Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92745 (KAR)
BHIMU AND ANR v. CHANNAPPA AND ANR
MFA/201795/2024 · 2025-11-27
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92745 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92745 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $%! &# '"( #&#
'"( #$(%""$
#"#&&"
)%* +, #"#&&"
)%*
+
,
!"#
$
%
&'(
'
!"
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' '
' )*+ !"#
$
%
+ '+(
'
+
+ *, %( + '
-"" ( + ( ' ' , ' +
+ +
'''
'
. ' ' + / ! ' +
( + +
+
,
'
- 0
' #
."#
$
%
&'(
- 3 -
'
!"
' '
' )*+ !"#
$
%
+1 '+(
'
+
+ *, %( + '
-"" ( + ( ' ' , ' +
+ +
''' '
. ' ' + / ! ' +
(+ +
'
+ ' '
' 2'
2'
- 4 -
"( %2'
(
34/4 566457/ 89:4; 4<=>?9 *,%( ?@ =34 '?=?; 43><74/<=-""%34;4>95@=4;;4@4;;4:=?5/A=34<=B@?;
/3?;=( 35C4 D449 @>74: DE =34 <75>F59=/ <357749G>9G =34 <?FF?9H8:GF49=59:5I5;::5=4:,65//4:DE =34;7 49>?;>C>7 8:G459:'!>H5E568;5>9' ?/ 59:
+5<=/ G>C>9G ;>/4 =? =34 @>7>9G ?@ =34 566457/ D;>4@7E /=5=4: 5;4 =35= ?9 # I349 =34 :4<45/4:
;5:446I5/5;>:4;>9'? 59:3>/@;>49:
9>75=3?:I5/56>77>?9;>:4;>9'? =34E I4;4 6;?<44:>9G ?9 5 '?=?;<E<74 D45;>9G ;4G>/=;5=>?9 ?!" !#- @;?F >H5E568;5! >9:5G> ;?5: 945;
59G595D5/5C
9=4;95=>?957 <3??7 ?998=5G> C>775G4 >H5E568;5 5= =35= =>F4 ?94 ?74;? ><J!86 D45;>9G ;4G>/=;5=>?9 ?! !,, I3><3 I5/ <5F4 @;?F ?66?/>=4/>:45=3>G3/644:59:I5/D4>9G:;>C49>95;5/3 59:94G7>G49=F5994;:5/34:5G5>9/==34F?=?;<E<74/
- 5 -
5 ;4/87= ?@ =34 5@?;4/5>: 5<<>:49= D?=3 =34 :4<45/4: /8/=5>94:G;>4C?8/>9H8;>4/59:/8<<8FD4:=?=34>9H8;>4/ , 34<75>F59=/@>74:564=>=>?989:4; 4<=>?9#,%(?@ =34 ' <= /44J>9G <?F649/5=>?9 @?; =34 :45=3 ?@ =34 :4<45/4:57?9GI>=3>9=4;4/=
6?9 /4;C><4 ?@ 9?=><4 =34 ;4/6?9:49= ?/ 59: 56645;4:=3;?8G3=34>;<?89/4759:@>74:I;>==49/=5=4F49= :49E>9G=345C4;F49=/F5:4>9=34<75>F64=>=>?9
9 =34 D5/>/ ?@ =34 6745:>9G/ ?@ =34 65;=>4/ =34 75>F/;>D8957@;5F4:=34>//84/59:=34;45@=4;;4<?;:4:
=34 4C>:49<4 34 ;>D8957 DE >F68G94: H8:GF49= 59: 5I5;: 35/ :>/F>//4: =34 <75>F 64=>=>?9/ 5/ 9?= F5>9=5>95D74 4>9G 5GG;>4C4: =34 6;4/49= 566457/ 35C4 D449@>74: # 45;94:<?89/47@?;=34<75>F59=35/<?9=49:4:=35= =34 5<<>:49= 35/ ?<<8;;4: ?9 # @=4; =34 5F49:F49= 5<= <5F4 >9=? @?;<4 4C49 =3?8G3 =34 <75>F 64=>=>?9 35/ D449 @>74: 89:4; 4<=>?9 #,! ?@ =34 '?=?;
- 6 -
43><74/ <= =34 ;>D8957 >=/47@ <?87: 35C4 =;45=4: =34 64=>=>?9/5/@>74:89:4; 4<=>?9#?@'?=?;43><74/<= 4<?9:7E89:4; 4<=>?9#?@'?=?;43><74/<=>9<5/4 ?@ :45=3 =34 <75>F59=/ 5;4 49=>=74: =? <?F649/5=>?9 ?@ / !49<434/?8G3=@?;577?I>9G=34566457/ * ;> 8:5;/359' 745;94: <?89/47 56645;>9G @?; =34 9/8;59<4 ?F659E 35/ <?9=49=4: =35= =34 <75>F 64=>=>?9/5;4@>74:?9#->45@=4;=345F49:4:
<= <5F4 >9=?
