- 1 - ! "# $ % & && '#( ) ! " # ! $ ! ! %& ! ! '(( '! !(! ! ! ! #)$ !*!! ! ! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! ! " # ! ! !% + ! !,! $ % % ,#$ % % * !! * !, ' % !(-() !(# !($ . / % % & ! % * 0 * % 12341 516 788679 :; 9:;56< =2> 7<?:;;:2@ A:51 516 B2@;6@5 2= 967>@6< B23@;69 =2> 516 87>5:6; :5 :; 57C6@ 38 =2>=:@79<:;82;79! ! 1:; 788679 :; =:96< 747:@;5 516 D3<4?6@5 7@< 7A7><<756<!! 87;;6<EF516 6@:2>:G:9*3<46 7@<97@<:@2!,2= ! - 3 - ! 16 B97:?7@5 ?65 A:51 7@ 7BB:<6@5 2@ !! 7@<;3;57:@6<4>:6G23;:@D3>6;!16>6=2>616 =:96< 7 B97:? 865:5:2@ E6=2>6 516 >:E3@79 B97:?:@4 B2?86@;75:2@2=;! A:51:@56>6;575 /8!7! 16 >:E3@79 B2@;:<6>:@4 516 6@5:>6 6G:<6@B6 2@ >6B2>< 4>7@56< B2?86@;75:2@ 2= ;!(-() A:51 :@56>6;5 75 )/ 8!7! =>2? 516 <756 2= 865:5:2@ 5:99 >679:;75:2@ 7@< <:>6B56< >6;82@<6@5 2! @;3>7@B6 2?87@F 52 <682;:5 516;7?6! (! 44>:6G6<EF516;7:<D3<4?6@57@<7A7><516 :@D3>6< B97:?7@5 17; 8>6=6>>6< 51:; 788679 :@ A1:B1 :5 :; B2@56@<6< 5175 16 A7; 7@ 74>:B3953>:;5 7@< 79;2 <2:@4 <:7>F =7>?:@4 7@< 67>@:@4 ;! 86> ?2@51! 16 <2B52> 7;;6;;6< 516 <:;7E:9:5F 75 (/ 52 516 >:415 92A6> 9:?E 7@< / 52 516 A1296 E2<F E35 516 >:E3@79 17; A>2@49FB2@;:<6>6<516<:;7E:9:5F75,/7@<5167?23@5; 4>7@56< 3@<6> 2516> 167<; 7>6 ?674>6! 16>6=2>6 >6H36;56<=2>6@17@B6?6@52=B2?86@;75:2@! ! 67><5167>43?6@5;2=E251;:<6;! - 4 - )! 12341 516 7886997@5 ;5756< 5175 16 A7; 67>@:@4;! 86>?2@511617;@258>2<3B6<7@F :@B2?68>22=!16>6=2>6516>:E3@7917;>:4159F57C6@1:; @25:2@79 :@B2?6 75 ;!, 86> ?2@51 7; 86> 516 43:<69:@6;2=5167>@757C7 5756 6479 6>G:B6;3512>:5F 7;5167BB:<6@5:;2=516F67> !;86>I!A23@< B6>5:=:B7565167886997@5A7;746<F67>;7@<516>6=2>6 516?395:89:6>A7;>:4159F57C6@7;J,K!;86>516A23@< B6>5:=:B756 516 7886997@5 17; ;3;57:@6< =>7B53>6 2= <:;92B75:2@2= 96=5 =2>67>? =>7B53>62=8>2I:?79 39@7! 16 <2B52> 7;;6;;6< 516 <:;7E:9:5F 75 (/ 52 516 >:415 92A6> 9:?E!6;5756<5175:5:;7B7;62= G39;:2@=>7B53>62= >:415 964 A:51 :@56>@79 =:I75:2@ ;B>6A; :@ 516 964 7@< 286>756<7@<;5:99516>6:;56@<6>@6;;7@<<6=2>?:5F:@516 9647@<516A1296E2<F<:;7E:9:5F:;7;;6;;6<75 /!