- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ "" %&' ( ! ""# $ ! ""# $ % % &'&% % ( ( ''")"" )&)*")" % %( + Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ( , , - ( - ( % $ ,- ( % ./0 122314 /0 56 7.3 841/91:70 033;/:< =>? 3:.1:8393:7 1?/0/:< >@7 >= A@B<93:7 1:B 1C1?B B173B )&)*")"/: >''")""21003B567.3 3:/>?/D/4 (@B<31:B .>?12@?=>?0.>?7E7.3?/5@:14F " .3 B173 >= 188/B3:7 /:D>4D393:7 >= 7.3 D3./843/:A@?60@==3?3B567.3841/91:71:B7.34/15/4/767> 2168>923:017/>:/0:>7/:B/02@73G7.3>:46B/02@73/0/: ?302387 >= /:1B3H@173 8>923:017/>: 8>921?3B 7> 7.3 /:A@?60@==3?3B/:D>4D/:<192@717/>:>=7.3?/<.74>C3?4/95 15>D3;:33 14>:< C/7. 8>92>@:B=?187@?3>= 0.1=7=39@? 1:B 7/5/1 1:B 140> :>: 8>:0/B3?17/>: >= /:8>93 >= 7.3 841/91:73D3:7.>@<..3.102?>B@83B7.3B?/D/:<4/83:83 17 I&#7>0.>C7.17.3C10C>?;/:<101B?/D3? - 3 - 31?B ?/ ?@21 1<1? 17/4 431?:3B 8>@:034 12231?/:<=>?7.31223441:71:B ?/ .1?1:12215101221 17/4 431?:3B 8>@:034 12231?/:< =>? 7.3 ?302>:B3:7 J >?2>?17/>: # ?/ ?@21 1<1? 17/4 C/7. 144 D3.393:83 8>:73:B3B7.177.31223441:7C10C>?;/:<101B?/D3?1:B 31?:/:<0&!)))23?9>:7.100141?61:B0"))10 B1/465.177121?7=?>9>?;/:<101B?/D3?.3C10140> C>?;/:< /: 1 51;3?6 1:B 31?:/:< 0&))) 23? 9>:7. 0 0@8. /: 7>714 .3 C10 31?:/:< 0#)))) 23? 9>:7. 41/91:7.102?>B@83B7.30141?683?7/=/8173/00@3B567.3 2?>2?/37>? >= 60>?3 3B/814 0/7@173B 17 .1.12@?1 7> 8>:73:B 7.17 7.3 1223441:7 C10 C>?;/:< C/7. ./9 10 1 B?/D3? /: ./0 3:1@47 @073? 1? 0/:83 ")&# 7/44 7.3 631? ")")/37.3631?>=7.3188/B3:7:7.3188/B3:7.3.10 0@==3?3B=?187@?37.17121?7./0?/<.743<C10192@7173B 1:B /: 73?90 >= 7.3 08.3B@43 2?>D/B3B @:B3? 7.3 924>6330- >923:017/>: 87 =>? 1: 192@717/>: 15>D3 ;:33 534>C >:3 7./?B >= 7./<. 7.3 B/015/4/76 /0 =/I3B 17 - 4 - ')K 5@7 7.3 ?/5@:14 .10 71;3: 7.3 0193 17 )K 1:B /:8>93170& )))23?9>:7.B302/73.3C10.>4B/:< 4/83:83 3 .10 =@?7.3? 8>:73:B3B 7.3 ?/5@:14 17 1?1<?12. >"# .10 8431?46 >503?D3B 2?303:7 8>:B/7/>: >= 7.3 1223441:7 1:B 07173B 7.17 7.3 1223441:7F0 ?/<.7 43< C108>92437346192@7173B@27>7./<.7.3?3=>?3.3/0:>7 15437>B>1:6B?/D/:<C>?;>??302>:B/:<7>./01<3/3 631?010>:7.3B173>=188/B3:77.3?