Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92772 (KAR)

ZAKIYA v. MAHIBOOB

RPFC/200033/2025 · 2025-12-18

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #!$!! %! &' %! ( & ' !"#$%& &' ( &) "( " " *" """ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (( " + ($ " !"#$%& *" + "+ + ,' + +"+ " ! $&&$ " $& &( ++ + "" ! + !" !" "+ " + + !" !"+ + "" + + ( & ' (' " -$))& " " + + - 3 - ) !"-$%& &$ ( &( "( " + " " """ +. (" "+ + ,' + +"-! $&&$ " "" ! + !" $& &$ + + /+ "+ 0! - 4 - 12345446217189:;<1=681685;18$&&$>5??1823 62@235A 2?B=$& &( =3 ;<1 C2A1 =C ;<1 88A "623B2>5A !D841+5@2A:=D6; 2E5:5>D6C=6?<=6;F;<1+5@2A:=D6;/9: G<2B< ;<1 +5@2A: =D6; G<2A1 5AA=G234 ;<1 >1;2;2=3 C2A18 D3816 1B;2=3 $ 6" <5? 8261B;18 ;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 ;= >5:?&&& -;=>1;2;2=316=;2AA<16A2C1;2@1=661@5662541 538 ?&&& - ;= >1;2;2=316 = ;2AA <1 5;;523? ;<1 541 =C @5E=62;: 538 ?&&& - ;= ;<1 >1;2;2=316 =( D3;2A <16 @5662541 C6=@ ;<1 85;1 =C 82?>=?5A =C ;<1 >6=B118234? D3816 =@1?;2B 2=A13B1B;>1;2;2=316?-G2C1538B<2A861356191C=61 ;<2? =D6; 23 "+ =&&&(( &$ ?11H234 13<53B1@13; G<2A1 ;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 2? 91C=61 ;<2? =D6; 23 "+ =&&&) &$?11H234ID5?<234=C;<1=6816 <1@566254191;G113;<1>1;2;2=316=-G2C1538 61?>=3813; <57234 ?=A1@32J18 =3 ,&)&, 538 >1;2;2=316 =? 538 ( <57234 9=63 ;= ;<1@ 2? 3=; 23 82?>D;1 <161 5>>156? ;= <571 9113 B16;523 @562;5A 82?B=68 91;G113 ;<1 >1;2;2=316=53861?>=3813;61?DA;23423>56;21?61?=6;234;= ;<1 A2;245;2=3? <1 >1;2;2=316 =-G2C1 <5? 5A?= 232;25;18 >6=B118234? D3816 ;<1 "6=;1B;2=3 =C =@13 C6=@ =@1?;2B - 5 - 2=A13B1 B; &&$ 5AA14234 314A2413B1 23 >6=728234 @523;1353B1 <1 <5? 5A?= 232;25;18 ;<1 >6=B118234? D3816 1B;2=3 $ =C 6" ?11H234 @523;1353B1 =C ?&&&& - 15B<;=>1;2;2=316=?;=( ( 1?>=3813; <D?9538 2? 58@2;;18A: G=6H234 5? 5 A231@53 23 5345A=61 A1B;62B2;: D>>A: =@>53: ;8 ? >16 ;<1 ?5A56: ?A2> C=6 ;<1 @=3;< =C !53D56: &';<1A5?;865G3?5A56:G5??)' -5C;16818DB;2=3;<1 31;>5:59A15@=D3;?<=G3;<161232??( - ' 156318B=D3?1AC=6;<1>1;2;2=316?D9@2;?;<5;;<1 +5@2A:=D6;G2;<=D;;5H234;<1B=3?28165;2=3=C;<1>=?2;2=3=C ;<1 >56;21? 538 ;<1 23B=@1 91234 156318 9: ;<1 61?>=3813;- <D?9538 <5? 5G56818 ;<1 @523;1353B1 G<2B< 2? @15416 538 8=1?3=;@11;;<161ID261@13; 1?D9@2;?;<5;;<1>1;2;2=316 <5? 3= ?=D6B1 =C 23B=@1 538 2? B=@>A1;1A:81>13813; =3 ;<1 @523;1353B1 >6=72818 9: ;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 1 ;<161C=61 ?D9@2;? ;<5; ?23B1 ;<1 ?5A56: ?A2> G5? =C ;<1 :156 &'G<2B<<5?3=G?D9?;53;25AA:13<53B18;<113<53B1@13; 5??=D4<;C=6915G56818 - 6 - $ 3 61?>=3?1 A156318 B=D3?1A C=6 ;<1 61?