- 1 - !"!# $%" & % ' '()* ' )) + ! "!!#$ %&! ! ! ! ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! () ! "# ! !* #!#$ ! ( !"$ ! + ! ,,, ( ! % ! % ! (,"$( % ( ! ( % ! , % ! -./0 # 1 1 ! % 2 2 31 # "!231 #$ 45/6/785/595:5;5<<5=45/946>-.9;4=?-/ 084 <40707-94/ /7 #44/595@-.65 5=7<507= =45/946 7@8 - 3 - -./0 -A4/9B490!=4564/?-/084?7/;0/4;<-96490596/7 85/595@-.65 # !507= =45/946 >-.9;4= ?-/ 084 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 87; <40707-9 7; ?7=46 .964/ 4>07-9 ( -? /7B795=-64-?!/->46./4C708084?-==-C79@</5D4/2 ! "" #$$$%&' ! " (&%&# ( ) *! + ! '$, ## -&' -&. /%+ #' 0 ) " 1 # 2 ' 3+ ) 4($.( + ! 0 " 5! 567" *! 8 9 5>0; 79 :/74? C87>8 5/4 .0B-;0 94>4;;5/D ?-/ 67;<-;5=-?084</4;490<40707-95/45;.964/2 84 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 ?7=46 5 >-B<=5790 C708 %-B49 !-=7>4 0507-9 5=5:./5@7 70D -9 96 4:/.5/D - 4 - 5@579;0 084 <40707-94/ C87>8 C5; /4@7;04/46 79 /7B4 - ?-/ 084 -??49>4; <.97;85:=4 .964/ 4>07-9; (, ( /456 C708 4>07-9 ( -? 96759 !495= -64 596 4>07-9; 596 ( -? -C/D !/-87:707-9>0, 7;0 -? 084 >-B<=5790 5A4/B490; C-.=6 /4A45= 0850 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 @-0 B5//746 0- -94 !59670 -9 ))59679084C46=->E084D85A4@7A49:7/080-5 :5:D @7/= :D 95B4 5@797 C8- 7; D45/; -=6 ?04/ D45/; -? B5//75@4 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 ;05/046 =7A79@ 79 5 8-.;4C87>8C5;>-9;0/.>04679 =5D-.0505=5:./5@7 4/8.;:596:479@0849@7944/79 .=:5/@54A4=-<B490 .08-/70D 7; 87@8=D 5??=.490 596 84 85;<./>85;46 ;4A4/5= /4;7649075= <=-0; 79 084 95B4; -? 87; ?5B7=D B4B:4/; ?04/64508-??5084/79=5C-?084;4>-96/4;<-9649084/ 8.;:596;05/0467==0/45079@84/-9084@/-.96085050084 07B4-?B5//75@49-6-C/DC5;@7A49 - 5 - 0 C5; ?./084/ >-9049646 :D 84/ 0850 5@797 7; 9-0 B4905==D ;-.96 >87=6 596 084/4?-/4 84 64A4=-<46 8-;07=4?44=79@C708084;4>-96/4;<-9649059685;597==7>70 /4=507-9;87< C708 084 <40707-94/ 84/479 596 5 ;4<5/504 /4;7649>4 79 59 5<5/0B490 85; :449 4;05:=7;846 :D 8.;:596945/.6/5C567-;<705= ( 9087;;>-/4084/4C4/4;4A4/5=67??4/49>4;79 084 B50/7B-975= /4=507-9;87< 596 C8494A4/ 7==7>70 /4=507-9;87< -? 084 8.;:596 -? 084 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 7; F.4;07-946:D;4>-96/4;<-96490084/47;0-:4F.5//4= 0C5;5=;-5==4@4608507?84/8.;:596C590;0- 85A4>-9079.46B50/7B-975=/4=507-9;87<C70884/;8485; 0-:/79@ >5;8596?7A40-=5;@-=65;6-C/D0 7;?./084/5==4@460850;84;8-.=6A5>5040848-.;4C87>8 C5;>-9;0/.>046:D84/?5084/79=5C ==4@507-9; 5=;- 79>=.64 0850 </4;490 <40707-94/ 5=-9@ C708 84/ /4=507A4; 596 /4=507A4; -? 8.;:596 -? /4;<-96490 - 85A4 7==0/45046 596 08/4504946 084 - 6 - ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 84 ;5B4 C5; 7907B5046 0- 084 <5/4905= 8-.;4 -? ;4>-96 /4;<-96490 596 -9 ) 50 5:-.0 2 ! C849 084 /4=507A4; -? 084 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490856A7;70468-.;4-?0848.;:596-?084;4>-96 /4;<-96490 </4;490 <40707-94/ 596 84/ ?5084/ 85A4 5== 5:.;46596084D85A45=;-5;;5.=046596E7>E460844=64/ :/-084/-?084>-B<=579590;4>-96/4;<-96490 ( 5;46 -9 ;.>8>-B<=5790 !-=7>4 /4@7;04/46 084 >5;4 79 /7B4 - ?-/ 084 5?-/4;576 -??49>4; 79A4;07@5046084B5004/596?7=46>85/@4;8440 9 /4>47<0 -? 084 >85/@4;8440 =45/946 /75= 1.6@405E49>-@97G59>4?-/084-??49>4;<.97;85:=4.964/ 4>07-9; (, ( /456 C708 ;4>07-9 ( -? 96759 !495= -64 596 4>07-9; 596 ( -? 084 -C/D !/-87:707-9>0596084>5;47;9-C:479@>-9079.4679 -,,,-?( 6B70046=D 084 >85/@4;8440 B504/75=; 6- 9-0 B5E4 -.0 59D @/-.96 C850;-4A4/ 0- </->446 C708 084 - 7 - >/7B795=>5;45@579;0084<40707-94/5;<40707-94/ 7; 5 ;0/59@4/ 0- 084 ?5B7=D 4;<4>75==D ?-/ 084 -??49>4; .964/4>07-9(,-?96759!495=-64 ) ./084/ 084 ;0504B490 -? 084 ;4>-96 /4;<-96490C-.=6B5E470>=45/0850C708-.0A4/7?D79@084 ?5>0; 79 084 >-B<=5790 ;84 85; B564 5==4@507-9; 5@579;0 084?5084/-?084<40707-94/84/479C8-6746=-9@:5>E == 084;4 5;<4>0; -? 084 B5004/ C849 A74C46 >5.07-.;=D 087; -./0 7; -? 084 >-9;764/46 -<797-9 0850 >-9079.507-9 -? 084 >/7B795= >5;4 5@579;0 084 <40707-94/ 84/479 7; 9-0879@ :.0 5:.;4 -? </->4;; -? =5C 596 084/4?-/49446;0-:4F.5;846 , 49>4084?-==-C79@2 7$ 84>/7B795=<40707-97;5==-C46 77$ !49679@ </->44679@; 79 -,,, ( <49679@ -9 084 ?7=4 -? 084 - 8 - 66707-95=7A7=1.6@459615=5:./5@7 5@579;0 084 <40707-94/ 84/479 95B4=D 5/795 4@.B;0596;F.5;846 777$ 0 7; B564 >=45/ 0850 087; -./0 85; 9-04H</4;;46 59D -<797-9 -9 084 B4/70 -? 084 B5004/ ,* '& ) " 7;0-2=-2( 2!