/5@:14.1071;3: 9@47/24/3? >= E&F =>? 8>:0/B3?17/>: %@?7.3? .3 .10 0@59/773B 7.17 7.3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B @:B3? 144 7.3 .31B03I832793B/8143I23:0301441?3>:7.34>C3?0/B3 1:B /7 ?3H@/?30 ?38>:0/B3?17/>: %@?7.3? .3 .10 140> 0@59/773B 7.17 7.3 ?/5@:14 .10 :>7 8>:0/B3?3B 7.3 8103 =>? 1C1?B/:< 122?>2?/173 8>923:017/>:@:B3? 7.3.31BJ @?8.103>=?7/=/8/14/95 >5@77?300./01?<@93:7.3.10?34/3B>:7.3 A@B<93:7>=>:-54323I>@?7/:7.38103>= - 5 - 1 C.3?3/:7.3>:F54323I>@?7.108>:0/B3?3B 7.3 8103 >= 7.3 1223441:7 7.3?3/: C.> .10 0@==3?3B *K B/015/4/76 1:B 71;3: 7.3 0193 10 &))K 7>C1?B0 4>00 >= 31?:/:<81218/761:B1BB3B#)K7>C1?B0=@7@?32?>023870 1:B 0> 140> 8>:0/B3?3B 7.3 8103 =>? 1C1?B/:< 8>923:017/>: 7>C1?B0 122>/:793:7 >= 1773:B1:7 C./43 <?1:7/:< 8>923:017/>: C/7./: 7.3 931:/:< >= A@07 8>923:017/>: : 7.3 8103>: .1:B 7.31223441:7 53/:< 7.3 B?/D3? .3 .10 4>07 ./0 1D>817/>: 10 ./0 ?/<.7 43< 192@7173B 15>D3 ;:33 .3 ?/5@:14 >@<.7 7> .1D3 8>:0/B3?3B7.34>00>=/:8>93177.3?173>=')K/:0731B >= )K 10 23? 7.3 08.3B@43 07173B >C3D3? 1 23?0>: C/7.>@7 1 43< /0 :>7 /: 1 2>0/7/>: 7> 8>:7/:@3 7.3 31?4/3?1D>817/>:101B?/D3?:7.3038/?8@9071:8307.3 8103 >= 7.3 1223441:7 .10 7> 53 8>:0/B3?3B =>? 1C1?B/:< 122?>2?/1738>923:017/>:/:73?90>=7.341C41/BB>C:56 7.3 >:-543 22344173 >@?7 /: 1 (2022) 15 SCC 620 - 6 - 88>?B/:<46.30>@<.77>144>C7.31223141:B9>B/=67.3 1C1?B1:B3:.1:837.38>923:017/>: 3=@7/:<7.30@59/00/>:>=7.3431?:3B8>@:034 12231?/:<=>?7.3841/91:71223441:7 ?/ .1?1:15101221 17/4 C/7. 144 D3.393:83 0@59/773B 7.17 10 23? 7.3 8.1?7 2?321?3B 56 7.3 3<14 3?D/830 @7.>?/76 >= 7./0 8>@?7 =>? 7.3 631? ")") 7.3 19>@:7 =/I3B /0 17 0&' ) >C3D3? 7.3 ?/5@:14 8>:0/B3?/:< 7.3 =187 7.17 7.3 1223441:7 C10 C>?;/:< 10 1 B?/D3? 71;3: 7.3 /:8>93177.3?173>=0 ))23?B161:B8>:0/B3?3B7.3 /:8>93 23? 9>:7. 17 7.3 ?173 >= 0& ))) .3 ?/5@:14.101C1?B3B122?>2?/1738>923:017/>:@:B3?144 7.3 .31B0 C./8. B>30 :>7 8144 =>? 1:6 /:73?=3?3:83 1:B .3:830>@<.7=>?B/09/0014>=7.3122314 ' 1D/:<.31?B7.3431?:3B8>@:03412231?/:<=>? 7.321?7/3023?@03B7.33:7/?31223142123?00>140>7.3 ?