- 1 - !" #$% $$ $ & &'() & (( * ! "### $ % & ' ' ( # $# ( & '' # ) ! "#$ % Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * ) * "% * # " '% % +,, # , ), " ),)% ' * ,),+,) ,,, # * * # * ' -# $ " -# $% ./0123/0/45627/7/45/08/92:;<7.2.=0;>5:?>99/5@/5 A=207/45 7.2 41:21 :>72: +,, 6>002: ;< 7.2 92>152: ::/7/45>9 /071/?7 >5: 200/450 =:@2 >:@/1 0/77/5@ >7 .41>6=1 /5 19 4, ), "9: 19 4),)% B.212;< 7.2 23/0/45>9 4=17 ?458/1C2: 7.2 41:21 :>72: ,),+,) 6>002: /5 19/0?4,,, ;< 7.2 92>152: 1/5?/6>9 /3/9 =:@2 >5:*.41>6=1>B>1:/5@C>/5725>5?2747.2B/82>7 - 3 - 7.2 1>72 48 0 ,,,, 621 C457. >5: 0,,, 621 C457.747.2:>=@.721 2>1: 7.2 92>152: ?4=5029 >662>1/5@ 841 7.2 627/7/4521 >5: 7.2 92>152: ?4=5029 841 7.2 120645:2570 21=02: 7.2 C>721/>9 45 12?41: >0 B299 >0 7.2 41:210 6>002:;<;47.7.24=170;294B .2 12?41: 1232>90 7.>7 120645:257 4 B/82 8/92:>627/7/45=5:212?7/45 487.24:2481/C/5>9 14?2:=12 /5 19/0?4,,, 022D/5@ C457.9< C>/5725>5?2 48 0 ,,, 5 0213/?2 48 547/?2 7.2 627/7/4521.=0;>5:257212:>662>1>5?2>5::/06=72:7.2 C>1/7>9129>7/450./657.2>97215>7/32.2?45725:2:7.>7 120645:257 4 B>0 @>/58=99< 2C694<2: >0 > 4C6=721 621>741 /5 7.2 88/?2 >7 .41>6=1 :1>B/5@ > C457.9< 0>9>1< ;27B225 0(,,, >5: 0 ,,,, 7 7.2 0>C2 7/C2 7.2 627/7/4521 >:C/772: ./0 527 /5?4C2 >8721:2:=?7/454894>5>C4=57074;20 , - 4 - ) .2 92>152: >@/071>72 >8721 >6612?/>7/5@ 7.2 C>721/>9 45 12?41: C412 6>17/?=9>19< 7.2 6><09/6 48 7.2 627/7/4521614:=?2:>7 E :/0?940/5@7.2@14000>9>1<48 7.2 627/7/4521 >0 0, >5: 527 0>9>1< >0 0)(( >994B2: 7.2 627/7/45 ;< 41:21 :>72: ,),+,) @1>57/5@ C>/5725>5?2 48 0 ,,,, 621 C457.747.2B/82>5:0,,,621C457.747.2C/541 :>=@.721 @@1/232: 7.212;< 7.2 .=0;>5: 61282112: > 123/0/45 627/7/45 ;28412 7.2 23/0/45>9 4=17 614:=?/5@ >::/7/45>9 :4?=C2570 74 0=;07>57/>72./0 ?457257/457.>7 7.2 B/82 B>0 2>15/5@ 0( 621 C457. 4B2321 7.223/0/45>94=17B./92547/?/5@7.20>/:8>?7:2?9/52: 74/57218212457.2@14=5:7.>77.2B/82B>0B41D/5@459< 45 > ?4571>?7=>9 ;>0/0 >5: >??41:/5@9< :/0C/002: 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/45 .2 ?45?=11257 8/5:/5@0 48 ;47. 7.2 4=170 ;294B >12 7.=0 =5:21 ?.>9925@2 /5 7./0 123/0/45 627/7/45 - 5 - + 52E>C/5>7/45487.241:210/C6=@52:>5:7.2 C>721/>94512?41:/7/023/:2577.>77.21/@.748>B/8274 ?9>/C C>/5725>5?2 =5:21 2?7/45 48 1 /0 > C2>0=124804?/>9F=07/?2/5725:2:746123257:207/7=7/45 >5: 3>@1>5?< .2 6143/0/45 .