Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92740 (KAR)
ALLISAB v. AYUB
CRL.A/200277/2024 · 2025-08-01
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92740 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92740 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
#%%
&'&(%)*
+&)) ,
! "#
$ %&'(
! )#&" ! "*" ! ++()+(+"
,
)*+(+)
! +(()+(+)
, ! '")(+(+(
! !! )& ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! ! -
$#
-
./ 011/22034 5/637 89:12063034 63
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
- 3 -
) ./;084C9;4./80C/635<6/;0</4.04 ./ 89:12063034 .0C ;62/= 4./ 1<6>04/ 89:120634 63
9('+(+( 5/;9</ 4./ <602 9?<4 07063C4 4./ 088?C/= ?3=/< /84693 +(( 9; < 022/7637 4./ 89::6CC6939;9;;/38/1?36C.052/?3=/</84693)&9;
84 4 6C 4./ 8934/34693 9; 4./ 89:12063034 4.04 ./ F0C .0>63789<=602</204693C.61F64.088?C/=F.96C05?C63/CC :03 638/ 4./ 088?C/= F0C 63 3//= 9; :93/A ./ </H?/C4/= 4./ 89:12063034 49 10A .03= 2903 9;
C&(((((% 889<=6372A 4./ 89:12063034 2/34 03 0:9?349;C&(((((%./088?C/=1<9:6C/=49</10A 4./ C0:/ F64.63 C6I :934.C ./ 89:12063034 =/:03=/= 508G 4./ 0:9?34 =?<637 /14/:5/< +(* 03= 204/< 4./ 088?C/= 6CC?/= 4./ 8./H?/ 5/0<637 9)#&#" =04/= +(#+(+( ;9< C&(((((% =<0F3 93 404/ 03G 9;
3=60 6@0A01?< <038.
49F0<=C 4./ =6C8.0<7/ 9; 2/7022A /3;9<8/052/ =/54 ./3 4./ 8./H?/ F0C 1</C/34/= ;9< /380C.:/34 4./ C0:/ F0C =6C.939</= 0C 4./</ F0C 63C?;;686/34 ;?3=C 63 4./ 0889?34 9; 4./ 088?C/= 2/702
- 4 -
39468/ F0C 6CC?/= 5A 4./ 89:12063034 63;9<:637 4./ 088?C/= </70<=637 =6C.939< 9; 4./ 8./H?/ 0:9?34 03= 8022637?193.6:49</10A4./8./H?/0:9?34./088?C/= 6CC?/=</12A39468/=/3A63759<<9F6379;4./0:9?3403= 8934/3=/=4.045203G8./H?/F0C6CC?/=9?49;893;6=/38/ 63 4./ 89:12063034 ;9< 5?C63/CC 1?<19C/ 638/ 4./ 088?C/= .0= 394 </106= 4./ 8./H?/ 0:9?34 4./ 89:12063034 .0C ;62/= 4./ 1<6>04/ 89:120634 07063C4 4./ 088?C/= </H?/C4637 4./ <602 9?<4 49 40G/ 89736J038/ 9; 4./9;;/38/./4<6029?<4499G89736J038/9;4./9;;/38/ 03=</76C4/</= 80C/ 63 9'")(+(+( 03= C?::93/= 4./088?C/= ./088?C/= .0C 011/0</= 5/;9</ 4./9?<4 03=12/0=/=3947?624A03=8206:/=495/4<6/=
" ./89:12063034/I0:63/=.6:C/2;0C%03= 794 :0<G/=
IC% 49 %# 63 C?119<4 9; .6C 8934/34693 ./ 088?C/= =/36/= 022 4./ 638<6:6304637 :04/<602C 0>062052/ 93 </89<= 63 .6C C404/:/34 ?3=/< /84693 )) </I0:63/=%03=794:0<G/=
I%./<602 9?<40;4/<40G6376349893C6=/<046930224./C/:04/<602C93
- 5 -
</89<= 80:/ 49 4./ 89382?C693 4.04 4./ 89:12063034 6C C?88/CC;?2 63 1<9>637 4./ 7?624 9; 4./ 088?C/= 5/A93= </0C93052/ =9?54 03= 0889<=6372A 10CC/= 4./ @?=7:/34 =04/= +(()+(+) 893>684637 4./ 088?C/= ;9< 4./ 9;;/38/ 1?36C.052/?3=/</84693)&9; 84/637077<6/>/= 5A 4./ C0:/ 4./ 088?C/= .0C 1</;/<</= <6:6302 11/02
9)*+(+) 5/;9</ 4./ !6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 ./ !6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 93 </%011</8604693 9; 4./ :04/<602C 93 </89<= 0229F/= 4./ 011/02 >6=/ @?=7:/34 =04/= ++()+(+" C/44637 0C6=/ 4./ 6:1?73/= @?=7:/34 9; 893>68469303=9<=/<9;C/34/38/10CC/=5A4./<6029?<4 /637 077<6/>/= 5A 4./ C0:/ 4./ 89:12063034 6C 5/;9</ 4.6C9?<4
