- 1 - ! ""#"$#% &!'##(#( #!#%%! )(* ##' ! " ! " # $ % $ # $ & & %& '( ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * % &' &+ *'%,, %& $& &)--' " . % ,,** * +! /! + + *** *'-%*, $ # $ % $ # $ &* & %& '( ) " ! " % &'* &+ *'%,, %& $& &)-- - 3 - * )*** -- " *. % **- +! ' + + *** *'-%*, ***%+,0 '((%+*0 + & & 1 !'" 23 45678493 9:;<84= 285 >?@3A :*,'%*( <78=?4B C: 53C 85?A3 C23 6AB;34C 84A 8D87AA8C3A***<8553A?4 :*-'%*,E=C23 AA?C?:48@ 34?:7 ?F?@ 6AB3 84A 8@8E678B? >:7 - 4 - 52:7C G C23 C7?E648@H! 23 9@8?;84C 285 >?@3A 7:E :*-%**533I?4B3428493;34C:>C239:;<3458C?:4 * 23>89C5@38A?4BC:>?@?4B:>C239@8?;<3C?C?:4873 8564A37& 4 *,*- 8C 8E:6C <; 4387 5C 8C3 :> 4A65C7?8@ 738 8<4::7 F?@@8B3 8@8E678B? C23 9@8?;84C D85 <7:933A?4B :4 7:8A5?A3 E= D8@I C C28C C?;3 8 @:77= E387?4B 73B?5C78C?:4 :*'%,, D85 E3?4B A7?F34 E= ?C5 A7?F37 ?4 8 7852 84A 43B@?B34C ;84437 A8523A C: C23 9@8?;84C A63 C: D2?92 C23 9@8?;84C 565C8?43A B7?3F:65 ?4J67?35 84A >789C6735 3 D85 52?>C3A C: C23 2:5<?C8@ 84A C8I34C738C;34C23?4J673A>?@3A9@8?;<3C?C?:423C7?E648@ 8553553AC239:;<3458C?:4<8553AC238D87A84A>?K3AC23 @?8E?@?C=:4C23456784939:;<84=C:<8=9:;<3458C?:423 45678493 9:;<84=8BB7?3F3A E= C236AB;34C84A 8D87A 285 >?@3A C23 8<<38@ 23 9@8?;84C D2: ?5 735<:4A34C : 285>?@3A97:55:EJ39C?:45533I?4B3428493;34C - 5 - 387A C23 @38743A 9:6453@ >:7 C23 8<<3@@84C%45678493 9:;<84= 84A C23 @38743A 9:6453@ >:7 C239@8?;84C%97:55:EJ39C:7 ' 38743A 9:6453@ >:7 C23 8<<3@@84C%45678493 9:;<84= D:6@A 9:4C34A C28C C23 9@8?;84C?4J673A 285 565C8?43A ?4J67?35 A63 C: 53@> >8@@ 84A ?4 9:@@65?:4 D?C2 C23 2:5<?C8@5C8>>A:9C:7584A<:@?93239738C3AA:96;34C584A C2373>:73 C23 45678493 9:;<84= ?5 4:C @?8E@3 C: ;8I3 <8=;34C :> C23 9:;<3458C?:4 8;:64C 3 >67C237 56E;?C5 C28C ?4 :7A37 C: <7:F3 C23 58?A 85<39C C23 :9C:7 :> C23 2:5<?C8@285E3343K8;?43A85+84A23285<7:A693A K' 84A K- 3 56E;?C5 C28C ?4 K- :456@C8C?:4 233C?C?5;34C?:43AC28CC23<8C?34C98;3C:C232:5<?C8@ D?C2 8 9:;<@8?4C :> 53@> >8@@ 84A 23 285 E334 8A;?CC3A :4 */*- 84A 56E53L634C@= C23 739:7A5 28F3 E334 ;84?<6@8C3A C: 52:D C28C 23 285 565C8?43A ?4J67?35 ?4 C23 7:8AC78>>?9899?A34C+?C2C2?523<78=3A>:73K:4378C?4BC23 456784939:;<84=>7:;?C5@?8E?