Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92756 (KAR)
M/S SHRIRAM TRANSPORT FINANCE CO.LTD v. AZEEMUDDIN S/O GOUSUDDIN
CRL.A/200244/2022 · 2025-07-24
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92756 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92756 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
!##
$%&$'#()
*+$(( ,
! "# $$#
%"&"$$'
! '&#
(
! ) **+$*$$
"'$*, ! ! %
( )
(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! (
-! ! -! ./01 02 /3/4/ 20/5 6./05.1 78953.6 :80 ;<. /==.66/5; % 78>=6/25/5; /51 02 /5?/@ /;26 6./05.1 78953.6:80;<.0.3=851.5;A/7793.1 $ ==./6 B@ ;<. 78>=6/25/5; 7</66.5C25C ;<. 4/6212;@8:;<.801.08:/7D92;;/6/7D92;;25C;<.0.3=851.5;
:80 ;<. 8::.57. =9523</B6. 951.0 .7;285 & 8: ;<. .C8;2/B6.53;09>.5;37;&&25 8"'$*,
/7;3 25 ;<. 59;3<.66 E<27< /0. 9;>83; 5.7.33/0@:80123=83/68:;<.=0.3.5;/==./6/0./3951.0 =024/;. 78>=6/25; 7/>. ;8 B. :26.1 951.0 .7;285$**8:;<.81.8:02>25/6087.190./66.C25C;<. 78>>2332858:;<.8::.57.=9523</B6.951.0.7;285&8:
;<. .C8;2/B6. 53;09>.5;3 7; 785;.5125C ;</;
- 3 -
78>=6/25/5;23/585%/5F25C:25/57.78>=/5@0.C23;.0.1 951.0 ;<. 512/5 8>=/52.3 7; /51 23 .5C/C.1 25 ;<. B9325.338:=0842125C:25/572/63.0427.951.0<20.=907</3. 6./3./5168/579><@=8;<.7/;285250.3=.7;8:62C<;>8;80 4.<276.3/51<./4@C88134.<276.3 $ .3=851.5;%/7793.1 /==08/7<.1 ;<. 78>=6/25/5;%8>=/5@:80=907</3.8:3<8F.@6/51 ,$
62C<; C8813 4.<276. 8: $**, >81.6 85 3.7851 </51 B/323 B@ E/@ 8: <20. =907</3. :;.0 1.;/26.1 1237933285 /3 ;8 ;<. ;.0>3 8: ;<. 68/5 / 39> 8:
3""****% E/3 6.5; ;8 B. 0.=/21 25 #& >85;<3 /685C E2;<:25/57. 7</0C.3 :80;<. 68/5 ;</;E/3 3/57;285.1 85 &*+$*$/515.7.33/0@1879>.5;3</4.B..5.G.79;.1 25;</;0.C/0125/39>8:3&$'+'%/3;<.;8;/668/5 />895; ;8 B. =/21 B@ ;<. 0.3=851.5; A /7793.1 <.0. E/35.7.33/0@.5;0@25;<..C23;0/;285.0;2:27/;.B88F25 0.3=.7;8:;<.4.<276.B./025C 8%H%",
- 4 -
3 =.0 ;<. /C0..>.5; ;<. 68/5 />895;
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