>0 > ?4507/7=7/45>9 =5:216/55/5@ 71>?2>;92 74 17/?92 &( 48 7.2 4507/7=7/45 485:/>7 7.20>C2 7/C27.2 257/792C257 74 C>/5725>5?2 >1/020 459< B.25 7.2 B/82 /0 =5>;92 74 C>/57>/5.210298.2 45G;92=612C24=17/5 .>0 2C6.>0/H2: 7.2 52?200/7< 841 ;47. 064=020 74 8=15/0. >5 >88/:>3/7 48 :/0?940=12 48 >00270>5:9/>;/9/7/207425>;927.24=1774>0?217>/57.2 71=28/5>5?/>9640/7/45487.26>17/20 5 7.2 6120257 ?>02 7.2 C>721/>9 69>?2: 45 12?41:/5?9=:/5@ E">:C/00/45/54(,,% 1232>90 7.>7 7.2 120645:257B/82 .>0 02?=12: 2C694<C2570=;02A=257747.28/9/5@487.2627/7/45>5:/0 61202579< :1>B/5@ > C457.9< 0>9>1< 48 0( 1", %) - 6 - .4=@. 7.2 23/0/45>9 4=17 744D 5472 48 7./0 8>?7 /7 :2?9/52: 74 /57218212 04929< 45 7.2 612C/02 7.>7 7.2 2C694<C257 /0 ?4571>?7=>9 =?. 12>045/5@ /5 7.2 46/5/45 48 7./0 4=17 /0 2114524=0 >5: 0=88210 814C 6213210/7< '.25 7.2 B/82 /0 @>/58=99< 2C694<2: >5: 2>15/5@ > 12>045>;92 C457.9< /5?4C2 2325 /8 45 > ?4571>?7=>9;>0/00.2?>5547;2?450/:212:>0=5>;9274 C>/57>/5 .210298 25?2 7.2 >B>1: 48 0 ,,,, 621 C457. >0 C>/5725>5?2 74 7.2 B/82 /0 =50=07>/5>;92 >5: B>11>570 /572182125?2 4B2321 ?450/:21/5@ 7.>7 7.2 :>=@.721 /0 6=10=/5@ .21 2:=?>7/45 /5 > 126=72: /507/7=7/45 45 #40?4 5@9/0. 12C/=C /@. ?.449 >:@/17.2C>/5725>5?2>B>1:2:747.2?./9::202132074 ;2 0=/7>;9< 25.>5?2: 74 C227 .21 2:=?>7/45>9 >5: :232946C257>9522:0 ( 7/0C>:2?92>17.>7/57.22325748>5<?.>5@2 /5 ?/1?=C07>5?20 /8 7.2 120645:257 4 B/82 94020 .21 2C694<C25741;2?4C20/5?>6>;9248C>/57>/5/5@.210298 - 7 - 841>5<3>9/:12>045/58=7=127.2612025741:210.>99547 612?9=:2 .21 814C 022D/5@ C>/5725>5?2 >8120. ;< 8/9/5@ >5>661461/>72>669/?>7/45/5>??41:>5?2B/7.9>B , ??41:/5@9<7./04=176>00207.284994B/5@: / .2123/0/45627/7/45/0>994B2:/56>17 // .2 41:21 :>72: +,, 6>002: ;< 7.2 92>152: ::/7/45>9 /071/?7 >5: 200/450 =:@2 >:@/1 0/77/5@ >7 .41>6=1 /5 19 4, ), "9: 19 4),)% ?458/1C/5@ 7.2 41:21 :>72: ,),+,) 6>002: /5 19/0?4,,, ;< 7.2 92>152: 1/5?/6>9 /3/9 =:@2 >5: * .41>6=1 /0 027>0/:2/5048>1>0/7129>720747.2>B>1:48 C>/5725>5?274120645:2574 B/82 /// .2 C>/5725>5?2 >B>1:2: 74 120645:257 4:>=@.721 /0 C4:/8/2: >5: 25.>5?2: 814C 0,,, "=6220 */32 .4=0>5: 459<%621C457.740 ,,,,"=622025 .4=0>5:459<%621C457. - 8 - /3 .2 627/7/4521.=0;>5: 0.>99 :2640/7 7.2 25.>5?2: C>/5725>5?2 >C4=57 814C 7.2 :>72 48 12?2/67 48 > ?217/8/2: ?46< 48 7./0 41:21 >5: ?457/5=2 74 6>< 7.2 0>C2 12@=9>19< 45 41 ;28412 7.2 ,7. 48 2321< 0=??22:/5@C457. 3 99 47.21 :/12?7/450 /00=2: ;< 7.2 92>152: >@/071>72 547 /5?450/07257 B/7. 7./0 41:21 0.>9912C>/5=5:/07=1;2: +) & $$( % /074 94