>=3813;- <D?9538 ?D9@2;? ;<5; ;<=D4< ;<1 ?5A56: ?A2> =C !53D56: &' 2382B5;1;<146=???5A56:;=91?)' -5C;16818DB;2=3<1 61B1271? =3A: 5 ?D@ =C ?( =C G<2B< <1 <5? ;= >6=7281 @523;1353B1;=;<1>1;2;2=3165?G1AA5?<2@?1AC538<2?541=A8 @=;<16 <161C=61 ;<161 2? 3= ?B=>1 =6 6==@ C=6 53: CD6;<16 13<53B1@13; 13B1?11H?C=682?@2??5A=C;<1>1;2;2=3C2A189: ;<1>1;2;2=316=-G2C1 1CD6;<16?D9@2;?;<5;;<1>1;2;2=316? <5715A?=232;25;18>6=B118234?D3816=@1?;2B 2=A13B1B;23 G<2B< >1;2;2=316? <571 9113 5G56818 23;162@ @523;1353B1 =C ?(&&& - ;= >1;2;2=316 = 538 ?&&& - 15B< ;= ;<1 B<2A8613<161C=61<1?D9@2;?;<5;;<161?>=3813;B533=;91 9D68131853:@=61 13B1?11H234C=65AA=G234=C;<1>1;2;2=3 C2A189:;<161?>=3813;-<D?9538?1;;2345?281;<1=6816>5??18 9:;<1+5@2A:=D6; 1568>16D?18;<161B=68? ) <1 61A5;2=3?<2> 91;G113 ;<1 >56;21? 2? 3=; 23 82?>D;1 538 ;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 91234 53 1@>A=:11 =C 1563234?5A56:5?3=;1859=715?=C;<1:156&'2? 5A?=3=;2382?>D;1<1+5@2A:=D6;;5H23423;=B=3?28165;2=3 - 7 - =C ;<1 @5;;16 <5? 5G56818 ?&&& - ;= >1;2;2=316 = ?&&& ;= >1;2;2=316 = 538 ?&&& - ;= >1;2;2=316 =( G2;<562816;<5;;<1?5285@=D3;?<5AA91>528=3A:5C;16;<1 82?>=?5A=C>6=B118234?D3816;<1=@1?;2B 2=A13B1B; % ; 2? 5A?= 3=; 23 82?>D;1 23 ;<1 =@1?;2B 2=A13B1 B; ;<1 >1;2;2=316? <571 9113 5G56818 23;162@ @523;1353B1 538 G<2B< 2? 5A?= 91234 >528 ;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 =3?2816234 ;<1 23B=@1 G<2B< 2? 8162718 9: ;<1 61?>=3813;- <D?9538 538 ;<1 ?;5;D? ;= G<2B< ;<1 >56;21? 561 5BBD?;=@18 ;<2? =D6; 2? =C ;<1 B=3?281618 721G ;<5; ;<1 2@>D4318 =6816 >5??18 9: ;<1 +5@2A: =D6; 91 @=82C218 9: 13<53B234 ;<1 @523;1353B1 5@=D3; 5G56818 ;= >1;2;2=316 = C6=@ ?&&& - ;= ?%&&&- @523;1353B1 5@=D3; 5G56818 ;= >1;2;2=316=C6=@?&&& -;=?($&& -538C=6>1;2;2=316 =(C6=@?&&&;=?($&& -DB<13<53B1@13;?<5AA91 C6=@;<185;1=C;<2?6172?2=3>1;2;2=3 , BB=68234A:;<1C=AA=G234 - 8 - 5 <1>1;2;2=323"+=&&&(( &$C2A189:;<1 >1;2;2=316?2? 9 <1>1;2;2=323"+=&&&) &$C2A189:;<1 61?>=3813;-<D?95382? B <1 61?>=3813;-<D?9538 2? 8261B;18 ;= >5: ?%&&& -;=>1;2;2=316=538?($&& -15B< ;=>1;2;2=316=?538( 8 ; 2? @581 BA156 ;<5; ?23B1 ;<1 =@1?;2B 2=A13B1 >6=B118234? 561 ?;5;18 ;= 91 ?;2AA >138234 B=3?28165;2=3 23 G<2B< 5A6158: 23;162@ =6816 <5? 9113 >5??18 ;<1 +5@2A: =D6; ?<5AA ;5H1 23;= B=3?28165;2=3 ;<1 5@=D3; 91 >528 538 >6=7281 5>>6=>625;158ED?;@13; ?1;=CC54523?;;<15@=D3; 13<53B18<16123 1 <1 61?>=3813; <D?9538 ?<5AA >5: ;<1 13;261 5@=D3;23BAD8234;<1566156?538?<5AAB=3;23D1;= >5:;<15@=D3;5?8261B;18<1612359=71614DA56A: - 9 - C <1 566156? ?<5AA 91 81>=?2;18 91;G113 G2;<23 5 >162=8 =C 124<; G11H? C6=@ ;<1 85;1 =C 61B12>; =C B16;2C218B=>:=C;<1=6816 )& *!!+ $ 2?;=A=' "