" 02 23</50/8 8
/0/@/5 /1/4 E/3 .G/>25.1 85 B.</6: 8: ;<. 78>=6/25/5; 5 62.9 8: .G/>25/;285%25%7<2.:/5/::21/42;7/>.;8B.:26.1B@3/21
- 5 -
23</50/8 E<.0.25 <. </3 0.2;.0/;.1 ;<. 78>=6/25;
/4.0>.5;3/51>/0F.185B.</6:8:;<.78>=6/25/5;;<. 123<85890.1 7<.D9. /5F .51803.>.5;3 78=@ 8: 6.C/6 58;27.=83;/60.7.2=;/7F58E6.1C.>.5;C.5.0/6=8E.08: /;;805.@/51/9;<802I/;2856.;;.0/3G3;8& , 5 <23 70833%.G/>25/;285 <. /1>2;3 ;</; .D9/;.1>85;<6@253;/66>.5;3E/325/39>8:3$*$,,% /51 / 39> 8: 3$***% </3 B..5 0.=/21 B@ ;<. /7793.1 <.68/5/77895;E/38=.5.12502.5;/6/5F8: 8>>.07.21/085&*+$*$.:90;<.0/1>2;3;</;
/:;.0 85. >85;< 8: 0.7.2=; 8: ;<. /5F .51803.>.5;
58;27. 7/>. ;8 B. 2339.1 . </3 /53E.0.1 ;</; 68/5 /==627/;285 /51 <@=8;<.7/;285 1..1 </3 B..5 =08197.1 B.:80. ;<. 890; 5 785:085;/;285 68/5 /77895; 1.;/263 =.0;/2525C;8;<./7793.123/1>2;;.1B@;<.E2;5.33/51 ;<.0.:80.3/>.E/3>/0F.1/3G ' ./638/1>2;3;</;25;<.78>=6/25;;<.0.2358 >.5;285/3;8E</;23;<./>895;19.:08>;<./7793.1
- 6 -
./1>2;3;</;25G85+*$*";<.0.E/3/19. 8: 3,'$#% /51 85 +*#$*" ;<. 19. E/3 3+&&'% & 5<23:90;<.070833%.G/>25/;285<.3=.72:27/66@ /1>2;3 ;</; ;<.0.E/3 856@ 85.68/5;0/53/7;285 B.;E..5 ;<. 78>=6/25; /51 ;<.
/7793.1 /51 68/5 79> <@=8;<.7/;285 1..1 23 B./025C 8*$*+"***" E<27<E/35.2;<.00.37<.196.15800.5.E.1 + ./1>2;3;</;B.:80.0.=833.3325C;<.6800@/ 58;27. E/3 2339.1 ;8 ;<. /7793.1 /51 3/21 58;27. 23 /638 =6/7.1B.:80.;<.890;/516800@B.685C25C;8;<./7793.1 E/3386185$"*+$*#.:90;<.0/1>2;3;</;<.</358 1879>.5;3 ;8 3<8E /3 ;8 E</; 23 ;<. />895; ;</; </3 B..50./62I.1B@3/6.8:;<.3/216800@./1>2;3;</;85 *$$* <. E/3 58; .>=68@.1 25 ;<. 78>=6/25/5; A 8>=/5@ * 3/C/253;;<..421.57.=6/7.1850.7801B@;<. 78>=6/25/5;/7793.1C8;.G/>25.1<2>3.6:/3(5
- 7 -
<23 .421.57. <. </3 3;/;.1 ;</; <. </3 8B;/25.1 68/5 />895;8:3""****%250.3=.7;8:3.7851</516800@25 ;<.@./0$**+/51/;;</;?957;90.B6/5FB851/51G E<27<E/325B6/5FE/3C24.5/33.7902;@.</33;/;.1 ;</; /B89; 3******% 23 0.=/21 5 ;<. @./0 $*$ E<.5<.4232;.1;<.78>=6/25/5;%8>=/5@:800.;9058:
;<. 7<.D9. />895; <. </3 B..5 ;<0./;.5.1 B@ 3;/;25C ;</; ;<. 7<.D9. E8961 B. 9;262I.1 /51 / 7/3. E8961 B. :26.1/C/253;<2> . </3 /638 1.=83.1 ;</; /:;.0 ;<. 6800@ E/3 3861B@;<.78>=6/25/5;A8>=/5@<.2358EE80F25C25 !/2 </E/52 </B/ . </3 3;/;.1 ;</; ( 23 58; ;<. =.0385E<8</325:80>.1<2>;</;;<..5;20.68/5/>895; </3B..5=/21.</3=08197.1;E.5;@.2C<;0.7.2=;3:80 </425C 0.=/21 ;<. />895; ;<. 3/>. E.0. >/0F.1 /3 G3;8$& $ 5<2370833%.G/>25/;285<.</3/1>2;;.1;</;
<. =907</3.1 ;<. 3.7851 </51 6800@ /51 :80 E<27<
- 8 -
=90=83. <. </3 ;/F.5 ;<. 68/5 25 ;<. @./0 $**+ /51 0.=/21 ;<. />895; ;266 $*$ . 1.52.1 </425C .G.79;.1 /5@1879>.5;25;<.@./0$*$./1>2;3;</;GE/3 32C5.1 /51 C24.5B@ <2> ;8 ;<. 78>=6/25/5;%8>=/5@ 25 ;<. @./0 $**+ /51 58; 25 ;<. @./0 $*" . 1.52.3 ;</; G3;8$&=.0;/253;8;<.68/5;0/53/7;2858:;<.@./0 $*$ /3.185;<./B84..421.57.850.78016./05.1 02/6 !91C. <./01 ;<. /0C9>.5;3 8: ;<. =/0;2.3 /51 123>233.178>=6/25;/51/7D92;;.1;<./7793.1 # <.4/6212;@8:;<.3/>.237/66.125D9.3;28525 ;<23/==./685;<.:8668E25CC089513
! - 9 -
"
#
$
% &
&
'
&
%
( )*$+
- 10 -
,
,
(
(
- 11 -
" &
! & &
-
" 02/3/4/20/56./05.178953.6/==./025C85 B.</6: 8: 02 >B.F/0 6./05.1 78953.6 :80 ;<. - 12 -
/==.66/5; 785;.513 ;</; 6./05.1 !91C. </3 58; =08=.06@ /==0.72/;.1 ;<. >/;.02/6 .421.57. 85 0.7801 /51 121 58;
785321.0 ;<. =0.39>=;285 /4/26/B6. ;8 ;<. 78>=6/25/5;
951.0.7;285&8:;<. .C8;2/B6.53;09>.5;37;/51 E085C6@ /7D92;;.1 ;<. /7793.1 0.396;25C 25 >237/002/C.8: ?93;27./51389C<;:80/668E25C;<./==./6 , . E8961 :90;<.0 785;.51 ;</; /1>2;;.16@ G3 ;8 $& =.0;/25 ;8 ./062.0 68/5 ;0/53/7;285 B9; 25 0.3=.7;8:3.785168/5;0/53/7;28558/>895;23=/21/51 E<.51.>/51.1G7/>.;8B.2339.1B@;<./7793.1 E<27< </3 B..5 123<85890.1 /51 ;<.0.:80. ;<. /7793.1 89C<; ;8 </4. B..5 785427;.1 :80 ;<. 8::.57. 951.0 .7;285&8:;<. .C8;2/B6.53;09>.5;37;/51389C<; :80/668E25C;<./==./6 ' .
