- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %&'%()*&'%)) + !"! # $% & ' !"! % ' % % # $% %& ' () ' $ & ( ' % $& % * *" !"! ' '' % () ! *"$*& $& ' % !"! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' '$ & ' +% ,-. /01-1-23 -. 4-506 78 9::;.06 2* .00<-3= =>931 24 >0=;59> 79-5 -3 >-?0 2*" !"! >0=-.10>06 78 5?05 25-:0 191-23 42> 1,0 24403:0. /;3-.,9750 ;360> 0:1-23. () ! *"$*& >096 @-1, 0:1-23 $& 24 %,9>91-89 8989 93,-19 !"!/036-3=231,04-50241,066-1-2395-A-5;6=0$>3& 9362;>1-369=--.1>-:1-B989/;> ! :2?/59-31:9?01270>0=-.10>069=9-3.1;3<32@3 /0>.23.9550=-3=1,9123*)*"!"!1,060:09.06>9339@,2 @9.@2><-3=9.96>-A0>2492?2?A0,-:50,966>2//061,0 :2?/59-3931,-..-.10>93621,0>5972;>0>.919:211234-05642> 5972;>@2><2@0A0>>93396-6321>01;>3-31,00A03-3=9. 0C/0:106,031,0.-.10>241,060:09.06:2319:106,-?2A0> /,230 936 >0D;0.106 ,-? 12 :2?0 936 /-:< ,0> 936 ,0> ?21,0> 1,0 60:09.06 9550=0658 .19106 1,91 E @-55 70 4-3-.,06 - 3 - 12698F ;>-3= 1,0 .9-6 /,230 :955 .,0 -. .19106 12 ,9A0 2A0>,09>6 .2?0 /0>.23. 97;.-3= 1,0 60:09.06 -3 1,0 79:<=>2;36 9410> @,-:, 1,0 :955 =21 97>;/158 6-.:2330:106 ;7.0D;03158230;>;>9B96--342>?061,0:2?/59-39311,91 >9339@9.42;36?;>60>06781,0.-60241,0>29697;11-3=1,0 59362@30678230;51,939105%9.06231,0.9-6:2?/59-31 9 :>-?0 @9. >0=-.10>06 9=9-3.1 ;3<32@3 /0>.23. 936 -3A0.1-=91-23@9.19<03;/ ;>-3=1,0:2;>.024-3A0.1-=91-239.>0450:1064>2? 1,0>0?9369//5-:91-231,03A0.1-=91-3= 44-:0>231,079.-. 24-342>?91-234;>3-.,067823091-.,959<0>-@,2-..19106 12709/25-:0-342>?0>9//>0,036069::;.062!@,2-.1,0 .23241,0/>0.031/01-1-230>9369::;.062@,2-.94>-036 24 9::;.06 2! 1 -. 9550=06 1,91 9::;.06 2! 6;>-3= -310>>2=91-23 ?960 9 :2340..-2395 .1910?031 .191-3= 1,91 1,0 60:09.06 >9339 @9. ,9A-3= 93 -55-:-1 >0591-23.,-/ @-1, ,-. ?21,0>-01,0/>0.031/01-1-230>93660./-1070-3=@9>306 1,060:09.066-6321?036,-.@98.1-.4;>1,0>9550=061,91 70-3=9==>-0A06781,0:236;:1241,060:09.069::;.062.! 936 ,91:,06 9 /593 12 05-?-3910 ,-? %9.06 23 1,0 .9-6 :2340..-2395.1910?031249::;.062!1,0/>0.031/01-1-230> - 4 - @9. 95.2 -?/5-:9106 23 1,0 9550=91-23 1,91 .,0 ,96 -3.1-=9106 ,0> .23 12 ,91:, 9 /593 936 05-?-3910 1,0 60:09.06 >9339 23.0D;03158 1,0 /01-1-230> :9?0 12 70 9>>0.106 23 !**"!"! ( 09>306 :2;3.05 9//09>-3= 42> 1,0 /01-1-230> >040>>-3= 12 1,0 9A0>?031. -3 1,0 :2?/59-31 9. @055 9. 1,0 >0?9369//5-:91-23@2;56.;7?-11,911,0>09>097.25;105832 -3:>-?-391-3= ?910>-95. 911>-7;1-3= 938 2A0>1 9:1 12 1,0 /01-1-230> 1 -. :23103606 1,91 1,0 .250 9550=91-23 9=9-3.1 1,0 /01-1-230> 91 1,-. .19=0 -. 1,91 .,0 ,96 -3.1-=9106 ,0> .23 12 05-?-39101,060:09.06 1 -. 4;>1,0> :23103606 1,91 1,0 /01-1-230> 93 -332:031 @2?93 9=06 972;1 809>. ,9. 7003 -3 B;6-:-95 :;.1268 .-3:0 !**"!"! 09>306 :2;3.05 @2;56 95.2 .;7?-1 1,919.;7.1931-95/2>1-23241,0-3A0.1-=91-23,9.95>09687003 :2?/50106 936 .1910?031. 24 ?910>-95 @-130..0. ,9A0 7003 >0:2>606,0>042>0:231-3;06-3:9>:0>91-23241,0/01-1-230>-. @,2558 ;330:0..9>8 /9>1-:;59>58 @,03 .,0 @9. 