@?C=C:<8=C239:;<3458C?:4 8;:64C - 6 - - 38743A 9:6453@ >:7 C23 97:55:EJ39C:7%9@8?;84C D:6@A9:4C34AC28CC23739:7A5<7:A693A?4A?98C3C28CC23 9@8?;84C 285 E334 8A;?CC3A ?4 C23 2:5<?C8@ :4 *,*- 84A 23 285 565C8?43A ?4J67?35 ?4 8 7:8A C78>>?9 899?A34C 3 56E;?C5C28C9287B35233C285E334>?@3A8B8?45CC23A7?F37 :>C23F32?9@384AC2373>:73?C9844:CE39:4C34A3AC28C?C ?5853@>>8@@E=C239@8?;84C356E;?C5C28CC239@8?;84C 565C8?43A C2733 >789C6735 84A C23 :9C:7+* D2: 3K8;?43A 2?; 285 ?5563A 8 A?58E?@?C= 937C?>?98C3 K 5C8C?4B C28C C23 9@8?;84C 285 56>>373A *0 <37;8434C A?58E?@?C= 23 C7?E648@ 285 3773A ?4 C8I?4B C23 A?58E?@?C= :> C23 9@8?;84C 8C 0 3 56E;?C5 C28C C23 ?49:;3 :> C23 9@8?;84C >?K3A 85 <37 C23 9287C <73<873A >:7 53CC@3;34C :> A?5<6C35?4C23:IA8@8C2>:7C23=387*-?55% 84AC23C7?E648@2853773A?4C8I?4BC23?49:;38C5/% <37;:4C2356E;?C5C28CC239:;<3458C?:48D87A3A>:7 <8?484A56>>37?4B5@:55:>?49:;3A67?4B@8?A6<<37?:A@:55 :> 8;34?C?35 84A 8CC34A84C >::A 84A 9:4F3=8493 9287B35 873 :4 @:D37 5?A3 3 56E;?C5 C28C C23 9@8?;84C D85 8A;?CC3A ?4 C23 2:5<?C8@ >:7 3?B2C A8=5 +?C2 C2?5 23<78=5 - 7 - >:7 3428493;34C :> C23 9:;<3458C?:4 8D87A3A E= C23 C7?E648@ , 8F?4B2387AC23@38743A9:6453@5C2?5 :67C285 <37653AC23?;<6B43A6AB;34C84AC23C7?8@ :67C739:7A5 / + ?5 7$4587? D2: 285 C738C3A C23 9@8?;84C ?4 6@C?5<39?8@?C= :5<?C8@ 8@8E678B? + 285<7:A693A98535233C) K'84A9:456@C8C?:45233C) K- 4 K' 84A K- C2373 ?5 8 ;34C?:4 C28C C23 <8C?34C98;3C:C232:5<?C8@D?C289:;<@8?4C:>53@>>8@@4 :7A37C:35C8E@?52C2358;3C23456784939:;<84=D2:285 3K8;?43AC2358?A:9C:785+9:6@A4:C3@?9?C84=C2?4B ?42?592?3>3K8;?48C?:484A285C738C3A2?;852:5C?@384A 97:553K8;?43A2?;4C2397:553K8;?48C?:48@5:4:C2?4B ;8C37?8@ 285 E334 3@?9?C3A D?C2 73B87A C: 53@> >8@@ E= C23 9@8?;84C 5 C23 9287B35233C 285 E334 >?@3A 8B8?45C C23 A7?F37 :> C23 F32?9@3 D2?92 73;8?43A 64928@@34B3A E= C23 A7?F37?C53@>?4A?98C35C28CC23899?A34C285:996773A84A?4 C23899?A34CC239@8?;84C285565C8?43A?4J67?352373>:73 - 8 - C2358?A9:4C34C?:4:>C23@38743A9:6453@>:7C2345678493 9:;<84=?54:C565C8?48E@3 23899?A34C285C8I34<@893:4*,*-84A 8C C23 C?;3 :> 899?A34C C23 9@8?;84C D85 8B3A * =3875 ?5 4:C?4A?5<6C3239@8?;84C285565C8?43AC2733>89C6735:> @3>C >3;67 @3>C 78A?65 84A 4858@ E:43 23 :9C:7 D2: 3K8;?43A 2?; ?3 +* 285 ?5563A A?58E?@?C= 937C?>?98C3 ) KD2373?4?C?55C8C3AC28CC239@8?;84C28556>>373A *0 <37;8434C A?58E?@?C= :45?A37?4B C23 >89C C28C C23 A?58E?@?C=937C?