02/5?/@/;266./05.178953.6 :80;<.0.3=851.5;39==80;3;<.2>=9C5.1?91C>.5;. E8961:90;<.0785;.51;</;(</33=.72:27/66@/1>2;;.1 ;</;;<.0.23856@85.;0/53/7;285;</;2325;<.@./0$**+
- 13 -
/51 ;<.0.:80. ;<. 123>233/6 8: ;<. 78>=6/25; 23 ?93; /51 =08=.0 & .E8961:90;<.0785;.51;</;;<.7<.D9.;</;
E/3C24.5/33.7902;@/;;<.;2>.8:68/5;0/53/7;2858:;<. @./0$**+</3B..5>2393.1B@;<.78>=6/25/5;/51:/63. 78>=6/25; 7/>. ;8 B. 681C.1 /C/253; ;<. /7793.1 /51 389C<;:80123>233/68:;<./==./6 + /425C<./01;<./0C9>.5;385B8;<321.3;<. :8668E25C=825;3E8961/023.:80785321.0/;285 /0 *
1 +23 4
"
5 /0 *
&
5 /0
"
4+ 6
&
5 /0 *5
- 14 -
-./'012.#1234*/20
$* 5 ;<. 7/3. 85 </51 G ;<. 7<.D9. B.685C25C ;8 ;<. /7793.1 /51 32C5/;90. :8951 ;<.0.25 23 ;</; 8: ;<. /7793.1 23 58; 25 123=9;. 7780125C ;8 ;<. 78>=6/25; ;<. /7793.1 8B;/25.1 68/5 25 / 39> 8:
3""****% :80 ;<. =90=83. 8: =907</325C / 6800@ 85 <@=8;<.7/;285B/323/51/C0..>.5;7/>.;8B..5;.0.125 ;<.@./0$*$ $ ; 23 /638 ;<. 7/3. 8: ;<. 78>=6/25/5; ;</; ;<. 7<.D9.7/>.;8B.2339.1;8E/0130.=/@>.5;8:;<.68/5 />895; E<27< 85 =0.3.5;/;285 7/>. ;8 B. 123<85890.1 ( </3 3=.72:27/66@ 3;/;.1 25 <23 .G/>25/;285%25%7<2.:
;</; / 39> 8: 3$***% 23 0.=/21 B@ ;<. /7793.1 /3 /C/253; ;8;/6 39> 8: 3&$'+'% . /1>2;3 ;</; 68/5% 79>%<@=8;<.7/;285 68/5 59>B.0 23 $*+"***" $$ <. =907</3. 8: 3.7851 </51 6800@ B./025C 59>B.0 %H%", 23 58; 25 123=9;. 38 /638 ;<. - 15 -
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
- 16 -
;0/53/7;285 B@ ;<. 78>=6/25/5;%8>=/5@ E2;< /7793.1 <. 1879>.5;3 ;</; /0. =6/7.1 85 0.7801 25 ;<.
:80> 8: G3;8$&2;23;8B.58;.1;</;;<.@/0./661/;.1 ./062.0;8$*$.G7.=;85.0.7.2=;5/>.6@G$231/;.1 **$$** G 23 1/;.1 *$** G# 23 1/;.1 **#$** G, 23 1/;.1 /; $*&$** /51 ;<. 6/3; 1879>.5;23=.0;/2525C;8"*,$*$E<.0.252;</3B..5 >.5;285.1;</;250.3=.7;8:6800@B./025C 8H#,#' / 39> 8: 3$"*** 23 0.7.24.1 :08> ;<. /7793.1 B@ ;<. 78>=6/25/5;%8>=/5@ $" ; </3 B..5 >.5;285.1 25 ;<. 3/21 1879>.5; ;</;;<.3/21=/@>.5;23;8E/013;<.253;/66>.5;7866.7;285 8;<.0 952; 7/3< 5 G ;<. =/@>.5; >/1. B@ ;<. /7793.123/77895;.1/51.4.5/7780125C;8G/385 +'$*";<./>895;19./3=.0;<./77895;>/25;/25.1 B@;<.78>=6/25/5;2;3.6: 23 25/39>8:3#+&#&'*% E<27<23/:;.0/1125C;<.=.5/625;.0.3;
- 17 -
