Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92751 (KAR)
CHOUDHARY GOPIE v. SANJEEVREDDY
CRL.P/201083/2025 · 2025-08-20
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92751 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92751 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
#
% %&'( %'' )
!! "#
$%% &'(
! ) *
+
#
%( %$($(,-
$%&. ) *
+
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! % & ! ( *
+
"
& / *
+ ! !! (&. ! ! ! #
#! ! 0
#
*
0
# +
12 3245456728 128257 9257: ;<<=>2? 57 6 & / *@?6 +327?57:67412A5@26A 412@2;872???54567;@275685B5@#=?:2;7?#!5?;8 C128257;A428 82A2882? 46 ;> 412 85;@ 6=84 A68 >1684D 5> >22E57:46F=;>1412<85G57;@386<22?57:>57545;42?;:;57>4 15G A68 412 6AA27<2> 3=75>1;9@2 =7?28 2<4567> (& ;7? . 6A 2:645;9@2 7>48=G274> <4 && C128257;A428 82A2882?46;>412<4D
12 A;<4> 6A 412 <;>2 57 9852A ;82 41;4 412 82>367?274A5@2?412385B;42<6G3@;574576
- 3 -
92A68241285;@6=84;:;57>44123245456728128257;@@2:57: <6GG5>>5676A4126AA27<23=75>1;9@2=7?282<4567(&6A <4
( 4 5> 412 <674274567 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 92A682 412 85;@ 6=84 41;4 412 ;<<=>2? ;7? 15> H5A2 6AA282? 46 >2@@!@;46$ 6H72?9I412GA68;<67>5?28;45676A >$12<6G3@;57;74;<<2342?4126AA28;7? 3;5?>&$;>;?B;7<2;7?386G5>2?463;I412 9;@;7<2;G6=746A>($;441245G26A2J2<=457:
412 >;@2 ?22? 9I 3;I57: 9;@;7<2 <67>5?28;4567 ;G6=74 12 ;<<=>2? ;7? 15> H5A2 2J382>>2? 41258 57;95@54I 46 2J2<=42 412 >;@2 ?22? ;7? ;:822? 46 823;I 412 ;?B;7<2 ;G6=746A>&$12<6G3@;57;74;<<2342?412 >;5? 6AA28 6A 823;IG274 6A 412 ;?B;7<2 ;G6=74 12 ;<<=>2? 1;> 5>>=2? ; <12F=2 92;857: 6&(/&. ?;42? ' A68 > $ 57 A;B6=8 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 12 <6G3@;57;74 824=872? 412 685:57;@ >;@2 ;:822G274 9I ;<<23457: 412 <12F=2 127 412 <12F=2 H;>382>2742?A6827<;>1G274412>;G2H;>?5>1676=82? - 4 -
;>A=7?>57>=AA5<527412<6G3@;57;745>>=2?@2:;@7645<2 57A68G57: 412 ;<<=>2? ;96=4 ?5>1676=8 6A <12F=2 ;7? <;@@57: =367 15G 46 3;I 412 <12F=2 ;G6=74 7>3542 6A >28B5<2 6A 7645<2 412 ;<<=>2? 1;?764823;5?412 <12F=2 ;G6=74 ;7? 412829I <6GG5442? 412 ;96B2 G2745672? 6AA27<2 1282A682 412 <6G3@;57;74 82F=2>42? 412 85;@ 6=84 46 4;E2 <6:75K;7<2 6A 412 6AA27<2 ;7? 46 57545;42 @2:;@ ;<4567 12 85;@ 6=84 466E <6:75K;7<2 6A 412 6AA27<2 ;7? 82:5>4282? 412 <;>2 57545;@@I ;> 6 H15<1 5> >=9>2F=274@I 827=G9282? ;> 6& /
. 12 <6G3@;57;74 ;332;8> 46 1;B2 A5@2? ;7 ;33@5<;4567 >22E57: ;G27?G274 6A 412 <6G3@;574 46 <67427? 41;4 412 ;:822G274 46 3=8<1;>2 !@;4 6$ ;7?3;IG2746A;?B;7<2;G6=746A>&$H;>57 2J<1;7:2 6A 412 386328452> >4;7?57: 57 412 7;G2 6A 412 <6G3@;57;749I2J2<=457:412>;@2?22?5782>32<46A@64 6>( ($( ' 9257: 82>5?2745;@ >542> A68G2? 57 I6 .6A;G;?;:5B5@@;:2I;@E;@;7?;@4;@=E