/0<= <6 0:0=01?< 2/0<3/= 89?3C/2 011/0<637 ;9< 4./ 011/22034 03= <6?7?C463 2/0<3/= 89?3C/2 ;9< </C193=/34 /<?C/= 4./ :04/<602C 6382?=637 4./<6029?<4</89<=C
- 6 -
' 3 >6/F 9; 4./ <6>02 8934/34693C ?<7/= 5A 2/0<3/= 89?3C/2 ;9< 4./ 011/22034 4./ 19634 4.04 F9?2= 0<6C/;9<:A893C6=/<046936C
A03CF/<494./059>/196346C634./D , ;9<4./;9229F637
# 46C4./8934/346939;4./89:120630344.04./ F0C G39F637 4./ 088?C/= >/<A F/22 03= 4./ 088?C/= </H?/C4/=;9<.03=29039;C&(((((%889<=6372A./ 2/34 03 0:9?34 9; C&(((((% =?<637 !/5<?0<A +(* 9F0<=C</10A:/349;4./C06=29030:9?34088?C/=.0= 6CC?/=4./8./H?/0C1/<
I' & 3 C?119<4 9; .6C 8934/34693 4./ 89:12063034 /I0:63/=.6:C/2;0C03=794:0<G/=8./H?/0C1/< I'
I 6C 4./ /3=9<C/:/34 76>/3 5A 4./ 503G
- 7 -
IC+ 03= ) 0</ 4./ 19C402 </8/614 03= 19C402 08G39F2/=7/:/34;9<.0>637C/<>/=4./2/70239468/934./ 088?C/=
I"6C4./891A9;4./2/70239468/
I6C4./ </12A 49 4./ 39468/ 6CC?/= 5A 4./ 088?C/=
I# 6C 4./ 503G8.02203 * >/3 4.9?7. F0C 8<9CC%/I0:63/= 04 2/374.394.637.0C5//3/26864/=49=6C5/26/>/.6C>/<C693 ./C?77/C46931?45A4./088?C/=6C4.0405203G8./H?/ F0C6CC?/=5A4./088?C/=03=4./C0:/F0C:6C?C/=5A 4./ 89:12063034 ?8. C?77/C4693C 0</ 022 =/36/= ./ 088?C/=/I0:63/=.6:C/2;0C498934/3=4.04./.0= 0>062/=4./29039;932AC+(((((%03=4./C0:/F0C 02</0=A =6C8.0<7/= 4 4./ 46:/ 9; 0>062637 4./ 2903 ./ .0=6CC?/=4./5203G8./H?/0CC/8?<64A03=4./C0:/F0C :6C?C/= 5A 4./ 89:12063034 4<037/2A 39 C?8. 8934/34693 F0C <06C/= 5A 4./ 088?C/= F.62/ 6CC?637 4./ </12A 39468/ 04
I ?8.
8934/34693 F0C 3/>/< <06C/= />/3 =?<637 8<9CC%/I0:6304693 9; 4./ 89:12063034 ./</
- 8 -
6C 720<637 63893C6C4/38A 63 4./ =/;/38/ 40G/3 5A 4./ 088?C/=F.68.6C394/I12063/= ( ./34./89:120630341<9=?8/C4./8./H?/0C 1/<
I' 03= 4./ 088?C/= 0=:64C 4.04 4./ C06= 8./H?/ 5/2937C49.6C503G0889?3403=645/0<C.6CC67304?</4./ 1</C?:14693?3=/</84693C&03=)*9; 84F9?2= 0<6C/ 03= 4./ 5?<=/3 C.6;4C 93 4./ 088?C/= 49 </5?4 4./ 2/7021</C?:14693 4 6C 4./ 8934/34693 9; 4./ 2/0<3/= 89?3C/2 ;9< 4./ </C193=/34 4.04 4./ 89:12063034 .0C 394 1<9>/= 4./ /I6C4/38/ 9; 2/7022A /3;9<8/052/ =/54 ./3 4./ 1</C?:14693?3=/</84693)*9; 84F9?2=0<6C/64 6382?=/C 4./ /I6C4/38/ 9; 2/7022A /3;9<8/052/ =/54 /70<=6374./94./<=/;/38/40G/35A4./088?C/=4.04./ .0=6CC?/=932A05203G8./H?/0CC/8?<64A03=4./C0:/ F0C;622/=?15A4./89:120630348033945/0799=7<9?3= 490>96=8<6:630226056264A34.6C</70<=:0A</;/<494./ =/86C693 9; 4./ 93,52/ 1/I 9?<4 63
- 9 -
F./</634./1/I9?<45A</;/<<63749 64C /0<26/< =/86C693C ./2= 63 10<07<01. 9C)" 03= )' 0C ?3=/< !"# $
%
" %
"
%
%
"
&"'
$
%%
%
( ) * + #
% %
"
+ :0A02C9</;/<494./=/86C6939;4./93,52/ 1/I 9?<4 63
! F./</63 4./ .<// ?=7/ /38. 9;
4./ 1/I 9?<4 =6C8?CC/= 04 2/374. 059?4 19C64693 9; 20F F64. </70<= 49 4./ 5?<=/3 9; 1<99; 63 4./ 9;;/38/ 1?36C.052/?3=/</84693)&9; 844</;/<</=4964C /0<26/< =/86C693 63 4./ 80C/ 9;
""
1 +(* "*# 2 +(+ +&)
- 10 -
""#03=./2=6310<07<01. 9C"'03= &0C?3=/< )!"