@?;<4 / ?9 =34 :5=4 ?@ @>7>9G <75>F 64=>=>?9/ 4<=>?9#,!?@'?=?;43><74/<=I5/9?=>9 @?;<434;4@?;4=34<75>F64=>=>?9/@>74:DE=34<75>F59=/ 5;4 9?= F5>9=5>95D74 49<4 ;>D8957 35/ ;>G3=7E :>/F>//4:=34<75>F64=>=>?9
" 45;:=34745;94:<?89/47@;?F=3465;=>4/ - =>/9?=>9:>/68=4=35=?9#;5:44659:
9>7 5=3?: I3? I4;4 =34 ;>:4; 59: 6>77>?9 ;>:4; I4;4 6;?<44:>9G ?//9 =34>; F?=?;<E<74 D45;>9G ;4G>/=;5=>?9 ?!" !#-;5:446I5/;>:>9G=34F?=?;<E<745=
- 7 -
5D?8=3?8;/?9>H5E568;5! >9:3>G>;?5:I349=34E ;45<34:945; 59G595D5/5C5
9=4;95=>?957 <3??75==35= =>F4=346><J86C43><74D45;>9G;4G>/=;5=>?9? ! ,, <5F4 @;?F ?66?/>=4 :>;4<=>?9 :5/34: =34 F?=?;<E<74 84 =? >F65<= =34 ;5:446 59: 9>7 5=3?:
@477 :?I9 /8@@4;4: G;>4C?8/ >9H8;>4/ 59: /8<<8FD4: =? =34>9H8;>4/
34 5<<>:49= 35/ ?<<8;;4: ?9 # 34 5F49:F49=<=<5F4>9=?@?;<4>9 46=4FD4;-15/?9 =34 :5=4 ?@ @>7>9G =34 <75>F 64=>=>?9/ 4<=>?9 #,! ?@ '?=?;43><74/ <= I5/ 9?= >9 @?;<434;4@?;4 =34<75>F 64=>=>?9/ 35C4 =? D4 =;45=4: 5/ =3?/4 @>74: 89:4; 4<=>?9 #?@'?=?;43><74/<=
4<=>?9#>/4K=;5<=4:D47?I@?;45/E;4@4;49<4
!"!# $ $!% &
- 8 -
! "
#
$ %
&
E;45:>9G=345D?C46;?C>/>?9 >=>/C4;E<745;=35= <75>F59=/ /3577 9?= D4 ;4L8>;4: =?6745:?;4/=5D7>/3 =35= =34 :45=3 ?; G;>4C?8/ 38;= >9 ;4/64<= ?@ I3><3 =34 <75>F 35/D449F5:4I5/:84=?59EI;?9G@875<=?;94G74<=?;
:4@587= ?@ =34 ?I94; ?@ =34 C43><74 ?; ?@ =34 C43><74
- 9 -
<?9<4;94:?;?@59E?=34;64;/?9
@=34:45=3?;G;>4C?8/ >9H8;E>/:84=?595<<>:49=5;>/>9G?8=?@=348/4?@F?=?; C43><74/<?F649/5=>?935/=?D465>: , = >/ 9?= >9 :>/68=4 =35= 9>7 59: ;5:446 :>4: >9 5 ;?5: =;5@@>< 5<<>:49= DE 8/4 ?@ =34 F?=?; C43><74/ 34;4@?;4 =34 <75>F59=/ 5;4 49=>=74: =? <?F649/5=>?9 89:4; 4<=>?9#?@=34'?=?;43><74/<=
=>/5<5/4?@ :45=3 >9<4 =34 >9C?7C4F49= ?@ ?74;? ><J!86 C43><74 >/ 9?= :49>4: 59: =34 /5>: C43><74 >/ <?C4;4: I>=3 59 >9/8;59<4 6?7><E =34
9/8;59<4 ?F659E >/ 7>5D74 =? 65E =34<?F649/5=>?9
/64; 4<=>?9#?@=34<=>9<5/4?@:45=3=34 <75>F59=/ 5;4 49=>=74: =? <?F649/5=>?9 ?@ / ! 57?9GI>=3#M>9=4;4/=64;5998F
<<?;:>9G7E=34@?77?I>9G?;:4;>/65//4:
%5( ?=3=34566457/5;4'' (
- 10 -
%D( 34H8:GF49=59:5I5;:65//4:DE=34;>D8957>/ /4=5/>:4 %<( 34 <75>F59=/ >9 ' ? 5;4 49=>=74:
=? <?F649/5=>?9 ?@ / ! 59: <75>F59=/ >9 ' ? 5;4 49=>=74:
=? <?F649/5=>?9 ?@ / ! 57?9G I>=3 #M >9=4;4/= 64; 5998F @;?F =34 :5=4 ?@ <75>F 64=>=>?9/=>77=3465EF49=?@=34<?F649/5=>?9 %:( 34
9/8;59<4 ?F659E >/ :>;4<=4: =? :46?/>= <?F649/5=>?9 5F?89= I>=3 >9=4;4/= D4@?;4 =34 ;>D8957 I>=3>9 />K I44J/ @;?F :5=4 ?@ ;4<4>6= ?@ <?6E?@=3>/H8:GF49= %4( ;>D8957 >/ :>;4<=4: =? ;4745/4 =34 5F?89= >9 @5C?8;?@=34<75>F59=/>94L8576;?6?;=>?9>9D?=3 =34<5/4/5@=4;:84C4;>@><5=>?9
#-+ )&#* (
#-+ )$(%""$* (
''>/=? 7?