321 />0.031 91 1,0.:0302424403:0936322A0>19:1-.911>-7;10612,0> - 5 - 509>306-=,2;>12A0>3?03150960> .1>23=582//2.061,0/01-1-23:231036-3=1,911,0/01-1-230>,96 -3.1-=9106 ,0> .23 12 :2??-1 1,0 ?;>60> 24 >9339 936 1,0>042>0:23.-60>-3=1,0.0>-2;.30..241,024403:01,-.-.321 94-1:9.012=>93179-5 G 9A-3= ,09>6 1,0 509>306 :2;3.05 42> 1,0 /9>1-0. 1,042552@-3=/2-319>-.0.42>:23.-60>91-23 E ! ! "#$%$&' ( &' ) $ $ * +! & ,' +-!$ $, . / ! HF 39:9>04;50C9?-391-23241,0>0?9369//5-:91-23 1,-.2;>1321-:0.1,911,0>09>0.0>-2;.9550=91-23.936 2A0>1 9:1.911>-7;1069=9-3.19::;.062.!936,0-3:>-?-391-3= ?910>-95.9=9-3.19::;.062.!9369>0/>-?9>-5879.0623 -342>?91-23 4;>3-.,06 78 1,0 9550=06 /25-:0 -342>?0> 91-., 959<0>-@,2-..1910612,9A02A0>,09>69::;.062.!936 ,91:,-3= 9 /593 12 05-?-3910 1,0 60:09.06 :2;/506 @-1, 1,0 - 6 - :2340..-2395 .1910?031. 3.249> 9. 1,0 />0.031 /01-1-230> -. :23:0>306 1,0 2358 9550=91-23 -. 1,91 .,0 ,96 -3.1-=9106 ,0> .231205-?-39101,060:09.069550=065870-3=406;/@-1,,-? ,0 />2.0:;1-23 1,02>8 9. 0?0>=-3= 4>2? 1,0 >0?936 9//5-:91-23 -. 1,91 1,0 /01-1-230> @9. -3 93 -55-:-1 >0591-23.,-/ @-1, 1,0 60:09.06 ,01,0> .;:, 9550=06 -55-:-1 >0591-23.,-/ 0C-.106 936 @,01,0> 1,0 /01-1-230> ,96 -3 49:1 -3.1-=9106 ,0> .23 12 :2??-1 1,0 24403:0 9>0 ?9110>. @,-:, >0D;->0 9//>0:-91-23240A-603:06;>-3=94;554506=061>-95 ) ,-. 2;>1 95.2 19<0. 3210 24 1,0 49:1 1,91 .;7.1931-95-3A0.1-=91-239//09>.12,9A07003:2?/50106,0 /01-1-230> -. 9 @2?93 9=06 972;1 809>. ,9. 32 :>-?-395 9310:06031. 936 -. .19106 12 70 9 :225-0 70523=-3= 12 9 52@ -3:2?0 =>2;/ 231-3;06 -3:9>:0>91-23 -3 1,0 97.03:0 24 938 6->0:12A0>19:1911>-7;10612,0>@2;56.0>-2;.58/>0B;6-:0,0> >-=,1125-40936/0>.23955-70>18=;9>931006;360>>1-:50!*24 1,023.1-1;1-232436-99A-3=>0=9>612,0>79:<=>2;361,0 /2..-7-5-18 24 ,0> 4500-3= 4>2? B;.1-:0 2> 19?/0>-3= @-1, 1,0 />2.0:;1-23 @-130..0. 620. 321 9//09> 12 70 -??-3031 ,0>042>0 1,-. 2;>1 -. 24 1,0 :23.-60>06 2/-3-23 1,91 78 - 7 - -?/2.-3=9//>2/>-910:236-1-23.1,0/01-1-230>:93700359>=06 2379-5@-1,2;1:9;.-3=.0>-2;./>0B;6-:0121,0/>2.0:;1-23 *" '2> 1,0 42>0=2-3= >09.23. 1,0 /2-31 4>9?06 42> :23.-60>91-23 -. 93.@0>06 -3 1,0 944->?91-A0 ::2>6-3=58 1,0 42552@-3= ,0/01-1-23-.9552@06 ,0/01-1-230>-.6->0:10612700359>=062379-5-3>-?0 2*" !"!>0=-.10>06785?0525-:0191-2342>1,024403:0. /;3-.,9750 ;360> 0:1-23. () ! *"$*& >096 @-1, 0:1-23 $&241,0%,9>91-89898993,-19!"!/036-3=231,04-50 241,066-1-2395-A-5;6=0$>3&9362;>1-369=- -.1>-:1-B989/;>9.;7B0:1121,042552@-3=:236-1-23. 9& ,0 /01-1-230> .,955 0C0:;10 9 /0>.2395 7236 42> 9 .;?24Rs.*""""" @-1,1@2.;>01-0.42>1,05-<0 .;?121,0.91-.49:1-23241,0B;>-.6-:1-23952;>1I - 8 - 7& ,0/01-1-230>.,9559//09>>0=;59>58239556910.24 ,09>-3=7042>01,0>-952;>1;350..0C0?/10642> A95-6>09.23.I :& ,0 /01-1-230> .,955 321 6->0:158 2> -36->0:158 1,>09103 -36;:0 2> 19?/0> @-1, 1,0 />2.0:;1-23 @-130..0.I 6& ,0 /01-1-230> .,955 321 -3A25A0 ,0>.054 -3 938 .-?-59>24403:0.-34;1;>0I 0& ,0/01-1-230>.,955321509A01,0B;>-.6-:1-23241,0 >-952;>1@-1,2;1/>-2>/0>?-..-23;31-56-./2.9524 1,0:9.0 ,* %!!) $ -.12*52*