- 5 -
L;1228;9;? ?5>485<4 ;7:;82??I 2@;7:;7; ;7? 412 3;IG2746A>=<1;G6=74H;>2541284186=:19;7E48;7>A28 68 4186=:1 <;>1 12 >;5? ;33@5<;4567 A68 ;G27?G274 <;G2 46 92 ;@@6H2? 9I 412 85;@ 6=84 B5?2 68?28 ?;42? . . <<68?57:@I 412 <6G3@;574 <;G2 46 92 ;G27?2? 12 3245456728 9257: 412 ;<<=>2? ;3386;<12? 415> 6=84 >22E57: F=;>157: 6A 412 <85G57;@ 386<22?57:> 57545;42?;:;57>415G
% 2;8? 85 B57;>1
3@;67E;8 @2;872?
<6=7>2@ A68 412 3245456728 ;7? 85 ;B5 ;45@ @2;872? <6=7>2@ A68 412 82>367?274 28=>2? 412 G;4285;@> 67 82<68? / 7 B52H 6A 412 85B;@ <674274567> =8:2? 9I 412 @2;872?<6=7>2@A6896414123;8452>4123657441;4H6=@? ;85>2A68GI<67>5?28;45675>
- 6 -
!"#$%
I;7>H2846412;96B2365745>57412 A68 412A6@@6H57:
4 5> 412 <674274567 6A 412 @2;872? <6=7>2@ A68 412 3245456728 41;4 412 ;G27?G274 >6=:14 9I 412 <6G3@;57;74 ;7? 328G5442? 9I 412 85;@ 6=84 1;> 4;E27 ;H;I 412 <;=>2 6A ;<4567 A68 412 <6G3@;57;74 46 A5@2 412 <6G3@;574 =<1 ;G27?G274 H;> ;@@6H2? 9I 412 85;@ 6=84 ;A428 4;E57: <6:75K;7<2 H15<1 5> 764 328G5>>59@2 =7?28 @;H
B27 ;A428 328G54457: ;G27?G274 412 85;@ 6=84 1;> 764 4;E27 412 <6:75K;7<2 67<2 ;:;57 4 415> >4;:241285;@6=84<;77644;E2<6:75K;7<26A4126AA27<2 67<2;:;57
& 7 >=33684 6A 15> <674274567 12 1;> 3@;<2? 82@5;7<2 67 412 ?2<5>567 6A 412 32J 6=84 57
- 7 -
7 412 >;5?<;>2;<6G3@;574;@@2:57:<6GG5>>5676A4126AA27<2 3=75>1;9@2 =7?28 2<4567 (& 6A <4 H;> A5@2? =9>2F=274@I ;7 ;33@5<;4567 A68 ;G27?G274 H;> A5@2? >22E57:46;G27?412?;426A<12F=2A86G 46 12 85;@ 6=84 82M2<42? 412 38;I28 12 5:16=84;@@6H57:41232454567A5@2?9I412<6G3@;57;74 328G5442? 412 ;G27?G274 6A 412 <6G3@;574 H15<1 H;> <1;@@27:2? 92A682 412 32J 6=84 12 32J 6=84 12@? 41;4 412 82;>67> ;>>5:72? 9I 412 <6G3@;57;74 41;4 9I G5>4;E2 H15@2 4;E57: <6352> A86G 412 <6G3=428 412 ?;42 6A 412 <12F=2 H;> G2745672? 57<6882<4@I <6=@? 764 92 ;<<2342? ;> M=>45A5;9@2 <;=>2 ;> 2B28 57 412 @2:;@ 7645<2 412 ?;42 H;> G2745672? ;>
;7? 764
' 7412382>274<;>257545;@@I545>412<674274567 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 41;4 412 ;<<=>2? ;:822? 46 >2@@ @64 6 $ 57 A;B6=8 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 A68 ; 464;@
1 &
' (
)*
+, +#"-"."##"(
!"-
- 8 -
<67>5?28;4567 6A >$ 6=4 6A H15<1 >&$H;>3;5?;>;?B;7<26H;8?>823;IG274 6A 412 >;5? ;?B;7<2 ;G6=74 412 ;<<=>2? 1;? 5>>=2? <12F=2 H15<1 5> >=9M2<4 G;4428 6A 415> <6G3@;574 H15<1 <;G24692?5>1676=82?7>35426A5>>=;7<26A7645<2412 ;<<=>2? 1;? 764823;5? 412<12F=2;G6=74 12829I12 1;> <6GG5442? 412 6AA27<2 3=75>1;9@2 =7?28 2<4567 (& 6A<4
6H 9I ;G27?57: 412 <6G3@;574 ;7?