$, 8 .G=6/5/;285 23 :80;<78>25C 85B.</6: 8: ;<. 78>=6/25/5; E2;< 0.C/01 ;8 ;<. 12370.=/572.3 :8951 25 /1>2;;.11879>.5;3/51;<.7<.D9./>895;(<.5;<.0. 23 856@ 85. ;0/53/7;285 ;</; </3 ;/F.5 =6/7. /51 />895;
</3 B..5 =/21 B@ ;<. /7793.1 /3 78961 B. 3..5 :08> G ;8 $& ;<. ;<.80@ =9; :80E/01 85 B.</6: 8: ;<. 78>=6/25/5; ;</; ;<.0. E/3 / 3.7851 68/5 ;0/53/7;285 25 ;<. @./0 $*$ /51 =/@>.5;3 /0. 19. 25 0.3=.7; 8: ;<. 3.7851 68/5 ;0/53/7;285 25 0.3=.7; 8: ;<. 3/>. 6800@ 7/558;B.7895;.5/57.1256/E1>2;;.16@58B81@E8961 >/F./=/@>.5;/5;272=/;25C;<.68/53/57;285 $' ;23/638=.0;25.5;;858;.;</;;<.78>=6/25/5; :/26.1;8=08197.B.:80.;<.890;;<.68/5/C0..>.5;80 <@=8;<.7/;285/C0..>.5;;8.3;/B623<;</;;<.0.E.0.;E8 12::.0.5; 68/5 ;0/53/7;2853 ;</; ;<. 78>=6/25/5; </1 E2;< ;<. /7793.1 /51 ;<. =/@>.5;3 >/1. B@ ;<. /7793.1 ;8E/013 ;<. ./062.0 68/5 ;0/53/7;285 /51 ;<. 7<.D9. D9.3;2857/>.;8B.2339.1250.3=.7;8:;<.3.785168/5 ;0/53/7;285
- 18 -
$& /F25C 58;. 8: ;<.3. /3=.7;3 8: ;<. >/;;.0 801.0 8: /7D92;;/6 0.7801.1 B@ ;<. 6./05.1 02/6 !91C. 23 B/3.185=08=.0/==0.72/;2858:;<.>/;.02/6.421.57.85 0.7801E2;<38951/5168C27/60./3853 $+ 4.5 /:;.0 0.%/==0.72/;285 8: ;<. >/;.02/6 .421.57.850.7801;<23890;238:;<.785321.0.18=25285 ;</; ;<. 78>=6/25/5; </3 :/26.1 ;8 >/F. 89; / 7/3. ;</; ;<.0.E/319.25/39>8:3""****%/385;<.1/;.8: GB.25C*&*#$*":08>;<.0.78013;</;</3B..5 /1>2;;.1B@;<.78>=6/25/5;/685.:;</;2338;<.5;<. =0.39>=;285 ;</; </3 B..5 .5?8@.1 B@ ;<. 78>=6/25/5;
E/3 39::272.5;6@ 0.B9;;.1 B@ ;<. /7793.1 B@ .G/>2525C <2>3.6:/51=6/725C;<.>/;.02/61879>.5;3 * (<.5 397< / 0.B9;;/6 .421.57. 23 =6/7.1 85 0.78018593/C/253<2:;.185;<.78>=6/25/5;;8.3;/B623< ;</; ;<. />895; >.5;285.1 25 G 25 / 39> 8: 3""****% E/3 6.C/66@ 0.784.0/B6. 1.B; :08> ;<. /7793.1 /51 ;<.0.:80. ;<. /7793.1 </3 78>>2;;.1 /5
- 19 -
8::.57. 951.0 .7;285 & 8: ;<. .C8;2/B6. 53;09>.5;3 7; 23 58; .3;/B623<.1 B@ ;<. 78>=6/25/5; B@ =6/725C 78C.5;.421.57.850.7801 <.0.:80.;<.801.08:/7D92;;/6=/33.1B@;<. 6./05.1 02/6 !91C. 5..13 58 25;.0:.0.57. .4.5 /:;.0 0. /==0.72/;2858:;<.>/;.02/6.421.57.850.7801 $ 7780125C6@825; 83/51$/0./53E.0.125 ;<. -./'012.#123%
257. 825; 83 /51 $ /0.
/53E.0.1 25 5.C/;24.;<23=825;E896158;/023.:80785321.0/;285 -./'012.5123 # 542.E8::25125C38:;<23890;85825; 83 ;8;<.:8668E25C801.023=/33.1
- 20 -
<.02>25/6==./623>.02;6.33/51<.0.B@ 123>233.1
0) $"(
23; 86 8#