- 1 - !"#$ % &' % &' #'(# %% )(* + !"# $ %& ' ( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * & !#)) +& !"# & & "++ &!"# $ %& ,- " ' &, , )%' , & &, (& * & ")" ( & & ,&"##"#+ . *#+ . &, & , & (& & / &( 012 / &( ( ' %/ &( ' 345 066708 9127: 7;<4=1 )%' => <37 &=<=: 734;875;<*""%37:7410><7::7>7::72<=05?<37;<@>=: 53=:<' 305 A771 >4872 AB <37 ;804C01<5 ;308871D41D <37 - 3 - E92DC71< 012 0F0:2 20<72 * 605572 AB <37 714=: 4G48 (92D7 012 224<4=108 & 308H4 41 & =")" ,0;<5 D4G41D :457 <= <37 >4841D => <37 066708 A:47>8B 5<0<72 0:7 <30< =1 ))) 0< 0A=9< ) 6C <37 27;70572 3012:0537H30: F05 6:=;77241D =1 345 C=<=:;B;87A70:41D:7D45<:0<4=1=+* +)*>:=C345 0D:4;98<9:78012A70:41DB="0<71H9:G4880D7<=345 3=95754<90<720<308H4=1308H4+9C10A02:=02 371 37 :70;372 170: 068069: ;:=55 0< <30< <4C7 0 124;0;0:A70:41D:7D45<:0<4=1=&++"F34;3F05 A741D 2:4G71410 :053 01217D84D71< C0117: ;0C7 >:=C =66=54<754270122053720D0415<<3727;7057250:7598< =><370>=:750420;;4271<<3727;70572595<04172D:47G=95 41E9:47F053=564<084I7201259;;9CA72<=<3741E9:475 37 ;804C01<5 >4872 0 67<4<4=1 9127: 7;<4=1 => <37 ;< 577H41D ;=C67150<4=1 >=: <37 270<3 => <37 27;7057208=1DF4<341<7:75< - 4 - # 6=1 57:G4;7 => 1=<4;7 <37 :756=1271< = 06670:72 <3:=9D3 ;=91578 012 >4872 F:4<<71 5<0<7C71< 271B41D <37 0G7:C71<5 C027 41 <37 ;804C 67<4<4=1 37 :756=1271<=27564<757:G4;7=>1=<4;72421=<06670: A7>=:7<37 :4A9108012F05680;727J+60:<7 1 <37 A0545 => <37 6870241D5 => <37 60:<475 <37 804C5 :4A9108>:0C72<37455975012<37:70><7::7;=:272 <37 7G4271;7 37 :4A9108 AB 4C69D172 E92DC71< 012 0F0:230560:<8B088=F72<37;804C67<4<4=10123782<30< <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= 0 ;=C67150<4=1 => 5"##"#+08=1DF4<341<7:75<0<<37:0<7=>.60 012 3782 <30< :756=1271< =5 012 0:7 840A87 <= 60B ;=C67150<4=1 0C=91< 08=1D F4<3 41<7:75< 741D 0DD:47G72<376:7571<066708305A771>4872 37870:172;=91578>=:<37;804C01<5305:04572<37 >=88=F41D;=1<71<4=15 0' ,4:5<8B <37 ;804C01<5 0557:< <30< <37 27;70572 F05 0D720A=9<*B70:50<<37<4C7=><370;;4271<0123020 - 5 - 011908 41;=C7 => 5+ AB 2=41D A9541755 012 0D:4;98<9:45< D:=F41D 59D0:;017 012 59668B41D <= <37 >0;<=:B =F7G7: <37 055755C71< => C=1<38B 41;=C7 => <3727;705720<5+AB<37 :4A91084591E95<4>472 0127::=17=95 A' 7;=128B <37 :4A9108 305 F:=1D8B ;=15427:72 <37 0D7=><3727;7057205567:<3780F80422=F1AB<37 =1@A87 96:7C7 =9:< 41 <37 ;057 => , %# - ! ! .$ 41 ;0575 F37:7 <37 27;70572F05578>+7C68=B72=::7;74G720>4J725080:B01 0224<4=1=>.=><3775<0A84537241;=C7<=F0:25?>9<9:7 6:=567;<5@ 45 F0::01<72 F371 <37 27;70572 F05 A7<F771 <37 0D7 => <= B70:5 37 5042 6:41;4687 305 <= A7 0668472<=<376:7571<;057 ;' 34:28B0567:<37E92DC71<=><37=1@A8796:7C7 =9:<41<37;057=> /( - ! ' . 70;3 => <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= ;=C67150<4=1 => 5#+ - 6 - 9127: <37 3702 => ?8=55 => 8=G7 012 0>>7;<4=1 012 ;=15=:<49C@ 2' 05<8B ;=15427:41D <37 0D7 012 0G=;0<4=1 => <37 27;70572 <37 =G7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A91084541027K90<7012=1<378=F7:5427 4<3 <37 0A=G7 ;=1<71<4=15 <37 870:172 ;=91578 5=9D3<<=088=F<37066708 ) 1 <37 =<37: 3012 <37 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 159:01;7 =C601B 305 :04572 <37 >=88=F41D ;=91<7:+ ;=1<71<4=15 0' ,4:5<8B 08<3=9D3 <37 ;804C01<5 ;804C <30< <37 27;70572F0570:141D5+67:0119CAB2=41D A9541755 012 D:=F41D 59D0:;017 012 59668B41D <= <37 >0;<=:B <37B 30G7 >04872 <= 59A5<01<40<7 <374: ;804C F4<3 5966=:<41D 2=;9C71<5 =157K971<8B <37 :4A9108 305 05575572<371=<4=10841;=C7F34;345=1<3734D37:5427 A' 7;=128B 541;7 <37 ;804C01<5 30G7 1=< 75<0A845372 <37 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 <37B 0:7 1=< 71<4<872 >=: ;=C67150<4=1<=F0:25?