57>28457:
3;8;$*;+ 412 <6G3@;57;74 <67427?> 41;4 3;IG274 6A <67>5?28;4567;G6=7446H;8?>3=8<1;>26A@646$ 57;>=G6A>&$5>57412A68G6A2J<1;7:26A 386328452> >4;7?57: 57 412 7;G2 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 52 @646>( (46( 'A68G2?57I6 .6A;G;?;:5 B5@@;:2H15<1H;>328G5442?9I41285;@6=84
12;G27?G27441;4H;>328G5442?9I41285;@ 6=84 H5@@ 764 <1;7:2 412 <674274567 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 H54182:;8?465>>=;7<26A412<12F=29I412<6G3@;57;74
- 9 -
;>82A2882?4657412<6G3@;57446H;8?>?5><1;8:26A@2:;@@I 27A68<2;9@2?294?5>1676=86A412>;G25>>=;7<26A@2:;@ 7645<2>28B5<26A412@2:;@7645<2;7?767$3;IG2746A412 <12F=2;G6=7457>35426A>28B5<26A7645<2
127 412>2 A;<4> <67>454=42 412 6AA27<2 3=75>1;9@2=7?282<4567(&6A<4;G27?G27441;4 H;>328G5442?9I41285;@6=8446<67427?41;43;IG274 6A;?B;7<2;G6=746A>&$46H;8?>3=8<1;>26A A@;4H;>57412A68G6A2J<1;7:26A412386328452>>4;7?57: 574127;G26A412<6G3@;57;74;>82A2882?46;96B2H5@@ 76457;7IG;7728;@428412<;=>26A;<456712;<<=>2? 5>27454@2?464;E2?2A27<292A68241285;@6=8482:;8?57:
412 <674274567 4;E27 9I 412 <6G3@;57;74 =4 412 ;G27?G274 76H 328G5442? 57 A;B6=8 6A 412 <6G3@;57;74 5776H;I;@428>412<;=>26A;<4567A68A5@57:412<6G3@;574 =7?282<4567(&6A<46826B282B27;<<68?57:46 412 3245456728 12 1;> 764 I24 ;332;82? 92A682 412 85;@ 6=847684;E27;7I?2A27<245>764412<6742745676A 412324545672841;4>121;?5>>=2?823@I46412@2:;@7645<2
- 10 -
41;4 H;> 5>>=2? 9I 412 <6G3@;57;74 7?28 412>2 <58<=G>4;7<2> ;G 6A 412 6357567 41;4 76 :86=7?> ;82 G;?2 6=4 46 >22E F=;>157: 6A 412 <85G57;@ 386<22?57:> <<68?57:@I;7>H28412;96B2365745741272:;45B2;7? 386<22?463;>>412A6@@6H57:
1285G57;@24545675>
*( %##' $
5>46@6.