%
$
%
(
)), (
) * +#" (
-. /
0
0
" #
"
% 1 2 3
4 " ( 5
% % 6
#
% (
) * +#
%
%
7 %
% 7
"
% %"
%
0
%
8
"""""9
3 +(+ +&)
- 11 -
):" ;
<
=
%
"
%
82
7
%
%
"( %
%"
)&" +
(
)), (
) *
" >( +
>
"( ? % % @ - . %
"
% ? '7- .%
%
%
"
)," '
% $
$
$ %
" # @ (
" > $? % 6
'
$
%%
%
( ) * + #
% %
"
-' . - 12 -
) :0A02C9</;/<494./=/86C6939;4./93,52/ 1/I9?<463$ % & '
$
&
( )F./</6364 6C./2=6310<07<01.
9#0C?3=/< A"
$
%
%
%
(
) * +"#" 7
" ;
" B%
%
8
"#
" %
% %
%
%
" %
7
(
) * +"#" " # C %B
4 +(+(*"
- 13 -
8
%
(
) *+"#""
(
) *
7 8
% 7
"
" .?C4./19C646939;20F6C>/<AF/22C/442/=; 4./=684?:9;4./93,52/1/I9?<46C893C6=/</=634./ 267.49;4./;084C03=86<8?:C4038/C9;4./1</C/3480C/ 0: 9; 4./ 9163693 4.04 4./ 89:12063034 .0C 1<9>/= 4./ /I/8?46939;4./8./?H//I/8?4/=04
I'5A4./088?C/= 49F0<=C =6C8.0<7/ 9; 2/7022A /3;9<8/052/ =/54 ./ 2/702 1</C?:14693 ?3=/< /84693 & 03= )* 9; 84 91/<04/C 63 ;0>9?< 9; 4./ 89:12063034 03= 07063C4 4./ 088?C/=
>/34.9?7.4./088?C/=.0C40G/363893C6C4/34 =/;/38/./.0C3941<9505026J/=03A93/9;4./:./3 4./088?C/=.0C394</5?44/=4./2/7021</C?:14693./6C 26052/;9<893>684693
- 14 -
.0>/793/4.<9?7.4./6:1?73/=@?=7:/349; 893>68469303=9<=/<9;C/34/38/=04/=+(()+(+)10CC/= 5A 4./<602 9?<4 4.0C40G/3 6349 893C6=/<04693022 4./ :04/<602C 0>062052/ 93 </89<= 63 1<91/< 1/<C1/846>/ 03= 893>684/=4./088?C/=0CC404/=059>/9F/>/<4./!6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 63 10<07<01. 9) 9; 64C @?=7:/34 /I12063/=4.044./</6C=6;;/</38/634./63G5/4F//34./ C67304?</9;088?C/=03=94./<8934/34C9;4./8./H?/63 I' ./</;9</ 4./ !6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 ;9<:/= 03 91636934.044./088?C/=:67.4394.0>/6CC?/=4./8./H?/ 63 .6C 9F3 .03= F<64637 3=/< C?8. 86<8?:C4038/C ./2= 4.04 4./ 89:12063034 .0C 394 1<9>/= 4./ 7?624 9; 4./ 088?C/= 5/A93= </0C93052/ =9?54 ./ !6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 .0C :6C2/0= 64C/2; 6739<637 4./ C/442/= 19C64693 9;
20F ./</;9</ 0: 9; 4./ 9163693 4.04 4./ 6:1?73/= @?=7:/34 10CC/= 5A 4./ !6<C4 11/2204/ 9?<4 6C 26052/ 49 5/C/40C6=/889<=6372A03CF/<4./059>/19634634./ 03=1<98//=4910CC4./;9229F637
- 15 -
6 ./011/026C* 66 ./ 6:1?73/= @?=7:/34 =04/= ++()+(+" 10CC/= 63 <6:6302 11/02 9)*+(+) 5A 4./ ==6469302 6C4<684 03= /CC693C ?=7/ 6@0A01?< 6C
./ @?=7:/34 9; 893>684693 03= 9<=/< 9; C/34/38/ =04/= +(()+(+) 10CC/= 63
9'")(+(+( 5A 4./ ==2 6>62 ?=7/03=!6@0A01?<06C 666 ./ 088?C/=</C193=/34 6C =6</84/= 49 C?<</3=/<5/;9</4./<6029?<4;9<4.F64. /76C4<A6C=6</84/=49C/3=508G4./<6029?<4 /89<=C 02937 F64. 891A 9; 4.6C @?=7:/34 ;9< 63;9<:0469303=3//=;?2084693
-* &##) $
6C4 92 9)# $