>9<9:76:=567;<5@ - 7 - ;' 34:28B =1 066:7;40<4=1 => =:08 012 2=;9C71<0:B 7G4271;7 012 ;=15427:41D <37 0D7 012 0G=;0<4=1 => <37 27;70572 <37 =G7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A910845E95<012:705=10A87 4<3 <37 0A=G7 ;=1<71<4=15 <37 870:172 ;=91578 5=9D3<<=245C455<37066708 " 70:2 <37 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 60:<475 012 67:9572<37E92DC71<0120F0:2=><37 :4A9108 * < 45 1=< 41 24569<7 <30< 27;70572 3012:0537H30: 2472 41 <37 :=02 <:0>>4; 0;;4271< =;;9::72 =1 ))) 297<=:05301217D84D71<2:4G41D=><37=>>71241DG734;87 AB4<52:4G7: 37 ;804C01<5 ;804C <30< 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5+ 67: 0119C A9< >04872 <= 6:=29;7 5966=:<41D2=;9C71<5<=59A5<01<40<7<374:;804C1<37 0A571;7=>6:==>=>41;=C7<371=<4=10841;=C7305<=A7 05575572 37 :4A9108 305 :4D3<8B 05575572 <37 1=<4=108 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 05 5+ 6C = <37 - 8 - 0>=:75042 41;=C7 . 305 <= A7 02272 =1 0;;=91< => >9<9:7 6:=567;<5 41 G47F => <37 80F 8042 2=F1 AB <37 =15<4<9<4=1 71;3 => <37 96:7C7 =9:< 41 0%# 1 %596:0' 395 <37 C=1<38B 41;=C7 ;=C75 <= 5+ 37 :4A9108305:4D3<8B2729;<72:2=><37 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 <=F0:25 67:5=108 7J671575 012 :7C04141D 0C=91< 305 A771 <0H71 05 345 ;=1<:4A9<4=1 <= <37>0C48BG71<3=9D3<37;804C01<530G76:=29;72<37 ;0:2=><3727;7057205J<3720<7=>A4:<305 C71<4=172 <37:741 45 #*" 37:7>=:7 05 =1 <37 20<7 => 0;;4271< <37 27;70572 F05 0D72 0A=9< * 37 C98<46847: 06684;0A87 <= 345 0D7 D:=96 45 ?*@ 395 <37 ;804C01<50:771<4<872<=;=C67150<4=1=>2$$3 %5LL*L'=10;;=91<=>?8=55=>27671271;B@ 1G47F=><3780F80422=F1AB<3796:7C7=9:<41 <37 ;057 => 0 1 %596:0' ;804C01< = F4>7 => <37 27;70572 45 71<4<872 >=: ;=C67150<4=1 =>2$3 9127:<37 3702=> /8=55=> 56=9508;=15=:<49C/;804C01<=5012;3482:71=><37 - 9 - 27;70572 0:7 71<4<872 >=: ;=C67150<4=1 => 2$3 70;39127:<373702=>?8=55=>60:71<08;=15=:<49C@ 37;=C67150<4=1=>5*"#+0F0:272AB<37 :4A91089127:<373702=>?C724;087J671575@45A0572=1 <37C724;08A48856:=29;72AB<37;804C01<501245277C72 E95<012:705=10A87 395 <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= <37 >=88=F41D ;=C67150<4=1 4567289:7;7<6= <:6=67968<2 4;79 8>8=<6<?@ 9A:2;=9 )2* =55=>27671271;B012 >9<9:76:=567;<5 *# ,917:087J671575012 <:0156=:<0<4=1=>2702A=2B =55=>75<0<7 =55=>;=15=:<49C &724;08J671575 *"# 98B $ $ - 10 - # 1<37:7598<<37>=88=F41D=:27:45605572 0' 37066708458BB>6<:758=9 A' 37E92DC71<=><37804C5 :4A910845C=24>472 ;' 37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= 0 <=<08 ;=C67150<4=1 => 2$ $3 05 0D0415< 5"##"#+0F0:272AB<37 :4A9108 2' 37 159:01;7 =C601B 45 24:7;<72 <= 276=54< <37;=C67150<4=10C=91<08=1DF4<341<7:75<0< . 60 >:=C <37 20<7 => >4841D => <37 ;804C 67<4<4=1 <488 <37 20<7 => :7084I0<4=1 F4<341 0 67:4=2=>54JF77H5>:=C<3720<7=>:7;746<=>0 ;=6B=><345E92DC71< 7' 37 066=:<4=1C71< 276=54< 012 :787057 => 0C=91< 53088 A7 C027 41 0;;=:201;7 F4<3 <37 <7:C5=><370F0:2=><37 :4A9108 >' 1G47F=><37=:27:20<72605572AB <345 =9:< <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 1=< 71<4<872 >=: - 11 - 41<7:75< =1 <37 71301;72 ;=C67150<4=1 >=: <37 2780B7267:4=2=>**20B541>4841D<37066708 <3 )% * ' <3 )#'(#* ' 45<=8="