/14 >@?7 38>?B 7.3 >:46 H@307/>: 7.17 1?/03 =>? >@? 8>:0/B3?17/>:/0 - 7 - LC.37.3? 7.3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B 56 7.3?/5@:1453=/7C/7./:7.33I2?300/>:>= A@07 8>923:017/>: /= 7.3 1:0C3? /0 >7.3?C/03C.37.3?7.30193?3H@/?301:6 /:73?=3?3:83177.3.1:B0>=7./0>@?7MN ! @?1:0C3?7>7.315>D32>/:7=>?8>:0/B3?17/>: /0E21?746/:1==/?917/D3F=>?7.3=>44>C/:<, 0 8>@4B 53 033: =?>9 7.3 ?38>?B0 /: 7.3 188/B3:7 7.3?/<.743<>=7.31223441:7C10192@7173B15>D3;:33 /3 A@07 534>C 7.3 7./<. 1:B /: 73?90 >= 7.3 08.3B@43 2?>D/B3B @:B3? 7.3 924>6330 >923:017/>: 87 7.3 B/015/4/76 /0 =/I3B 17 ')K .3 188/B3:7 /0 >= 7.3 631? ")").3841/91:7C10C>?;/:<101B?/D3?.3?/5@:14 71;/:<7.301/B102387>=7.391773?.1071;3:7.3/:8>93 17 0& ))) 23? 9>:7. >C3D3? 10 .10 533: 8>:73:B3B 56 7.3 8>@:034 =>? 7.3 1223441:7 .3 C10 31?:/:< 0&!))) 23? 9>:7. 14>:< C/7. 0")) 10 5.1771 1:B /: D/3C >= 7.3 83?7/=/8173 /00@3B 56 ./0 3924>63?7.31223441:7C1031?:/:<0))23?B167.17 - 8 - C>@4B 8>930 7> 0&!))) 23? 9>:7. .3 1223441:7 C101<3B 631?0177.37/93>=188/B3:7188>?B/:<46.3 8>930C/7./:#)631?0>=1<31:B/:D/3C>=7.3A@B<93:7 41/BB>C:567.3>:-54323I>@?7/: #)K7>C1?B0=@7@?32?>02387@0/0?3H@/?3B7>531BB3B7> 7.33I/07/:</:8>931;/:</:7>8>:0/B3?17/>:>=7.31<3 >= 7.3 1223441:7 E&F 9@47/24/3? /0 122?>2?/173 C./43 8148@417/:< 4>00 >= =@7@?3 31?:/:< .3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B @:B3? 144 7.3 .31B0 56 7.3 ?/5@:14 3I8327 93B/814 3I23:030 C.3: 8>921?3B 7> 7.3 /:A@?6 0@==3?3B ?30@47/:</:192@717/>:0>140>=?187@?37>>7.3?4/951?3 >: 7.3 4>C3? 0/B3 1:B 7.3 ?/5@:14 .10 =1/43B 7> 8>:0/B3? 7.38103 >= 7.31223441:7 =>? 1C1?B/:< 1:6 8>923:017/>: 7>C1?B0@?8.103>=?7/=/8/14/952?>07.37/84/951:B10 0@8. =344 /: 3??>? /: D/3C >= 7.3 =>?3<>/:< ?310>:0 7.3 3:7/?38>923:017/>:1C1?B3B567.3?/5@:14?3H@/?30?3 8>:0/B3?17/>:1:B?3B373?9/:17/>: - 9 - * 1;/:< ')K 7>C1?B0 4>00 >= 31?:/:< >= /:A@?3B 1:B140>1BB/:<#)K7>C1?B0=@7@?32?>02387010C34410 12246/:< ?343D1:7 9@47/24/3? >= E&F 7.3 4>00 >= =@7@?3 /:8>938>9307>0!)) &) >C8>9/:<7>7.3102387>=21/:1:B0@==3?/:< 7.3 /:A@?3B C10 1: /:217/3:7 =>? 1 23?/>B >= ") B160 1:B 7.3?