>?98C3285E334?5563AE=84:4C738C3A:9C:7 C23C7?E648@2857?B2C@=C8I34A?58E?@?C=8C023C7?E648@ 285 C8I34 C23 ?49:;3 :> C23 9@8?;84C 8C 5/% <37 ;:4C2 E6C C23 C7?E648@ :6B2C C: 28F3 C8I34 C23?49:;38C 5% <37 ;:4C2 85 <37 C23 9287C <73<873A >:7 53CC@3;34C :> A?5<6C35 ?4 C23 :I A8@8C2 23 C7?E648@ 285 C8I34;6@C?<@?378CG,H4F?3D:>C238E:F3C239@8?;84C?5 34C?C@3>:7@:55:>>6C673?49:;38564A37& +, - --./+ , - 9 - ( 23 9@8?;84C 285 E334 8A;?CC3A ?4 C23 2:5<?C8@ >:73?B2CA8=5 :45?A37?4BC2733>89C6735C239:;<3458C?:4 8D87A3A >:7 <8?4 84A 56>>37?4B 84A @:55 :> 8;34?C?35 ?4 8 56;:>5%3892?5:4@:D375?A384AC239@8?;84C?5 34C?C@3 C: 5/-% 3892 C:D87A5 <8?4 84A 56>>37?4B 84A @:55 :> 8;34?C?35 5 C23 9@8?;84C D85 8A;?CC3A ?4 C23 :5<?C8@ >:7 3?B2C A8=5 23 ?5 34C?C@3 C: 8CC34A84C 84A 9:4F3=8493 9287B35 ?4 8 56; :> 5% 85 8B8?45C 5'% 85 8D87A3A E= C23 C7?E648@ 23 9@8?;84C ?5 34C?C@3 C: @:55 :> ?49:;3 A67?4B @8?A 6< <37?:A >:7 C2733 ;:4C25?35%M;:4C25N5*'%858B8?45C 5(%858D87A3AE=C23C7?E648@ 4 F?3D :> C23 8E:F3 C23 9@8?;84C ?5 34C?C@3 C: C:C8@9:;<3458C?:48564A37& #0 123+45617+2897 5617+2897 2:2;313 <= 8>9+?;8 :55:>>6C673?49:;3 5,(,% * 8?484A56>>37?4B5 5/-% CC34A84C84A9:4F3=84939287B35 5% ' 3A?98@3K<34535 5-% - :55:>?49:;3A67?4B@8?A6<<37?:A 5*'% , :55:>8;34?C?35 5/-% 820 + - 10 - 23 9@8?;84C ?5 34C?C@3 C: C:C8@ 9:;<3458C?:4 :> 5'-(',% 85 8B8?45C 5***% 85 8D87A3A E= C23 C7?E648@D?C2?4C3735C8CC2378C3:>,0<378446; * 4F?3D:>C238E:F3C23>:@@:D?4B& " ?! :*,'%*( >?@3A E= C23 456784939:;<84=?5A?5;?553A. ??! 7:E :*-%** >?@3A E= C239@8?;84C?58@@:D3A?4<87C. ???! 23 9@8?;84C ?5 34C?C@3 C: C:C8@ 9:;<3458C?:4 :> 5'-(',% 85 8B8?45C 5***% 85 8D87A3A E= C23 C7?E648@ D?C2 ?4C3735C 8C C23 78C3 :> ,0 <37 8446; >7:; C23 A8C3:><3C?C?:4C?@@738@?O8C?:4. ?F! 45678493 9:;<84= 528@@ A3<:5?C C23 8D87A 8;:64C D?C2 ?4C3735C D?C2?4 8 <37?:A :> 3?B2C D33I5 >7:; C2?5 A8= >8?@?4B D2?92 ?C ?5 - 11 - @?8E@3 C: <8= ?4C3735C 8C C23 78C3 :> (0 <37 8446;. F! 23 9@8?;84C ?5 4:C 34C?C@3 C: ?4C3735C >:7 C23 A3@8=3A <37?:A :> , A8=5 85 <37 C23 :7A37A8C3A***'. F?! 23 :7A37 :> A3<:5?C <8553A E= C23 C7?E648@73;8?45648@C373A. F! 23 8;:64C A3<:5?C3A E= C23 45678493 9:;<84= ?5 :7A373A C: E3 C7845;?CC3A C:C23C7?E648@. F?! 3B?5C7= ?5 A?739C3A C: 73C674 C23C7?8@ :67C739:7A58@:4BD?C289:<=:>C2?56AB;34C #3 )#(#(* '" ?5C :&@ :&*,