>< 2= (/ B2?6; 52 /! 16>6=2>6 51:; 23>5 =:@<; :5 >67;2@7E96 52 57C6 516 <:;7E:9:5F 75 / :@;567< 2= ,/ 57C6@ EF 516 >:E3@79! 13; 516 92;; 2= =353>6 67>@:@4; A239<E6 - 5 - ;!,I I,I/L)()! ,! 16 >:E3@79 17; 7A7><6< 7@ 7?23@5 2= ;!,) 52A7><; ?6<:B79 6I86@;6; 7; 86> 516 >696G7@5<2B3?6@5;7@<:5@66<;@25:@56>=6>6@B6! ! 16 7886997@5 A7; 7<?:556< :@ 516 12;8:579 =2> <7F;! 2@;:<6>:@4516@753>6 2=:@D3>:6;7@<86>:2<2= 12;8:579:;75:2@ 51:; 23>5 =:@<; :5 >67;2@7E96 52 4>7@5 7@ 7?23@52=;!=2>87:@7@<;3==6>:@4;! =2> 92;; 2= 7?6@:5:6; 7@< ;! =2> 5>7@;82>575:2@ 6I5>7@23>:;1?6@57@<7556@<7@5B17>46;! -! 16 7886997@5 ?:415 @25 17G6 7556@<6< 7@F A2>C 75 967;5 =2> 7 86>:2< 2= =23> ?2@51; <36 52 516 :@D3>:6;;3;57:@6<!16>6=2>651:;23>5=:@<;:5>67;2@7E96 524>7@57@7?23@52=;!#;!,I($=2>92;; 2=:@B2?6<3>:@497:<3886>:2<! ! 6@B65167886997@5:;6@5:596<=2>516?2<:=:6< B2?86@;75:2@3@<6><:==6>6@5167<;7;E692A - 6 - 7:@7@<;3==6>:@4 ;! 6<:B796I86@;6; ;!,) 2;;2==353>667>@:@4; ;!)() 2;;2=:@B2?6<3>:@497:<3886>:2< ;! >7@;82>575:2@ 6I5>7 @23>:;1?6@5 7@<7556@<7@5B17>46; ;! 2;;2=7?6@:5:6; ;! 2579 6;;7A7><6<EF>:E3@79 @17@B6?6@5 ;!)) ;!(-() * ! 16 @;3>7@B6 2?87@F 17; 79>67<F <682;:56< 516 7?23@5 7A7><6< EF 516 >:E3@79! 13; 516 7886997@5 :; 6@5:596<=2>6@17@B6<B2?86@;75:2@2=;! A:51 :@56>6;5 75 )/ 86> 7@@3? 7@< 516>6=2>6 516 788679 <6;6>G6;52E67992A6<:@87>5! ! @516>6;395516=2992A:@42><6>:;87;;6< #:$ 88679:;7992A6<:@87>5! #::$ 16 7886997@5B97:?7@5 :; 6@5:596< =2> 516 6@17@B6< B2?86@;75:2@ 2= ;! A:51 :@56>6;5 75 )/ 86> 7@@3? =>2? 516 <756 2= 865:5:2@ 5:99 516 <756 2= >679:;75:2@! - 7 - #:::$ 6;82@<6@5 2! @;3>7@B6 2?87@F :; <:>6B56< 52 <682;:5 516 7=2>6;7:< B2?86@;75:2@ 7?23@5 A:51:@2@6?2@51=>2?516<7562=51:;D3<4?6@5! #:G$ @ ;3B1 <682;:5 516 7886997@5 :; 86>?:556< 52 A:51<>7A 516 6@5:>6 7?23@5 792@4 A:51 :@56>6;5 7BB>36< 2@:5! *+, '& ( % :;52! 92!)