2:/03>=3/45 8D=@ >2:/03>=3/45 =58 ?2>3/6/?=3/45 .<0 2B25 /6 3.2 ?4@17=/53 /0 3=925 =3 /30 6=?2 B=7<2 5452 46 3.2 200253/=7 /5:>28/2530 46 3.2 46625?20=772:28=>28/0?74028=583.2>2:/03>=3/45463.2 )/03.2>264>2<50<03=/5=A72/57=E - 9 - ( .2>264>2/53.27/:.3462?3/450!!(+ , "'=58%463.2.=>=3/D= D=D==5./3='!2B25/6 3.2 =772:=3/450 /5 3.2 ?4@17=/53 =>2 3=925 =3 3.2/> 6=?2 B=7<2=58=??21328/53.2/>253/>23D5452463.2200253/=7 /5:>28/2530?4503/3<3/5:3.246625?20=772:28/53.2)=>2 @=82 4<3 =0 =:=/503 3.2 123/3/452>0 453/5<=3/45 46 3.2 /5B203/:=3/45=581>402?<3/45/50<?.?/>?<@03=5?20E4<78 543 457D 1>2L<8/?2 3.2 >21<3=3/45 =58 A<0/5200 46 3.2 123/3/452>0H6/>@A<3E4<78=704=@4<5334=5=A<02463.2 @=?./52>D 46 ?>/@/5=7 7=E ./0 4<>3 /0 3.2>264>2 0=3/06/28 3.=3 3.2 1>20253 ?=02 E=>>=530 2J2>?/02 46 3.2 /5.2>253L<>/08/?3/4534;<=0.3.21>4?228/5:0 " ??4>8/5:7D 3./0 4<>3 1>4?2280 34 1=00 3.2 64774E/5: +/, .2123/3/45/0.2>2AD=774E28 +//, .21>4?228/5:0/5>/@2 4(%'>2:/032>28 AD3.2>20145825347/?21258/5:453.26/72463.225/4> - 10 - /B/7 <8:2 =58 ) .=79/ /8=> 64> 3.2 46625?20 1<5/0.=A72 <582> 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 /:=>23320 =58 3.2> 4A=??4 >48<?30 ?3 ''! + , =58 2?3/450 ! !(+ , "' =58 % 46 3.2 .=>=3/D= D=D= =5./3= '!/5046=>=03.2123/3/452>0=>2?45?2>528=>2.2>2AD ;<=0.28 +///, .25B203/:=3/5:66/?2>/08/>2?3283464>3.E/3. >272=02 3.2 02/I28 1>48<?30 34 3.2 123/3/452>0 0<AL2?3 34 8<2/8253/6/?=3/45 +/B,771258/5:003=588/01402846 -+ ' ##* & /03 47 4!