Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92766 (KAR)
SHABANA BEGUM AND ORS v. MD. ALLAHBAKSH AND ANR
MFA/201998/2024 · 2025-11-17
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92766 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92766 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%! & '!%! & '!#'$ #
! !%%
() *
!"#"$
%
&%
!"#"$
'
%
!"#"$
(
) *
+
, #%&#
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
, !"#"$
%
-
!"#$$%$
(
) &$%$%" * ) -%*
- - $ )* - %
*- %% - - , , -
. *
- ,
&$&%$% %$%% , , -
. - /&$"$ %0 /"$$$$$
%0
- ,
1 ,
1 , ,
- 3 -
' ) 1 , *
23/ 455647 89:6; 6<=3>9 $)* >? =26 @57>A66/ >@569/4=3>9 <= % )26;6394?=6; ;6?6;;6: => 4/ B=26 <=.?>;/2>;=*24/C669?376:CA=26<743@49=/<247769D39D =26E8:D@69=49:4F4;::4=6:&$&%$%54//6:CA=26 ;7 693>; 3G37 ,8:D6 H , H >@@3//3>96; ->;
>;I@69./ >@569/4=3>9 )?>; /2>;= B=26 <743@ ;3C8947.* 3:4;39 >%$%%
% -4<=/ D3G39D ;3/6 => =26 ?3739D >? =26 455647 C;36?7A/=4=6:4;6=24=>9$%$%%F269=26:6<64/6:
F4/ F>;I39D 4/ 4 F>;I@49 89:6; ?877 =3@6 6@57>A@69= F3=2 ;6/5>9:69= > 4/ 4 :;3G6; >? G623<76 > &" 9 $%$%% :6<64/6: 4/ 56; =26 39/=;8<=3>9 >? ;6/5>9:69= > =26 :6<64/6: 7>4:6:
G6D6=4C76/ 39=> =26 >76;> 3<I85 G623<76 4= A:6;4C4:
49: 5;><66:6: =>F4;:/ 49D4;6::A ?>; 897>4:39D = 4C>8= %" 5@ F269 26 <4@6 964; - 49:
- 4 -
49D4;6::A B. ,89<=3>9 26 7>/= 23/ <>9=;>7 >G6; =26 G623<76 :86 => />@6 =6<293<47 5;>C76@ 49: :4/26: => @>=>;<A<76C64;39D> %&$$;6/87=39D39:64=2>? 53773>9;3:6;49:39E8;A=>=26;3:6;>?=26/43:@>=>;<A<76 3/G623<76=8;96:=8;=76<48/39D?4=47264:39E8;A=>23@ / 4 ;6/87= >? =26 4?>;6/43: 4<<3:69= =26 :6<64/6: /8/=4396:D;36G>8/39E8;36/49:/8<<8@C6:=>=2639E8;36/
26<743@49=/?376:456=3=3>989:6;6<=3>9$ >? =26 <= % /66I39D <>@569/4=3>9 ?>; =26 :64=2>?=26:6<64/6:47>9DF3=239=6;6/=
5>9/6;G3<6>?9>=3<6=26;6/5>9:69=>49:
% 45564;6: =2;>8D2 <>89/67 49: ?376: F;3==69 /=4=6@69= :69A39D=264G6;@69=/@4:639=26<743@56=3=3>9
" 9=26C4/3/>?=265764:39D/>?=2654;=36/=26 743@/;3C8947?;4@6:=263//86/49:=26;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=26 6G3:69<6 26 ;3C8947 CA 3@58D96: E8:D@69= 49: 4F4;:24/54;=7A477>F6:=26<743@56=3=3>949:267:=24= =26 <743@49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 <>@569/4=3>9 >? - 5 -