/<.743<>=7.31223441:7C10192@7173B15>D3;:33 /3A@07534>C7.37./<..3:83/7/0122?>2?/1737>1C1?B 1 8>923:017/>: >= 0"))))) 7>C1?B0 E21/: 1:B 0@==3?/:<F && 0 23? 7.3 3D/B3:83 1:B 4/83:03 >= 2?>B@83B 17 I&# 7.3 /:8>93 /0 71;3: 10 0&!))) 88>?B/:<46 >: ?3B373?9/:17/>: 7.3 1223441:7 /0 3:7/743B =>? 0&)!))) @:B3? 7.3 .31B E4>00 >= /:8>93 B@?/:< 41/B23?/>B=>?0/I9>:7.0F &" :0>=1? 10 1773:B1:7 8.1?<30 2@?8.103 >= 1?7/=/8/14 4/952?>07.37/8 4/95 1:B 4>00 >= 193:/7/30 1?3 8>:83?:3B >: ?3B373?9/:17/>: 1 0@9 >= 0 )))) - 10 - 7>C1?B0 E:8/B3:714 1:B 1773:B/:< 8.1?<30 /:84@B/:< 8>:D361:83F1C1?B3B0# ))))7>C1?B0E2@?8.103>= 1?7/=/8/14 4/95F 1:B 0& )))) 7>C1?B0 E4>00 >= 193:/7/30F & :7.17D/3C>=7.391773?>:?3B373?9/:17/>: 7.31223441:7/03:7/743B=>?7.38>923:017/>:10=>44>C0, )*+,-./)0,*120 .301 >00 >= =@7@?3 31?:/:< O&!)))P#)KI&"I&I ')K 0 !!!) 1/:1:B0@==3?/:< 0 "))))) 3B/8143I23:03 0 &')' >00 B@?/:< 41/B @2 23?/>B =>? 0/I9>:7.00&!)))I 0 &)!))) :8/B3:714 1:B 773:B/:< .1?<30/:84@B/:<>:D361:83 0 )))) @?8.103>=1?7/=/8/144/95 0 # )))) >00>=193:/7/30 0 & )))) , 445 - 11 - 88>?B/:<46 7.3 841/91:7 /0 3:7/743B =>? 1 0@9 >= , 44510 1<1/:07 0&#'00@8. 7.3 3:.1:83B8>923:017/>:C>@4B8>9307>,4665 &# %>? 7.3 =>?3<>/:< ?310>:0 C3 2100 7.3 =>44>C/:<, / .3122314/0 // .3 A@B<93:7 1:B 1C1?B 21003B 56 7.3 ?/5@:14 /: 1C1?B B173B )&)*")" /: >''")"" 21003B 56 7.3 3:/>? /D/4 (@B<3 1:B .>?12@?/09>B/=/3BG /// .3 1223441:7 /0 3:7/743B =>? 3:.1:83B 8>923:017/>: >= ,4665 C./8. 0.144 81??6 /:73?307 17 7.3?173 >= K =?>97.3B173 >=237/7/>:7/44?314/Q17/>: /D .3?302>:B3:7 >?2>?17/>: 0.144 B32>0/7 7.3 3:7/?3 3:.1:83B 8>923:017/>: 14>:< C/7. /:73?307?17307173B53=>?37.38>:83?:3B - 12 - ?/5@:14 C/7./: 1 23?/>B >= 0/I C33;0 =?>9 7.3 B173>=?383/27>=8>26>=7./0>?B3? D @7>=8>923:017/>:' K24@0/:73?307/07>53 B32>0/73B /: 1:6 :17/>:14 51:; /: 1: /:73?307 531?/:< =/I3B B32>0/7 =>? 1 23?/>B >= 631?0 C/7.1?3:3C1543841@03=>?1:>7.3?7C>73?90 >=7.?33631?0318. D/ 141:83 " K 14>:< C/7. 188?@3B /:73?307 53 ?343103B/:=1D>@?>=7.31223441:7841/91:7>: 2?>23?/B3:7/=/817/>: D// >>?B3?107>8>07 +5 %" ' $ +5 %' $ /07>,& 4>, ,(