/&$"$47>9DF3=239=6;6/=4==26;4=6>?%054 49: :3;6<=6: =26 ;6/5>9:69= >% => :65>/3= =26 <>@569/4=3>9 4@>89= 47>9D F3=2 39=6;6/= 639D 4DD;36G6:=265;6/69=45564724/C669?376:
& 64;96:<>89/6745564;39D?>;=26<743@49=24/ <>9=69:6:=24=4==26=3@6>?=264<<3:69=:6<64/6:F4/ F>;I39D 4/ 4 :;3G6; >? 4 D>>:/ G623<76 C67>9D/ => ;6/5>9:69= > 49: 26 F4/ D6==39D @>9=27A /474;A >? /$$$$56;@>9=2F3=24:437AC4=4>?/$$
2376 4 39D =26 @>9=27A 39<>@6 >? =26 :6<64/6: =26 ;3C8947 24/ =4I69 =26 39<>@6 4/ /"$$$ 49: =26 /$$ C4=4 24/ 9>= C669 <>9/3:6;6: 6 ?8;=26;
/8C@3==6:=24=6G6939=26
>;I@49./>@569/4=3>9<= 39 4::3=3>9 => =26 @>9=27A /474;A =26 C4=4 24/ => C6 <>9/3:6;6:9/855>;=>?23/<>9=69=3>92624/;6736:>9 E8:D@69=>?56J>8;=39=26<4/6>? ! "
;65>;=6: 39
- 6 -
+ ,-.//(!)054;4%>?=26E8:D@69= F23<2;64:/4/89:6;
K% 39<6 963=26; >? =26 54;=36/ 5;>:8<6: 49A :><8@69=>9;6<>;:=>5;>G6=266J4<=4@>89=>? F4D6/C639D64;96:CA=26:6<64/6:4==26=3@6>?
=264<<3:69==>4;;3G64==264@>89=>?F4D6/=26 764;96: >@@3//3>96; =>>I 39=> <>9/3:6;4=3>9 =26 ?4<= =24= =26 :6<64/6: F4/ 4 23D27A /I3776: F>;I@4949:F>87:>?=69C6;6L83;6:=>89:6;=4I6 7>9DE>8;96A/>8=/3:6=26=4=639=267396>?:8=A 6/56<3477A <>9/3:6;39D =26 ?4<= =24= =26 G623<76 39 L86/=3>9 24: 4 ;6D3/=6;6: 4=3>947 >8=6 6;@3= 26 F4D6/ >? =26 :6<64/6: F6;6 4<<65=6: 4/ /$$$56;@>9=2M:437AC24==4>?/&$$$ 56; @>9=2 F23<2 4@>89=/ => 4 =>=47 >? /$$$$ 26 3D2 >8;= :3: 9>= D3G6 49A ;64/>9>9F23<2C4/3/3=39=6;?6;6:F3=2=26?39:39D ;6<>;:6: CA =26 >@@3//3>96; >9 =26 4/56<= >? @>9=27A F4D6/ 64;96: CA =26 :6<64/6: 26 3@58D96: E8:D@69= :>6/ 9>= 6G69 @69=3>9 F24= 4<<>;:39D => =26 3D2 >8;= =26 F4D6/ >? =26 :6<64/6:F6;64==26=3@6>?=264<<3:69=8<249 8996<6//4;A39=6;?6;69<6>954;=>?=263D2>8;= F4/ 4C/>78=67A 89<4776: ?>; 6/56<3477A 39 73D2= >? =26?4<==24==2645567749=>/49:%4;6>7:49:
24G6 7>/= =263; 67:6; />9 49: =26A 24G6 C6<>@6 :6/=3=8=6/ -8;=26; 89:6; =26 4A@69= >? 4D6/ <=&=26>98/3/>9=266@57>A6;=>@439=439
- 7 -
=26;6D3/=6;49:;6<>;:/>?F4D6/6<=3>9>? F23<2;64:/4/89:6;
N
)* G6;A 6@57>A6; /2477 @439=439/8<2;6D3/=6;/49:;6<>;:/D3G39D /8<2 54;=3<874;/ >? 56;/>9/ 6@57>A6: CA 23@ =26 F>;I 56;?>;@6: CA =26@ =26 F4D6/543:=>=26@=26:6:8<=3>9/@4:6 ?;>@ =263; F4D6/ =26 ;6<635=/ D3G69 CA =26@ 49: /8<2 >=26; 54;=3<874;/ 49: 39 /8<2?>;@4/@4AC65;6/<;3C6:
)%* G6;A;6D3/=6;49:;6<>;:;6L83;6:=> C6@439=4396:89:6;=23//6<=3>9/2477?>; =2658;5>/6/>?=23/<=C65;6/6;G6:?>;
4 56;3>: >? =2;66 A64;/ 4?=6; =26 :4=6 >? =2674/=69=;A@4:6=26;639N
-;>@ 4 56;8/47 >? =26 4?>;6@69=3>96: /6<=3>9 3= C6<>@6/<764;=24==26>98/=>@439=439=26F4D6;>77 F4/ >9 =26 6@57>A6; 36 ;6/5>9:69= > % 39<6 39 =2639/=49=<4/6=266@57>A6;24/?4376:3923/:8=A=> @439=439=265;>56;;6<>;:/>?F4D6/>?=26:6<64/6: =2645567749=/<499>=C6@4:6=>/8??6;?>;3=O
3=2=264C>G6<>9=69=3>9/=26764;96:<>89/67 />8D2==>477>F=26455647
- 8 -
# 26764;96:<>89/6745564;39D?>;=2639/8;49<6 <>@549A24/<>9=69:6:=24=/39<6=26<743@3/89:6;=26 >;I@49./ >@569/4=3>9 <= 4/ 56; =26 6<=3>9 4 @393@8@F4D624/C669?3J6:CA3//839D49>=3?3<4=3>9CA =26 69=;47 >G6;9@69= 4/ /"$$$$ <<>;:39D7A ;3C894724/;3D2=7A<>9/3:6;6:=26/4@669<626/>8D2= ?>;:3/@3//47>?=26455647
64;: =26 764;96: <>89/67 ?>; =26 54;=36/ 49: 56;8/6:=26E8:D@69=49:4F4;:>?=26;3C8947 $ 26 /8C/=49=347 L86/=3>9 >? 74F =24= 4;3/6/ ?>; >8;<>9/3:6;4=3>93/ K
26=26; =26 >@@3//3>96; ?>;
>;I@49./ >@569/4=3>9 F4/ E8/=3?36: 39 <>9/3:6;39D =26 39<>@6 >? =26 :6<64/6: 4/ /"$$$ 56; @>9=2 39 =26 ?4<=/ 49: <3;<8@/=49<6/ >? =26 <4/6P
= 3/ 9>= 39 :3/58=6 =24= :6<64/6: 4G66:I249 :36: :8;39D =26 <>8;/6>? =26 6@57>A@69= 49: 3= 3/ 47/>
- 9 -
9>= 39 :3/58=6 =24= 4G66:I249 F4/ F>;I39D 89:6; ;6/5>9:69=>
% G69 =2>8D2 <743@49= 24/ <743@6: =24= :6<64/6:F4/64;939D/#$$$56;@>9=24/4/474;A 49: /$$ :437A C4=4 / 56; 6<=3>9 >?
>;I@49 >@569/4=3>9 <= =26 @4J3@8@ @>9=27A 39<>@6 24/ C669?3J6:3//"$$$9;6/56<=>?C4=43/<>9<6;96: =26E8:D@69=;6736:85>9CA=2645567749=39=24=<4/6=26 G623<76 ;6D3/=6;6: 94=3>947 ;>8=6 56;@3= 39<6 =26 :6<64/6:;6L83;6:=>89:6;=4I67>9DE>8;96A/>8=/3:6=26 =4=639=267396>?:8=A6/56<3477A<>9/3:6;39D=26?4<=>? =26G623<7639L86/=3>926>9.C7656J>8;=24/267: =24=39<4/6263/69=3=76:?>;C4=4394::3=3>9=>=26:437A F4D6/26/43:E8:D@69=3/9>=45573<4C76=>=26?4<=/>? =26 5;6/69= <4/6 26;6?>;6 ;3C8947 24/ ;3D2=7A <>9/3:6;6: =24= @>9=27A /474;A >? =26 :6<64/6: 3/ /"$$$CA;3D2=7A4557A39D=26?4<=>;/49:D;49=6:49 4E8/=49:;64/>94C76<>@569/4=3>926;63/9>6;;>;>;
- 10 -
3;;6D874;3=36/ 39 =26 >;:6; 54//6: CA =26 ;3C8947 <<>;:39D7A=264556473/:3/@3//6:
!12 (%!) '
!12 (#'$ #) '
3/=>7>#